
James Penrice dismisses 'weird' Hearts claims despite the story Neil Ciritchley's record tells
Penrice also reflected on an impressive personal season despite the Jambos as a whole missing their targets
James Penrice has dismissed 'weird' claims Hearts can't handle big games despite their Scottish Cup semi-final defeat to Aberdeen.
Neil Critchley' s record against the bigger clubs in Scotland makes for grim reading, with just three points from 12 clashes against Celtic, Rangers, Hibs and Aberdeen.
A late defeat to the Dons in Saturday's cup clash has proved the final straw for a number of fans, who want the board to make a change in the dugout after seeing their side come off second best in another big game.
The Jambos ended extra-time with nine men after Michael Steinwender's first-half red card and Cammy Devlin' s second yellow just before Oday Dabbagh's winner denied them a chance at a penalty shoot-out.
The club have demanded answers from the SFA over ref John Beaton's call to dismiss the Aussie. But Penrice insists that despite losing, he and his team-mates showed they can perform on the big occasions.
He said: 'There were weird shouts in the Press earlier on in the week – 'we couldn't handle big games'. But I don't think anyone walked off that park in a Hearts jersey that was disappointed in their performance.
'Every single one of the boys was brilliant. That's what you need. That's what you need every week when you play with this club.
'You need to put 100 per cent in and that needs to be the first thing. That's what we've got to do going forward now.'
After also missing out on the top six, Hearts now face an underwhelming end to the campaign, although they could do with another win to remove any lingering relegation play-off doubts.
And Penrice admits they have no choice but to lift themselves. 'Don't get me wrong, it's very disappointing but I think that's your job,' he added.
'You can't always have it easy in football. This is what you're judged on when it is tough. Can you bounce back? That's what us as a group of players have got to do.
'We've got to bounce back now and go and finish these five games strongly because we owe it to the fans as well.
'We've got to win these five games. That's the least we can do. Hopefully we can do that.
Despite a disappointing campaign for the club, Penrice has been a stand-out and was named in the PFA Scotland Team of the Year.
He said: 'It's a massive achievement for me. I was hoping that didn't get released until after the game.
'It's a massive credit to where I was. Almost a year ago I wasn't even playing football and I was injured.
'It's a lot of hard work that's gone into it but it's not just me, it's the boys in there as well.
'They help for that and I'm very thankful to the club for giving me an opportunity to play.'
After arriving from Livingston expecting to be a squad player, Penrice can't help but be pleased with his displays during his maiden season in maroon.
He added: 'I've loved every minute of it. It's been a massive jump up for me. I've taken it in my stride and I'm playing with confidence.
'Ultimately, I'd like to be doing a wee bit better than we are. I joined this club to compete in the finals and finish up the higher end of the league and go and play in Europe.
'On that end, it's disappointing. But from a personal point of view, I've loved every minute of it. It's a club I've taken to straight away.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Courier
an hour ago
- The Courier
Who would you pick for your greatest Dundee United team of all time?
Who were the best-ever players to play for Dundee United? Lifelong Arab and former club historian Tom Cairns watched his first United game in September 1961 during the era of Doug Smith and Dennis Gillespie. Jerry Kerr turned United into a top-flight European team in the 1960s. Legends were established. The Tangerines dismantled Barcelona and Juventus in the Fairs Cup in 1966, before Jim McLean took over in the 1970s and guided the club to unimaginable success. New names were added to Tannadice folklore. Paul Hegarty, David Narey, Ralph Milne and Paul Sturrock became gods. Guido van de Kamp, Gordan Petric, Andy McLaren, Christian Dailly and Craig Brewster became latter day-greats when United won the Scottish Cup in 1994. Craig Conway became a hero in 2010 when the trophy returned to Tannadice. They are among the all-time greats but how many others have you forgotten? We asked Tom to pick his all-time United XI in a 4-4-2 formation, along with five substitutes, and highlight some of the players who didn't make the cut. Is this United's greatest team? MacKay played for United from 1962 to 1972. Tom said: 'He was confident, brave and a great shot-stopper. 