Plans to limit Airbnb-style lets delayed over fears it would 'kill' tourism
Proposals to introduce a Highland-wide restriction on holiday lets have been delayed amid concerns it could 'kill off' tourism in the region.
The blanket proposals would have implemented measures that would have seen applications for short-term lets scrutinised more intensely by council officers.
However, councillors instead opted for a more 'pragmatic' and 'sensible' approach, which would allow local areas the power to decide on restrictions.
Rural councillors accused the proposals of letting Inverness 'make decisions for them' and resulted in the city councillors' proposal being withdrawn until a later date.
Councillors ultimately found an alternative proposal, originally tabled by Aird and Loch Ness councillor Chris Ballance, to be more appropriate.
His proposal, which was spearheaded by vice convenor Ken Gowans, delayed any blanket control zone of short-term lets until council officers could prepare a report on the consequences.
His suggestion was supported by other councillors such as Wester Ross' Biz Campbell, who said: 'We do not cut off the hand that feeds us.'
The plans would also give councillors the chance to implement local area restrictions, as have been successfully implemented in the Badenoch and Strathspey area.
Councillor Gowans said the more tentative approach, which could still result in an overall clampdown across the region in the future, was 'pragmatic' and 'sensible.'
In support of a scrapping the blanket ban, Skye councillor John Finlayson said: 'The introduction of any short-term let control areas across Highland should only be considered at a local level.'
He said: 'No area, no local members and no communities need Inverness or other councillors from other areas to make decisions for them.'
Fellow Skye councillor Ruraidh Stewart said the proposals could 'kill off Highland tourism,' but asked to scrap all restrictions on short-term lets as the current legislation 'has brought out the worst in communities.'
Inverness councillor Michael Gregson told councillors the traditional Highland bed and breakfast experience was being lost to Airbnb-style visits with 'no welcome.'
He said problems with housing in the Highlands are being created by companies buying multiple properties for short-term lets, and houses that could be used as homes lay empty.
Councillor Gregson added: 'We are losing what could be valuable income in non-domestic rates and council tax.'
Inverness councillor Duncan Macpherson said locals who feel like they are living next to 'miniature hotels' have 'no recourse' against the coming and going of visitors to their area of residence.
However, after a period of debate in the chamber, they later agreed to withdraw their proposals.
Inverness councillors Michael Gregson and Duncan Macpherson brought forward proposals in the hope it would tighten controls on short-term lets across the Highlands.
They argued that the 7,011 short-term lets that have been approved, compared to just four refusals, highlight the scale of holiday lets across the region and a lack of action to restrict them.
As part of their proposal, the council would have asked the Scottish Government to review short-term let licensing to allow applications to be rejected on the grounds of 'overprovision.'
They also believed the council did not have enough powers with the current licensing legislation to reject applications.
Edinburgh was the first council area to introduce the stricter controls back in 2022.
In the Highlands, the Badenoch and Strathspey ward brought a control zone into their area last year.
A short-term let control zone gives councils extra powers to manage short-term lets in an area that is particularly popular with holiday lets.
While all holiday let hopefuls have to apply for a short-term let licence, in a control zone, applicants also need to apply for planning permission, which further scrutinises their proposals.
A council report identifying how individual areas could implement restrictions similar to Badenoch and Strathspey will be prepared for September.
The report will also include further information on a region-wide Highland clampdown of short-term lets, which could still be implemented.
