After fatal crash, proposed law would ban tourist helicopter flights around NYC
New Jersey and New York congressional members have proposed a bill that would ban 'non-essential' helicopter flights like the one that crashed on April 10. The bill comes at the same time a citizens group has asked federal officials for an immediate ban.
Roughly a month after a tourist helicopter plunged into the Hudson River near Jersey City, killing all six people aboard, a federal bill has been introduced that would ban tourist and other 'non-essential' helicopter flights within a 20-mile radius of the Statue of Liberty.
The bipartisan bill, proposed by U.S. Reps. Rob Menendez (D-8th Dist.), Jerrold Nadler (D-Manhattan), and Nicole Malliotakis (R-Staten Island), would ground non-essential helicopter flights starting 60 days after it is signed into law.
The bill exempts police, medical, disaster and emergency response, infrastructure maintenance and other helicopter flights deemed to be in the public good, including news media helicopters.
A bi-state citizen group, Stop the Chop, asked for an 'immediate ban' on non-essential flights over the New York Metropolitan area in a May 21 letter to U.S. Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy and FAA Administrator Chris Rocheleau.
A tourist helicopter broke apart into three pieces in midair and crashed into the Hudson River near Jersey City at 3:15 p.m. on April 10. All six people on board were killed, including a family of five from Spain visiting New York City and the pilot.
The National Transportation Safety Board is still investigating the cause.
That crash involved a tourist helicopter that was based in Kearny and flew over densely populated Jersey City and Hoboken neighborhoods to reach Manhattan.
'In light of the recent tragedy on April 10 and the ongoing Air Traffic Control shortages in the area, the risks of having more than 100 of these flights cross right over our heads every day is undeniable and needs to be put to an end,' Nick Wierda, a Stop the Chop member and Jersey City resident, said. 'We are urging the federal government, the only body with real regulatory power over our skies, to do just that.'
The letter supports the Menendez bill and made it clear that 'we support and respect the vital role of helicopters in medical, law enforcement, military, and emergency operations. We are not calling for any changes to flight paths or rules governing essential aircraft.'
Hoboken, Jersey City and New York City councils passed resolutions calling on the Federal Aviation Administration to ban non-essential helicopter traffic over and near populated urban areas in the wake of the crash.
The FAA has jurisdiction over the nation's airspace.
The FAA took similar action on March 14 in the wake of a deadly collision between a military helicopter and a commuter jet that killed 67 people on Jan. 29 by banning helicopter traffic from the busy airspace near Reagan Airport in Washington. That ban exempted presidential flights, law enforcement and air ambulance flights.
It also resulted in the FAA convening a helicopter safety roundtable in April with safety experts, government and industry representatives, where the Hudson River crash was mentioned.
Residents said the FAA needs to do the same thing in New York and New Jersey, citing air space that is as congested as in Washington D.C., and the safety risk of flights over densely populated neighborhoods.
'For years this has been a major quality of life issue that has continued to worsen,' said Melissa Elstein, Stop the Chop board chair. 'On high-traffic days, usually weekends when the weather is clear, we see many times north of 100 helicopters zipping out to the Hudson and back in, skimming our roofs, shaking our houses, so close you can see the passengers inside.'
Bailey Wood, a spokesperson for Vertical Aviation International, an association of helicopter operators, pilots, owners and manufacturers said accident data says the fatality rate per 100,000 hours of flight are the lowest since 2007.
'The legislation is as misguided as it is short sighted as the future of vertical flight is about to take off in ways we only once imagined,' he said.
Advanced air mobility aircraft, like those from Joby, Archer, Supernal and others, will grow the existing helicopter industry to connect people more efficiently across urban, suburban, and rural area, reducing travel time, easing congestion, and creating a new paradigm of accessible and sustainable transportation, Wood said.
A total of 8,848 flights went over New York City land or water in May 2023, and a large portion of these flights are non-essential, Menendez said in a March letter to Duffy. An estimated 43% are tours originating from the Downtown Manhattan Heliport, the Kearny Heliport and Linden Airport.
Helicopters are subject to different minimum altitude restrictions than airplanes, said an FAA spokesperson.
Airplanes must fly at least 1,000 feet above the nearest obstacle when over densely populated areas. Helicopter pilots must fly so they don't pose a hazard to people or property on the ground, said Rick Breitenfeldt an FAA spokesperson.
'Helicopters typically fly over the New York and New Jersey area using Visual Flight Rules (VFR) and just outside Newark (airport) Class B airspace,' he said. 'Pilots operating VFR use the see-and-avoid method to conduct their flights. The responsibility for flying neighborly resides with the pilot operating the helicopter.'
But residents familiar with the fly neighborly program said that isn't being adhered to, given the low altitudes they said they've observed.
'People in the helicopter industry claim that they do everything they can to 'fly neighborly,' but that has not been our experience,' Wierda said. 'They fly loud and low, with no regard for our safety or sanity.'
Our journalism needs your support. Please subscribe today to NJ.com.
Larry Higgs may be reached at [email protected]. Follow him on X @CommutingLarry.
