Dispute between nurse Sandie Peggie and transgender doctor Beth Upton posed 'no risk to patients'
Nurse Sandie Peggie was suspended after she objected to having to share a changing room with Dr Beth Upton at the Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife, on Christmas Eve 2023.
Ms Peggie was placed on special leave and then suspended after the doctor made an allegation of bullying and harassment and cited concerns about "patient care".
Ms Peggie has lodged a claim against NHS Fife and Dr Upton, citing the Equality Act 2010, including sexual harassment; harassment related to a protected belief; indirect discrimination; and victimisation.
Service manager Lottie Myles told the tribunal on Monday she perceived the dispute which led to Ms Peggie being suspended as a "she said/she said" situation, and there was "nobody who could provide evidence".
Ms Myles said she was tasked with conducting a suspension review on 27 February 2024, and was told by the nurse's manager, Esther Davidson, that Ms Peggie was "anti-trans" and "had transphobic views because of an incident that occurred in the changing room".
She said Ms Davidson alleged Ms Peggie had "some gender critical beliefs" alongside others that "may not be everybody's belief", an hour before a suspension review meeting.
However, Ms Myles said she was not given any documentation to examine prior to the review.
Jane Russell KC, counsel for NHS Fife, asked about these "other beliefs".
Ms Myles said: "There was views that Sandie was homophobic and there were elements of racism in her beliefs. It's hearsay. I try to disregard views which haven't been documented or there's little evidence of."
She noted Ms Peggie referred to Dr Upton using "male terminology", but said she believed Ms Peggie's feelings about Dr Upton were "circumstantial", and later challenged why allegations she branded "hearsay" had not been documented or escalated.
Ms Myles said: "I think Sandie probably wasn't too happy with Dr Upton, but I think that was more from the incident which had happened.
"In summary notes, I had asked if she was to treat a patient who was transgender, would she treat them differently. I was reassured she said she wouldn't treat anyone trans differently; I felt that it was circumstantial."
Ms Russell asked for Ms Myles's views on how Ms Peggie "might deal with transgender patients" after a suspension review meeting on 7 March 2024.
Ms Myles replied: "I felt reassured she wouldn't treat them differently. Sandie has been a nurse for 30 years, I'm sure in that time she has dealt with transgender patients. I felt there were no safety concerns."
She said she referred to the Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) code, including on freedom of expression, and the Equality Act 2010 which she described as a "grey area in a lot of workplaces", and said there were "several reasons" why she lifted the suspension.
Ms Myles said: "I wanted to be sure I wouldn't be treating either party in breach of the Equality Act. I wanted to have Dr Upton and Sandie Peggie treated fairly and equally."
She said a meeting between herself, Ms Peggie and Royal College of Nursing (RCN) representative Stuart Fraser was "very difficult" and "emotional" for Ms Peggie, who was determined to return to the emergency department rather than be moved to another department managed by Ms Myles.
Ms Myles said: "I wanted both parties to be treated fairly and equally. The situation was 'she said/she said', we were limited on witnesses and things being documented."
Ms Myles said a return to work would be "beneficial" for Ms Peggie, and that she wanted to "make it as seamless as possible", after discussions about moving departments and moving on to dayshifts were both rejected.
Ms Myles said she was aware of reports of "negative interactions", which she branded "hearsay".
She said: "I actually challenged that by saying, 'why wasn't this documented? Why wasn't it escalated?'
"Nobody could confirm, but I felt that was hearsay. I felt that to try to prevent any other allegations from happening, having a senior team member on duty would be supportive for her."
Ms Myles said it was agreed to put the pair on "opposite shifts" and for Ms Peggie to be supervised during a phased return, describing it as a "compromise".
