NPA petitions the Supreme Court of Appeal over Cholota ruling appeal
The National Prosecuting Authority has petitioned the Supreme Court of Appeal following a controversial dismissal by the Free State Division of the High Court, Bloemfontein on its application for leave to appeal.
The petition, filed on Monday, comes after Judge Loubser dismissed the NPA's request for the judge to reserve questions of law under Section 319 of the Criminal Procedure Act.
The ruling has drawn attention as it relates to the jurisdictional authority of the Free State Division of the High Court to hear the case against Moraidi Cholota, who has been implicated in the ongoing asbestos scandal that has plagued the region.
The court found that it has no jurisdiction to try the former Free State premier Ace Magashule's personal assistant in the R255-million asbestos case, as her extradition from the United States of America was unlawful.
NPA national spokesperson, Mthunzi Mhaga, said the judge's decision not only undermined the legal process but also initiated a potential gap in justice surrounding the serious allegations presented in the case.
"The NPA is of the firm view that the Honourable judge erred in dismissing the application for leave to appeal, and that there are reasonable prospects of success to appeal the Cholota judgment, and that there are compelling reasons for the SCA to hear our appeal.
"We are also exploring the possibility of approaching the Constitutional Court, challenging the same judgment, given the possible far-reaching implications on many other extradition matters," said Mhaga.
It is important to note that during the previous trial within a trial concerning the jurisdiction issue, the merits of the state's case against Cholota were neither adjudicated nor formally assessed.
This withdrawal from a full examination has led the NPA to maintain that the charges she faces remain viable and can be substantiated in a subsequent trial.
sinenhlanhla.masilela@iol.co.za
IOL News
Get your news on the go, click here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
4 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
NSFAS' R2.5m-a-month luxury offices hit by ceiling collapse, flooding
The National Student Financial Aid Scheme is forking out more than R2.5m a month for its swanky Cape Town headquarters, but the building's ceiling has collapsed, floors have been flooded and staff say unsafe conditions persist. Unions are now demanding proof that the space is safe before returning. The National Student Financial Aid Scheme (NSFAS) is spending more than R2.5-million a month on rent for its five floors in the glossy Halyard building on Cape Town's Foreshore. Yet staff were left stunned last week when a burst pipe caused the ceiling to collapse, flooding carpets and almost destroying computers. The incident occurred on the 17th floor in the early hours of Wednesday, 13 August 2025. Workers were not in the office at the time, and sources who work there say the damage could have caused panic and injury had they been present. 'The roof (ceiling) collapsed in the early hours of Wednesday morning; no one was at the office. The roof fell on PCs (computers); the pieces of the roof were on desks, and there was water. Before this, the workers were smelling diesel, but the health and safety officer downplayed this and said this came from the harbour and had nothing to do with the building,' said a female worker, who spoke to Daily Maverick anonymously. An internal NSFAS email dated 18 August, seen by Daily Maverick, said the incident was 'caused by a burst sprinkler pipe due to a mechanical failure in the sprinkler pump room, resulting in pressure build-up and subsequent rupture on the 17th floor. No diesel pipes are installed or present on the 17th floor.' The email also noted that repairs had been completed. Staff remain unconvinced 'We refrain from coming to the office until we are satisfied that our constituency can go back to the institution… The sprinklers damaged computers, and the carpet was wet,' said another source, adding that the 17th floor houses more than 100 employees, including 50 interns. The NSFAS branch of the National Education, Health and Allied Workers' Union has now intervened. Branch chairperson Linda Mcetywa said no staff under the membership of the union should return until the union is satisfied that the building meets safety standards: 'We said that there is no way that we can allow any staff member of NSFAS to come and occupy the building until certificates of compliance have been issued to the trade union. This certificate is supposed to come from the Department of Labour.' Read more: NSFAS battles backlogs, staff and tech woes as MPs criticise R2m rent for swish Cape Town offices. She added that despite the steep rental bill, the offices are not even disability friendly. 'And also remember NSFAS has a facility for working that is called the working centre to allow students who are residing within our proximity to come and enquire about any matters related to funding. You could imagine that even students who may have disabilities cannot access the building because the building itself is not disability friendly.' The ceiling collapse comes after workers staged a three-day picket outside the building this month, demanding action against alleged corruption, mismanagement and poor working conditions. NSFAS responds NSFAS spokesperson Ishmael Mnisi confirmed the incident but downplayed its impact. 'This was a technical malfunction that could not reasonably have been foreseen or prevented. The fault has since been fully repaired by a professional company appointed by the property owner,' he said. 'No NSFAS equipment or furniture was damaged. Following a full inspection by ICT, all systems and devices were found to be operational. The sprinkler pipe was repaired before 11am on the same day, and the affected carpeted areas were vacuumed and steam-cleaned by the landlord's contractors.' He added that 'comprehensive remediation has been undertaken, including replacement of damaged ceiling boards, secondary deep cleaning of the affected areas, and ongoing use of humidifiers to ensure the space remains dry.' Regarding ongoing staff complaints about the lifts, Mnisi said these remained the landlord's responsibility. 'We can confirm that the lifts underwent their most recent scheduled service on 4 August 2025.' Staff members are working remotely until the union receives a certificate confirming that the environment is safe. DM
