‘False fuel saving claim': CCP imposes Rs40mn penalty on Al-Ghazi Tractors
In January 2022, AGTL ran a front-page ad in an Urdu newspaper, claiming its new Holland tractor models offered 'up to 30% extra diesel savings compared to any competitor's tractors.' The ad cited a report by the Agricultural Mechanisation Research Institute (AMRI), Multan as basis of its claim.
CCP says recovered Rs10mn penalty from PIA for 'abusing dominant position'
'Farmers across Pakistan, especially small landholders often make purchasing decisions based on savings and efficiency. For them, a claim like 'up to 30% extra diesel savings' can mean the difference between affordability and hardship.
'But this claim, made by Al-Ghazi Tractors Limited in a newspaper ad, has now been declared false and misleading by the Competition Commission of Pakistan. The bench comprising Dr Kabir Ahmed, the Chairman CCP and Mr Salman Amin (Member) has imposed a penalty of PKR 40 million on AGTL for violating competition law and misguiding consumers,' the CCP statement read.
According to the CCP, it found that AMRI had not issued any report supporting the claim.
'In fact, AMRI had warned AGTL to stop using its name for false claim and to retract the advertisement.'
The AMRI report, which AGTL selectively quoted, only tested tractors from two manufacturers—AGTL and one competitor, the CCP said. 'It did not provide market-wide fuel efficiency comparisons. AMRI also emphasised that its report contained general energy-saving tips, not certification of any tractor model's performance.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Recorder
2 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Rupee extends winning streak against US dollar
Rupee's Performance Against US Dollar Since 04 March 2025 The Pakistani rupee maintained its upward momentum against the US dollar, appreciating 0.07% in the inter-bank market on Wednesday. At close, the currency settled at 282.22, a gain of Re0.20. On Tuesday, the rupee had closed at 282.42. This marks the fifth successive session of appreciation for the rupee, supported by improved sentiment in the currency market amid an ongoing crackdown by the law enforcement agencies against illegal currency dealers and smugglers. Last week, a Pakistan court sentenced three illegal currency dealers to five years in prison and imposed a fine of Rs1 million on each for their involvement in unlawful foreign exchange trading. Internationally, the US dollar weakened on Wednesday after a tame reading on US inflation bolstered expectations of a Federal Reserve rate cut next month, with President Donald Trump's attempts to extend his grip over US institutions also undermining the currency. US consumer prices increased marginally in July, data showed on Tuesday, in line with forecasts and as the pass-through from Trump's sweeping tariffs to goods prices has so far been limited. Investors eyeing imminent Fed cuts cheered the data and moved to price in a 98% chance the central bank would ease rates next month, which in turn dragged on the dollar. Against the yen, the dollar was last 0.05% lower at 147.76, while the euro was steady at $1.1676, having risen 0.5% in the previous session. The dollar index last stood at 98.08, after falling roughly 0.5% on Tuesday. US Treasury yields similarly fell on the heightened rate cut expectations, with the two-year yield last at 3.7371%, having swung in a range of nearly 10 basis points on Tuesday. The benchmark 10-year yield was little changed at 4.2965%. Oil prices, a key indicator of currency parity, erased losses on Wednesday after U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said sanctions against Russia or secondary tariffs could go up if Friday's meeting between President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin does not go well. Brent crude futures edged up 6 cents to $66.18 a barrel by 1243 GMT, while U.S. West Texas Intermediate crude futures were up 2 cents to $63.19. Inter-bank market rates for dollar on Wednesday BID Rs 282.22 OFFER Rs 282.42 Open-market movement In the open market, the PKR gained 10 paise for buying and lost 8.93 rupees for selling against USD, closing at 283.70 and 293.83, respectively. Against Euro, the PKR lost 2.30 rupees for buying and 2.28 rupees for selling, closing at 331.25 and 333.38, respectively. Against UAE Dirham, the PKR gained 9 paise for buying and 6 paise for selling, closing at 77.19 and 77.49, respectively. Against Saudi Riyal, the PKR gained 4 paise for both buying and selling, closing at 75.49 and 75.81, respectively. Open-market rates for dollar on Wednesday BID Rs 283.70 OFFER Rs 293.83