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
STV News
6 hours ago
- STV News
Plans to limit Airbnb-style lets delayed over fears it would 'kill' tourism
Proposals to introduce a Highland-wide restriction on holiday lets have been delayed amid concerns it could 'kill off' tourism in the region. The blanket proposals would have implemented measures that would have seen applications for short-term lets scrutinised more intensely by council officers. However, councillors instead opted for a more 'pragmatic' and 'sensible' approach, which would allow local areas the power to decide on restrictions. Rural councillors accused the proposals of letting Inverness 'make decisions for them' and resulted in the city councillors' proposal being withdrawn until a later date. Councillors ultimately found an alternative proposal, originally tabled by Aird and Loch Ness councillor Chris Ballance, to be more appropriate. His proposal, which was spearheaded by vice convenor Ken Gowans, delayed any blanket control zone of short-term lets until council officers could prepare a report on the consequences. His suggestion was supported by other councillors such as Wester Ross' Biz Campbell, who said: 'We do not cut off the hand that feeds us.' The plans would also give councillors the chance to implement local area restrictions, as have been successfully implemented in the Badenoch and Strathspey area. Councillor Gowans said the more tentative approach, which could still result in an overall clampdown across the region in the future, was 'pragmatic' and 'sensible.' In support of a scrapping the blanket ban, Skye councillor John Finlayson said: 'The introduction of any short-term let control areas across Highland should only be considered at a local level.' He said: 'No area, no local members and no communities need Inverness or other councillors from other areas to make decisions for them.' Fellow Skye councillor Ruraidh Stewart said the proposals could 'kill off Highland tourism,' but asked to scrap all restrictions on short-term lets as the current legislation 'has brought out the worst in communities.' Inverness councillor Michael Gregson told councillors the traditional Highland bed and breakfast experience was being lost to Airbnb-style visits with 'no welcome.' He said problems with housing in the Highlands are being created by companies buying multiple properties for short-term lets, and houses that could be used as homes lay empty. Councillor Gregson added: 'We are losing what could be valuable income in non-domestic rates and council tax.' Inverness councillor Duncan Macpherson said locals who feel like they are living next to 'miniature hotels' have 'no recourse' against the coming and going of visitors to their area of residence. However, after a period of debate in the chamber, they later agreed to withdraw their proposals. Inverness councillors Michael Gregson and Duncan Macpherson brought forward proposals in the hope it would tighten controls on short-term lets across the Highlands. They argued that the 7,011 short-term lets that have been approved, compared to just four refusals, highlight the scale of holiday lets across the region and a lack of action to restrict them. As part of their proposal, the council would have asked the Scottish Government to review short-term let licensing to allow applications to be rejected on the grounds of 'overprovision.' They also believed the council did not have enough powers with the current licensing legislation to reject applications. Edinburgh was the first council area to introduce the stricter controls back in 2022. In the Highlands, the Badenoch and Strathspey ward brought a control zone into their area last year. A short-term let control zone gives councils extra powers to manage short-term lets in an area that is particularly popular with holiday lets. While all holiday let hopefuls have to apply for a short-term let licence, in a control zone, applicants also need to apply for planning permission, which further scrutinises their proposals. A council report identifying how individual areas could implement restrictions similar to Badenoch and Strathspey will be prepared for September. The report will also include further information on a region-wide Highland clampdown of short-term lets, which could still be implemented. Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Telegraph
9 hours ago
- Telegraph
Fury at plans to turn Canterbury Cathedral entrance into Airbnb
Canterbury Cathedral's historic entrance could be transformed into an Airbnb-style holiday let, prompting criticism of the 'Church's continued commercialisation'. Christ Church Gate, built in the early 16th century, serves as the main entrance to Canterbury Cathedral and is one of the most photographed Christian landmarks in the country. However, church authorities have proposed to convert the historic tower into 'unrivalled' Airbnb-style accommodation featuring a one-bedroom apartment featuring an open-plan kitchen and living room, a biofuel fire, a breakfast bar and two lavatories. The Dean and Chapter of Canterbury described the accommodation, which would replace office space on the first and second floors, as 'high quality' and said that it would provide a long-term use for the building. However, the plans to transform the Grade-I-listed gate, which is the main entrance to the cathedral and believed to have been built between 1504 and 1521, have divided Christians as well as members of the local community. Dr Gavin Ashenden, former chaplain to the late Queen Elizabeth II, who has since converted to Catholicism, described this as the 'continued commercialisation' of the Church. Dr Ashenden, who was a choral scholar at King's Canterbury, said: 'As The Church of England continues its meltdown, it's no surprise that they have to go to ever increasing links to raise money. 'To give credit where it is due, at least turning this famous cathedral gateway into an Airbnb doesn't involve the degree of blasphemy and irresponsibility that some of the other money making ventures like turning the cathedral into a nightclub involved. Perhaps local residents should be grateful. It's just Airbnb rather than a casino.' Hilary Brian, chair of the Canterbury Society, branded the idea 'outrageous' and urged Cathedral authorities to change their minds. 'The gate is such an important piece of Canterbury's history, and it should be preserved,' she told Kent Online. 'It seems such a shame to see one of the city's biggest landmarks disregarded in this way.' 'Centuries-old practice of hospitality' A Canterbury Cathedral spokesperson said: 'The best long-term way to care for our historic buildings, and ensure that they are maintained for future generations, is for them to be used and loved by residents and visitors. 'The rooms in the Gate remain unrefurbished and, in their current condition, are of limited use. 'As we consider how these rooms could be used, the Cathedral is working closely with historic building specialists, conservation architects and planners to bring them into use. 'This will help us continue our centuries-old practice of hospitality and welcome as we seek to serve the wider community, both here in Canterbury, and across the world. We are looking to share more information as plans unfold.' Purcell Architects, the company which would transform the historic building, said in documents submitted to the council: 'It is clear from the layout and fixtures, including the large fireplaces and windows originally with shutters, that they were designed for domestic use.' This is not the first time that cathedrals have been accused of becoming increasingly secularised and commercialised. In 2019 Southwark Cathedral was accused of promoting the ' antithesis of the Christian gospel ' by allowing its nave to be used as a catwalk to sell clothes by fashion designer, Julien MacDonald. Norwich Cathedral also faced criticism for 'treating God like a tourist attraction' after it installed a 55-ft helter skelter in its nave.
