EXCLUSIVE I've managed the diets of sports stars and soldiers... this is why you're eating the wrong foods and should ditch fibre
A food expert who has worked with elite sports teams and the military has made the wild claim that the public have been 'indoctrinated' to eat the wrong foods, and should be following an all-meat diet.
Retired academic Bart Kay spent decades working across 10 universities around the world, specialising in the fields of human nutrition, cardiovascular pathophysiology and exercise physiology.
He has published a number of scientific papers and was a consultant to the famed New Zealand All Blacks rugby union team, the Australian Defence Force, the New Zealand Army and NRL referees' association.
Professor Kay claimed the carnivore diet was superior and even argued fibre should be cut out because no actual 'evidence' existed that it was beneficial.
His beliefs fly in the face of longstanding advice that a diet should consist of an equal balance of red meat, fruits, vegetables and carbohydrates.
Dietitians Australia president Dr Fiona Willer warned the carnivore diet was not 'healthy' and that fibre was beneficial as it was proven to lower the risk of developing certain diseases and cancers.
Professor Kay told Daily Mail Australia labelled fruits and vegetables 'plants' and went as far as to call them 'toxins'.
'Plant material is not helpful in any way to us as a source of food or nutrient. In fact, it's the exact opposite, it's anti-nutrient, it's toxin, it's irritant,' he said.
'Plants basically don't want to be eaten and the only way they can fight back is chemically, which they do, and the wool has been pulled over our eyes for generations to think we should eat a diet rich in plants and we shouldn't.'
The carnivore diet includes meat, fish, and other animal products like eggs and some dairy.
It excludes all other foods, including fruits, vegetables, legumes, grains, nuts, and seeds.
Professor Kay claimed that the public has been 'indoctrinated' and led to 'believe their entire lives that they must eat the rainbow'.
'When I say the correct diet for a human being is hyper-carnivore, with as little plant material as possible, that's my opinion based on my significant understanding of human physiology, human nutrition science and cardiovascular pathophysiology,' he said.
Professor Kay added the average person could go even more extreme and live on what's called the 'Lion Diet' which consists of only red meat, salt and water.
'As long as they eat enough fat with the red meat,' he said.
'The closer you can get to 100 per cent carnivore and zero plant material the better.'
Professor Kay also took aim at fibre, labelling it a 'health myth'.
'The exact amount of evidence anywhere that proves that fibre is beneficial for human health, or any hard health outcomes of any kind, is none whatsoever. It does not exist,' he claimed.
'It's astonishing that we have this narrative that's accepted without question by almost everyone in the industry that says fibre is great.
'Fibre keeps you regular, no it doesn't. If anything, fibre tends to be associated with idiopathic constipation.'
Professor Kay has been on a carnivore diet for nearly 10 years and despite consuming virtually no fibre, he claimed he has a regular bowel movement once a day.
Dr Willer rejected Professor Kay's claims.
'The carnivore diet is certainly not aligned with the best evidence of a healthy diet, certainly for long-term health outcomes,' Dr Willer claimed.
'There are ways we can reduce our health risks and bump up longevity, but the carnivore diet doesn't tick those boxes.
'Meat itself is fine but the issue is in exclusion of all other kinds of foods.'
Dr Willer slammed the anti-fibre rhetoric, saying fibre intake was associated with many health benefits and was 'healthy for our bowel bacteria'.
'We know that eating enough fibre is associated with a lower risk of heart disease and diabetes and bowel cancer as well,' she said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
40 minutes ago
- The Sun
Mum who nearly died after falling sick in Spain issues warning after anti-sickness pills left her ‘acting possessed'
A MUM is urging Brits to be careful buying medicine on holiday - after she nearly died when an over-the-counter anti-sickness tablet left her acting "possessed". Keira Morrison had been unwell during her family holiday to Salou, Spain, and had been throwing up around 10 times a day. 4 4 When Dioralyte didn't improve the 29-year-old's symptoms, her partner Liam Bridgeman, 33, went to a nearby pharmacy and bought her some anti-sickness tablets for 1.90 euro. Metoclopramide is an anti-sickness medication that is only available on prescription in the UK, however it's available over the counter in Spain. After two days of taking the tablets, the former hairdresser's jaw suddenly "locked" as they sat in their hotel room - and she soon lost control of her body. A panicked Keira and Liam went to their hotel manager for help and once they showed him the tablets he offered to drive the couple to a nearby medical centre. Here the mum-of-two deteriorated quickly and began to act "possessed" - losing control of her arms and legs and her eyes rolling back in her head. She admits it was so bad she "thought it was the end". Staff put her on an IV drip while they ordered an ambulance to take her to hospital in Tarragona, where doctors manged to ease her symptoms with an injection. It has since emerged that the recommended dosage is one 10mg tablet three times a day - but Keira claims the pharmacist had told her to take two of the tablets at once. This meant she was taking twice the recommended dosage on each occasion. She is now raising awareness about the terrifying experience online and about the potential risks of adverse reactions to common medications, particularly if more easily available with prescriptions when on holiday. Beware 3 of the most dangerous medicines in the world - including one found in almost EVERY home Keira, from Liverpool, Merseyside, said: "Liam said it was like I was possessed. "I thought it was the end, I did. It was not a nice experience at all. "It was like I wasn't in my body, it was like someone had control over my body. That's