Hotel Guard Suspended, Accused of Asking Woman in Bathroom to Prove Gender
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources.
Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content.
A security guard at a Boston hotel was suspended after being accused of forcibly removing a woman from a bathroom after confronting her about her gender, the hotel confirmed to Newsweek.
Why It Matters
The incident, which stirred backlash against the Liberty Hotel in Boston's Beacon Hill neighborhood, comes amid what many LGBTQ+ people view as a rise in anti-trans rhetoric, particularly surrounding transgender women's access to women's bathrooms. Critics have warned that the rising tensions could have ramifications for all women, regardless of whether they are transgender.
What To Know
Elizabeth Victor wrote in a since-removed Google review that she and her girlfriend, Ansley Baker, attended a Kentucky Derby party at the luxury hotel on Saturday. She wrote that Baker, described as a "6-foot tall, short haired woman," was "forcibly removed from the woman's restroom" by a staff member who required them to show her ID to prove her gender.
Bathroom signage is pictured in San Ramon, California, on July 20, 2017.
Bathroom signage is pictured in San Ramon, California, on July 20, 2017.
Smith Collection/Gado/Getty Images
"This was not just unprofessional — it was traumatizing, discriminatory, and dehumanizing," the review wrote. "My partner and I are devastated."
In a statement provided to Newsweek, the hotel confirmed the guard had been suspended following an investigation.
"The Liberty Hotel is and always will be an ally of the LGBTQ+ community and a place where everyone is welcome and celebrated," the statement reads. "We will continue to educate and train our team to ensure that everyone feels safe and accepted within our four walls and guests who do not show tolerance and acceptance towards others will be removed."
Contact information for Baker and Victor could not be found. Newsweek reached out to a family member for comment via Facebook.
But CBS News reported that the hotel previously said that "several women alerted security of two adults sharing a bathroom stall," but the couple have denied they were ever in a stall together.
What People Are Saying
Nina Selvaggio, executive director of the Greater Boston PFLAG, told CBS News: "For gender nonconforming, lesbians, women in general, being harassed in public restrooms is a tale as old as time. I do think the surge in national anti-trans rhetoric is contributing to an increased policing of women's bodies and their expression of gender."
The couple told WCVB: "We have not seen any public statement with an apology nor a retraction of their original claims to clarify that Ansley was the only one in the stall."
What Happens Next
In addition to the suspension, the hotel said it would reach out to Baker and Victor, conduct mandatory retraining for all staff members on inclusive practices starting next week and make a donation to a local LGBTQ+ organization they have partnered with in the past, according to the statement provided to Newsweek.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
4 hours ago
- Newsweek
Puppy Dumped Outside Woman's Home, Hearts Break as She's 'Literally Smiling'
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. An 8-week-old brown puppy dumped outside a home has captured the hearts of thousands online—especially after she was spotted smiling through her ordeal. Brooke Harris, 28, who lives in Dallas, Texas, shared the story on TikTok (@13rookeharris), where the video quickly gained traction, reaching over 203,000 views and thousands of likes. "We were so upset that someone could do this to an innocent baby, but we were so relieved she happened to be placed in front of our homes," Harris told Newsweek. Harris said that she and her neighbors first discovered the puppy after one of them noticed an unfamiliar truck parked outside and asked about it in their neighborhood WhatsApp group. When the truck's owner—a neighbor's boyfriend—was identified, another neighbor responded by posting a photo of the puppy curled up in the bed of the truck. Harris said the puppy had clearly been dumped, as there was no way she could have climbed in herself. A bowl of water had been left with her. A split image of the dumped dog in the truck; and in the yard. A split image of the dumped dog in the truck; and in the yard. @13rookeharris/@13rookeharris "She's literally smiling," Harris wrote as the text overlaying the video of the image of the pup looking like she was grinning. Fortunately, the woman whose boyfriend owned the truck took the puppy into her home. Her boyfriend, who is a veterinarian, checked the pup over. She was covered in fleas and ticks, but he had the appropriate medication and bath products to treat her. Harris and the other neighbors, all dog lovers, quickly came together to support the puppy. "Me and neighbor 1 have dogs, so we brought over a bed, food, bones, and toys to keep her happy until we figure out what to do with her," she said. "She is the sweetest little pup ever, so innocent and so happy to be around people. We really wanted to make the best decision on her rehoming." After sharing the photo of the puppy in the truck bed on her Instagram story, a friend suggested Harris post it to TikTok to reach a wider audience. The response was overwhelming. "The TikTok unexpectedly blew up, and I had about 10 to 15 people asking to adopt her," Harris said. After considering several offers, Harris and her neighbors agreed to place the puppy with a woman who already had a female dog and a large backyard. She frequently takes her dog hiking and on trips, and the group felt confident she would give the puppy the loving home she deserved. "Her new owner has been updating us with pictures, and she's settling in so great already and gets along with her new sister perfectly," Harris added. Reflecting on the whirlwind of emotions the experience brought, Harris said: "How we felt about the whole situation was a mixture of mad, sad, and happy. We were so upset that someone could do this to an innocent baby, but we were so relieved she happened to be placed in front of our homes. "The three of us are big animal lovers, and it just worked out perfectly. Now this pup gets a second shot at life. It was a very rewarding experience to be able to do something good for the world," Harris added. TikTok users flooded the comments with gratitude and heartbreak. "Thank you for helping this sweet baby!" one user wrote. "I hope she went to a good home," said another. "How could they hurt this baby angel please lord God help this baby angel," commented one viewer. "She smiled at you, why didn't you just say 'stay' you even took the picture," another user posted. "Some Humans are not humane. Thank you for helping," added Moe. Do you have funny and adorable videos or pictures of your pet you want to share? Send them to life@ with some details about your best friend, and they could appear in our Pet of the Week lineup.
