Independent review ordered into Community Living B.C. after starvation death
The B.C. Crown corporation that oversees the care of developmentally disabled people will have its home-share program independently reviewed after an inquest into a starvation death earlier this year.
Florence Girard, a woman with Down syndrome, weighed about 50 pounds when she died in 2018 in the Port Coquitlam home of Astrid Dahl, a caregiver funded through Crown corporation Community Living B.C. (CLBC).
After the week-long inquest into Girard's death in January, a jury made 11 recommendations to CLBC, including better pay for front-line caregivers and changes to support family members of a vulnerable individual who want to care for their relative in their home.
CLBC, the corporation that oversees the care of developmentally disabled people, was created in 2005. It is in charge of caring for 29,000 British Columbians with disabilities such as autism, fetal alcohol syndrome and Down syndrome.
Now, the province says it is commissioning an independent review of the organization's home-sharing program, to be conducted by contractor Tamar Consultancy.
"Although CLBC has made a lot of changes since 2018, we still hear about concerns," Poverty Reduction Minister Sheila Malcolmson told CBC News.
"And today we've launched a review of ClBC's home-sharing program to make sure that the changes [made] since 2018 are getting people the highest quality of service possible."
The province's statement says that it would create an advisory body made up of individuals, families and service providers to inform the review and give recommendations to the ministry. The review is expected to be finished in late September.
Malcolmson told CBC News that the independent review would cost the government $75,000, and said the government needed to know the home-sharing model was as strong as possible.
"We are really counting on home sharing. Four thousand families across B.C. open their homes to adults with developmental disabilities," she said. "The demand is growing.
"It's a model that holds so much promise for people that, at another time, would have been living in institutions."
In a news release, the CEO of CLBC's board welcomed the independent review.
"We want to do everything we can to make sure this model is as strong as it can be, because this is about keeping people safe, and we believe the number of people supported through the home-sharing model will grow considerably," Shane Simpson said.
In its statement, the province says that CLBC made a number of changes after Girard's death in 2018, including mandating home visits every three months and annual doctor visits.
WATCH | Down syndome advocate and Girard's sister call for changes:
Advocates and unions had called for a shakeup of CLBC after the inquest into Girard's death, including demands its board resign.
Tamara Taggart, the president of advocacy organization Down Syndrome B.C., said the province didn't need to hire a consultancy firm to make changes at CLBC, given the inquest's recommendations in January.
"I have no idea how much money this is costing, but whatever it is, it's too much because we know what the answers are," she told CBC News.
"To continue to consult and research and have some public consultations and interviews and all that sort of stuff ... I feel like I am in the movie Groundhog Day," Taggart added.
Taggart said that she was interested to see what happens with the review, but was critical of the government for hiring an external consultancy firm for the job.
In a statement sent to CBC News at the time, CLBC said that none of its current board members were on the board in 2018 and that by law, the board must include representation from people with developmental disabilities, family members of those who receive services funded by CLBC, and Indigenous people.
Following the Girard inquest, CLBC's CEO provided an "unreserved apology" to Girard's family, friends and loved ones and said the organization had failed the B.C. woman's family.
In astatement at the time, CLBC said it welcomed the inquest's recommendations and said it was committed to taking concrete actions to strengthen the delivery of home sharing services.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
9 hours ago
- Yahoo
Winnipeg's Assiniboine Park Zoo welcomes family of 5 grey wolves from Vancouver
Assiniboine Park Zoo in Winnipeg is inviting guests to connect with and meet a new family of five grey wolves that it welcomed from the Greater Vancouver Zoo on Thursday. The pack includes the parents, seven-year-old Chinook and Gigi, and their three offspring — Comet, who is male, and Stella and Virgo, who are female — curator Shane Pratt told CBC News on Friday. The pups are three years old. "This is really big. They're very interactive animals," Pratt said. "We really like having people connect with our animals and inspire people to conserve," as well as "learn about how important they are for ecosystems," he said. The family's arrival follows the death of Bear, 14, in March, the last grey wolf in the zoo's original pack, the Assiniboine Park Conservancy said in a Friday press release. "Grey wolves are an iconic Canadian species that can be found across the country, including right here in Manitoba," Dr. Chris Enright, senior director of zoological operations, said in the release. "Unfortunately, fear and misunderstanding have led to instances of human-wolf conflict and, in some cases, over-hunting," he said. "Educating people about the critical role keystone species like wolves play in their ecosystems and why they should be protected is an important part of what we do here at the zoo." So far, the new pack appears to be adapting fairly well into their expansive boreal forest and grasslands habitat, Pratt said, with Gigi being the first to come out and showing the most confidence. Due to the ongoing wildfire situation, Pratt says they're keeping a close eye on air quality statements, especially for those animals with the most sensitive lungs, such as birds. The zoo has policies and protocols in place to help move animals into a cleaner air environment, Pratt said. "We haven't really seen any animals in distress yet," he said. "We're very thankful, because we like keeping animals outside as long as possible." The family of grey wolves joins other new additions at the zoo since last fall, including three red pandas, called Suva, Mei Mei and Kelly, and a Siberian musk deer named Ozzy, the conservancy said in the release. The zoo is also hosting an exhibit called the Survival of the Slowest featuring a hedgehog, a bearded dragon and two-toed sloths, along with other animals, until Sept. 1.
