Alabama attorney general pushes for trial of an ex-officer accused of fatally shooting an armed man
In a court brief filed late Tuesday, Attorney General Steve Marshall said a lower court was correct in ruling that former Decatur police officer Mac Marquette, 25, failed to show "a clear legal right to prosecutorial immunity' when he fatally shot Stephen Perkins on Sept. 29, 2023.
Shortly before 2 a.m., Marquette and two other officers accompanied the tow truck driver to repossess Perkins' pickup truck at his home in Decatur. When Perkins emerged from his house pointing a gun at the truck driver, Marquette fired 18 bullets less than two seconds after the officers emerged from a concealed position and identified themselves as law enforcement, according to body camera footage.
The appeals court decision, and the fate of the trial, hinges on Alabama's ' stand your ground ' law, which grants immunity from prosecution to anyone who uses deadly force as long as they reasonably believe they're in danger and are somewhere they're rightfully allowed to be. Alabama allows judges to determine if someone acted in self-defense before a case goes to trial.
After a Morgan County judge denied Marquette immunity in April, the ex-officer's lawyers asked the Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals to overturn the decision. The appeals court said the circuit judge's decision was a 'gross abuse of discretion' because the judge didn't give enough weight to Marquette's assertion that he feared for his life after Perkins pointed his gun at the officer before he was shot.
If the appeals court rules against Marquette, he will go to trial in September.
The shooting drew regular protests in the north Alabama city, and the three officers were fired after personnel hearings. Marquette is white.
While the attorney general's brief didn't contest that Marquette feared for his life, he argued that witnesses in a pre-trial hearing failed to establish that Marquette was at Perkins' house on legitimate police duty, and therefore 'there remain open questions regarding whether he had a legal right" to be there.
The brief, written by the Assistant Attorney General Kristi Wilkerson, pointed to conflicting testimony from the two officers who were with Marquette when he shot Perkins.
One officer testified that the three officers were at Perkins' house to investigate a misdemeanor menacing charge since Perkins had previously pulled a gun on the tow truck driver in an attempt to repossess Perkins' truck earlier that night. The other officer testified that he was unaware of a menacing investigation, saying that he believed they were there to assist in 'keeping the peace.'
Alabama law requires a court order for law enforcement to be involved in a vehicle repossession — which the officers didn't have.
Testimony from a state agent who investigated the shooting, Jamie King, also conflicted with both officers' accounts of the moments leading up to the shooting. King said that while Marquette may have feared for his life, the three officers were not positioned in an effective way to keep the peace or to investigate menacing since they were intentionally out of Perkins' view until seconds before the shooting.
Marquette's attorneys have argued that there is more than one way to conduct police operations.
In light of the ambiguity, Marshall's office said deference should be given to the trial court's position, and that a jury "alone is in the best position to determine the trustworthiness of testimony presented to it.'
All parties in the case are prohibited from speaking to the media.
___
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
17 minutes ago
- The Independent
District attorneys says Alabama teen killed by police had grabbed a gun
A district attorney said Wednesday that an Alabama police officer who fatally shot a teenager in the back was justified in his use of deadly force because the youth grabbed a gun after struggling with the officer. But the teen's family questioned that conclusion and said they have many unanswered questions about what had happened. Jefferson County District Attorney Dany Carr announced that no charges will be brought against the officer who shot and killed Jabari Peoples, 18. Peoples was shot on June 23 by a police officer in a parking lot in Homewood, an affluent suburb near the city of Birmingham. Peoples and a friend had been parked in the parking lot. Carr said an officer had approached the car at about 9:30 p.m. and attempted to detain Peoples because of suspected marijuana in the car. The officer attempted to put handcuffs on Mr. Peoples 'for officer safety' after noticing a gun in the car door but a struggle ensued, Carr wrote. He said Peoples then ran back to his vehicle and grabbed a gun. 'At the time of the shooting, Mr. Peoples had the gun in his right hand and the officer fired one shot, hitting Mr. Peoples in the left side of the back causing injury that ultimately caused his death,' Carr wrote in a statement. Carr made the announcement immediately after showing the family body camera footage of the shooting. The footage has not been released to the public. But a family member said they were only shown a short clip that was hard to see and want additional information. 'I have so many unanswered questions, still. Today, what I saw on this video, my brother was afraid. He was scared. He was running for his life,' Angel Smith, People's sister, said. Smith said her brother could be heard saying, 'Sir, I promise I'm not trying to resist.' Ben Crump, an attorney representing the family, said they want full transparency. He said the police department should release all of the available video. 'We want exactly what you would want if this was your son that was shot in the back running away from the police,' Crump said. Homewood Police Chief Tim Ross did not immediately return an email seeking comment. Groups have staged regular protests in Homewood since the shooting, criticizing the police department's refusal to show the video to family members. Carr made the decision to show the video to family members after the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency turned its findings over to his office. Peoples was a 2024 graduate of Aliceville High School in the city of the same name, about 100 miles (160 kilometers) west of Homewood.
