Wee defends call to reform tax appeals system
PETALING JAYA : MCA president Wee Ka Siong has defended his call for the tax appeals system to be reformed, which led to a call for him to be referred to Parliament's rights and privileges committee.
The Ayer Hitam MP had cited the legal dispute between Tenaga Nasional Bhd and the Inland Revenue Board (LHDN) yesterday when calling for LHDN to be made an independent statutory body reporting to Parliament.
He said such an approach would be a key reform to ensure LHDN was free from political interests or pressure.
TNB is facing a RM5.05 billion tax bill following a Federal Court ruling that it is not eligible to claim reinvestment allowance. The apex court had earlier overturned a Court of Appeal ruling that found TNB to be in the business of manufacturing electricity.
The Federal Court said TNB should actually have been considered a utility company under Schedule 7B of the Income Tax Act 1967 (ITA).
The dispute arose when LHDN disallowed TNB's claim under Schedule 7A of the ITA on the basis that the generation, distribution and transmission of electricity was not manufacturing of electricity.
In a statement today, Wee said that no one was disputing the court's ruling that TNB should have applied under Schedule 7B, nor was it about the company's status as a utility or manufacturer.
'The real issue is the fate of RM5 billion in rakyat's savings,' he said.
He said what DAP's Chong Zhemin 'conveniently ignores' was that TNB was majority-owned by public savings funds through Amanah Saham Nasional Bhd, EPF, the Retirement Fund Inc (KWAP), Lembaga Tabung Haji and others.
If the government, via LHDN, enforced the court ruling, the RM5 billion would go into its coffers, he said.
He said the law clearly gave the finance minister absolute power to approve TNB's appeal and re-application under Section 7B to waive the disputed amount.
Yesterday, Wee and Chong, who is the Kampar MP, traded bards in the lower house when Wee claimed that it would be 'daylight robbery' if the government decided to enforce the ruling.
This led to Chong claiming that the 'daylight robbery' remark was inaccurate, and accused Wee of misleading the house. Chong also demanded Wee retract the claim and threatened to refer him to the rights and privileges committee.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Free Malaysia Today
3 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Abolishing student loans doable, Shafie Apdal insists
Warisan president Shafie Apdal said his pledge is not a political gimmick. (Facebook pic) PETALING JAYA : Warisan president Shafie Apdal has defended his promise to write off outstanding student loans for Sabahans if his party forms the government after the upcoming state election. The former Sabah chief minister said his pledge was not a political gimmick and that it was financially doable, Malaysiakini reported. 'In 2019, I paid RM1 billion of debts left by BN,' he was quoted as saying, referring to the time the state government he led settled the federal government's bond ahead of its maturity date. 'If I can pay BN's debts, why can't we pay the debts of our students?' Shafie said the pledge could be realised by channelling revenue from timber concessions into Yayasan Sabah for education. He claimed to know which timber concessions can be set aside so the money goes to Yayasan Sabah. 'Then Yayasan Sabah can use it to pay off our children's debts,' he said. On Tuesday, a youth NGO dismissed Warisan's pledge as mere rhetoric. The Sabah Youth Council said even if Warisan kept its promise, the financial implications would be huge, and would impact other sectors in terms of funding. Its president, Abqaree Fawwaz Abekan, said it would be more practical for Warisan to subsidise the loans by 50%, especially for the needy.
Free Malaysia Today
4 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Masidi calls out Shafie's RM1bil debt settlement boast
Sabah finance minister Masidi Manjun said by the time the Warisan administration took office in 2018, most of the funds needed for repayment had already been secured. (Bernama pic) PETALING JAYA : Sabah finance minister Masidi Manjun has hit out at Warisan president Shafie Apdal for claiming that his administration had settled a RM1 billion debt left by the previous government in 2019. Masidi said Shafie's claim was aimed at showing that his administration was good at managing government finances, 'but the facts speak for themselves'. Masidi, who is also the Gabungan Rakyat Sabah secretary-general, said the federal bond in question was issued in December 2014 during the Barisan Nasional-led state administration. He said one of the conditions imposed by the central bank for the issuance of the bond was that the state government must set up a dedicated sinking fund to ensure full repayment of the debt upon maturity. 'This was a safeguard to prevent the repayment from becoming a huge financial burden on the state's finances,' he said in a statement. Masidi said that under the terms of the bond, the state government needed to place RM200 million into the sinking fund each year for five years, until 2019. By the time the Warisan administration took office in 2018, he said, most of the funds needed for repayment had already been secured. He said that in the following year, RM1 billion was already in the sinking fund, which allowed the state government to make a one-off bullet payment being full settlement of the bond debt. 'Therefore, it is not accurate to suggest that this repayment was the result of any special action by the Warisan government. 'The payment was the outcome of prudent financial planning put in place by the previous administration years before the bond matured,' he said. Yesterday, Shafie defended his promise to write off outstanding student loans for Sabahans if Warisan forms the government after the upcoming state election. Responding to a youth NGO's claim that the pledge was mere rhetoric, the former Sabah chief minister said his promise was not a political gimmick and that it was financially doable. 'In 2019, I paid RM1 billion of debts left by BN,' he was quoted as saying. 'If I can pay BN's debts, why can't we pay the debts of our students?'
Free Malaysia Today
5 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Developer harassing us for redevelopment consent, claim residents
The residents of the Kuchai Entrepreneurs Park flats said the developer had approached them directly, in breach of the Strata Management Act 2013. KUALA LUMPUR : Residents of the Kuchai Entrepreneurs Park flats are urging the government to intervene and stop what they claim is harassment by a developer pushing for the area's redevelopment under the proposed Urban Renewal Act (URA). Nasrun Ismail, a member of the residents' action committee, claimed that the developer was bypassing the flats' management corporation and approaching residents directly for consent without proper explanation, in breach of the Strata Management Act 2013. 'They sent us letters and asked whether we agree or not. Then, they set a date for us to reply,' he told reporters after a public briefing at the flats today. FMT is withholding the name of the developer pending a response. Nasrun alleged that some residents were offered RM100 or RM200 to support the redevelopment, which he described as a form of bribery. He said some visits took place at night, causing concern among the residents. 'We will request our management corporation to take any necessary action, including lodging a police report and obtaining a court order, as the developer has violated the Strata Management Act,' he said. He also urged the government to prioritise rejuvenation over redevelopment, especially for low-cost and heritage housing, warning that a shift to condominium living would impose higher maintenance fees, sinking funds, and other hidden costs on residents. Spearheaded by the housing and local government ministry, the URA seeks to lower the threshold of strata owner consent to 80% for buildings under 30 years old, 75% for those over 30 years old, and 51% for abandoned properties. The bill is expected to be tabled in Parliament this month. The Kuchai Entrepreneurs Park flats consist of five blocks, with a total of 480 housing units and 20 shoplots. The flats' leasehold tenure is expected to expire in 2081.