Yahoo
11 hours ago
- Yahoo
Testimony differs between doctor, family in Grace Schara's wrongful death case vs Ascension
The doctor and registered nurse who cared for Grace Schara were among the witnesses to testify during the first week of the wrongful death trial, providing the jury their first opportunity to hear details from those responsible for her care. Grace, who had Down syndrome, died at age 19 on Oct. 13, 2021, after being admitted to Ascension NE Wisconsin − St. Elizabeth Hospital in Appleton for symptoms of COVID-19. Her father filed a wrongful death lawsuit a year and a half later. The hospital, Dr. Gavin Shokar and Hollee McInnis, a registered nurse, are named in the lawsuit. Testimony provided by Shokar and McInnis highlighted differences from testimony earlier in the week from Grace's parents, Scott and Cindy Schara. It also stood in stark contrast to the testimony given by the family's medical expert, who argued Grace failed to be correctly diagnosed and died of a drug overdose as a result of an illegal do not resuscitate order, not COVID-19 pneumonia. The jury is being provided the chance to submit questions to the judge following testimony from each witness. Outagamie Circuit Court Judge Mark McGinnis then decides if witnesses are allowed to answer them. More: Grace Schara's family wants jury to decide hospital caused her death, not COVID-19. What to know about the case. More: Grace Schara's wrongful death trial against Ascension St. Elizabeth begins As of June 6, those questions have sought clarity on whether Grace had power of attorney and do not resuscitate documents in her chart and how confusion over Grace's code status, specifically the fact a "do not resuscitate" order was placed in her chart by Shokar on the day of her death. Grace's parents and her older sister, Jessica Vander Heiden, were Grace's powers of attorney. They had two phone conversations with Shokar regarding what should occur in the event her health deteriorated. The first took place on Oct. 12, the day prior to Grace's death. Shokar told the family he really had no more 'wiggle room' to continue treating her on the BiPAP breathing machine, should her lungs continue to deteriorate. Shokar told the family that Grace's lungs were scarring, and the BiPAP machine was operating at its maximum capacity. The only breathing machine remaining as an option was a ventilator, Shokar said he told the family. When asked, he told the family there was a "roughly 20% survival rate" for patients in Grace's condition, if the family chose intubation, Shokar said. Shokar said he discussed what recovery could look like, including the possibility Grace might need a tracheotomy, the life-long use of supplemental oxygen, or a lengthy amount of time on a ventilator and rehabilitation. If a ventilator was not an option, discussions including keeping her on BiPAP and 'hope for the best," Shokar said while testifying. Shokar said he asked the family to decide quickly, "as Grace could crash at any time," and the night team would like to know what to do if that happens. Failing to receive a callback, Shokar called the family on the morning of Oct. 13, 2021. 'Doctor, thank you for all your time and explaining everything. I talked about this with my family and we have decided to move forward with a DNI,' Shokar said he recalled being told by Scott Schara. A DNI means a patient should not be intubated. It is a separate order from a do not resuscitate order. 'Absent of intubation,' Shokar testified all he could do was attempt to slow her breathing rate, which eventually included giving her morphine. It was unclear from Shokar's testimony if this was his rational for placing a DNR order on Grace's chart. He stressed he spoke with the family on two occasions, each time for close to an hour, and was clear about the futility of chest compressions, should Grace need to be resuscitated. He also testified he had "never unilaterally placed a DNR order on a patient's chart." McInnis, the nurse, testified she could not remember if Grace was wearing the purple, do not resuscitate bracelet that St. Elizabeth health care staff place on DNR patients. McInnis said if she was not wearing it, it was only because she had gotten too busy to put it on Grace. A normal breathing or respiratory rate is 12 to 20 breaths per minute. The day of Grace's death she was taking 60 breaths per minute. Breathing this fast is unsustainable and an emergency situation, McInnis and Shokar said while testifying. Prior to the start of the trial, Grace's parents and her older sister detailed how Vander Heiden made a FaceTime call to her parents when she saw Grace's condition worsening during the early evening hours of Oct. 13. With phone in hand, Vander Heiden said she ran out of Grace's room, shouting for someone to help her sister. It was at this point they learned Grace was a "do not resuscitate," they said. When they shouted, "save our daughter," no staff responded, the family members said. "I have no recollection of this," McInnis said. Neither did Shokar, according to his testimony. A patient's code status is not static, medical professionals told the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, it can be changed at anytime. Dr. Gilbert Berdine is an associate professor of internal medicine and medical education at the Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center and earned his medical degree from Harvard University School of Medicine. Berdine testified it is his belief that Grace died when she failed to be diagnosed and then be treated for metabolic acidosis, a condition that occurs when too much