Daily Record
10 hours ago
- Daily Record
Senior member of Anas Sarwar's shadow cabinet 'opposed' to Labour welfare cuts bill
EXCLUSIVE: A senior party figure said Duncan-Glancy is angry about the cuts being proposed. A member of Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar 's shadow cabinet is opposed to Keir Starmer's welfare cuts for disabled people. A senior party figure said Pam Duncan-Glancy is against a Labour Government bill campaigners warn will cost the vulnerable hundreds of pounds a year. The insider said the education spokeswoman, a permanent wheelchair user, is angry about the plans. They said: 'Pam has brought her lived experience to bear in leading the internal campaign against disability cuts. She has consistently made the strongest case against the cuts and has the ear of senior government figures.' The Prime Ministe r is under mounting pressure over a welfare bill that would cut around £5bn from disability and sickness benefits. A number of the benefit changes are UK-wide and the cuts are forecast to plunge 50,0000 children into poverty. But the bill could be dumped after over 100 Labour MPs, twelve from Scotland, backed an amendment that would torpedo the whole package. A party insider said Duncan-Glancy's opposition showed the Labour shadow cabinet at Holyrood is split over the plans. When approached, Scottish Labour released a statement in Duncan-Glancy's name. She said: 'Everybody agrees reform is needed to address the structural challenges in the system, but those reforms need to be fair. 'Labour's plans include positives, for example increasing the Universal Credit standard allowance, scrapping the Work Capability Assessment, introducing a 'right to try', and investing £1 billion in employability support.'Disabled people are raising their concerns and it's right that people work to ensure these reforms deliver on Labour's ambitions to fix a broken system and support disabled people.' Sarwar has so far walked a careful line between backing the principles of welfare reform while encouraging Starmer to listen to concerns. In a Holyrood Sources podcast, Sarwar said of the bill: 'I support the principle of reform.' 'We do have to look at the structural challenges that exist in our welfare system.' He also said there are ' many positives ' in the bill, such as £1bn for back to work schemes. Asked if he agreed with the rebels, Sarwar said: 'Conversations are ongoing, as you would expect. People are legitimately raising their concerns, having those conversations.' He added: 'We have to support the principle of reform. What those reforms look like have to be balanced and have to be fair.' His comments are milder than the criticisms of mayors Sadiq Khan and Andy Burnham. Meanwhile, Starmer is in talks with Labour rebels over concessions to save the welfare reform package. Sir Keir told MPs there was 'consensus" across the House on the "urgent need for reform' of the 'broken' welfare system. 'I know colleagues across the House are eager to start fixing that, and so am I, and that all colleagues want to get this right, and so do I,' he said. 'We want to see reform implemented with Labour values of fairness. That conversation will continue in the coming days, so we can begin making change together on Tuesday.' SNP MSP George Adam said: "The UK Labour government is slashing vital support for disabled people and under Anas Sarwar's leadership, Scottish Labour is rowing in behind them. "So far, Anas Sarwar has faithfully backed his Westminster bosses - but a growing number of his own colleagues have finally seen the irreparable damage these cuts will do. "While Scottish Labour won't stand up for Scotland, the SNP has called for the cuts to be scrapped. "The people of Scotland deserve far better than continued Westminster austerity. Only with the full powers of independence can Scotland escape Westminster's austerity obsession." A key element of the welfare package is freezing the rate of the health element of Universal Credit and Employment and Support Allowance payments until 2030. In a briefing to parliamentarians, the Trussell charity estimated that there are nearly 300,000 people receiving these payments in Scotland: "All would stand to be affected by the freeze which by 2029/30 amounts to [a] real terms cut of £500 per year.' The Scottish Labour MP sceptics are Richard Baker, Scott Arthur, Euan Stainbank, Brian Leishman, Lilian Jones, Tracy Gilbert and Elaine Stewart. Kirsteen Sullivan, Patricia Ferguson, Martin Rhodes, Maureen Burke and Irene Campbell are also opposed.
