
College Football Playoff copying NFL format would be foolish
At least one high-ranking conference commissioner, the Big 12's Brett Yormark, appreciates college football's need to remain intentionally divergent from the NFL. That's true, Yormark says, of how college football should operate its postseason.
Conference commissioners are embroiled in an ongoing debate about the future shape and structure of the College Football Playoff. Two models have been socialized most.
In one corner is the Big Ten-backed auto-bid plan that would reduce the selection committee's role and award 13 of the 16 playoff spots as automatic bids, preassigned to conferences based on historical clout. Big Ten commissioner Tony Petitti drew inspiration from professional leagues while cooking up this playoff plan. Petitti's quest for play-in games is ripped from Major League Baseball's old playbook of a play-in round for wild-card teams.
In the other corner is Yormark's favored 5+11 playoff model that would preserve and expand the selection committee's role in choosing and seeding the bracket. Five automatic bids would go to conference champions, leaving 11 at-large bids to be picked by the committee. The Big 12 and ACC back this plan, and the SEC has shown interest, too.
BIG PLANS: The billionaire booster who wants to save college sports
TOP 25: Ranking the best college football quarterbacks
The NFL, of course, would never allow a committee to choose its playoff - but that shouldn't influence how college football models its postseason.
"We do not need a professional model, because we are not the NFL," Yormark said at Big 12 media days. "We are college football, and we must act like it."
Yormark nailed it. The NFL assigns playoff bids based off division standings, and wild-card selections go to teams with the best records. No committee is needed, because the NFL is neatly confined to 32 teams, divided evenly into conferences and divisions of equal size. Every team plays each divisional opponent twice during the regular season. The league fosters parity through the NFL draft, a salary cap and collective bargaining.
College football features none of this NFL structure, and it won't soon feature any of this structure. So, why should its postseason structure draw inspiration from a professional league it doesn't resemble?
Answer: It shouldn't.
"There is nothing in sports like college football," Yormark said, "and we must protect what makes it special and do what's right for the fans of the game."
To be clear, the selection committee does not form college football's lifeblood. A playoff didn't even exist until 2014. The sport's backbone is formed by rivalries, pageantry and stadium atmospheres that hit differently than the NFL.
The committee becomes useful, though, in choosing a playoff field. Unlike the NFL's tidy structure, the FBS features more than 130 programs in conferences of varying sizes competing for one prize. Just consider the Power Four conferences and Notre Dame, and you're already at 68 teams - more than twice the NFL's size. Many schools play only half the teams in their own conference during the season. Schedules vary wildly in terms of difficulty.
When we're left with a 10-2 team from one conference and a 9-3 team from another, the committee helps separate the wheat from the chaff.
We engage in heated debates about whether the committee makes the right selections, just as we do for March Madness. Those debates are an asset to college sports, not a hindrance that requires a playoff with a stacked deck.
Yormark says he's "doubling down on" his preference for a 5+11 model that would preserve the committee's role.
"I have a lot of faith in the selection process," the Big 12 commissioner said. "They are doing a full audit of the selection process to figure out how they can modernize and contemporize and how they use data and how certain metrics."
Amid that audit of the committee, it's worth questioning whether a sitting athletic director should chair the group. Anointing an athletic director as the committee's point-person creates, at the least, the illusion of bias.
But, if the alternative to a selection committee choosing most of the field is the Big Ten's auto-bid plan that would stack the deck for the two most powerful conferences, before the season starts, then put me down in favor of the committee.
The process is messy. It's controversial. It's captivating. It's subjective. And it's brilliantly unique and necessary to college sports.
