German legislator's concealed meeting with Putin confidants sparks security concerns
Ralf Stegner, a member of the Bundestag's Parliamentary Control Committee, was among politicians from the SPD and Chancellor Friedrich Merz's conservatives who took part in the April meeting in Baku.
Among those they met on April 13 in the Azerbaijan capital was former Russian Prime Minister Viktor Subkov, head of Gazprom's supervisory board, and Valery Fadeyev, EU-sanctioned chair of Russia's human rights council.
On both sides, the participants were former members of the Petersburger Dialogue, a forum founded in 2001 by Russian President Vladimir Putin and then-Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder. The forum was officially disbanded in 2021 after Russia's crackdown on several participating civil society organisations.
Four German participants - Stegner, Ronald Pofalla - who once led former Chancellor Angela Merkel's office - and two former regional ministers - confirmed in a statement to Reuters that they had been at a "private" event in Baku.
"Talking even in difficult times of growing tension is a fundamental principle of good foreign policy," they wrote, adding that the "confidential" meeting was not secret, and none of them had a public mandate to be there or had been paid for their presence.
The meeting, first reported by ARD public television and newspaper Die Zeit, took place at a time when Russia's ties with the EU are in a deep freeze over its invasion of Ukraine. The timing raised questions over the apparent willingness of some politicians to seek rapprochement even as Moscow wages war on a German ally.
In Stegner's case, critics also raised security concerns: Members of the parliamentary control committee have privileged, confidential access to the work of Germany's foreign and domestic security services, both of them heavily involved in gathering intelligence relating to Russia and the war.
"This is a quite impossible and irritating development that must immediately be cleared up," Konstantin von Notz, the Green chair of the committee, told Der Spiegel.
Roderich Kiesewetter, a conservative member of the committee, said Stegner should explain himself, while liberal European legislator Marie-Agnes Strack-Zimmermann said Stegner should not be nominated for a new term on the committee.
"People in such a key role have to be above all suspicion," she told Funke newspapers. "That is not the case for him."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
3 minutes ago
- The Independent
What happened the one and only time Zelensky and Putin met?
Ukraine's leader Volodymyr Zelensky may soon meet Russian president Vladimir Putin again, for the first time since 2019. A summit in Paris six years ago was the first and only time the two presidents ever met, flanked by French president Emmanuel Macron and Germany's then-chancellor Angela Merkel. At the time, Putin and Zelensky were looking to hash out a ceasefire deal for war in Donbas in Ukraine's east, where Russia-backed forces were fighting Ukrainian troops. The two world leaders are now potentially set for another meeting as part of US president Donald Trump's bid to end the devastating Ukraine war. However, this is far from set in stone with Putin's initial suggestion that it could take place in Moscow quickly rejected by the Ukrainian president. What happened in 2019? Ukrainian forces and Russian separatists had been embroiled in conflict in Donbas, in Ukraine's east, since 2014. Zelensky and Putin travelled to Paris in December 2019 for the Normandy Format Summit, a diplomatic forum designed by French, German, Russian and Ukrainian diplomats after the outbreak of conflict. The Ukrainian president had been elected just months earlier in spring that year - his first role in political office - beating former foreign minister Petro Poroshenko to the presidency. The summit in Paris led to progress, but was not groundbreaking. The two sides agreed to implement 'all necessary ceasefire support measures' before the end of 2019 and to release all the prisoners of war. Both sides also expressed their desire to implement the Minsk agreements signed in 2014 and 2015, the first attempt to achieve a ceasefire between Ukraine and Russia after Putin's forces rolled into and took over the Crimean peninsula. What did the leaders say about each other? The mood between the pair was chilly at first. There was no public handshake and they are said to have largely avoided eye contact during the meeting. Clean shaven and sporting a suit, 2019 Zelensky cut a strikingly different figure compared to his more familiar appearance now as a war-time leader. After the summit, Putin hailed the talks as an 'important step' towards de-escalation. He expressed what at the time appeared to be cautious hope: "All this gives us the grounds to suppose that the process is developing in the right direction.' Zelensky also hailed the meeting as a 'big step towards peace'. When he was asked by reporters who he believed had emerged victorious from the exchanges with his Russian counterpart, he said: "I don't know who (beat) who. I think it would be appropriate to be diplomatic as we've just started talking. Let's say for now it's a draw." What happened afterwards? Despite a number of prisoner exchanges, the 2019 meeting was not a catalyst for any major long-term change in Russo-Ukrainian relations - and little over two years later Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine. Several key sticking points remained after the 2019 negotiations. Kyiv continued to demand the withdrawal of Russian-backed troops and a complete ceasefire, with a return of border control to Ukraine. Russia insisted that before Ukraine regained control of its eastern border, local elections should be held in the occupied territories. Putin also demanded that Donbas have a special constitutional status in Ukraine, to give it a degree of autonomy. In January 2022, just weeks before the full-scale Russian invasion, the summit in Paris took place again, but was attended by officials from the same four countries, rather than their leaders. Senior diplomats met in February 2022 in an attempt to prevent a conflict. After the Russian invasion on 24 February, Zelensky said the invasion had 'ruined' the progress made by the Normandy Format.