©2025 Advance Local Media LLC. Visit nj.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Major US airlines urge FAA to delay new cockpit security measures
-- Major U.S. airlines are urging the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) to postpone a new requirement demanding a secondary barrier to the flight deck in new passenger airplanes. This regulation, slated to come into effect in August, aims to prevent unauthorized intrusions into the cockpit. Airlines for America, the trade association representing major carriers such as American Airlines (NASDAQ:AAL), United Airlines, and Delta Air Lines (NYSE:DAL), has asked the FAA to delay the implementation of this requirement, which was finalized in 2023. The airlines' primary concern is that the FAA has not yet approved a secondary cockpit barrier. Additionally, no manuals, procedures, or training programs have been authorized to support the new requirement. The call for enhanced flight deck security arose after the hijacking of four U.S. airplanes on September 11, 2001. In response to this tragedy, the FAA established standards to make flight decks more resistant to forcible intrusion and unauthorized entry. The upcoming requirement for a secondary barrier is a part of these ongoing security enhancements. Related articles Major US airlines urge FAA to delay new cockpit security measures Legal startup Harvey AI reportedly raising $250M at $5B valuation Pope Francis passes away at 88
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
US airlines want FAA to delay secondary flight deck barrier requirement
(Reuters) - Major airlines want the Federal Aviation Administration to delay a requirement set to take effect in August requiring that new passenger airplanes have a secondary barrier to the flight deck to prevent intrusions, the agency said on Tuesday. Airlines for America, the trade group representing American Airlines , United Airlines , Delta Air Lines and other major carriers, said the FAA should delay the requirement finalized in 2023 because the agency has not yet approved a secondary cockpit barrier and no manuals, procedures or training programs have been authorized. After the hijacking of four U.S. airplanes on Sept. 11, 2001, the FAA adopted standards for flight deck security to make them resistant to forcible intrusion and unauthorized entry.
San Francisco Chronicle
5 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Confusion on sensor plane's abilities delayed response in Ohio train derailment, report says
A specialized plane equipped with advanced sensors that the government deploys to chemical disasters could have helped authorities avoid needlessly blowing open five rail tank cars and burning their toxic contents after the disastrous 2023 East Palestine train derailment, a new report says. The report released Tuesday found the single-engine Cessna wasn't called into action until the night before the rail cars filled with vinyl chloride were blown open because officials with the Environmental Protection Agency on the ground didn't fully understand the aircraft's sophisticated capabilities. The report by the EPA's Inspector General said the agency's on-scene coordinator mistakenly thought the so-called ASPECT plane could only measure 20- to 30-degree differences in temperature. In reality, the report noted, the sensors can measure slight temperature differences of less than 1 degree. That information could have helped first responders avoid the key mistake the National Transportation Safety Board identified of blowing open the tank cars filled with the toxic plastic ingredient. The on-scene coordinator's 'limited awareness or use of the full range of ASPECT capabilities could negatively impact emergency response decision-making,' the report said. The towering plume of black smoke The explosion and fire generated a massive plume of black smoke over East Palestine that billowed eastward over the nearby Ohio-Pennsylvania border three days after the derailment. State and local officials in charge of the response feared those tank cars would explode even though the limited temperature information they had showed the cars were starting to cool off. The National Transportation Safety Board had previously faulted the Norfolk Southern railroad for not sharing the opinion of the chemical maker that the vinyl chloride wasn't going to explode with decisionmakers. Norfolk Southern has said OxyVinyls officials offered conflicting information that left the railroad's experts worried about a dangerous chemical reaction. Much of the small town of East Palestine had to be evacuated for days because of the toxic chemical fire. Many residents still complain of lingering health symptoms, fearful of potential long-term health consequences. The EPA has maintained that dangerous levels of chemicals were never found after the evacuation order was lifted five days after the Feb. 3, 2023, derailment. Some have questioned whether the agency did enough to detect the chemicals in the aftermath and doctors are still trying to determine what prolonged exposure to low levels of the chemicals might mean. Recently released records show officials with the Federal Emergency Management Administration have acknowledged residents' fears that cancer clusters could develop years from now in area residents despite the EPA's assurances. Robert Kroutil, the man who wrote the software and helped interpret the data from the plane's advanced radiological and infrared sensors, has said having accurate temperature data from the plane could have helped avoid the vent-and-burn operation. 'The report noted that EPA officials believe that the on-ground monitoring equipment provided superior detection capabilities, which is incorrect,' Kroutil said. "This demonstrates EPA's complete lack of understanding of the ASPECT technology and how it works to protect chemically impacted sites.' The East Palestine derailment was the worst rail disaster in a decade. It prompted a national reckoning with rail safety and calls for reform — although proposals for new industry rules stalled in Congress. The railroad's contractors who led the response to the derailment told the NTSB they had difficulty getting accurate temperature readings on the cars because the fire surrounding them made it especially dangerous. Kroutil's concerns prompted the IG investigation. The EPA said in its official response to the report that it has developed a detailed fact sheet and plans to train its emergency responders about the plane's capabilities and when it should be deployed over the next year. But the agency didn't immediately respond Tuesday to questions about the delayed response in East Palestine. Lingering questions about the flights The Government Accountability Project watchdog group that helped Kroutil document his concerns questioned why the Inspector General didn't look into other aspects like Kroutil's concerns that the plane's sensors were intentionally shut off over the creeks around East Palestine and that the final report on the flights was changed to overlook the incomplete data that was generated in just two flights before the plane was sent home. GAP's Senior Environmental Officer Lesley Pacey said 'the investigation's scope was too narrow, failing to address the most serious allegations.' The EPA didn't even call for the sensor plane until two nights after the derailment when officials were already contemplating the vent-and-burn operation. The plane took off from its Texas base within a half hour of getting the call, but it didn't make a pass over the derailment as it flew into the area that night, and then weather conditions kept it from flying during the controversial burn operation the next day. It didn't gather any data until the following day after most of the chemicals had already been distributed by the wind. The Inspector General said the emails and documents it reviewed showed that officials followed existing practices on deploying the plane, but those procedures lacked the clarity needed to help them decide when to deploy the plane.