how I felt and I did feel like I was going to die. "There were leaflets on the wall and when I was looking at the words, I couldn't see the words. They were going blurry. "I was pleading with them [the doctors] like, 'please help me.' "At the point before I had the injection my head was banging off the bed, my eyes were going to the back of my head and flickering. My legs and arms were flying everywhere. It felt like I was having a seizure. I just wanted the feeling to stop Keira Morrison "It felt like I was having a seizure. I just wanted the feeling to stop, I've never experienced a feeling like that in my life. I was screaming, 'please help me, please help me!' "If I didn't go to hospital when I did I probably would have thrown myself off the balcony because I wanted the feeling to stop that much. I was crying, screaming." Keira said one of the doctors in the hospital explained that she had a reaction to the tablets. After spending a night in hospital Keira left the following day because she was due to fly home and she said she thinks she experienced a side effect called tardive dyskinesia. According to Mind, this is a condition where your face, body or both make sudden, irregular and uncontrollable movements. This is a known potential side effect of the medication and a 2014 report by the European Medicines Agency's Committee on Medicinal Products for Human Use and recommended restricting the dose to "help minimise the risk of potentially serious neurological adverse effects". 4 Since returning to the UK, she has been to her doctor to have an allergy test and to have her heart checked as she had been experiencing palpitations. Keira said: "My doctor did say in the UK you've got to have a prescription to get that medication. "You can't get that over the counter here. You shouldn't be selling that over the counter. "It has scared us. We have another holiday booked and we are in talks of cancelling. We're in shock and we can't believe it happened. "I'll never ever buy anything over the counter again. "If I ever do go away now I'll make sure I've got my own anti-sickness medication from the UK and it was something I'd had before. "I can't describe the feeling, it was horrendous. I wouldn't wish it on my own enemy." Accord, the manufacturer of the tablets, have been contacted for comment. Safety measures when buying medicines abroad IF medication needs to be acquired abroad, it's recommended to purchase from licensed pharmacies in large cities and to verify that the medication contains the same active ingredient as the one typically taken. Also: Whenever possible, obtain all required medications before travelling, as this avoids the risk of purchasing falsified medicines. Do not purchase medicines from street markets or unregulated online sources, as these are high-risk areas for counterfeit products. Discuss the need for medications abroad with your doctor or pharmacist, who can provide guidance on obtaining them safely and legally. Be cautious of misspellings or incorrect packaging, as these can be indicators of falsified medications. Some embassies can provide lists of reliable pharmacies in the country you are visiting. Be cautious when buying medicines online, as there is a high risk of purchasing counterfeit products.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Why has there been a global surge of new Covid variant NB.1.8.1?
India is the latest country to report a surge in new Covid cases, as the latest variant NB.1.8.1 spreads across the globe. Cases have now been reported in Asian countries such as Thailand, Indonesia and China, while the UKHSA recorded the first 13 cases in England last week. However, the true numbers are unlikely to be known, given the significant decrease in the number of people testing compared to the figures seen during the global pandemic five years ago. What do we know about the variant NB.1.8.1? NB.1.8.1 stemmed from the Omicron variant and was first detected in January this year. It has quickly spread across China and Hong Kong, and has now been recorded in several states across the United States and Australia. By late April, NB.1.8.1 comprised about 10.7 per cent of submitted sequences globally, according to the World Health Organization (WHO). This rose from just 2.5 per cent one month before. The WHO declared the NB.1.8.1 strain a 'variant under monitoring' on 23 May, which means scientists believe it could potentially affect the behaviour of the virus. Why has there been a surge in new cases? Lara Herrero, a virologist from Griffith University in Australia, suspects that NB.1.8.1 spreads more easily than other variants. 'Using lab-based models, researchers found NB.1.8.1 had the strongest binding affinity to the human ACE2 receptor of several variants tested, suggesting it may infect cells more efficiently than earlier strains,' Dr Herrero wrote last month in The Conversation. Dr Chun Tang, GP at Pall Mall Medical, added: 'NB.1.8.1 isn't too different from the Omicron variant, but it does have some tweaks to its spike protein, which might make it spread a bit more easily or slip past some of our existing immunity. 'That said, early signs suggest it doesn't seem to cause more serious illness, but of course, we're still learning more about it.' 'Its spread has been identified in around 22 countries,' said Dr Naveed Asif, GP at The London General Practice. 'The WHO assesses the additional risk to the global public as currently low, and existing Covid-19 vaccines are considered effective in preventing severe disease.' However, Nimbus does appear to be more transmissible than previous variants, with notable increases reported in India, Hong Kong, Singapore, and Thailand, notes Dr Asif. What are the symptoms? Common symptoms of the NB.1.8.1 variant include a severe sore throat. fatigue, mild cough, fever, muscle aches and congestion. It has also been reported that some patients have experienced gastrointestinal symptoms such as nausea and diarrhoea. Healthcare experts have stressed, however, that there is no evidence that the new strain is more deadly or serious than previous variants, and that current Covid vaccines are expected to remain effective and protect anyone infected from severe illness.
