HC seeks Centre reply on plea on Delhi Police's powers over online content
The Delhi high court has sought responses from the Union government and lieutenant governor (LG) Vinai Kumar Saxena on a petition challenging a Central notification that empowers Delhi Police officers to issue takedown orders to social media platforms for removing online content.
A bench of chief justice DK Upadhyay and justice Tushar Rao Gedela on Wednesday issued notice to the LG and the Union ministry of electronics and information technology (MEIT) on a plea filed by the Software Freedom Law Centre (SFLC). The matter will be heard next on September 17.
The petition pertains to a gazette notification issued on December 26, 2024, through which Saxena authorised at least 23 senior Delhi Police officers to issue takedown orders under Section 79(3)(b) of the Information Technology (IT) Act. This section makes intermediaries — such as Facebook, YouTube, Jio, and Cloudflare — liable for third-party content if they fail to remove unlawful material after being notified by the 'appropriate government' or its agency.
According to the notification, officers authorised to issue such notices include DCPs of Delhi's districts, the intelligence fusion and strategic operations (IFSO) unit, economic offences wing, crime branch, special cell, special branch, IGI Airport, Railways and Metro units. These officers can act in cases reported within their jurisdiction and 'notify instances of information, data or communication links' connected to any computer resource used to commit an unlawful act.
The notification also designated the joint commissioner of police, IFSO, as the state nodal officer, with the DCP IFSO appointed as assistant state nodal officer.
SFLC, represented by advocate Talha Abdul Rehman, argued that empowering police officers to issue unilateral takedown orders without judicial oversight was 'arbitrary' and 'violative of due process'.
'The statutory power to block or remove online content is exclusively vested in the Central Government under Section 69A of the IT Act, read with the Information Technology Rules, 2009. The impugned notification, by granting these powers to the police, oversteps constitutional and statutory boundaries and is, therefore, ultra vires the parent legislation,' the plea said.
It further argued that only the Centre has the authority to issue such directives under Section 69A and that the move violates Articles 19 and 21 of the Constitution. It also contradicts landmark Supreme Court judgments that underscore the importance of legal safeguards and proportionality in actions affecting fundamental rights.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
29 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Delhi Police bust pan-India cybercrime syndicate
The Delhi Police Crime Branch has dismantled a sprawling, pan-India cybercrime syndicate allegedly involved in a range of illegal activities, including sextortion, banking fraud, and cyber scams, officials said on Tuesday. The criminal network operated across Delhi, Rajasthan, and Uttar Pradesh, according to the police. The operation resulted in the seizure of 28 mobile phones, 30 SIM cards, two laptops, eight cheque books, 15 debit cards, and several bank account credentials used for illegal financial transactions, the police stated. Videos and photographs used to blackmail victims were also recovered, and a money trail amounting to over Rs 5 crore has been identified, officials added. The operation was initiated on May 24 following a tip-off regarding the movement of a suspicious consignment containing synthetic bank account kits in the New Ashok Nagar area, the police said. 'These kits were reportedly being used in various high-tech crimes such as sextortion, cyber fraud, banking scams, debit or credit card cloning — crimes that have seen a recent surge both in frequency and sophistication,' Aditya Gautam, Deputy Commissioner of Police (DCP), Crime Branch, said. The intelligence indicated that the kits were to be delivered and distributed near the vicinity of Mayur Vihar Phase-1 Extension, DCP Gautam said, adding that 'an immediate and decisive operational response was formulated'. The operation resulted in the arrests of three men, identified as Ujjawal Pandey, 30, Gaurav Barua, 24, and Yug Sharma, 19. The accused were allegedly arrested with the synthetic kits and associated paraphernalia, including pre-activated SIM cards, forged bank documents, and digital devices used to carry out fraudulent transactions, the police said. These kits enabled fraudsters to bypass KYC norms and execute untraceable financial operations, the police added. Further investigation based on inputs from those arrested led to a raid in the Mundka area where a fake call centre was masquerading as a bank loan provider, according to the police. Here, seven