The Independent
3 minutes ago
- The Independent
War-torn Ukraine's Zelensky reacts as Trump calls DC ‘the most unsafe place anywhere'
The president of war-torn Ukraine looked shocked when Donald Trump described Washington DC as 'the most unsafe place anywhere' during a meeting at the White House. Volodymyr Zelensky was in the Oval Office for talks about bringing an end to Russia's brutal invasion of his country which has seen civilians bombed on a near-daily basis. During questions from the press, President Trump began discussing his federal takeover of the capital which he described as 'the most unsafe place anywhere' before his unprecedented deployment of the National Guard. Zelensky looked surprised and shocked by Trump's words as the Commander-in-Chief began telling a story about a friend whose golfer son now felt 'safe' to go out for dinner. Trump went on to claim restaurants are now booming thanks to his actions. Statistics show restaurants have suffered as much as a 30% drop since troops were deployed.
The Guardian
4 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Trump rules out sending US ground troops to Ukraine and warns Putin of ‘rough situation' if he does not move towards peace
Update: Date: 2025-08-19T16:08:13.000Z Title: Donald Trump Content: US president says it's possible Russian leader does not want to make deal Matthew Pearce (now); Jakub Krupa, Jane Clinton and Adam Fulton (earlier) Tue 19 Aug 2025 17.08 BST First published on Tue 19 Aug 2025 04.46 BST From 4.07pm BST 16:07 has ruled out the deployment of American troops in Ukraine in his first interview since yesterday's White House meeting with Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskyy and European leaders. 'You have my assurance, and I'm president,' Trump told Fox News talkshow Fox & Friends in a phone interview on Tuesday, when pressed on whether US forces could be sent to defend against another Russian incursion. The US president reiterated that Ukraine would not be admitted into Nato under his watch, but said that Kyiv would still receive security guarantees. These, he suggested, European allies would 'front load'. Trump said France, Germany and the UK were among the countries considering sending their own troops to bolster Ukraine's defences. 5.08pm BST 17:08 Volodymyr Zelenskyy has given a golf club belonging to a wounded serviceman during his visit to Washington this week, Kyiv said on Tuesday. Trump, an avid golfer who owns several courses, accepted the gift and presented Zelenskyy with symbolic keys to the White House in return, the Ukrainian leader's office said. The warm exchange marks a turnaround from February, when Zelenskyy left the White House early after a televised shouting match with Trump and US vice-president JD Vance. Since then, Zelenskyy has sought to repair ties, praising Trump's efforts to secure peace. 'The president of Ukraine presented the president of the United States with a golf club,' Zelenskyy's office said. The club belonged to Kostiantyn Kartavtsev, a soldier who 'had lost a leg in the first months of Russia's full-scale invasion while saving his brothers-in-arms', it added. Zelenskyy also showed Trump a video of Kartavtsev. Later on Tuesday, Ukrainian veteran organisation United by Golf published a video of Trump holding the club and thanking Kartavtsev. 'I just watched your swing. I know a lot about golf and your swing is great,' Trump said. 'You're an amazing person, and you just keep playing golf and doing all of the other things. Your country is a great country. We're trying to bring it back to health.' Zelenskyy also brought a letter for Melania Trump from his wife, Olena, thanking the US first lady for writing to Vladimir Putin and urging him to save children's lives. 4.47pm BST 16:47 The EU has dropped its calls for a 'ceasefire' in Ukraine and is instead demanding that Russia 'stop the killing', in a semantic shift that aims to grab the ear of US President , according to AFP. European Commission spokesperson Arianna Podestà told reporters: 'The message for us is: stop the killing. Anything that stops the killing is welcome.' Her remarks echoed EU chief Ursula von der Leyen, who stood alongside Ukraine's Volodymyr Zelenskyy in Brussels on Sunday. 'The effect must be stop the killing,' she said. 'That's the most important part. Whether we call it a ceasefire or a peace deal, stop the killing.' European sources said Trump now disliked the term 'ceasefire', and the intention was to avoid antagonising the US president on a matter of form as high-stakes negotiations on Ukraine and European security were under way. Yet at the White House summit on Monday, European leaders made clear their basic demands had not changed. 'I can't imagine that the next meeting would take place without a ceasefire, so let's work on that and let's try to put pressure on Russia,' said German Chancellor Friedrich Merz. French President Emmanuel Macron summed it up by saying that 'a truce, a ceasefire or at least, to stop the killings' was 'a necessity'. 