When everyone is having a menty B
Influencers give pretty speeches in which they claim 'Mental health is important!' and give a cheerful thumbs-up of support.
According to its own mission statement, Active Minds, the American non-profit organisation behind this latest ice bucket challenge, claims to foster a 'diverse movement of peer mental health champions' that 'transform mental health norms across society'.
And while that is a well-intentioned cause, what exactly does it have to do with mental health awareness?
The non-profit's website bats around words such as depression, anxiety, advocacy and change, but it's unclear what exactly this organisation is doing with the US$300,000 (about RM1.29mil) raised by the ice bucket challenge – and the actual impact of these efforts is murky to discern at best.
Besides, if the success of the original ice bucket challenge in raising awareness of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) was questionable, why do we think it would work for mental health now?
A little knowledge is not enough
The problem nowadays with mental health isn't that it's taboo to discuss; it's how much we've turned mental health terms into buzzwords and online trends that spread misinformation.
Youths may think their limited exposure to, and experience with, mental illness, be it in health class or through a stint of now-very-common depression or anxiety, means that they understand all there is to the endless ocean that is mental health.
This false security in knowledge means that they aren't likely to seek out more information and may dismiss people who tell them to educate themselves.
For example, when I asked people at my lunch table to stop gossiping about a classmate's recent suicide, I was told that I was overreacting and that they 'understood' because of going through a rough patch during Covid-19 – despite knowing that I had a close friend die under similar circumstances the week before.
And now these youths are being turned into 'champions'.
Don't get me wrong.
It's a good thing that there are 'more than 15,000 young adults... (who are) passionate advocates and educators for mental health,' as Active Minds reports.
But this may be like having someone with melanoma (a skin cancer) advocating for those dealing with leukaemia (a blood cancer) and claiming they have personal connections to this battle because of their experience with melanoma.
Instead of actually educating themselves about serious mental illnesses, these youths may be convinced to douse themselves in water and throw around terms such as 'Menty B', meaning 'mental breakdown'.
Romanticising mental illness
The danger of using these terms so flippantly, particularly as internet slang, is illustrated by the 'prevalence inflation hypothesis', as presented in a 2023 paper by researchers from Britain and Australia.
I repeatedly hear kids say they're having a panic attack when in fact they're mildly stressed by an upcoming test – so much to the point that I may not get the help I need for an actual panic attack.
As kids hear these disorders referenced more often, through trends such as the ice bucket challenge, they may 'misinterpret milder and more transient forms of distress as mental health problems,' the researchers conclude.
ALSO READ: The difference between being mentally unhealthy and mentally ill
Active Mind's #SpeakYourMIND promotes exactly this.
If we hear the concept enough times, we may start applying it to our daily lives, leading to incorrect self-diagnoses.
We're following the trend of romanticising mental illnesses.
As a Texas State University student put it: 'We are a culture of extremes, and attempts to destigmatise mental illness have inadvertently glamorised it', so much so that it's seen as having ''beautifully tragic' qualities'.
Life-threatening conditions have been turned into what can only be called microtrends, but many people still don't under- stand what those illnesses entail.
Seasonal affective disorder, better known as SAD, isn't just when you feel tired in the winter.
People who have schizophrenia aren't dangers to society, and bulimia and anorexia certainly aren't the same thing!
We must reform our use of mental health language so that we're not propagating stereotypes and allowing them to be turned into an 'interesting' facet of our personalities.
This all begins with a more critical look at what the #SpeakYourMIND ice bucket challenge actually is: a dumb trend for people chasing internet virality while trying to look cute, who are not raising awareness for mental health. – By Abigail AuYeung/Chicago Tribune/Tribune News Service
Abigail AuYeung is a senior (final-year student) at Hinsdale Central High School near Chicago in the United States.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
6 days ago
- New Straits Times
MSF condemns 'orchestrated killings' at Gaza aid sites
KUALA LUMPUR: Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) has accused Israeli forces and private American contractors of orchestrating violence against Palestinians at food distribution sites run by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), calling for the immediate shutdown of these operations. In a new report titled "This is not aid. This is orchestrated killing," MSF documents targeted and indiscriminate attacks at GHF-run sites in Gaza, which have become deadly hotspots amid the ongoing conflict. Between June 7 and July 24, MSF treated 1,380 casualties — including 28 fatalities — at its clinics near the GHF distribution points. Among them were 71 children wounded by gunfire, 25 of whom were under the age of 15. MSF General Director Raquel Ayora alleged that children have been shot in the chest while simply reaching for food. "People have been crushed or suffocated in stampedes, and entire crowds have been gunned down at distribution points. In nearly 54 years of MSF's operations, we have rarely witnessed such systematic violence against unarmed civilians. "These Gaza Humanitarian Foundation distribution sites, which are supposed to provide aid, have instead become laboratories of cruelty. This must end immediately." MSF's data shows 11 per cent of gunshot wounds treated were to the head and neck, with another 19 per cent to the chest, abdomen, and back — indicating intentional targeting rather than accidental fire. Mohammed Riad Tabasi, a patient at the Al-Mawasi clinic, recounted, "I saw it with my own eyes, about 20 corpses around me. All of them shot in the head, in the stomach." The GHF, operated under full Israeli military control and "secured" by private American armed contractors, replaced the UN-led aid effort in May amid allegations of aid diversion. MSF called the scheme a "laboratory of cruelty" and urged governments to suspend all financial and political support. MSF emergency coordinator Aitor Zabalgogeazkoa said patients also suffer theft and violent assaults while trying to secure or protect food rations, with many listed as "Beaten By Others" in medical records. "On Aug 1, 15-year-old Mahmoud Jamal Al-Attar was killed at a GHF site while trying to get food. "We only treat a fraction of those killed or injured. The murder of children at these sites is intentional." MSF calls on governments, especially the United States, to suspend all support for the GHF and urges the immediate restoration of UN-coordinated aid distribution to protect civilians in Gaza.