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
I tried the walking method that offers ‘10 times the benefits' of walking 10,000 steps per day
Walking is an accessible form of movement with impressive health-boosting credentials; I think there is enough research available to safely make that statement. Treating 10,000 steps per day as the gold standard for a healthy lifestyle is far more contentious. The number stems from a 1960s Japanese marketing campaign for a pedometer called the Manpo-Kei, or '10,000 steps metre'. It's a nice round number, but it's not one identified by science as the holy grail for health – a 2023 study by the University of Granada suggests that, while more is better, 8,000 is sufficient 'to significantly reduce the risk of premature death'. Walking 10,000 steps also takes a fair old while. Even at a decent nick, this task is likely to take you upwards of 90 minutes each day, making it a struggle for busy folks. Recently, an alternative walking protocol – colloquially termed 'Japanese walking' due to its country of origin – has stepped into the spotlight online. It takes just 30 minutes per day, with fitness coach and content creator Eugene Teo claiming it offers '10 times the benefits' of walking 10,000 steps per day in his viral video above. As a fitness writer, I've covered walking extensively, finding it's one of the best ways to help people of all fitness levels introduce more movement into their regular routine. So, intrigued, I endeavoured to try 'Japanese walking' and find out if the impressive health claims around it held water. How to try the 'Japanese walking' method Complete the sequence below five times without any breaks: Three minutes of walking at a low intensity (40 per cent peak aerobic capacity, or a relaxed pace) Three minutes of walking at a high intensity (70 per cent peak aerobic capacity, or a brisk pace) Benefits of Japanese walking The 'Japanese walking' protocol comes from a study published in the Mayo Clinic Proceedings journal in 2007. It was designed to test whether high-intensity interval walking training (IWT) can offer greater benefits than moderate-intensity continuous walking training, in terms of improving thigh muscle strength, peak aerobic capacity (the maximum amount of oxygen you can take in and use during exercise) and blood pressure. Over five months, 60 men and 186 women with an average age of 63 were divided into three groups; no walking training, IWT and CWT (continuous walking training). The CWT group was instructed to walk at 50 per cent of their peak aerobic capacity (a fairly slow pace) and take 8,000 or more steps per day at least four times per week. The IWT group was told to complete the protocol above, four or more times per week. Among participants who met these conditions, those in the IWT group saw a 13 per cent increase in isometric knee flexion, a 17 per cent increase in isometric knee flexion, and an eight per cent increase in peak aerobic capacity for walking. This was 'significantly greater than the increases observed in the moderate-intensity continuous walking training group'. The research also found a greater reduction in resting systolic blood pressure in the IWT group, despite the fact they didn't spend as much time walking each week. The conclusion states: 'high-intensity interval walking may protect against age-associated increases in blood pressure and decreases in thigh muscle strength and peak aerobic capacity.' What happened when I tried Japanese walking I don't have a full science lab set up at home; what I do have is two legs, a Garmin watch and a lot of walking experience, so I decided to put these to good use. During my Monday lunch break, I took my dog for a 30-minute walk as normal. Then, at 1pm the following day, I tried the 'Japanese walking' method on the same looped route, setting my Garmin Vivoactive to record both sessions and taking note of any subjective changes I felt. My usual 30-minute walk saw me accrue nearly 3,000 steps, covering 2.12km at an average speed of 14min 10sec per kilometre. My heart rate averaged 85bpm, remaining fairly constant throughout, and I burned an estimated 157 calories. As anyone who has owned a dog might expect, there was a good deal of stopping and starting to inspect particularly interesting trees and bollards, and I defaulted to a fairly casual pace amid a busy work day. For the Japanese walking protocol, my numbers looked a bit different, with my fast pace falling just below 120 steps per minute and my slow pace a few shy of 100 steps per minute. I travelled significantly further, covering 2.94km and 3,500 steps at an average speed of 10min 12sec per kilometre. My average heart rate came out very similar (86bpm) but there were noticeable peaks (104bpm) and troughs in line with the high- and low-speed intervals. My estimated calorie burn was also significantly higher: 211. Benefits of the Japanese walking method The idea that walking faster, or sprinkling more intensity into your exercise, holds greater benefits is nothing new. Specialist in walking for health, Dr Elroy Aguiar, is an assistant professor at the University of Alabama's department of kinesiology. He was the lead author on a 2024 paper published in the Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports, which correlated as little as one minute of high-intensity activity with improved health outcomes. 