4.23pm BST 16:23 Turkish foreign minister Hakan Fidan and US secretary of state Marco Rubio discussed potential steps to end the Ukraine war in a phone call on Tuesday, a Turkish foreign ministry source said. The source said the two also discussed the outcomes of talks between the U.S. and Russian presidents in Alaska and a meeting in Washington involving European leaders, Ukraine and the US, according to Reuters. Fidan and Rubio also discussed ceasefire efforts in Gaza and the latest situation in Syria, the source said, adding Fidan had called for an immediate truce in Gaza and unhindered access of humanitarian aid. 4.07pm BST 16:07 has ruled out the deployment of American troops in Ukraine in his first interview since yesterday's White House meeting with Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskyy and European leaders. 'You have my assurance, and I'm president,' Trump told Fox News talkshow Fox & Friends in a phone interview on Tuesday, when pressed on whether US forces could be sent to defend against another Russian incursion. The US president reiterated that Ukraine would not be admitted into Nato under his watch, but said that Kyiv would still receive security guarantees. These, he suggested, European allies would 'front load'. Trump said France, Germany and the UK were among the countries considering sending their own troops to bolster Ukraine's defences. 3.38pm BST 15:38 Vladimir Putin suggested holding a possible meeting with Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskyy, aimed at ending the war in Ukraine, in Moscow, according to two sources familiar with a phone call between US president and Putin. 'Putin mentioned Moscow' during their call on Monday, one of the sources told AFP, adding that Zelensky had said 'no' in response. 3.22pm BST 15:22 Luke Harding What security guarantees might Ukraine get in return for a peace deal? As western leaders meet, four key questions remain about the steps they could take to prevent any future Russian aggression: What security guarantees might Ukraine get? How might the US contribute? What does Russia say? What does history tell us? Guardian foreign correspondent Luke Harding breaks down each one in this explainer: 3.02pm BST 15:02 Jakub Krupa I'm handing the blog over to Matthew Pearce, who will guide you through the late afternoon in Europe. 3.02pm BST 15:02 Slovak prime minister Robert Fico, who repeatedly clashed with Ukraine in the past and sought to block or delay some EU sanctions on Russia, also spoke in the last few minutes. In a three-minute video posted on his social media channels, recorded after his participation in the European Council meeting on Ukraine, he insisted that 'the first basic prerequisite for ending the conflict is the understanding that Ukraine cannot become a member state of Nato.' He noted that he expressed this view before, and faced heavy criticism. He also said: 'Equally important is the factual understanding that without a discussion about territorial changes in Ukraine, no progress can be made,' he said. He added that he was disappointed that the EU 'had to wait for to show us the path towards peace,' praising the US president's initiative as 'enormous personal success.' Fico also rejected the suggestion that EU countries could take part in buying €100bn-worth of military equipment for Ukraine, saying it sounded 'like a bad joke.' He said he could not imagine a siutation in which Slovakia spends money on US weapons to send them to Ukraine for free. Unsuprisingly, he's also 'sceptical' about the idea of further sanctions against Russia. But he said he hoped for peace 'as soon as possible' and was ready to support Ukraine's ambitions to join the European Union instead. 2.48pm BST 14:48 We are just getting a line from Reuters that a meeting between Nato military leaders on Ukraine is provisionally expected to take place tomorrow. We will bring you a confirmation once we have it. 2.31pm BST 14:31 European Council president António Costa told Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskyy that the EU was united in its 'unwavering support for Ukraine' when the pair spoke on the phone this afternoon. The former Portuguese prime minister added the bloc was also committed to maintaining pressure on Russia to get it to discuss and agree to ending the war in Ukraine. 'Our top priorities are to stop the killing, advance the exchange of prisoners, and secure the return of the thousands of children abducted by Russia,' he said. He added: 'We will work together with the United States on concrete and essential security guarantees. Together with President Zelenskyy and the US, we will prepare the next steps to achieve a just and lasting peace. We must continue to support the Ukrainian people and move forward with the enlargement process. Ukraine's future also lies in the prosperity and stability that EU membership can provide.' Updated at 2.33pm BST 2.06pm BST 14:06 The UK prime minister's office has just released a short statement after the meeting of the Coalition of the Willing on Ukraine, co-chaired by Starmer and French president Emmanuel Macron. It looks like the focus was on planning the next steps on security guarantees and potential sanctions to push Putin's Russia even further. The statement said the participating countries agreed on a meeting of planning teams with their US counterparts 'in the coming days to further strengthen plans to deliver robust security guarantees and prepare for the deployment of a reassurance force if the hostilities ended.' The leaders also talked about 'how further pressure – including through sanctions – could be placed on Putin until he showed he was ready to take serious action to end his illegal invasion.' The coalition gathered over 30 international leaders, No10 said.