'For many years he shared the goalkeeping duties with Sandy Davie.' Gough was part of the league-winning side in 1983. 'He was athletic, excellent in the air and very dependable,' said Tom. 'Gough combined well with Ralph Milne and played for United from 1980-1986.' Dundonian Jimmy Briggs was a hard-tackling left-back and former captain of the team who played for the Tangerines from 1955 to 1970. Tom said: 'At times he played up front and scored over 30 goals – mostly penalties. 'He was even an emergency goalkeeper on occasion.' Paul Hegarty won the League Cup in 1979 and 1980 and the league in 1983. He served United over 700 times and scored 82 goals. Tom said: 'He was commanding in aerial duels and scored his fair share of goals. 'Hegarty was a Scotland international and United's greatest captain.' David Narey made his United debut on November 21 1973 at home to Falkirk in a 2-1 win and spent 22 glorious and trophy-laden years at Tannadice. Tom said: 'He was elegant, skilful and always there when needed. 'Narey was a class act and famously scored against Brazil for Scotland.' Kirkwood won double League Cups and the 1983 league championship. 'He was hard-working, hard-tackling and could score a goal,' said Tom. 'Billy was one of those players you didn't appreciate until he wasn't there.' Jim McInally signed from Coventry City in 1986 and was part of the side that got to the 1987 Uefa Cup final and won a 1994 Scottish Cup medal. 'Another hard-working and committed player who took no prisoners,' said Tom. 'Jim wouldn't cuddle up to opposition players at the end of a game if things hadn't gone well for United – he ran off the park and straight up the tunnel. 'He was there to win and he did.' The prodigiously talented Ralph Milne is the club's record European goalscorer. He made 286 appearances and scored 75 goals. 'A hugely talented and exciting player,' said Tom. 'Electric pace and could take the ball past the best of defenders. 'He was also a great goalscorer.' Eamonn Bannon signed for United in October 1979 from Chelsea. 'He was signed just two months before the first League Cup win,' said Tom. 'Bannon was the final piece in the jigsaw of success. 'He was exciting when running at the opposition.' Dossing signed from Danish club Viborg in 1964. He became a cult hero. Tom said: 'He was one of several Scandinavians who changed the club's fortunes. 'Quite simply, he scored goals – lots of goals.' Paul Sturrock signed for United in July 1974 and his career coincided with the most successful period in the club's history. 'Another exciting player who ran at defenders continuously,' said Tom. 'Scored and made many goals for United during the Jim McLean era including five in one game against Morton in the league in November 1984.' Hamish the Goalie took over from MacKay and kept goal for 14 years. He was immortalised in song by singer Michael Marra for his 1983 testimonial. 'An absolute character, who, for a short time, took United's penalties,' said Tom. Petric signed from Partizan Belgrade in November 1993. 'He was a classy central defender,' said Tom. 'Unflappable under pressure and a key player in our 1994 Scottish Cup win.' Rolland was a full-back who played for United from 1967 to 1978. Tom said: 'Thrilling runs brought goals from this legend at Tannadice. 'He was a hard tackling and committed player.' Gillespie played inside-forward and signed for United in 1959. Tom said: 'He was the first United player to win international honours whilst at United, after being chosen to play for the Scottish League against Ireland. 'Totally reliable and helped establish the club in the First Division.' Olofsson was signed by Tommy McLean in 1996. He was inducted into the Hall of Fame in January 2012. Tom said: 'He was an exciting goalscorer over three years at Tannadice.' Who were the players who didn't make Tom's bench, though? Tom's long-list included centre-back Doug Smith, left-back Maurice Malpas, winger Orjan Persson and strikers Andy Gray, Kevin Gallacher and Davie Dodds. Was there ever a doubt who the manager would be? Tom explained: 'Given the success United had with Jim McLean at the helm, there should only be one choice. 'He is my choice for the outstanding talent he nurtured and such tactical knowledge. 'But for Jerry Kerr to miss out seems a shame. 'He contributed a wonderful amount to establish United in the top league.' Tom said pulling together his greatest side was a difficult task. So what do you make of Tom's XI? What would your team be? Let us know.