Daily Mail
18 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
JD Vance ridicules CNN 'fake news' on secret Jeffrey Epstein strategy meeting and says they need 'better sources'
Vice President JD Vance denied Wednesday that he would host a meeting to discuss the administration's response to the Jeffrey Epstein files, ridiculing a CNN report that reported details of the planned event as 'fake news.' The vice president was specifically asked to address the report by President Donald Trump during an event in the Oval Office. 'I saw the report today, and it's completely fake news, we are not meeting to talk about the Epstein situation,' Vance replied. 'I think the reporter who reported it needs to get better sources.' Trump described the whole Epstein controversy as a 'hoax' that was 'put out by the Democrats ' to distract from his administration's success. 'That's just a way of trying to divert attention to something that's total bulls*it,' the president added. CNN reported that Vance was hosting a meeting Wednesday evening to discuss the Epstein files that would include White House chief of staff Susie Wiles, Attorney General Pam Bondi, FBI Director Kash Patel and Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche. The report was bylined by five different CNN reporters citing 'three sources familiar' with details of the event. The vice president's office denied the scheduled meeting after the CNN report was published Wednesday morning. 'The CNN story is pure fiction,' William Martin, Communications Director to the Vice President told the Daily Mail. 'There was never a supposed meeting scheduled at the Vice President's residence to discuss Epstein Strategy.' The White House did not respond to a Daily Mail request for comment. The vice president has been working behind the scenes to get Bondi and Patel on the same page, but is not specifically leading the administration's response to Epstein. A second source close to the FBI told the Daily Mail that Vance likely sees the Epstein files as a possible liability for his all-but-certain run for president in 2028, 'so trying to distance himself from the mishaps but also be part of the solution' is important to him. Blanche recently spent nine-hours meeting with Ghislaine Maxwell to discuss the case. Maxwell, Epstein's ex-girlfriend and business associate was was convicted of sex trafficking and sentenced to 20 years in prison in 2022. During the meeting, Maxwell told Blanche that Trump never did anything harmful in her presence according to sources speaking to ABC News. Administration officials are weighing whether to release transcripts of the interviews, but have not made a decision. Maxwell was transported from a federal prison in Tallahassee, Florida after her meeting with Blanche to a more relaxed security prison in Texas. Maxwell's attorney said after the meeting that she 'didn't hold anything back' in the interview, and spoke about 'one hundred' different people in the case. President Trump said he was unaware of Maxwell's transfer but described it as routine. 'I didn't know about it at all. I read about it just like you did,' he told reporters on Tuesday. 'It's not a very uncommon thing.' Trump has not ruled out a pardon for Maxwell. The family of Virginia Roberts Giuffre, a survivor of Epstein's abuse, issued a statement calling for the adminstration to meet with 'any survivor of the vicious crimes of convicted perjurer and sex trafficker Ghislaine Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein.' 'Their voices must be heard, above all. We also call upon the House subcommittee to invite survivors to testify,' Sky and Amanda Roberts said in a joint statement with Danny and Lanette Wilson. Giuffre died in April 2025, as the cause of death was ruled a suicide. 'Any information that may be released by the government should take into account the survivors who wish to remain anonymous, for their safety and well-being. They should be consulted first,' the family members concluded. Democrats were quick to target Vance's role in the controversy, given that he once was a vocal proponent of releasing all the documents related to the deceased pedophile. 'The Epstein files coverup is happening before our eyes and the entire Trump White House is complicit including JD Vance who at one point tried to distance himself from it all,' said Tommy Vietor, the former Obama national security official and current podcast host. The Trump administration continues to weigh their response to the controversy that began a month ago after the Department of Justice released a memo that said Epstein did not have a 'client list' that could be released and that there was no evidence of foul play in Epstein's death in prison, after it was ruled a suicide. Vance last addressed the administration's handling of the files, denying that the they were 'shielding' Epstein and his clients. 'We're not shielding anything,' the vice president told a reporter who asked him about protestors in Ohio. 'The president has directed the attorney general to release all credible information and frankly to go and find additional credible information related to the Jeffrey Epstein case.' Vance has defended Bondi for her handling of the case, even as prominent Trump allies have blamed her for the tone-deaf handling of the case. 'I know, because I talk to her all the time, the attorney general is hard at work on that now,' Vance said. Vance insisted that Trump had 'nothing to hide' in the Epstein files and predicted more details about the Epstein case in the coming days.
