Attempt to strip historic Glasgow Vogue cinema's listed status fails
It was then granted listed status by Historic Environment Scotland following an inspection, only for this to be appealed by owners Allied Vehicles.
The Scottish Government's reporter has now thrown out that appeal, after considering the 'cultural significance' of the cinema and its unique, historic architecture.
The reporter's investigation has now been made public. Dismissing the appeal, they said: 'In the circumstances of this case, I find that what remains of the building is of special architectural and historic interest.
'There are no factors which would justify the building not being listed. Consequently, the building should remain listed.'
The Art Deco Vogue opened in 1933 (Image: NQ) With a storied history serving the community of Possilpark, the Vogue was built in 1933 to a design by the renowned architect James McKissak, and has been used as a cinema and bingo hall.
Much of the building has become derelict, but the front structure remains, as do some of the architectural features.
Now the appeal has been dismissed, the building will be subject to strict controls and will be protected from demolition unless it become too dangerous to leave standing.
The owners will also have a duty to preserve what remains.
The report said: 'I have considered the building's design, architecture, age and rarity; its setting and historical location, function and importance; and its social and cultural significance together with the changes over time which have altered the building and its surrounds.
'I agree with HES that cinemas as a building type were once common across Scotland but those surviving from the 1930s period are now exceptional.
Architect Professor Alan Dunlop, who has been vocal in his support of retaining the cinema, said he was 'delighted' the appeal had been rejected.
The architect believes it is now time for a 'reasonable compromise' to resolve the situation, and called for the owner to submit a new planning application which preserves what remains of the building.
Professor Alan Dunlop outside the Vogue Cinema (Image: NQ) Prof Dunlop, a Fellow Royal Incorporation of Architects in Scotland, said: 'As someone born in Springburn and who lived just off Hawthorn Street, close to the junction of Balmore Road, the Vogue Cinema was distinctive and it marked an important road junction.
'The Springburn that I knew, particularly Springburn Road which was once a thriving shopping and community street, has been destroyed, The Princess Cinema on Gourley Street and many other buildings of architectural merit have been demolished.
'Possilpark now seems to be suffering the same fate. The Vogue Cinema is not a classic but it is the only building of any character and architectural worth left in this area of Possilpark and certainly worthy of retaining.'
He added: 'As an architect with forty years experience of building major projects, including working with listed buildings and on conservation projects, bringing them back to life, I know this building can be and should be saved.
'Granting the appeal would have created an unwelcome precedent and perverse incentive for any owner to unilaterally seek to demolish a building that is subject to a designation assessment before Historic Environment Scotland has had the opportunity to conclude its assessment.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
Ann Seth obituary
My mother, Ann Seth, who has died aged 90, worked for decades as an English and history teacher before she decided to develop her interest in art instead. In 1981 she enrolled for a second degree in visual studies at Oxford Polytechnic, where she became hooked on photography. She went on to exhibit a series of multimedia installations, using innovative methods such as infrared film and stereoscopy. On one occasion in the mid-1980s she took over the former St Paul's church in Jericho, Oxford (now known as Freud's cafe) filling it with triptychs, sculpture and abstract photography. Her artistic interests turned increasingly towards landscape photography. In the early 2000s she was commissioned by Oxfordshire county council to document the beautiful countryside across the south of the county. This was one of her favourite jobs, allowing her to spend time at White Horse Hill near Uffington, one of her most beloved places. Ann was born in York and grew up as bombs fell on the wartime city. Her father, Fred Delaney, an Irish immigrant who dreamed of becoming a professional footballer, was called up at the start of the second world war, and was among the thousands of servicemen listed missing in the sinking of the RMS Lancastria troopship in 1940. He never returned. Ann, an only child, was brought up by her mother, Edith (nee Glenn), who scraped a living doing clerical work around York. Home life was lonely, but Ann loved school and she especially loved books, devouring five each week from York's library. Encouraged by her headteacher at the Bar Convent school, she applied to university, the first in her family to do so. In 1953 she arrived to study English literature at Sheffield, where she met Bhola Seth, a young Indian engineer studying for a PhD. They married in 1960, a time when mixed marriages were rare. After graduating, Ann and Seth (as he was always known) moved first to Tyneside, where Ann taught at Blyth grammar school, and then in 1962 they arrived in Oxfordshire, where they remained for the rest of their lives. Seth worked at the Esso Research Centre near Abingdon, while Ann taught history at a secondary school in Didcot. Her social life revolved around sport – badminton and tennis – and theatre, which remained one of Ann's great loves. They also made frequent trips to the Lake District, where Ann slowly introduced Seth to the joys of fell-walking. The couple continued to visit the Lakes throughout their marriage, climbing 70 separate 'Wainwrights' in Ann's 70th year. After Seth died in 2013, Ann spent more time in and around her home village of Letcombe Regis, where she became increasingly active in Green party politics. As her health began to fail, her village walks became shorter and she eventually settled for excursions around her back garden, walking determinedly up and down the lawn ('doing the rounds'), and sitting under the old apple tree. The dedication of her long-term carer, Lynette, enabled her to remain at home until the end of her life. She is survived by me.
The Independent
2 days ago
- The Independent
Rare Barbara Hepworth work to be displayed in public for first time
A rare 1943 sculpture by Yorkshire -born artist Barbara Hepworth, titled Sculpture with Colour (Oval Form) Pale Blue and Red, has been acquired for permanent public display. A total of £3.8 million was raised to secure the artwork, following a temporary export bar that prevented it from leaving the UK last year. The fundraising appeal was led by The Hepworth Wakefield and national charity Art Fund, with major contributions from the National Lottery Heritage Fund, Art Fund, and over 2,800 public donations. Having been in private ownership for decades, the wooden carving will now be publicly exhibited for the first time at The Hepworth Wakefield in West Yorkshire, the artist's birthplace. The piece is one of only a few wooden carvings Hepworth created in the 1940s and the first to use strings, reflecting her adaptability during wartime in Cornwall.
Times
3 days ago
- Times
Snow cats, sunrises — and other gems from Edinburgh's photo exhibition
The 161st Edinburgh International Photography Exhibition is at Edinburgh Photographic Society at 68 Great King Street, Edinburgh, until August 24
