logo
Mum calls for change to school holidays as costs burden Kiwi families

Mum calls for change to school holidays as costs burden Kiwi families

NZ Herald6 days ago
'While there are private school holiday programmes available, they are often unaffordable, costing $50 to $70 per day. We're aware of subsidy programmes, but unfortunately, we don't meet the eligibility criteria. This leaves us – and many others – in a difficult position.
'I understand that the current system may have worked better in the past when single-income households were more common. But in today's economy, dual-income families are often a necessity, and the school calendar hasn't adapted to reflect this reality.'
The Ministry of Social Development's OSCAR subsidy is available for school holiday programmes up to 50 hours a week. The amount parents can get depends on the number of children they have and how much they earn.
Someone with two children can get $326 per child, per week in the holidays if they earn less than $1264 a week before tax. That drops to $101.50 a week if their income is between $2485 and $2669. Above that, there is no subsidy available.
Tendler said she was relatively new to the country and was surprised when she discovered the situation. Even working from home was not a good solution, she said.
'To work from home when you have a 5-year-old son with you, it's not a productive day.'
She said the model was outdated.
'It's very oriented in terms of one parent working, one parent is staying at home. Maybe it was like that in the past in New Zealand, but I feel the economy now and the cost of living now is not really representing that anymore, and there are a lot of families that both of the parents are working now and you need to find a solution around it.'
She said it seemed that teachers did not want to lose the days off.
'You could still have a balance and have holidays, but not two weeks. Reduce it to one week and keep summer as it – it will help some parents.'
She said even with two parents splitting leave, they did not have enough days to cover the holiday.
Other options could be to give parents more paid leave, or provide cheaper, government-run holiday programmes, she said.
Days in school agreed in 2016
Sean Teddy, hautū (leader) of operations and integration at the Ministry of Education, said the school holidays were set – in agreement with sector groups – in 2016.
Schools can choose a start date between Auckland Anniversary Day and the day after Waitangi Day, and can end no later than December 20 in any year.
Secondary and composite schools need to be open for 380 half-days a year. Primary, intermediate and special schools need to open between 380 and 390 half-days, depending on the timing of Easter.
'In most years, the first school holidays for primary schools are timed to include the Easter break. To create terms of a reasonably uniform length in years when Easter falls particularly early, all or some of the Easter break will fall during the first term. In these years, fewer half-days can be completed before the latest end date.'
The ministry told Tendler it was important to strike a balance between ensuring students were in school long enough to receive the education they needed, and having holidays long enough to give them a chance to rest and recuperate.
Financial mentor David Verry at North Harbour Budgeting Services said Tendler was not alone in her concerns. He said it was something families struggled with every year.
The summer holidays could be even tougher on family budgets. Photo / 123rf
'One of the big issues is they come up in one big lump sum that you have to pay.
'If it's $50 a day, that's $250 a week and that's after-tax dollars people have to come up with. Over a couple of weeks, if you have two children, that's $1000. That's a huge chunk of cash to have to front with.'
The summer holidays could be even tougher on family budgets, he said, because people would also have to cover the cost of Christmas and back-to-school. It was even harder on single parents, he said.
Verry said he would advise people to set money aside for holiday programmes through the year, if they could, so they had the funds available when they needed them.
'So you can dip into that without having to go, 'Oh gosh, we're going to have to cut our food budget because we just haven't got enough.''
While people who could work from home might have flexibility to reduce the hours their children went to holiday programmes, or not use them at all, manual workers did not have that luxury.
'It's a bit harder when you have a manual job or you're working in a supermarket because you've got to be there.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Air New Zealand inks direct partnership with ChatGPT maker OpenAI, pair create virtual customers
Air New Zealand inks direct partnership with ChatGPT maker OpenAI, pair create virtual customers

NZ Herald

time4 hours ago

  • NZ Herald

Air New Zealand inks direct partnership with ChatGPT maker OpenAI, pair create virtual customers