more people were caught. According to the police, the operation was led by Dilshad Ali, who ran the centre along with his associate, Amit, who is currently absconding. The call centre's modus operandi involved luring victims with attractive loan offers, collecting their identification details, and then extorting money under the guise of processing fees before cutting all contact, the police said. Ali, who was previously involved in a 2019 case under various sections of the Indian Penal Code and the IT Act in Maharashtra, acted as the team leader, the police said. Six call centre employees were also arrested. The police said they were mostly young telemarketers who were computer literate and earning between Rs 8,000 and Rs 9,000 per month. Building on leads from the arrested individuals, another raid was conducted in New Ashok Nagar, resulting in the arrest of four more accused and the exposure of a well-organised sextortion racket, the police said. 'These individuals employed a deceitful method to lure and exploit victims. Initially, they would send friend requests on Facebook and obtain the victim's mobile number through Facebook Messenger. Subsequently, they would initiate a video call on WhatsApp, during which they would stream pornographic clips, secretly recording the victim's screen and reactions using screen recording tools. The recorded content was then used to blackmail the victim under threats of publicly circulating the video on social media platforms, thereby coercing them into transferring money,' said DCP Gautam. The accused in the case come from diverse backgrounds and regions, the police said. Pandey, originally from Krishna Nagar, Delhi, came into the cyber fraud world through his cybercafe venture, according to the police. Barua, a graduate from IGNOU, allegedly transitioned from a legitimate job in an insurance company to fraudulent financial operations. Sharma, the youngest among the arrested, assisted in supplying fake SIM cards and account kits, and Ali, who had a corporate background, played a central role in managing the fraudulent call centre, as per the police. The accused in the sextortion gang were identified as Jahid, 20, Raheesh, 21, and Sohil, 18, all from Deeg in Rajasthan. Jahid, a third-year student, was identified as the alleged ringleader of the sextortion racket, while Raheesh and Sohil allegedly assisted in blackmail operations. Jayshree, a 24-year-old graduate from Alwar University and a former SBI BPO employee, also played a vital role in making calls and luring victims, the police said.
NDTV
32 minutes ago
- NDTV
Court Upholds Tamil Nadu's Night Ban On Online Gaming, Cites Loss Of Lives
The Madras High Court on Tuesday upheld the Tamil Nadu government's restrictions on the ban from midnight to 5 AM on playing online real money games. The court, while hearing petitions by online gaming companies to declare as unconstitutional the Tamil Nadu Online Gaming Authority (Real Money Games), Regulations 2025 enacted by the Tamil Nadu Online Gaming Authority, upheld the MK Stalin-led government's restrictions, citing that nearly 50 people have died by suicide due to online gaming losses. The requirement for platforms to implement Aadhaar-based authentication to ensure only adults (18+) can access real-money games was also sustained by a bench of Justices SM Subramanian and K Rajasekar. They dismissed the pleas filed by various online gaming operators who argued that the state government overstepped its constitutional bounds and that regulation should fall solely under the central government's purview. "The state government has placed sufficient material on record to demonstrate the existence of a public health crisis arising from online gaming addiction, leading to financial ruin, mental distress, and tragically, loss of life," the court observed in its judgment. "In light of the specific and grave situation within Tamil Nadu, exemplified by the reported deaths of at least 47 individuals, the state is well within its powers under the Constitution to enact measures to protect its citizens on grounds of public health and public order," the bench added. The government presented data showing instances of suicides and extreme distress directly linked to massive debts accumulated through losses in online real-money games. The dismissal is a significant setback for the online gaming companies operating in Tamil Nadu. The mandatory "blank hours" directly impact user engagement and potential revenue during late-night periods. The Aadhaar-based authentication, while aimed at protecting minors, adds a layer of compliance and potentially affects user acquisition and ease of access. Representatives of the online gaming industry expressed disappointment with the ruling, reiterating concerns about state overreach and the impact on legitimate businesses.
