Tales of the Shire receives mixed reviews as critics cite weak story
Jessica Filby of Dexerto described the game as 'a confusing cozy game,' pointing to its strong cooking and fishing systems but found much of the remaining content uninspired. 'Despite fantastic fishing and cooking mechanics,' she noted, 'Tales of the Shire often struggled to hold my attention.'
Travis Northup from IGN delivered a more critical perspective, describing the title as 'one of the most disappointing cozy games' in recent memory. He argued that most mechanics are 'shallow' and felt the core gameplay loop offered 'tedious repetition with very little payoff.' While he acknowledged some 'humorous writing' and a comparatively more robust cooking system, Northup concluded that these were outweighed by technical issues and underdeveloped features.
Kate Harrold, writing for Radio Times Gaming, offered a more tempered assessment. While she found many of the game's elements 'half-baked,' she praised the effort to include companion planting in gardening and utensil-specific meal preparation in cooking. However, Harrold maintained that the game 'lacks wow factor' and questioned its ability to stand out in an already competitive genre.
Emma-Jane Betts of GamesRadar+ credited Tales of the Shire for its faithful use of Tolkien lore and innovative community-focused progression. Yet, she also found its gameplay loop stagnant, noting that 'Bywater feels stagnant after a good few hours,' and the game lacks long-term engagement despite its initial charm.
Overall, while critics appreciated the atmosphere and some mechanics, the consensus suggests that Tales of the Shire delivers a limited and uneven experience.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
a day ago
- Express Tribune
Tales of the Shire receives mixed reviews as critics cite weak story
Tales of the Shire, the latest cosy life simulation set in J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-earth, has received a wide range of responses from critics across gaming publications. While the cooking and fishing mechanics have been highlighted positively, the broader gameplay experience has drawn criticism for its lack of depth and engagement. Jessica Filby of Dexerto described the game as 'a confusing cozy game,' pointing to its strong cooking and fishing systems but found much of the remaining content uninspired. 'Despite fantastic fishing and cooking mechanics,' she noted, 'Tales of the Shire often struggled to hold my attention.' Travis Northup from IGN delivered a more critical perspective, describing the title as 'one of the most disappointing cozy games' in recent memory. He argued that most mechanics are 'shallow' and felt the core gameplay loop offered 'tedious repetition with very little payoff.' While he acknowledged some 'humorous writing' and a comparatively more robust cooking system, Northup concluded that these were outweighed by technical issues and underdeveloped features. Kate Harrold, writing for Radio Times Gaming, offered a more tempered assessment. While she found many of the game's elements 'half-baked,' she praised the effort to include companion planting in gardening and utensil-specific meal preparation in cooking. However, Harrold maintained that the game 'lacks wow factor' and questioned its ability to stand out in an already competitive genre. Emma-Jane Betts of GamesRadar+ credited Tales of the Shire for its faithful use of Tolkien lore and innovative community-focused progression. Yet, she also found its gameplay loop stagnant, noting that 'Bywater feels stagnant after a good few hours,' and the game lacks long-term engagement despite its initial charm. Overall, while critics appreciated the atmosphere and some mechanics, the consensus suggests that Tales of the Shire delivers a limited and uneven experience.
Express Tribune
23-07-2025
- Express Tribune
Wuchang Fallen Feathers launches with layered combat, divisive bosses and deep build experimentation
Wuchang: Fallen Feathers has launched to a wave of reviews highlighting its fast-paced combat and layered systems, while also noting challenges in its difficulty balance. Polygon's Austin Manchester noted that the game's clash mechanic, allowing players to hit through enemy attacks while deflecting damage, made him feel as powerful as the bosses faced in-game. Manchester highlighted the weapon variety and skill tree, praising the 'layered combat system with engaging playstyles' while noting boss difficulty could be uneven. Dexerto's Nathan Warby described Wuchang as 'a bone-crushingly difficult experience,' praising its deep Skyborn Might system, which rewards precise dodging to power special moves. However, Warby found some sections more frustrating than challenging, citing surprise hazards and occasional difficulty spikes. IGN's Mitchell Saltzman commended Wuchang's 'best-in-class skill tree' and flexible build options, stating the system allowed for meaningful experimentation. Saltzman praised its interconnected level design and fast-paced combat but noted some later boss fights provided limited openings for damage, reducing the satisfaction of perfect dodges. Android Police's Tomas Franzese shared a contrasting view, stating that while Wuchang 'understands what works about Soulslike,' it 'flies a little too close to the sun.' Franzese found the relentless bosses and lack of co-op systems led to a frustrating experience, adding that for players who prioritise fun over challenge, Wuchang may not resonate. Despite mixed views on its pacing and difficulty, Wuchang: Fallen Feathers has sparked conversation among Soulslike fans and reviewers alike for its approach to combat depth and experimentation, positioning it as a notable addition to the genre in 2025.
Express Tribune
09-07-2025
- Express Tribune
Lord of the Rings Director aims to revive New Zealand's Moa bird species extinct for 600 years
Peter Jackson is collaborating with Colossal Biosciences to revive New Zealand's Moa bird species, which has been extinct for 600 years. Known for directing The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit films, Jackson has invested in the Texas-based biotech company to support the potential revival of the giant Moa bird. These flightless birds span nine unique species, with some standing up to 3.6 metres tall and weighing as much as 500lbs. Colossal Biosciences is working with the Ngāi Tahu Research Centre in New Zealand to collect Moa bones for DNA sampling. Jackson and his partner Fran Walsh have already gathered around 400 Moa bones, which have been sampled for DNA to assist in creating a complete genome. 'Fran and I have a collection of around 400 Moa bones, and we've already sampled them for DNA,' Jackson told IGN. 'I see my role over the next year or two as gathering as many more bones as I can. The more bones, the better the genome.' Jackson added, 'I've always loved the idea of de-extinction. Particularly, since the science can also have huge benefits with endangered species too.' The Moa project is a personal passion for Jackson, who told MSN, 'The movies are my day job, and the Moa are my fun thing I do.' Colossal Biosciences has recently been in the spotlight for similar projects. The company's work aims to use de-extinction science to support biodiversity and conservation efforts globally.