The Citizen
4 hours ago
- The Citizen
Former rhino conservationist among six accused in horn trafficking
Former rhino conservationist among six accused in horn trafficking Six accused, including the founder of a rhino conservation enterprise, appeared in the Pretoria Magistrate's Court in connection with an international rhino horn trafficking syndicate, reportedly worth R250-million. They were all granted bail and are expected to return to court on December 9. The group is facing 55 charges, which include multiple counts of racketeering, fraud, contravention of the National Environmental Management Biodiversity Act (NEMBA), involving 964 rhino horns, contravention of the Riotous Assemblies Act, theft, and money laundering. The accused are: – John Frederick Hume (83), the founder and former owner of the Platinum Rhino Conservation Enterprise. – Clive John Mervan Melville (63), a transport maintenance manager. – Izak Hermanus du Toit (50), a practising attorney. – Elizabeth Catharina van Niekerk (58), a director of a non-profit organisation. – Mattheus Hendrikus Wessels Poggenpoel (37), an insurance broker and part-time farmer. – Johannes Abraham Hennop (52), a game reserve manager. Bail was set at R100 000 for Hume, R10 000 each for Melville and Van Niekerk, and R20 000 each for Du Toit, Poggenpoel, and Hennop. National Prosecuting Authority's spokesperson Lumka Mahanjana said it is alleged that between 2017 and 2024, the accused operated an international rhino horn trafficking syndicate and defrauded the Department of Forestry, Fisheries, and the Environment (DFFE). 'They allegedly obtained permits to trade rhino horn locally, while intending to channel the horns into illegal international markets in South-east Asia.' Mahanjana stated that the fraudulent scheme is estimated to have involved 964 rhino horns, valued at R250-million. 'After intensive investigations by the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation's (DPCI) Wildlife Trafficking Section of the Serious Organised Crime Investigation Unit, based at national headquarters, the six handed themselves over at the Pretoria Central Police Station on August 19, where they were formally arrested.' She explained that during bail proceedings, they all asked to be released on bail because they are not flight risks, and had co-operated with the police investigation. She continued that two of the accused, Melville and Poggenpoel, had stated in affidavits that they had previous convictions for fraud and possession of rhino horn, with both paying fines. Poggenpoel also disclosed that he has a case against him pending in the Winburg Magistrate's court in the Free State, because police allegedly found ammunition that was not properly secured, and for which he did not have a permit. Scheduled medicine was also apparently found during this visit. According to Mahanjana, Advocate Patsy Jacobs read an affidavit by investigating officer Edward du Plessis, saying that the State did not oppose bail as the accused are not flight risks, their addresses had been confirmed, and they had co-operated with investigators. The court granted bail to the six with the following conditions: – All accused must hand over their passports and may not apply for new travel documents while the matter is pending. – They must report to their nearest police station once a week. – They may not interfere with investigations, tamper with evidence or influence witnesses. – They must not commit any further offences while on bail. ALSO READ: Six alleged international rhino horn traffickers to appear in Pretoria court Do you have more information about the story? Please send us an email to [email protected] or phone us on 083 625 4114. For free breaking and community news, visit Rekord's websites: Rekord East For more news and interesting articles, like Rekord on Facebook, follow us on Twitter or Instagram or TikTok.
TimesLIVE
6 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Alleged murder mastermind Katiso 'KT' Molefe loses bid for release on bail
Katiso 'KT' Molefe, the alleged mastermind behind the murder of DJ Sumbody and three other people, was denied bail by the Alexandra magistrate's court on Wednesday. According to magistrate Renier Boshoff, there are a number of concerning aspects not only linking Molefe to the crimes but also regarding his circle of influence and capabilities. He said it appeared the state's case against him and other accused — who had abandoned their bail applications — was 'extremely strong'. 'The counts are of a serious nature and can increase the risk to abscond. His application for bail is refused,' said Boshoff. Molefe faces four counts of murder and four of conspiracy to commit murder over the killings of DJ Sumbody (Oupa Sefoka), who was with his bodyguards Sibusiso Mokoena and Sandile Myeza when they were shot in Woodmead, Johannesburg, in November 2022. DJ Vintos, whose real name was Hector Buthelezi, also died in a hail of bullets outside a nightclub in Orlando East, Soweto, in March 2022. In his ruling, the magistrate said Molefe, who claims to have been born and raised in South Africa, had once left the country using a false Lesotho passport and a fake name. 'This raises concerns about what he is capable of,' said Boshoff. Speaking outside court, NPA Gauteng spokesperson Phindi Mjonondwane said the prosecution team believed the ruling was in the interests of justice, as there was a risk Molefe could interfere with investigations if released from custody. 'The evidence against the accused is overwhelming. We showed in court how he is linked to the offences, including WhatsApp messages between him and the other accused who are believed to be the gunmen,' said Mjonondwane. According to the NPA, there are several dockets under investigation against the men, including two in Sandton, two in Pretoria and one in Vereeniging. The prosecution is working on an application to centralise these cases so that one team can handle them. 'Today's [Wednesday] ruling affirms the criminal justice system is there to protect society and we welcome it,' Mjonondwane said. Molefe and his co-accused, Michael Pule Tau, Tiego Floyd Mabusela and Musa Kekana, are expected back in court on September 18.