Ms Myles said her involvement ceased around 19 April at the request of head of nursing Gillian Malone, and she had no role in the investigation.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Sick and injured children from Gaza to be evacuated to UK for NHS care
Top ministers are understood to be working on a scheme to bring children from Gaza to the UK for NHS medical care, with plans expected to be unveiled within weeks Plans are being drawn up to evacuate more seriously ill children from Gaza for NHS treatment. Top ministers are understood to be working on a scheme to bring sick children to the UK for free medical care, with plans expected to be unveiled within weeks. More than 50,000 children have been killed or injured in the conflict since October 7 2023 according to the UN charity Unicef. It comes after furious Bob Geldof issued a desperate plea on Sky News to save babies in Gaza. Only three kids have been granted medical visas to come to Britain for treatment so far through work by the group Project Pure Hope, which was set up by volunteer medical professionals. Earlier this year, Ghena, 5, and Rama, 12, came to the UK via Egypt for privately-funded treatment for serious health conditions unrelated to the conflict. Rama, who has a lifelong bowel condition, was able to get surgery in Britain that was unavailable in her home of Khan Younis, in war-torn Gaza. Ghena had laser surgery to relieve fluid pressing against her optic nerve, which could have cost her her sight in her left eye. Last week, 15-year-old Majd Alshagnobi was flown to Britain for facial reconstructive surgery after an Israeli tank shell destroyed his jaw while he was seeking aid in February 2024. Keir Starmer promised Mirror readers last month that he would act to help more sick and injured Palestinian children, saying the public were 'sickened' by scenes of desperation and starvation in Gaza. The PM said at the time: "We are urgently accelerating efforts to evacuate children from Gaza who need critical medical assistance – bringing more Palestinian children to the UK for specialist medical treatment." It is unclear how many children would be covered by the new scheme but it is understood ministers are looking to significantly increase numbers. Each child would be accompanied by a parent or guardian and siblings if necessary, according to the Sunday Times. The Home Office will carry out biometric and security checks before they travel. In 2022, 21 Ukrainian children were brought to the UK to get cancer treatment on the NHS. More than 100 MPs signed a letter urging the Government to fast-track the scheme to help children from Gaza. The letter, coordinated by Labour MP Stella Creasy, said: 'Parliament may be in recess but the commitment we all share to help these children remains absolute and urgent – with every day, more are harmed or die, making the need to overcome any barriers to increasing the support we give them imperative. 'We stand ready to support whatever it takes to make this happen and ask for your urgent response to this request. Let's make it happen.' A Government spokesperson said: "We are taking forward plans to evacuate more children from Gaza who require urgent medical care, including bringing them to the UK for specialist treatment where that is the best option for their care. "We are working at pace to do so as quickly as possible, with further details to be set out in due course." The UK and Jordan are working together to airdrop aid into Gaza after Israel temporarily paused military activity amid international outrage at widespread starvation and malnutrition. Mr Starmer said last week that the UK would recognise a Palestinian state in September if Israel did not change course.
The Independent
3 hours ago
- The Independent
Great Ormond Street Hospital surgeons forced to use mobile phone torches during surgery after power cut
Surgeons at Great Ormond Street Hospital (GOSH) for children were forced to use mobile phone torches during an operation due to a power outage, the NHS's safety watchdog has found. The leading children's hospital has faced ongoing concerns over the maintenance of its estate and operating theatres, which have led to water leaks and power outages, according to a report by the Care Quality Commission. The CQC warned of 'recurrent' problems, including a power outage during spinal surgery and ventilation failures. The watchdog's inspection came after GOSH faced scrutiny over the care of hundreds of children by orthopaedic surgeon Yaser Jabber. In its report, the CQC said it found concerns around 'surgical accountability and oversight' at the trust. The news comes as the NHS in England faces a £14 billion backlog in estate maintenance spending, meaning hospital buildings are facing issues which can impact patient safety and lead to the cancellation of operations. Earlier this year, the National Audit Office warned that around 5,400 clinical service incidents occur in the NHS each year due to building or infrastructure failures. The CQC report's findings into building failures, first revealed by The Sunday Times, said: 'Concerns were raised about the maintenance of operating theatres and equipment safety. A recent power outage during a spinal surgery procedure required staff to use mobile phone torches to complete wound closure. 'This incident, alongside reports of water leaks affecting electrical systems and theatre closures due to filtration failures, indicated ongoing issues with estates and facilities management.' The CQC report said the trust took actions to address the problems; however, it warned there were 'recurrent theatre maintenance failures that had resulted in delayed or cancelled surgical procedures, impacting patient safety and access to timely care.' A spokeswoman for the trust said the incident was caused by an electrical system power failure and that an external review had been commissioned. The trust told The Sunday Times the surgical lights immediately over the patient remained during the power cut, but that theatre staff moving around the operating theatre had to use a phone torch to avoid cables and find the equipment needed. The Independent has approached GOSH over the use of physician associates to fill doctor rota gaps. According to the think tank, The Health Foundation, the NHS needs its capital spending to grow by 10.2 per cent a year between 2024-25 and 2029-30 to address its maintenance backlog, to invest in technology, buildings and equipment to improve services. Following the government's spending review, the capital budget for the Department for Health and Social Care is expected to grow by £2.3 billion from £10.9 billion in 2023-24 to £13.2 billion in 2025-26. Hospitals across the country report incidents due to poor infrastructure or building issues. Last month, Gloucester Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust experienced an issue with its servers, which forced it to rely on paper ahead of a five-day junior doctor strike. According to the Sunday Times, in June, the Princess Royal Hospital in Telford was forced to close several wards and divert ambulances due to a burst pipe. St Helier Hospital in Sutton, which had to cancel urgent tests due to flooding, told the paper 'Our ageing hospitals are deteriorating faster than we can fix them — with issues such as floods, leaking roofs, and broken-down lifts, as well as buildings that have had to be demolished because the foundations are sinking'. Last year, the government identified more hospitals which had been impacted by a long-running issue of having reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete (RAAC) across its estates – a total of 47 hospitals have been identified.