As well as being OpenAI CFO, Friar is a long-time member of the board of Walmart. Before returning home to run Air New Zealand, Foran was in charge of the giant retailer's US operation. There have been several meetings between senior Air New Zealand and Open AI senior leaders over the past year 'and they saw that Air New Zealand could well be the petri dish for innovation in the critical infrastructure and aviation game', Ravishankar said. The airline's use of OpenAI's generative artificial intelligence (AI) has run from the mainstream – summarising complicated documents – to creating the aforementioned virtual focus group. OpenAI's Sarah Friar overlapped with Air NZ CEO Greg Foran at Walmart. Photo / Getty Images 'Our customer service teams have created customer personas by feeding them all the feedback and complaints we've got – to test service improvements before we introduce them to a focus group,' Ravishankar said. Ideas could be 'pre-tested' on and honed on the virtual personas, which were based on hundreds of thousands of pieces of customer comments, helping to fine-tune ideas from a much broader pool of perspectives, before putting them before a human focus group. 'AI allows you to do complex, integrated planning much more seamlessly,' Ravishankar said. 'We're starting to look at how we use AI to optimise our loyalty tier benefits, for example, and how we can optimise turnaround to improve on-time performance management.' What about customer-facing AI? Air New Zealand was an early adopter of Soul Machines' avatar technology, before the Kiwi firm flamed out, but switched from the homegrown solution to its inhouse-developed chatbot 'Oscar'. Is Oscar about to get an an AI makeover? 'As are a lot of organisations, we're doing a ton of work on whether generative AI is ready for prime time; ready to directly interface with customers to provide an, if you will, chatbot on steroids. We're doing a lot of testing, but we're just not fully satisfied it's there yet,' Ravishankar said. 'But it's maturing at a rate of knots. I'm a technologist by trade, and I've never seen anything move as quickly.' Behind the scenes, staff are using AI to help deliver more personalised service to customers, he said. All up, the airline is using 1500 CustomGPTs to introduce efficiencies to internal workflows. CustomGPTs are set to specific tasks and can be ring-fenced to access a company's own data – addressing the dangers of an AI hallucinating or breaching privacy or commercial confidentiality. How do you market to an AI concierge? OpenAI recently released a ChatGPT 'agent' that can carry out autonomous tasks, such as booking travel (or 'looking' at a photo of a meal you like on Instagram, then ordering the ingredients for you from an online supermarket). The initial release was restricted to those on US$200 ($330) per month pro plans, but it's being rolled out this month to those on cheaper Plus plans too. So far, many early testers have found the ChatGPT agent slow and clumsy, in part because human approval is needed at various steps – including credit card purchases – so you can't walk away from your device. 'Uncharted territory' But while the ChatGPT agent might be a while off for OpenAI's free tier, pundits see 'agentic AI' as the next big thing – and it's already starting to figure in the airline's thinking. 'We're starting to wonder what the role of a brand is when ... a customer's own concierge [AI] agent is deciding which product to put in front of the customer,' Ravishankar said. 'That's uncharted territory ... if anyone tells us they know exactly how that's going to play out, they're making it up. 'But we're paying close attention to it, and then we're seeing multiple models emerge. 'It could be we provide an Air New Zealand concierge, or our concierge interacts with a customer's own concierge. Or we just make our environment open to customers' own agents, being able to interact with us. 'It's too soon to say what pattern emerges. If I was a betting man, I'd say we'll probably see multiple models.' Direct collaboration As part of the collaboration, Air New Zealand will gain early access to OpenAI technologies to develop and apply use cases, and equip its people across corporate roles with secure, enterprise-grade AI tools, Ravishankar said. 'By working directly with OpenAI, we not only access leading-edge technology but we also shape how it's used in the real world.' 'Air New Zealand is taking meaningful steps to bring AI across key parts of its business using OpenAI's technology. We have been particularly impressed with how quickly they have built over 1500 CustomGPTs to introduce efficiencies to internal workflows,' OpenAI international managing director Oliver Jay said. 'Their focus on innovation and responsibility shows how the aviation sector can adopt advanced tools in practical ways that deliver value for both employees and customers.' POSTSCRIPT: Captain's chair? Foran resigned as CEO in May. He will depart the airline in October. The Australian recently reported that Ravishankar has the inside running to replace him. The Herald asked Ravishankar if he wanted to take the opportunity to rule himself in or out. 'That is definitely above my pay grade, and you probably want to speak to the board about that,' he replied. There was no immediate response from the board. Boards typically don't comment on potential candidates prior to an executive appointment. Chris Keall is an Auckland-based member of the Herald's business team. He joined the Herald in 2018 and is the technology editor and a senior business writer.