Scotsman
2 hours ago
- Scotsman
Islam Chesnokov addresses Hearts transfer links as uncertainty remains
He has emerged as a target for Hearts this summer and has provided his take on the links to Gorgie. Sign up to our Hearts newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Islam Chesnokov has provided his take on where he stands with regards a move to Hearts this summer. The winger is one of a few players the Jambos are looking at this summer. Wideman Daniel Arzani is also on the radar as he comes out of contract at Melbourne Victory while head coach Derek McInnes wants to reunite with defender Stuart Findlay, who he worked with at Kilmarnock. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Hearts have been linked with a move for the Kazakhstan international since the winter transfer period but nothing was agreed with his club, FC Tobol. They have already been busy in the market and are set to do more business over the course of the window. Hearts transfer target on his future After playing in Kazakhstan's 1-0 defeat to North Macedonia in a World Cup qualifier this week, Chesnokov was too despondent to discuss the transfer links in depth, but admitted he was none the wiser to whether he would become a Hearts player or not. Chesnokov has been capped 13 times by Kazakhstan and scored his first goals for his country with a double during victory over San Marino in 2024. He said: 'I don't want to comment any more about Hearts right now. Nothing is confirmed. If something happens, I am sure it will be announced. Right now, I am too disappointed and upset about this loss to talk about my future.' The player's representative, Yaroslav Zvarych, spoke to the Evening News in January as negotiations with Hearts emerged. 'There is interest from Hearts. We are currently in the process of deciding many things because we have a lot of offers,' he said. 'Islam is one of the most talented players in Kazakhstan and we are working on the next step with the transfer window open. We are currently in the stage of negotiations over the offer from Hearts. They are interested and we do speak with them. We are moving forward with them already. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Hearts interest in Islam Chesnokov 'Islam is a very interesting player who is extremely talented. He has a powerful left foot, a powerful shot and he does a big volume of work. He would be very suitable for Scottish football. He is very technical and he has established himself as one of the best players in Kazakhstan. He is a right-winger, more of an inverted winger who likes to go into the middle.' He's not the only winger to address transfer links this week. Arzani said while on duty with Australia: 'I think anyone now, any of the boys looking to move or off contract, that thought process will be in their head. It's a big deal, a World Cup. It's massive. Everyone wants to be a part of it. It is going to be really competitive and we have a lot of talent coming out of Australia as well. I think it is definitely important that if I go somewhere that I'll be playing week in, week out. I'm not sure what I am doing yet, what direction I am heading in but that's definitely part of the equation."


Scotsman
2 hours ago
- Scotsman
Stuart Findlay's Hearts role as transfer progresses - Derek McInnes bond and a Celtic comparison
Oxford United are in talks with the Edinburgh club Sign up to our Hearts newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Stuart Findlay will be handed a key role in Derek McInnes' new-look Hearts team as his move from Oxford United nears completion. Detailed talks have taken place and the centre-back is ready to rejoin McInnes at Tynecastle Park after playing under him as a Kilmarnock loanee for the last two years. Age 29, Findlay has one year remaining on his Oxford contract but is not part of the plans at the Kassam Stadium. Hearts are ready to pay a six-figure transfer fee to secure his services, although a season-long loan deal has not been ruled out. Either way, McInnes wants Findlay as the linchpin of his defence and views him as a key component after working closely with him at Rugby Park. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Findlay captained Kilmarnock on several occasions. His leadership and character are commodities McInnes values highly. He would take the left centre-back role at Hearts despite three other players in the squad playing that position - Jamie McCart, Stephen Kingsley and Harry Milne. One of those is likely to leave this summer. Injuries hindered Kingsley last season and it remains to be seen what part he will play under the new Hearts management team. McCart and Milne only arrived in Edinburgh in January. Hearts paid £70,000 to sign McCart from Rotherham United so he could provide a quick profit under the Jamestown Analytics model if there is a desire to sell this summer. Milne can also play left-back so may be needed as English clubs ponder a move for James Penrice. Transfer business continues at Hearts ahead of pre-season training McInnes wants Findlay in situ in time for the Hearts players reporting to Riccarton for pre-season training next week. Talks are heading towards a conclusion with all parties willing for the move to happen. The bond between manager and player developed and strengthened at Kilmarnock, where Findlay became one of the first names on the team sheet. He suffered ligament damage last November which sidelined him for five months. Killie were joint-sixth in the Premiership table at the time and Findlay's absence was a central reason they were unable to secure a top-six finish. McInnes compared the blow to Celtic losing Cameron Carter-Vickers. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'It's a blow for us, he's a big player, a defender who plays every week for me,' said McInnes ahead of a game against Celtic. 'It's a real blow for us, but we need to deal with losing important players at some stage in the season. 'Managers will have to deal with coping without key players and there's no point in crying about it, we just need to deal with it. 'He's almost been perfect for us. He's the equivalent of Cameron Carter-Vickers being out of the Celtic team, that's how big an influence he is. Losing key players in key positions, it's up for others now to go and step in and take on that responsibility that he's shown for us since he came to the club.' With four players already committed to Hearts for next season, another two are in the pipeline. Norwegian right-back Christian Borchgrevink, Greek winger Alexandros Kyziridis, Belgian striker Elton Kabangu and Irish midfielder Oisin McEntee have all agreed permanent contracts. Findlay and the Portuguese striker Claudio Braga are next in line as the Riccarton summer revamp continues. READ MORE: Hearts working to tie up two transfer targets