lactic acid builds up in the body. Lactic acid is produced by muscle and red blood cells when a body is low on oxygen, and consequently low on energy. "Your heart consists of muscle fibers, and when your blood is too acidic, muscle fibers can no longer contract," he said. "Your heart stops beating." He said instead of Shokar administering ativan and morphine, Grace should have been given bicarbonate to counter the acidity in her body, Narcan to reverse the impacts of the drugs, and norephedrine to increase blood pressure and heart rate. Berdine cited various results of Grace's blood-gas lab tests as evidence she was experiencing, but not being treated, for the condition. Instead, she continued to be given drugs that lowered her respirator and heart rates, namely precedex, lorazepam and morphine. There was no discussion of metabolic acidosis during Shokar's testimony. Berdine said placing Grace on a ventilator on Oct. 13 would have been a good idea, but not for the same reasons as her doctors. "Placing her on a ventilator would have led to a blood-gas test," Berdine said. "They would not have been able to miss the metabolic acidosis anymore. And yes, it would have been helpful but it was not necessary on the 12th, for the same reason. It would have led to the correct diagnosis." He said it is a "breach of the standard of care," if Grace's family was not made aware of all the drugs she was receiving and informed of oversedation episodes. Scott Schara testified he was not aware his daughter was being given any of these drugs. "Patients or their advocates can't make correct decisions without being informed," Berdine said. "That is not a good way to run a hospital." Jessica Van Egeren is a health care reporter and assistant breaking news editor with the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. She can be reached at jvanegeren@ This article originally appeared on Milwaukee Journal Sentinel: Grace Schara's wrongful death trial: Ascension doctor, nurse testify during week 1
Hamilton Spectator
12 hours ago
- Hamilton Spectator
Provincial housing minister praised NDP program during visit to Penticton
British Columbia's Minister of Housing believes the provincial NDP government has come up with a funding model program established only two years ago that will be followed by government leaders across the country to allow Canadians to remain in housing they can afford. During a stop in Penticton Thursday afternoon, Ravi Kahlon, the provincial Minister of Housing and Municipal Affairs, revealed details about B.C.'s Rental Protection Fund, established back in 2023. As part of the fund, the provincial government announced the purchase of 14 homes at a housing complex located at 680 Wade Avenue East, purchased by the Penticton and District Society for Community Living. Kahlon said hundreds of families, seniors and individuals now have certainty that they can stay in homes they can afford due to the new funding provided by the Rental Protection Fund. 'I would say that the fear that many British Columbians have is when they drive by an encampment, many British Columbians think 'could that be me',' said Kahlon. 'When they see a 'For Sale' sign in front of their building, they think how close I could be if I lose my housing to be in a vulnerable situation. 'So while we address issues like the encampment here in Penticton, we have to ensure that the housing stock that we have protects the people that need it. That's the beauty of this Rental Protection Fund. Over 50 per cent of all the buildings purchased or sold last year, were purchased by the Rental Protection Fund. That is a significant shift of housing into the not-for-profit housing space.' The fund is not only allowing the government to protect the housing needed to provide a home for so many who are struggling to survive, but also ensuring that people can live dignified lives, said Kahlon. Kahlon said he and his government believe funding like this, which allows those struggling to access housing that is accessible and affordable, is going to become a national model for tackling Canada's affordable housing crisis. 'This program, I can guarantee you, will be scaled across the country,' he said. 'It's not whether the federal government wants to or doesn't want to. They have no choice because the data and success we're seeing in British Columbia is clear. 'We have multiple communities in today's announcement, but the reason I wanted to do it in Penticton was because Mayor and Council here are showing all councils across the province that you can be an active participant to protect the vulnerable people in your community and I'm hoping that it inspires other communities to do the same thing, so we can continue to expand this program going into the future. 'My message to the federal Housing Minister (former Vancouver Mayor Gregor Robertson) is you don't need to spend time trying to figure it out, we have the solution. Just write us a cheque.' Penticton Mayor Julius Bloomfield, who attended Thursday's announcement with members of Council and senior city administration, had high praise for the program. 'Today's announcement highlights the success of our affordable housing pilot funding program,' he said. 'This program, along with our updated permissive tax-exemption policy, reflects our commitment to non-market housing and partnerships to protect affordable rentals so residents can stay in homes they can afford.' Raymond Kendell, a tenant in Penticton, was also ecstatic. 'I was worried I wouldn't find a place,' he said. 