The Sun
6 days ago
- The Sun
A man's love for his sick wife melts hearts online
AN old man's loving commitment to look after his sick, wheelchair-bound wife has won the hearts of netizens on Reddit. In a clip posted by Reddit user @Far_Spare6201, the old man, who sells drinks at a market for a living, said he loves his wife very much despite her being unable to move her body after suffering from a stroke and diabetes. The old man even said he loves and takes care of his wife even more now that she is ill. He also admitted to suffering from diabetes and stage 5 kidney cancer. Despite, doctors advising him to undergo dialysis for his kidneys, but he refused because he wanted to take care of his wife. He concluded by telling people to always look after the ones you love and never leave them to go through hardship alone. He now earns a living with the help of his 21-year-old daughter who works hard to put food on the table. Touched by the old man, @eddxtrastrange said God loves those who he tests in life. Some netizens admittedly got teary-eyed watching the video, like @BestCroissant, who jokingly asked if someone was cutting onions around him. @Superdaneru was inspired by the video: 'They looked so happy and proud. They looked like they are going to have the brightest future with nothing stopping them. Life is hard. Huge reminder to me to be kind to others.' However, @kubakg_pc93 expressed concern for the old man for not undergoing dialysis. 'Wait a couple of months and that chronic kidney disease will lead to a complete shutdown of the body, Pak Cik. 'Then who is going to take care of both your girls.' On Instagram, @geneeee0609 urged the government to help people like the old man and his family as they are the ones who deserve help. 'This is the type of people the government should be focusing on helping, help make their lives better, take care of them.' @gojesgold_jewelry praised the old man's daughter for being willing to give up her studies to help her parents make money. 'The girl is such a strong soul for sacrificing her studies and time with friends to help her parents out. Oh God, please give success to this young girl and give good health to her parents.'
The Star
6 days ago
- The Star
‘Food content creators can help make nutrition accessible'
PETALING JAYA: Food content creators are not just serving up mouth-watering visuals – they also promote healthy eating habits. Take Zhi Ling. She is a nutritionist with over 200,000 Instagram followers who makes videos showing the nutritional benefits of local fruits as well as how to cook healthy dishes. Then there is Thevi Ramalingam, the culinary mind behind Thevi's Kitchen with some 65,000 followers across Instagram and Facebook. She promotes vegetables in regular cooking. Zhi Ling, who is known for her quick cooking tips and smart grocery picks, said the Health Ministry should partner with content creators who are also healthcare professionals as they already have established trust with their audience. ALSO READ: Balancing expertise and influence 'Most have the skills to translate medical or dietary guidelines into digestible information.' She also called for high-quality, authentic content creators to work with the ministry. 'It does not have to be limited to food creators. Food reviewers and recipe creators can make nutritious food like fruits, vegetables and whole grains appear fun and accessible.' She emphasised that campaigns that balance the needs of the ministry and content creators could reach bigger audiences. 'Like role models, healthcare professionals can break down complex guidelines into digestible bits, increasing public willingness to adopt them.' Zhi Ling suggested that the government, academicians, influencers and agencies be brought together in public health awareness campaigns. 'The messages should be firm, assertive and fun, without relying on fear tactics,' she added. Thevi said she had always incorporated more vegetables into her meals to inspire healthier eating habits. 'Kids are getting news from TikTok. It's time they also get recipes and ideas online,' she added. Her influence is evident as followers have shared stories of trying new vegetables and local ulam after watching her videos. 'Some of these ladies had never eaten certain vegetables but found them nice after giving them a try.' She also champions the use of local ingredients and conscious dining. 'When we eat out, we need to be aware – focus on local produce,' she said. 'We can still indulge sometimes but be moderate without stressing our body.' 'The Health Ministry's approach to use influencers can help build a healthier Malaysia,' added Thevi. Maria Tunku Sabri, a TV host and content creator, believes engaging influencers for public health messaging is a 'smart and timely move'. 'By working with influencers who have built trust with their communities, the ministry can make health education more relatable and actionable,' she said. Maria said she uses her influence responsibly, offering recipes that look and feel good - nourishing, balanced and easy to adopt. 'My goal is to show that healthy eating can be fun.' She follows the 80-20 rule. 'It's 80% nourishing content and 20% treats. That's a realistic, non-restrictive approach.' Patsy Kam, a former journalist turned food content creator, however, said the ministry should specify its goals when using influencers. She acknowledged that influencers can promote healthier diets but stressed the challenge is getting people to act on the messages. While she sees value in using influencers for health promotion, she cautioned that it 'may not be a sustainable solution'.