Yahoo
11 hours ago
- Yahoo
San Francisco's aggressive push to get more unhoused people off city streets
San Francisco — One day in May, Reily was the latest unhoused person in San Francisco to be caught up in the city's year-long aggressive enforcement tactics. Involved in the arrest was San Francisco police Sgt. Dennis Hoang, the department's homeless unit supervisor. "I asked Reily how many times they've been cited for illegal lodging, and they times," Hoang told CBS News. "We're at a point where we are no longer tolerating chronic illegal behavior." In mid-2024, San Francisco began more targeted sweeps of homeless encampments across the city in an effort to address its homeless crisis. "These public sidewalks are for the public," Hoang said. "And, unfortunately, it's not a place for people to store their personal belongings." Between June of 2024 and June of this year, nearly 1,000 people have been arrested or cited for illegal camping in San Francisco, according to city data, but few are ever charged. "I'm going to get kicked out of the shelter," Reily told CBS News. "I'm going to come back on the street. I'm going to get cited again, it's a broken system." Unhoused people who spoke to CBS News said some of the shelters do not fit their needs for a variety of reasons, such as dormitory-style housing that requires having roommates, no storage for personal possessions and no pets allowed. Arrests are a last resort, conducted only if the person repeatedly ignores citations and refuses the city's multiple offers of shelter and services. The city's efforts seem to have paid off with visible results. Nearly half of the 8,000 homeless that live in San Francisco are sheltered, per city data, up 35% from 2019. In San Francisco's Mission District, police and city workers are faced with tense and emotional challenges. Jeff, who didn't want to share his last name, was upset by his arrest. He said he sleeps outdoors by "choice." "I'm getting their help already," said Jeff when asked by CBS News why he refused assistance and resources from the city. "Where does that lead me?" Democratic San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie, who took office in January, was elected by voters frustrated by the city's large homeless encampments and its soaring crime rates. Despite the crackdown on homeless encampments, Lurie contends that it is "absolutely not" the city's view that it is a crime to be either poor or homeless in San Francisco. "Our focus is getting people off the street and into shelter and into mental health and drug treatment beds," Lurie told CBS News. "We lead with services," Lurie said. "We lead with our values, which is taking care of people." He believes his tough-on-crime policies and focus on rehabilitation have created safer public spaces. "We're getting a lot of business leaders engaged and involved in the city in a way that they haven't been for a long time," Lurie said. "And there's this feeling of hope and optimism." What to know about President Trump's travel ban on nationals from 12 countries Trump says he's disappointed by Musk criticism of budget bill, Musk says he got Trump elected Is Tren de Aragua gang overwhelming police in Aurora, Colorado?
CBS News
12 hours ago
- CBS News
San Francisco's aggressive push to get more unhoused people off city streets
San Francisco — One day in May, Reily was the latest unhoused person in San Francisco to be caught up in the city's year-long aggressive enforcement tactics. Involved in the arrest was San Francisco police Sgt. Dennis Hoang, the department's homeless unit supervisor. "I asked Reily how many times they've been cited for illegal lodging, and they times," Hoang told CBS News. "We're at a point where we are no longer tolerating chronic illegal behavior." In mid-2024, San Francisco began more targeted sweeps of homeless encampments across the city in an effort to address its homeless crisis. "These public sidewalks are for the public," Hoang said. "And, unfortunately, it's not a place for people to store their personal belongings." Between June of 2024 and June of this year, nearly 1,000 people have been arrested or cited for illegal camping in San Francisco, according to city data, but few are ever charged. "I'm going to get kicked out of the shelter," Reily told CBS News. "I'm going to come back on the street. I'm going to get cited again, it's a broken system." Unhoused people who spoke to CBS News said some of the shelters do not fit their needs for a variety of reasons, such as dormitory-style housing that requires having roommates, no storage for personal possessions and no pets allowed. Arrests are a last resort, conducted only if the person repeatedly ignores citations and refuses the city's multiple offers of shelter and services. The city's efforts seem to have paid off with visible results. Nearly half of the 8,000 homeless that live in San Francisco are sheltered, per city data, up 35% from 2019. In San Francisco's Mission District, police and city workers are faced with tense and emotional challenges. Jeff, who didn't want to share his last name, was upset by his arrest. He said he sleeps outdoors by "choice." "I'm getting their help already," said Jeff when asked by CBS News why he refused assistance and resources from the city. "Where does that lead me?" Democratic San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie, who took office in January, was elected by voters frustrated by the city's large homeless encampments and its soaring crime rates. Despite the crackdown on homeless encampments, Lurie contends that it is "absolutely not" the city's view that it is a crime to be either poor or homeless in San Francisco. "Our focus is getting people off the street and into shelter and into mental health and drug treatment beds," Lurie told CBS News. "We lead with services," Lurie said. "We lead with our values, which is taking care of people." He believes his tough-on-crime policies and focus on rehabilitation have created safer public spaces. "We're getting a lot of business leaders engaged and involved in the city in a way that they haven't been for a long time," Lurie said. "And there's this feeling of hope and optimism."