School system 'fair' but we've been pretending it's 'great'
School system 'fair' but we've been pretending it's 'great'

RNZ News

timea day ago

  • RNZ News

School system 'fair' but we've been pretending it's 'great'

An international consultancy firm rated New Zealand's education system at the top of "fair", along with countries including Armenia and Greece, and behind Australia which was considered low in the "good" ranking. Photo: Supplied / Ministry of Education How good is the school system? According to an internal Education Ministry document it's "fair" and we've been fooling ourselves that it's "great". The document, sighted by RNZ and understood to date from 2023, also sets out three options for improving the system by specifying through the curriculum what teachers teach and how they teach it. "Our data suggests that the New Zealand education system would be defined at the top of FAIR by McKinsey 2010 yet we have been behaving as if it is GREAT," it said. The McKinsey reference appeared to be to a report by an international consultancy firm that rated education systems from "poor" to "excellent" based on performance in OECD tests between 2000 and 2010. The report placed New Zealand at the top of "fair" along with countries including Armenia and Greece and behind Australia which was considered low in the "good" ranking. Despite steadily declining scores , New Zealand ranked 10th in reading, 11th in science and 23rd in maths in the most recently published OECD Pisa tests of 15-year-olds. The ministry's document said the introduction of a new curriculum in 2007 without sufficient support caused problems for schools. "As we sought to shift from great to excellent, the 2007 curriculum went straight from a detailed curriculum to a very open curriculum. It did so however, without providing the supports needed to maintain and build on system coherence and capability," it said. "Some schools with strong networks, resources, and accountabilities manage to perform well with minimal system supports but many of those carrying the weight of high needs and complex issues struggle. Teacher and learners both struggle." The options for increasing the level of prescription in the curriculum ranged from a high degree practiced in "developing nations including Rwanda" to allowing a balance between the national curriculum and local decision-making similar to schools in Scotland and British Columbia. The document said the most severe option was designed to move schools from poor to fair and the least severe from good to great. The middle option, for moving school systems from fair to good, would mandate the school-level curriculum including what would be taught and when, though schools would retain some ability to localise their curriculum. It said similar approaches were used in Australia and Alberta in Canada. The document said under-prescription left decisions with schools and teachers "who do not always have the capacity or expertise to select appropriate content or approaches". "This can contribute to learner under-achievement and exacerbate inequitable outcomes. The New Zealand curriculum environment shows evidence of under prescription in the highly variable quality of learning that students receive," it said. The paper said over-prescription limited the ability of schools to respond to learners and contexts and to be innovative. "Over time, over prescription may contribute to curriculum overcrowding and a focus on coverage rather than meaningful learning; this can contribute to poor learner outcomes," it said. "Prescribed curricula are also liable to become outdated and require monitoring and support to stay up-to-date. A primary rationale for the design of the 2007 curriculum was to address over prescription in previous curricula." The paper said over-prescription limited the ability of schools to respond to learners and contexts and to be innovative. Photo: RNZ / Mark Papalii The ministry did not tell RNZ which of the options was being followed. However, it said it had advised successive governments about the need to balance national direction with local flexibility. "While high autonomy suits systems with uniformly strong practice and outcomes, New Zealand's variable, inconsistent, and inequitable performance-particularly for Māori, Pacific, disabled and low socio economic students means our current high autonomy settings are not justified," acting curriculum centre leader Pauline Cleaver said. She said the previous government acted on the ministry's advice by starting to make the curriculum clearer about what all learners must know and do, and deciding to mandate a common practice model for how literacy and mathematics should be taught. "The current minister has continued that trajectory, starting with issuing detailed curriculum and teaching practice expectations for English (Years 0-6), Mathematics & Statistics (Years 0-8), Te Reo Rangatira (Years 0-6) and Pāngarau (Years 0-8)." Cleaver said the documents specified what students should learn over time, when and how key content must be taught, and how it should be assessed. Auckland University professor of curriculum and pedagogy Stuart McNaughton said New Zealand's results in international tests were relatively good, but its ability to improve was only fair. "In terms of the the quality judgement from the OECD in point of time and then over time, we're relatively good, relatively high quality," he said. "But having said that, it is also true to say that we have had some declines in achievement and we need to recognise those overall declines in achievement which have in some of the assessments come from high performing students not performing quite as highly," he said. "It is an unfair system and we have a real problem with our equity profile." McNaughton agreed a greater level of prescription was required in the curriculum to improve New Zealand's school system, but he worried it might be going too far in places. "It depends very much on the degree to which both content and teaching are prescribed because if you take it too far, you undermine the agency of the teacher, which is a great risk in a system that that prides itself on innovation and expertise, and the second risk is you've got to be really sure that you've got a good evidence-base for the content that you're providing," he said. McNaughton said the recently-introduced primary school English curriculum over-prescribed how the youngest children should be taught to read because years of evidence showed different children needed different approaches. Post Primary Teachers Association vice-president Kieran Gainsford said he agreed schools lost centrally-provided support in 2007. He said teachers were hopeful it would be restored under the current reforms, but worried the ministry might not be able to provide it and teachers would be left to introduce the new curriculum on their own. Principals Federation president Leanne Otene. Photo: Supplied Principals Federation president Leanne Otene said years of "flip-flopping" education policies had damaged the school system. "We have never been given an opportunity as a workforce to embed a curriculum and to really ensure that our workforce is confident and competent in the curriculum document and its teaching so that we can see improvement in student outcomes. We are just flip-flopping every time there's a change of government," she said. Otene said the problem was happening again with more than 70 percent of teachers and principals telling a recent NZEI survey that curriculum change was happening too fast. "At the moment that pace of change is overwhelming schools... Our principals who are leading teaching and learning for goodness sake, haven't even received any professional development yet and they are supposed to be leading these curriculum changes in their schools. So I would agree, we're not a world class education system," she said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

