Father who took seven-year-old son to Manvers hotel riot jailed
A father who took his seven-year-old son to a riot at a hotel housing asylum seekers has been jailed.James Garbutt, 41, was seen with they boy on his shoulders outside the Holiday Inn Express in Manvers, Rotherham, on 4 August when major violence broke out.Sheffield Crown Court was also shown footage of Garbutt, of Kingsbrook Chase, Rotherham, pushing two supermarket trolleys into a fast-moving police car in the nearby Aldi car park.Jailing him for two years and four months earlier, the Recorder of Sheffield, Judge Jeremy Richardson KC, told the defendant he was "a dreadful example" to his son and should be "comprehensively ashamed".
Father-of-three Garbutt, who had 18 previous convictions for various offences such as drug trafficking, harassment, assault and driving while over the prescribed limit, had previously pleaded guilty to violent disorder.He was also issued with a 10-year criminal behaviour order during the hearing.The court heard Garbutt, a sales manager who lived near the hotel, came across the disorder while on a day out with the youngster and decided to stay.
Footage showed the pair walking through an increasingly volatile crowd and taking turns filming the scene with Garbutt's mobile phone.At around 13:45 BST, Garbutt and the boy were seen in the Aldi supermarket car park, located near to the hotel, where Garbutt grabbed hold of two supermarket trolleys and pushed them into an oncoming police car.In other clips, Garbutt could be seen bare-chested shortly before a fire was started in front of the hotel's emergency exit, which prevented those inside from evacuating.Judge Richardson accepted while Garbutt was "well to the fore" he was there as a "supporter, egging others on" and only actively participated in the disorder in one episode.Judge Richardson told him: "Unquestionably the most serious aggravating feature of this case is the fact that at all material times you had your seven-year-old son with you. "At any stage of various incidents you could and should have removed not only yourself but most certainly your son."Listen to highlights from South Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
a day ago
- The Sun
Moment evil soldier who raped woman in town centre is caught cowering in toilet cubicle after fleeing ‘horrific' attack
THIS is the moment an "evil" soldier who raped a woman after dragging her off the street was caught hiding in a loo. Shrewsbury Crown Court heard that Private John Harvey didn't know the woman, who is in her 20s. 4 4 4 The 25-year-old man targeted her and dragged her off the street in Shrewsbury, Shropshire. He then raped the terrified victim twice during the "horrific" 20-minute attack. Harvey, who lived at a military barracks near Market Drayton and had a "respectable" army career, attacked the woman in the early hours of July 6 last year. After raping her, Harvey - who is said to be an "educated man with a degree" - fled and the woman bravely called police. Later, Judge Richard McConaghy said the recording of the 999 call was "harrowing" to listen to. Cops swarmed the area in their hunt for the sick soldier. Harvey was found hours later at around 6.30am, cowering inside a toilet cubicle at Shrewsbury train station. He had missed his last train and headed back towards the woman he attacked. But a court heard he was "put off" by the fact she was on the phone to the police and went back to the train station to hide. Bodycam footage showed the moment officers handcuffed him after forcing open the door. Harvey initially admitted raping the woman but then changed his plea, forcing the survivor to face him in court. During the trial at Shrewsbury Crown Court, the jury heard the victim had been forced to relive "the worst moment of my life repeatedly". Following a nine-day trial in February, Harvey was found guilty of rape by a unanimous verdict. Yesterday, he was jailed for nine years and ordered to sign the sex offenders' register for life. Detective Constable Sam Jones, from Shropshire's Reactive CID, said: "I am extremely pleased with the sentence that has been given to Harvey by the judge today, as he is a danger to the wider public, in particular women. "In July last year Harvey committed a purely evil crime. "Despite admitting to the offences during a police interview when he was arrested, he then changed his story at court, subjecting his victim and her loved ones to sit through a trial and relive that awful night. "I would like to take this opportunity to thank the victim for her bravery and resilience throughout the entire investigation and trial." 4
The Independent
2 days ago
- The Independent
Army private raped stranger in doorway before hiding in railway station toilet
An Army soldier who raped a stranger in a doorway in the early hours and then hid in a railway station toilet cubicle, has been jailed for nine years. Private John Harvey made a full confession to police after accosting and attacking the young woman as she walked through Shrewsbury town centre. But he then pleaded not guilty and forced her to 'relive the worst moment of my life' by giving evidence at a nine-day trial. Harvey, of Clive Barracks in Tern Hill, near Market Drayton, Shropshire, was found guilty of two counts of rape and one of assault by penetration at Shrewsbury Crown Court in February. Harvey, 25, appeared relaxed in a video-link from HMP Hewell at Stoke-on-Trent Crown Court on Thursday, as Judge Richard McConaghy told him the offence was aggravated by the fact he was drunk and the 'vulnerable' woman was walking alone at night. The judge told Harvey: 'She walked away and rang 999, audio of that call in the state that she was in is harrowing to listen to.' The court heard Harvey, who had missed his last train, went back towards the woman after the sexual assaults, but was 'put off' as she was on the phone to police, and went instead to Shrewsbury railway station. Video released by West Mercia Police after Harvey was jailed showed him being arrested by officers at the station at 6.32am in July last year. The video clip shows officers ordering Harvey to open the cubicle and then handcuffing him before he provided his name. Harvey, who was also ordered to serve an extended three-year period on licence after his eventual release, was said by the judge to be an 'educated man with a degree' and to have had a 'respectable career' at the time of the attack. In a victim impact statement to the court read by counsel, the woman, who cannot be identified, said her 20-minute ordeal had left her with post-traumatic disorder. The woman said: 'My home has become the only place I feel calm. The offender has convinced me terrible people who can do terrible things are everywhere.' 