Time of India
43 minutes ago
- Time of India
Strengthening national security: A unified approach to CAPF and IPS integration
Throwing the baby with the bathwater is not a good idea. And, the solution is not as complex as it seems. Last week, the Supreme Court, in a significant ruling, decreed that the Group 'A' cadres of the Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs) be recognised as 'Organised Services' for all purposes. Also adding that, IPS deputation to CAPFs in senior ranks be 'reduced progressively within two years'. Given that both CAPFs and IPS are crucial components of our security architecture, what does this ruling imply for our national security? CAPFs and IPS – both integral components of internal security apparatus The CAPFs and the IPS constitute crucial links in the all-important chain of the country's internal security architecture. While CAPFs like BSF (Border Security Force), ITBP (Indo Tibetan Border Police), SSB (Sashastra Seema Bal) are responsible for securing the country's borders against illegal immigration, infiltration of undesirable elements, trans-border crimes including smuggling of narcotics, firearms, etc., the role of CISF (Central Industrial Security Force) is to provide similar security to the critical infrastructure and strategic industrial establishments of the nation. The primary role of CRPF (Central Reserve Police Force) is to assist the state police forces in handling public disorder situations and countering insurgency. The CAPFs, thus, not only perform various internal security-related policing tasks, but also have to work in close concert with state police forces for effective discharge of their responsibilities. The IPS, on the other hand, is an All-India Service, under Article 312 of the Constitution. The founding fathers had recognised the IAS and IPS as important instruments to respectively steer the administrative and security apparatuses of the nation. Thus, in keeping with the quasi-federal nature of its polity, these two services were classified as 'All India Services' – as distinct from Central Services and State Services – that would man senior positions under both the Union and the State governments, besides serving as a valuable bridge between the two. IPS, thus, was envisaged as a binding mechanism between the state and central internal security organisations, and not as merely a glorified State Service Now, the internal security (IS) architecture of the country comprises several disparate state and central agencies and is rather loosely structured, with one of the principal IS organs – the police being under the states' domain, and the CAPFs under the union government. In pursuit of their common overall objective, all wings of the IS apparatus must work in total unison. The IPS, with its members manning leadership positions at cutting-edge as well as policy and direction levels – in all components of the apparatus – provides the necessary binding thread in the country's IS structure. This arrangement has stood the test of time – joint actions have been successful in countering major internal security challenges, like terrorism in Punjab, insurgency in Tripura, or left-wing extremist violence in the hinterland. What's the issue? The grievances of directly recruited gazetted officers of the CAPFs are genuine. Having been recruited to a Group 'A' service and then denied the status of members of an 'organised service', along with constricted promotion prospects, are valid gripes. Things were fine as long as their own officer cadres of CAPFs were limited to Group 'B', filled by either departmental promotees or deputationists, mostly from the state police. Direct recruitment was then limited, and that too, only at Group 'B' level. The original scheme perhaps envisaged that most senior-level posts – barring small numbers earmarked for promotion of departmental officers – would be manned by IPS officers. The IPS (Fixation of Cadre Strength) Regulations provided for a 'Reserve' in each state cadre, to the extent of 40 percent of senior posts authorised for that cadre, to cater specifically for postings in central organisations. However, the increasing security challenges over the decades necessitated not only expansion of the existing security set-up, but also creation of new organisations. Operational needs also necessitated the presence of Group 'A' officers in good numbers in the field. This led to direct recruitment of Group A' officers in CAPFs. These officers, upon promotion to senior scale, have since started manning most senior posts in their respective CAPFs – practically all posts at the Commandant level in most CAPFs are now filled with officers from their own cadres. 80 percent of the posts at the DIG level, and 50 percent at the IG level, are also manned by CAPFs' own cadre officers. A workable solution: Integration of CAPF officers with the IPS The bonafide grievance of the CAPF cadre officers needs to be addressed, and on an urgent footing. Yet, upsetting the apple cart by 'reducing the IPS deputations progressively within two years' does not make sense. Why throw the baby out with the bathwater! The solution really is not as complex as it seems. It requires the Group 'A' cadres of CAPFs to be integrated with the overall structure of the IPS. The National Police Commission had, in its Sixth Report, in fact, made a useful recommendation for creation of an IPS Cadre for CAPFs. This pragmatic NPC recommendation, which had remained unimplemented, can now be implemented – perhaps with some necessary modifications. This appears imperative now, given the dire need to ensure cohesion in the higher echelons of the country's IS apparatus. A workable proposition would entail identifying all senior posts (Commandants and above) of various CAPFs as 'senior duty posts', for inclusion in this IPS cadre of CAPFs. Picture credit: X/CAPF Why this is a win-win for all All officers holding 'senior posts' in CAPFs would then be from the IPS – either via direct recruitment through the Civil Services examination and allocated to CAPF cadre; or promoted to the IPS from the Group 'B' cadres of CAPFs; or IPS officers on deputation from state cadres. Existing Group 'A' officers of CAPFs, too, would be eligible for absorption in the newly created IPS cadre. What's important is, they would all be officers of one single service – namely, the IPS. This will provide for the crucial familial bond between senior officers of all internal security organisations – whether central or state police agencies – as it now exists between IPS officers of different state cadres. A provision for deputation of the CAPF-cadre IPS officers to states would also enrich the state armed police wings, given their all-India experience and outlook. Overall, this is a practicable way to bring about a meaningful cohesion in the country's internal security apparatus without causing problems for either of the two categories. And this would surely strengthen our internal security architecture. Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email Disclaimer Views expressed above are the author's own.