Daily Mail
18 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Ex-Trump investigator Robert Mueller discovered in memory-care facility as Republicans demand his Epstein testimony
Former FBI Director Robert Mueller, the man who led the Russia investigation into President Donald Trump, has reportedly lived in a memory-care facility for years. Muller, 80, served as the sixth director of the FBI from 2001 until 2013 and the special counsel overseeing the federal government's multi-year investigation into Russia's ties to the 2016 Trump campaign. The probe found that neither Trump nor members of his campaign team coordinated with the Russians on their interference. It did not conclude whether Trump obstructed the investigation, citing DOJ policy not to indict sitting presidents. Mueller's investigation dominated years of news coverage, and Trump frequently lashed out at the special counsel and his efforts, repeatedly labeling the effort as a 'witch hunt' and 'Russia hoax.' Now, just a few years after the bombshell report was released, Mueller is spending time in a memory-care unit, sources familiar with the matter told Real Clear Investigations. 'Sources tell me Mueller has been living in a memory-care facility for the past few years,' reporter Paul Sperry wrote on X Tuesday. The news comes as Mueller is scheduled to sit with the House Oversight Committee investigators regarding the FBI's work relating to Jeffrey Epstein next month. Mueller testified before lawmakers in July 2019 to speak about his investigation. He frequently had to consult his notes during the session The committee is seeking information Mueller may know about Epstein from overseeing the FBI during the pedophile's 2005 Florida prostitution case, a matter in which the FBI eventually intervened. Many critics have said Epstein's sentence in that case was too lenient. The Daily Mail reached out to a former Mueller spokesman for a statement. And one former lawmaker is now saying the signs of Mueller's decline have been evident for years. 'It was clear this is where things were heading when we questioned him before Congress,' ex-Rep. Matt Gaetz, R-Fla., posted on social media. 'Mueller was used by some very vicious people,' Gaetz, now a conservative TV host, continued. 'I'm not sure he really ever knew what was happening in the investigation.' Mueller testified before Congress about his report's findings in the summer of 2019. During that hearing, the former special counsel struggled at times to remember the questions from lawmakers, often asking them to repeat their inquiries. He also appeared flustered at times when trying to remember key portions of his probe. During his testimony, he forgot that Fusion GPS, an opposition research firm, was behind the infamous Steele Dossier - a file that alleged false ties between Trump and the Russians that many presume was the origin of the Trump-Russia allegations. A spokesperson for the House Oversight Committee did not respond to the Daily Mail's request for comment on whether they sent Mueller's subpoena to a memory-care unit. Still, the committee's chairman, James Comer, R-Ky., says he is expecting Mueller to show up and talk. Comer posted on his X on Tuesday that Mueller is scheduled to appear for a transcribed interview with the committee on September 2. Other top Trump and Obama administration officials will also testify in the committee's probe into Epstein. Bill and Hillary Clinton are both scheduled to sit with the committee in October. Former Attorneys General Eric Holder, Loretta Lynch, Merrick Garland and Trump's former DOJ boss Bill Barr are also expected to talk to the lawmakers. It's a spectacular move by Republicans to pressure Trump's Attorney General Pam Bondi to put out more documents related to the disgraced financier while the administration has been embroiled in controversy over 'cover-up' claims. Bondi has been blamed by both Democrats and Republicans for stalling the release of the files. The Trump administration has since hurried to find out more about the Epstein scandal. Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche has met with Epstein's accomplice and longtime partner, Ghislaine Maxwell, to speak about what she knows about the late pedophile's crimes. Blanche spent several days in Florida at the detention facility where Maxwell was staying to interview the woman who is currently serving a 20-year sentence for sex trafficking crimes. She has repeatedly claimed she was treated wrongly during her trial, a claim that will soon be argued before the Supreme Court.