Blake Toppmeyer is the USA TODAY Network's national college football columnist. Email him at BToppmeyer@gannett.com and follow him on X @btoppmeyer.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Veteran running back Latavius Murray ends 11-year NFL career with defiant social media message
As good as college and NFL scouts may be, players do get overlooked. Veteran running back Latavius Murray is perfect example, as he reminded his Instagram followers while announcing his retirement from the league on Thursday. 'They never saw a pro in me but 11 years later, I showed what a pro really looks like!' wrote Murray alongside his personal highlight reel stretching from his days at Central Florida through his decade-long NFL career. Despite a career that included several years as a starter and one Pro Bowl nod in 2015, Murray's opportunities were dwindling and he spent the last two seasons languishing on the free-agent market. His last carry came for the Buffalo Bills on New Year's Eve in 2023. The 35-year-old was the New York state Gatorade Football Player of the Year in 2007 while playing at Onondaga Central outside Syracuse. But outside of the Orange, Boston College Eagles, Maryland Terrapins and UCF Knights, major schools didn't show much interest. Murray went with UCF and spent three of his next four seasons battling injuries and splitting carries before breaking out as a senior in 2012. Not only did he rush for 1,106 yards and 15 touchdowns in his final college season, but he added another 231 yards and four scores on 27 receptions. View this post on Instagram A post shared by Latavius Murray (@lataviusmurray) The disrespect didn't end in college, though, and Murray slid to the sixth round of the 2013 NFL Draft, where he was picked by the Oakland Raiders – the first of his six teams. In total, 24 running backs were taken in that draft, but Murray's 6,552 career rushing yards are greater than all but Le'Veon Bell's 6,554. What's more, Murray had 59 career touchdowns compared to Bell's 42, likely due to his durability and reliability, Outside of his rookie season, which he spent on Injured Reserve, Murray remained one of the league's most durable running backs over the last decade. In 2015, while rushing a career-high 266 times, he reached the 1,000-yard plateau mark for the first and only time in the NFL. Murray would go on to play with the Minnesota Vikings, Baltimore Ravens, Denver Broncos, Buffalo Bills, and two stints with the New Orleans Saints. 'A true professional in every sense of the word,' one fan wrote on Instagram. 'Someone who brought presence and respect to every interaction. It never mattered if you owned the team or took out the trash. 'He treated everyone with the same appreciation, knowing that every role matters. Keep being that driven and thoughtful leader. This isn't the end, it's just the beginning. Congrats on an unreal career my dawg!' Murray's post-NFL career prospects are looking strong. Not only does the married father of four have a bachelor's degree from UCF, but he's earned his MBA from Syracuse University's Martin J. Whitman School of Management. In total, Murray earned more than $22 million in NFL salary despite being initially overlooked at both the college and professional levels.


Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Seahawks LT Charles Cross (finger) has surgery, eyes Week 1 return
July 31 - Seahawks starting left tackle Charles Cross is recovering from finger surgery and hopes to be ready for Week 1, multiple outlets reported Thursday. Cross underwent a procedure Wednesday to repair a dislocated finger on his right hand after initially trying to play through the injury with a splint, per ESPN. The expectation is that Cross, 24, will be ready for the Sept. 7 season opener against the visiting San Francisco 49ers. A first-round pick (ninth overall) by Seattle in 2022, Cross started all 17 games last season and all 48 of his games through his first three NFL seasons. In April, the Seahawks exercised the fifth-year option on Cross that will pay him a guaranteed $17.56 million for the 2026 campaign. He carries a $6.8 million cap hit in 2025. --Field Level Media


Reuters
2 hours ago
- Reuters
Colts sign veteran CBs Tre Herndon, Duke Shelley
July 31 - The Indianapolis Colts addressed their thinning secondary by signing free agent cornerbacks Tre Herndon and Duke Shelley on Thursday. Indianapolis also placed cornerback David Long Jr. on injured reserve and released tight end Albert Okwuegbunam Jr. In addition to Long's groin injury, the Colts have been navigating training camp hamstring injuries to cornerbacks Jaylon Jones and JuJu Brents. Herndon, 29, saw action in one game for the New Orleans Saints last season. He has 243 tackles, 32 passes defensed and three interceptions in 84 games (34 starts) for the Jacksonville Jaguars (2018-23) and New Orleans. Shelley, 28, appeared in one game for the New York Giants last season. He has 93 tackles, 14 passes defensed and one pick in 53 games (11 starts) with the Chicago Bears (2019-21), Minnesota Vikings (2022), Los Angeles Rams (2023) and New York. Long, 27, played in 13 games (no starts) with the Colts in 2024. He has 96 tackles and one interception in 79 career games (12 starts) with the Rams (2019-22), Las Vegas Raiders (2023), Carolina Panthers (2023), Green Bay Packers (2023) and Colts. Okwuegbunam, 27, spent part of last season on the Indianapolis practice squad and last appeared in an NFL game in 2023. He has 54 catches for 546 yards and four touchdowns in 30 career games (seven starts) with the Denver Broncos (2020-22) and Philadelphia Eagles (2023). --Field Level Media