'I was forced to endure rape. The offender also forced me to fight my corner in a trial. I was forced by him to relive the worst moment of my life repeatedly. 'This event from the beginning to the end is the worst and hardest thing I have ever had to endure.' During his sentencing remarks, the judge told Harvey, who is now working as a prison cleaner and training as a mentor: 'You co-operated on arrest and made full admissions to having raped her. 'You however chose to throw that mitigation away by contesting the trial in the face of very strong evidence and made her give evidence despite your own confession of what you had done.' After the sentencing, Detective Constable Sam Jones said: 'I am extremely pleased with the sentence that has been given to Harvey by the judge today, as he is a danger to the wider public, in particular, women. 'In July last year Harvey committed a purely evil crime, and despite admitting to the offences during a police interview when he was arrested, he then changed his story at court, subjecting his victim and her loved ones to sit through a trial and relive that awful night. 'I would like to take this opportunity to thank the victim for her bravery and resilience throughout the entire investigation and trial.' No details of Harvey's military service or his employment by the Army were disclosed at his sentencing hearing. Clive Barracks is the long-term home of the 1st Battalion of the Royal Irish Regiment. In a statement which did not confirm details of Harvey's unit, an Army spokesperson said: 'We can confirm that Private John Harvey appeared for sentencing at Stoke-on-Trent Crown Court on June 5 2025, convicted of a sexual offence. He was sentenced to nine years imprisonment.'
The Independent
2 days ago
- The Independent
Army private who carried out ‘harrowing' rape of stranger jailed for nine years
An Army soldier who raped a stranger in a doorway in the early hours and then hid in a railway station toilet cubicle, has been jailed for nine years. Private John Harvey made a full confession to police after accosting and attacking the young woman as she walked through Shrewsbury town centre. But he then pleaded not guilty and forced her to 'relive the worst moment of my life' by giving evidence at a nine-day trial. Harvey, of Clive Barracks in Tern Hill, near Market Drayton, Shropshire, was found guilty of two counts of rape and one of assault by penetration at Shrewsbury Crown Court in February. Harvey, 25, appeared relaxed in a video-link from HMP Hewell at Stoke-on-Trent Crown Court on Thursday, as Judge Richard McConaghy told him the offence was aggravated by the fact he was drunk and the 'vulnerable' woman was walking alone at night. The judge told Harvey: 'She walked away and rang 999, audio of that call in the state that she was in is harrowing to listen to.' The court heard Harvey, who had missed his last train, went back towards the woman after the sexual assaults, but was 'put off' as she was on the phone to police, and went instead to Shrewsbury railway station. Video released by West Mercia Police after Harvey was jailed showed him being arrested by officers at the station at 6.32am in July last year. The video clip shows officers ordering Harvey to open the cubicle and then handcuffing him before he provided his name. Harvey, who was also ordered to serve an extended three-year period on licence after his eventual release, was said by the judge to be an 'educated man with a degree' and to have had a 'respectable career' at the time of the attack. In a victim impact statement to the court read by counsel, the woman, who cannot be identified, said her 20-minute ordeal had left her with post-traumatic disorder. The woman said: 'My home has become the only place I feel calm. The offender has convinced me terrible people who can do terrible things are everywhere.' 'I was forced to endure rape. The offender also forced me to fight my corner in a trial. I was forced by him to relive the worst moment of my life repeatedly. 'This event from the beginning to the end is the worst and hardest thing I have ever had to endure.' During his sentencing remarks, the judge told Harvey, who is now working as a prison cleaner and training as a mentor: 'You co-operated on arrest and made full admissions to having raped her. 'You however chose to throw that mitigation away by contesting the trial in the face of very strong evidence and made her give evidence despite your own confession of what you had done.' After the sentencing, Detective Constable Sam Jones said: 'I am extremely pleased with the sentence that has been given to Harvey by the judge today, as he is a danger to the wider public, in particular, women. 'In July last year Harvey committed a purely evil crime, and despite admitting to the offences during a police interview when he was arrested, he then changed his story at court, subjecting his victim and her loved ones to sit through a trial and relive that awful night. 'I would like to take this opportunity to thank the victim for her bravery and resilience throughout the entire investigation and trial.' No details of Harvey's military service or his employment by the Army were disclosed at his sentencing hearing. Clive Barracks is the long-term home of the 1st Battalion of the Royal Irish Regiment. In a statement which did not confirm details of Harvey's unit, an Army spokesperson said: 'We can confirm that Private John Harvey appeared for sentencing at Stoke-on-Trent Crown Court on June 5 2025, convicted of a sexual offence. He was sentenced to nine years imprisonment.'