'It's expensive here in Penticton. I've lived here 4.5 years. I appreciate that the Penticton and District Society for Community Living improved our building. Most people in the building seem stress-free and much happier now.' Tarra Kenney, CEO, Penticton and District Society for Community Living (PDSCL), said the fund will help many people in Penticton and across the province. 'The acquisition of the apartments at 680 Wade Ave. E. in Penticton, made possible through the Rental Proection Fund (RPF), marks a significant step in ensuring affordable housing for our community,' she said. 'Thanks to this funding, PDSCL has been able to maintain lower rental rates, providing stability and accessibility for residents who need it most.' In the midst of a global housing affordability crisis and rising costs, the provincial NDP government is securing affordable housing that gives people stability and peace of mind to help them thrive in their communities, said Kahlon. 'When people lose their homes, it can be a real struggle to find another affordable rental and communities can lose the people who work in local businesses, schools and hospitals,' he said. 'We created the Rental Protection Fund to help people stay in the homes they can afford now and in the future.' To make sure more people throughout B.C. can remain in their homes affordably, the Rental Protection Fund has supported non-profit organizations to buy a total of 220 homes, including the 14 in Penticton. As well, they recently purchased: • Chilliwack: 85 homes at Camelot Apartments, bought by Affordable Housing Societies • Fort St. John: 18 homes at Alpine Lodge., and 24 homes at Grandview Townhomes., bought by Connective • Kamloops: 25 homes at Riverside Gardens, bought by Connective Kamloops • Prince George: 21 homes bought by More than a Roof Mennonite Housing Society • Vancouver: 33 homes in Abana Court., bought by the New Vista Society. To secure these homes, the Rental Protection Fund provided partners with more than $26 million in capital contributions and renewal grants, including approximately $2.3 million to improve the buildings and ensure the homes remain in good condition for the people living there, said Kahlon. 'We're safeguarding affordability for renters across the province in communities big and small,' said Katie Maslechko, CEO, Rental Protection Fund. 'These acquisitions show what's possible when governments, community housing providers and even residents work together to keep our housing Canadian and affordable through community ownership.' The homes range from studios to three bedrooms, and are suitable for the diverse needs of seniors, families and individuals. The homes are centrally located within walking distance of core services that people rely on, such as childcare, schools, parks and transit. 'I have lived here for the past eight years, and prior to the Penticton and District Society for Community Living acquiring the property, the uncertainty and constant worry about potentially having to move or paying one-third or more for rent elsewhere in the city was extremely unsettling,' said Vicki Rylander, a tenant in Penticton. 'Being on a limited income, such a change would have had a seriously negative impact on my financial stability.' The properties in this announcement are part of the nearly 1,600 homes protected through the fund since its launch in 2023. Based on its effect so far, the fund is on track to exceed its target of protecting 2,000 homes well ahead of schedule. The fund is part of a $19-billion housing investment by the B.C. government. Since 2017, the Province has nearly 92,000 homes delivered or underway, including more than 360 homes in Penticton. In January 2023, the Province made a historic initial investment of $500 million to establish the B.C. Rental Protection Fund. The fund provides one-time capital contributions to non-profit housing organizations so they can buy existing affordable rental buildings and co-operatives, protecting the people living there, safeguarding the units and keeping those units as affordable, long-term housing. On average, rents secured through the fund are 44 per cent lower than local market rates and are kept below market to ensure long-term affordability for people with low or moderate incomes. Rob Botterell, BC Green Party house leader; MLA for Saanich North and the Islands, praised the program. 'These projects show what's possible when communities and non-profits are given the tools to take housing off the speculative market,' he said. 'When we protect and expand affordable housing, we don't just solve the housing crisis - we make progress on health, education and economic stability. To create lasting change, we need continued and expanded support for protecting existing affordable homes.' Stephen Bennett, CEO, Affordable Housing Societies, was also pleased. 'We are grateful for the support of the Province through the Rental Protection Fund for our purchase of the Camelot apartments in Chilliwack,' he said. 'Because of this purchase, we have been able to ensure the residents of that building continue to have housing stability at rents they can afford.' Lee-Anne Michayluk, CEO, More Than A Roof Housing Society, credited the government for taking action on one of the most serious issues facing the province and its residents. 'This acquisition underscores our ongoing commitment to fostering strong, thriving communities by prioritizing sustainable and affordable housing solutions,' she said. 'We extend our appreciation to the RPF team and the provincial government as we work together to create lasting, positive impacts for current and future residents. Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