'One of the really interesting findings from our paper was that, if you look at people's highest one minute of activity across each day, averaged across the monitoring period, that was a very strong signal for whether they had one or more metabolic syndrome risk factors [elevated waist circumference, high triglycerides, low HDL (or 'good' cholesterol), high blood pressure and high blood sugar] present,' he tells me. Another series of studies he worked on, featured in the British Journal of Sports Medicine, pointed to the fact that 'if you walk at a cadence of about 100 steps per minute, that's equivalent to what's called 'moderate-intensity', and all of the research in this area suggests that most of the benefits [of walking] accumulate at a moderate or higher intensity'. Beyond this, completing the Japanese walking method four times per week leaves you half-an-hour away from the World Health Organisation's 'global recommendations of at least 150 minutes of moderate-intensity physical activity per week'. Add a couple of short full-body strength training sessions into the mix and you have a decent minimalist workout plan for beginners. Potential drawbacks of the Japanese Walking method All of the information above paints the Japanese walking method in a favourable light – as it should, with the protocol delivering impressive results in a non-intimidating time-span. However, if we are questioning the claim that it is 'better' than walking 10,000 steps a day, there are a few further areas to consider. Firstly, Dr Aguiar's 2024 paper supported the idea that the 'best' walking method for reducing metabolic risk factors involves a combination of high volume (number of steps) and high intensity (walking speed). 'Accumulating a high volume of walking throughout the day [8,000-plus steps], then focussing on at least 30 minutes of faster walking or jogging, would be a way to move the metrics in a positive direction and lower your metrics for each of the [metabolic syndrome] risk factors,' he says. I racked up a little over 3,500 steps when trying the Japanese Walking method – less than half of the 8,000 daily steps research has repeatedly linked to many favourable health outcomes, and short of the 5,000 mark often viewed as the threshold for a sedentary lifestyle. Using this method as part, rather than all, of your daily steps could be a better approach for achieving your health goals. However, if you only have 30 minutes per day free, it still offers dramatically more benefits than not moving at all, and improved return on investment over a regular 30-minute walk. Another area where the Japanese walking method loses out to walking 10,000 steps per day is movement regularity. While the former involves a concentrated 30-minute dose of activity, the latter can be spread throughout the day, encouraging you to abandon your office chair and sofa more often. A 10-year study of 8,000 people, published in the American Journal of Epidemiology, found that those replaced 30 minutes of daily sitting with light activity had a 17 per cent lower risk of dying in that period. This even applied if they accrued these 30 minutes across short intervals throughout the day – hence why your smartwatch is constantly sending you reminders to stand up and move. Regular movement can also help maintain mobility and reduce stiffness in our joints and muscles. 'When we're dealing with an adaptation from stillness, movement is the answer, so any movement is better than just being still,' movement mechanics expert and The Training Stimulus founder Ash Grossmann summarises. The final factor to consider is enjoyment. By adding a rigid framework, Japanese walking ensures intensity. However, it also meant I was unable to stop and chat to people in the park or appreciate my surroundings to the same extent. For me, this lowered the stress-busting potential of my walk, sacrificing some of the usual mental health benefits of walking for physical ones. The Japanese walking method: the verdict In my time writing about health and fitness, the net positive effect of regular movement has been one of the most striking common denominators. For those looking for a minimum effective dose: any movement will do you a lot of good, particularly if your starting point is a sedentary lifestyle. But if you can fit one or two quick full-body strength training sessions, regular aerobic activity (like walking) and an occasional dash of more intense exercise into each week, it will stand you in very good stead. Walking is among the most accessible forms of exercise there is, lowering the barrier to entry for exercise for billions of people, which is why I'm always keen to promote it. However, in the modern world, even finding time for a quick walk can be tricky for particularly busy individuals. The Japanese walking method provides a time-savvy way to enjoy many of the benefits of a greater volume of daily walking. Sure, you could enjoy higher-intensity exercise in any number of other forms, from cycling to a HIIT workout, but walking remains the most efficient – you don't even need a change of clothes. So should you try it? Yes, especially if you're short on time and looking for a way to squeeze health-boosting movement into your day. And should you stick with it? This depends. If you enjoy this framework, or find it's something you can stick to with a good degree of regularity, that's the ticket to a sustainable movement habit and the many health benefits that come from it. If not, look for an alternative form of moderate- to high-intensity exercise that you find fun, and commit to this instead – consistency is the key to long-term results.