Canterbury Christian Schools Expanding
Canterbury Christian Schools Expanding

Scoop

time2 days ago

  • Scoop

Canterbury Christian Schools Expanding

Building project planning has started at two North Canterbury Christian schools, following approval to grow their school rolls. The Ministry of Education has granted permission to Rangiora New Life School and St Joseph's Catholic Primary School (Rangiora) to increase their maximum rolls. Rangiora New Life School will raise its roll from 470 to 570 students, while St Joseph's School will increase its roll from 175 to 225 over the next three years. The two schools have growing waiting lists as more families move to North Canterbury and seek a Christian education for their children. Schools throughout North Canterbury have experienced rapid growth over the last decade, as communities struggle to keep up with growing housing developments. St Joseph's board of trustees presiding member Emma Dangerfield said it is the first time in 25 years the school has been able to increase its roll, despite the growing population. ''The Catholic Parish of Waimakariri has also seen growth in the number of active members. ''While we are grateful to achieve the maximum roll increase, we are conscious it is unlikely to exceed the demand we have for enrolments.'' Ms Dangerfield said the school will build six new classrooms, as it takes the opportunity to replace some ageing teaching spaces. The new classrooms will be built next to the playing field, off Percival Street, while classrooms on the George Street / Victoria Street corner will be decommissioned at a later date. The school aims to have the work completed next year. Rangiora New Life School principal Stephen Walters said ground works got under way during the recent school holidays for six new classrooms, a resource room and an extension to the administration block. ''I'm excited. We're not reliant on Ministry funding or oversight, so we just have to meet council regulations. ''We will have it done swiftly by the middle of next year and probably earlier. ''It is very exciting times for us. It is a real blessing to be able to add more space for Christian families in North Canterbury.'' Mr Walters said the school has been carrying waiting lists for a number of years. ''It's always lovely to make the call to those families and offer them a space.'' The bulk of the new places will be offered to primary students at the year 1 to 13 school. But Mr Walters said there are already plans to apply for a further roll increase for the secondary end of the school in three years time. Students come to Rangiora New Life School from anywhere between the Hurunui and Waimakariri rivers, with 40 percent travelling to school by bus. ''I encourage people, that we've got good local schools, but if you are a Christian family we are an option for you,'' Mr Walters said. The two schools are special character schools, with elected boards of trustees and operate the same way as state schools, receiving Ministry funding for staff and resourcing. As the Ministry does not pay for the buildings, local churches own the buildings and recover the cost through school fees.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store