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
Rupee gains further against US dollar
Rupee's Performance Against US Dollar Since 04 March 2025 The Pakistani rupee maintained its upward momentum against the US dollar, appreciating 0.01% in the inter-bank market on Tuesday. At close, the currency settled at 282.42, a gain of Re0.03. On Monday, rupee closed at 282.45. Internationally, the US dollar held steady on Tuesday, with markets braced for a key consumer inflation report later in the day that could shape expectations for Federal Reserve interest rate cuts. The Australian dollar was steady hours before a policy decision by the Reserve Bank of Australia. The US dollar index - which measures the currency against six counterparts, including the euro and yen - was steady at 98.497 as of 0046 GMT, after advancing 0.5% over the past two sessions. Prior to that, the dollar had retreated as US President Donald Trump's dovish-leaning pick to replace a Fed governor, and similarly inclined potential candidates for chairman, led traders to increase easing bets. In addition, Fed officials have sounded increasingly uneasy about the labour market, signalling their as soon as September. Cooling inflation could cement bets for a reduction next month, but if signs emerge that Trump's tariffs are fuelling price pressures, that might keep the central bank on hold for now. Traders currently put the odds of a quarter-point cut on September 17 at about 89%. The greenback rose 0.1% to 148.28 yen on Tuesday. The euro was flat at $1.1615. Oil prices, a key indicator of currency parity, were little changed on Tuesday after the United States and China extended a pause on higher tariffs and data showed a rise in U.S. inflation in July. Brent crude futures lost 36 cents, or 0.54%, to $66.27 a barrel by 1240 GMT. U.S. West Texas Intermediate crude futures eased by 45 cents, or 0.7%, to $63.51. U.S. President Donald Trump extended a tariff truce with China to November 10, staving off triple-digit duties on Chinese goods as U.S. retailers prepared for the critical end-of-year holiday season. This raised hopes that an agreement could be reached between the world's two largest economies and avert a virtual trade embargo between them. Tariffs risk slowing global growth, which could sap fuel demand and drag oil prices lower. Inter-bank market rates for dollar on Tuesday BID Rs 282.42 OFFER Rs 282.61 Open-market movement In the open market, the PKR gained 6 paise for buying and remained unchanged for selling against USD, closing at 283.80 and 284.90, respectively. Against Euro, the PKR gained 1.10 rupee for buying and 1.05 rupee for selling, closing at 328.95 and 331.10, respectively. Against UAE Dirham, the PKR remained unchanged for buying and gained 5 paise for selling, closing at 77.28 and 77.55, respectively. Against Saudi Riyal, the PKR remained unchanged for buying and gained 3 paise for selling, closing at 75.53 and 75.85, respectively. Open-market rates for dollar on Tuesday BID Rs 283.80 OFFER Rs 284.90
Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
CCP 2019 order: Appellate Tribunal grants partial relief to flour mills, upholds Rs35mn fine
The Competition Appellate Tribunal (CAT) upheld the order of the Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP) against the Pakistan Flour Mills Association (PFMA) for 'fixing the price of wheat flour'. However, the CAT reduced the fine amount to Rs35 million from previously Rs75 million the CCP had imposed in its 2019 order, according to a CCP statement on Tuesday. In 2019, the CCP had noted that the PFMA had been involved in fixing the wheat grinding quota for each member mill, which led to an increase in flour prices across the country. The PFMA later challenged the CCP order before the CAT. According to CCP's Tuesday statement, CCP's counsel argued in court that Sections 4(1) and 4(2)(a) of the Competition Act, 2010 prohibit any agreement or decision between undertakings, including associations, aimed at fixing prices. Sugar crisis: Finance minister Aurangzeb, CCP chairman Sidhu discuss ways to stabilise market 'The CCP maintained that the repeated and structured issuance of price instructions by PFMA displaced the commercial autonomy of individual mills, constituting a horizontal agreement with an anti-competitive object.' After hearing arguments from both sides and examining the record, the tribunal upheld CCP's findings but reduced the penalty to Rs35 million.
