logo
‘Aap Jaisa Koi' doesn't wage war on patriarchy. It asks it to listen

‘Aap Jaisa Koi' doesn't wage war on patriarchy. It asks it to listen

Indian Express15-07-2025
In Indian cinema, patriarchy rarely announces itself with a clenched fist. It arrives as habit. As inheritance, and politeness. It lingers in the pauses of male entitlement — in who gets to interrupt, who is expected to adjust, who walks ahead on the street, and who apologises first in love. Netflix's new film, Aap Jaisa Koi, directed by Vivek Soni, doesn't wage war on patriarchy. It does something rarer — asking it to sit down quietly and listen.
The film explores what equal love might look like — not as ideology, but as everyday practice. In doing so, it touches one of Indian cinema's enduring blind spots: The inability to portray intimacy without hierarchy.
Patriarchy in Indian cinema has often been dramatised as violence — a father opposing a marriage, a man slapping his wife, or an overt villain controlling the heroine's choices. But its most persistent form is subtle, woven into affection, justified by culture, and disguised as care.
Aap Jaisa Koi understands this deeply. Its male protagonist, Shrirenu Tripathi (played with affecting restraint by R Madhavan), is not a patriarch in the classical sense. He is soft-spoken, educated, even kind. But his kindness comes with conditions. His affection arrives with hesitation. His silence, as the film shows, is not always humility — sometimes it's avoidance, sometimes entitlement.
In one of the most telling scenes, Shrirenu delays expressing his feelings for Madhu Bose (Fatima Sana Shaikh), even as she meets him halfway emotionally. When she finally says, 'Don't make your hesitation my burden,' it's not a line crafted for applause. It's a quiet resistance — the kind women are forced to offer in relationships built on unequal emotional labour.
What distinguishes Aap Jaisa Koi is its commitment to subtlety — not as aesthetic, but as politics. The film resists loud feminism or confrontational drama. Instead, it offers something more intimate: A portrait of negotiation. Between two people. Between tradition and selfhood. Between care and control.
Shaikh's Madhu is not a cinematic 'strong woman'. She is not angry, argumentative, or radical in the traditional sense. Her strength lies in her refusal to bend quietly. She asks questions. She sets boundaries. She is warm, but unyielding when needed. And crucially, she does not 'fix' the man — she waits for him to meet her on equal ground, or not at all.
That itself is a disruption of cinematic convention. Indian heroines have long been expected to absorb — the anger, the indifference, the delay, the distance.
Madhavan's portrayal of Shrirenu is particularly moving because it shows a man struggling not with love, but with unlearning. He is not cruel; he is conditioned. Raised in a family where men withdraw rather than speak, where decisions are made on their behalf by well-meaning elders, his emotional language is half-formed. His journey is not about transformation, but about recognising that passivity can be a form of control, too.
In one key moment, when Madhu offers him affection and clarity, he withdraws, calling himself 'not ready'. But the film does not applaud this honesty. Instead, it holds him accountable. Readiness, it suggests, is not a virtue when it leaves someone else waiting in uncertainty.
The film's point here is profound: Emotional withholding, when unacknowledged, becomes its own form of power.
Director Vivek Soni and cinematographer Debojeet Ray craft this story with warmth and quietness. There is no spectacle. A raised eyebrow, a pause, a half-finished sentence become tools of power and protest.
One such moment comes when Madhu, returning from a frustrating family visit, confronts Shrirenu not with anger but with clarity. She says what women are often expected to leave unsaid: That love without equality is not romantic — it is exhausting.
And the film listens.
We are living in a time when mainstream Indian cinema is haltingly turning its gaze inward. Aap Jaisa Koi is part of that shift. It doesn't deliver a lecture on gender. It models a conversation — one where silence is interrogated, not celebrated; where love is offered, but not at the cost of self.
In doing so, it asks: What does a truly equal relationship look like in a culture still learning to name its biases? And what happens when we stop applauding the bare minimum from men, and start expecting more?
The film doesn't offer easy resolutions. But it offers something better: The possibility that if we can acknowledge our conditioning, we can change it. Gently. Daily. Together.
The writer is an actor, educator, filmmaker, and public policy advocate
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Park Ju Hyun gets into car accident missing Iron Girls 2 filming, agency shares health update
Park Ju Hyun gets into car accident missing Iron Girls 2 filming, agency shares health update

Pink Villa

time12 minutes ago

  • Pink Villa

Park Ju Hyun gets into car accident missing Iron Girls 2 filming, agency shares health update