The Guardian
3 hours ago
- The Guardian
UK to evacuate injured children from Gaza to receive NHS care
The UK government will evacuate seriously ill and injured children from Gaza to the UK for NHS treatment under a scheme to be announced within weeks. Ministers will enable children in severe need to receive taxpayer-funded care. Three children were brought to the UK this year through a private scheme by the charity Project Pure Hope. A government spokesperson said: 'We are taking forward plans to evacuate more children from Gaza who require urgent medical care, including bringing them to the UK for specialist treatment where that is the best option for their care. 'We are working at pace to do so as quickly as possible, with further details to be set out in due course.' More than 50,000 children have been killed or injured in Gaza since the outbreak of the war between Hamas and Israel in October 2023, according to Unicef data. Keir Starmer said last week that the UK was 'urgently accelerating' efforts to bring children over for treatment. The government scheme will operate in parallel to the initiative by Project Pure Hope, which was set up to bring sick and injured children from Gaza to the UK privately for treatment. Through the charity's initiative, Majd al-Shagnobi, a 15-year-old from Gaza, became the first Palestinian child to be flown to the UK for treatment for war injuries. He required complex facial reconstructive surgery after an Israeli tank shell destroyed his jaw when he was trying to access aid in February last year. His treatment at Great Ormond Street hospital in London is being privately funded by Project Pure Hope and is being carried out by a medical team who will all work for free. Earlier this year, the charity secured visas for two girls from Gaza – 13-year-old Rama and five-year-old Ghena – to have privately funded operations in the UK for lifelong medical conditions. News of the government's plans comes after domestic political pressure. More than 100 MPs signed a letter coordinated by Stella Creasy, the Labour MP for Walthamstow, calling on ministers to evacuate 30 severely ill children to the UK for treatment. A foreign affairs select committee report at the end of July said ministers had 'declined to support a medical evacuation of critically injured children to the UK, involving coordinating travel permits, medical visas and safe transport to the UK, where the children can receive specialised care unavailable to them in Gaza'. The Guardian reported last month that the government was facing legal action from a law firm acting on behalf of three critically ill children in Gaza. Other countries have been faster to act. Italy has evacuated dozens of Palestinian children and families for medical treatment, with the first group arriving in January 2024. The Sunday Times, which first reported the story, cited a senior Whitehall source who said up to 300 children could be brought to the UK from Gaza under the government's scheme. They will be accompanied by a parent or guardian and their siblings if necessary, and the Home Office will carry out biometric checks before travel, according to the newspaper. Project Pure Hope welcomed the government's announcement and said it would be sharing its expertise from nearly two years of successful evacuations. 'Our blueprint can help ensure the UK acts quickly and effectively so that every child who needs urgent care has the best chance of survival and recovery,' a spokesperson said. The charity has been urging the government to create a scheme similar to the one established for Ukrainian refugees since November 2023. The UK has been working with the Jordanian government to airdrop humanitarian aid into Gaza in response to the widespread starvation caused by Israel's blockade. Starmer has announced plans for the UK to recognise a Palestinian state in September before the UN general assembly unless Israel agrees to a ceasefire, allows more aid into Gaza, stops annexing land in the West Bank and commits to a peace process leading to a two-state solution.