All Park Ju Hyun fans, if you are wondering why the actress did not appear in the Iron Girls 2 broadcast on July 25th, then we have some shocking news. The actress, who is a fixed member of the tvN entertainment program episodes, met with a traffic accident, which led to her absence from the set. Kim Dong-hyun revealed the reason during the show. Yui, Geum Sae-rok, Park Ju Hyun, and Seol In-ah are appearing with Director General Kim Dong-hyun as regular members on Iron Girls 2. When Park couldn't come for the filming of the episode, Kim noted, 'Ms. Ju Hyun had a minor traffic accident in the morning. Ju Hyun really wanted to attend, but it was decided that resting was the right call, so she ended up not participating." For the unversed, Iron Girls 2 is a reality show about girls who have become warriors, trying to shake off their fears and challenge boxing champions as they push beyond their limits. The news of Park's accident has left her fans concerned about her health. Park Ju Hyun's representative told OSEN that the actress was involved in a traffic accident 2-3 weeks ago. The representative further added that it was a minor accident with no serious injuries, such as fractures. The representative further explained, 'It was challenging for her to participate in the filming, so she requested understanding and took a break. She is currently managing her scheduled commitments after recovery.' Talking about her work front, Park Ju Hyun made her debut in 2019 with tvN drama Drama Stage-The Wife's Bed. Her breakthrough role came after her stint in the Netflix original series Human Class. Her recent work is the U+ and Disney+ drama Hunter with a Scalpel, which was released last month. Additionally, she continues to meet the public through Iron Girls 2 and Shakespeare in Love. Well, we hope to see her in the next episode of the reality show and wish her a speedy recovery. Stay tuned to Pinkvilla for more such updates.

Amitabh Bachchan called me during lockdown, says Radhika Madan: ‘Main behosh hogayi thi'
Amitabh Bachchan called me during lockdown, says Radhika Madan: ‘Main behosh hogayi thi'

Indian Express

time12 minutes ago

  • Indian Express

Amitabh Bachchan called me during lockdown, says Radhika Madan: ‘Main behosh hogayi thi'

Amitabh Bachchan is known not only for his legendary career but also for being a generous supporter of fellow actors. One such heartwarming gesture came when he personally praised Radhika Madan for her performance in Angrezi Medium (2020). In a recent vlog hosted by Farah Khan, Radhika shared how the megastar sent her a handwritten letter and even called her in his iconic Kaun Banega Crorepati style. While giving a tour of her home, Radhika proudly showed Farah her collection of awards. Farah's eyes immediately landed on the framed letter from Amitabh Bachchan, prompting her to ask, 'Amit ji sent you a letter?' Beaming, Radhika replied, 'Amitabh Bachchan sent me this letter after watching Angrezi Medium.' 'You must have died, no?' Farah asked with dramatic flair. 'I completely lost it,' Radhika laughed. 'Main toh behosh ho gayi thi (I fainted)!' As Farah read through the letter, where Big B praised Radhika's acting, she jokingly protested, 'Amitabh sir, you have never written to me. Please, koi toh letter bhej do (send me one too)!' Radhika then shared another unforgettable moment. 'I got a call during the lockdown. I picked up and heard, 'Hi, main Amitabh Bachchan bol raha hoon.' For a second, it felt like I was on Kaun Banega Crorepati!' The mood lightened further when Farah turned to her staff member Dilip and teased, 'Look, Amitabh Bachchan wrote to her. Have you ever received a letter?' Dilip chuckled, 'No ma'am, even my wife doesn't write to me.' The conversation then moved to Radhika's love life. Farah asked, 'Are you crazy in love types?' To which Radhika replied with a laugh, 'I'm nas kata pyaar.' The dramatic statement had Farah visibly alarmed, exclaiming, 'Why is everyone obsessed with cutting nerves these days?' ALSO READ | War 2 trailer: Hrithik Roshan, Jr NTR recite Bhagvad Gita's shloka, declare 'India first' as they prepare for war; Kiara Advani comes in all guns blazing. Watch Radhika explained that she's old-school when it comes to love. 'I still believe in writing letters,' she said. 'So you're a Raanjhanaa type of girl?' Farah asked. Radhika quickly disagreed, 'No, more like Veer Zaara.' When asked if she's a Shah Rukh Khan fan, Radhika said without hesitation, 'Of course, I am!' Then, channeling Salman Khan, she ran her thumb under her nose and added playfully, 'But I'm also a Bhai fan.' Farah offered an observation, 'Salman's films have always worked best when he's paired with a very Indian, sanskari kind of girl–like in Maine Pyaar Kiya and Tere Naam. That combo just works.' Radhika nodded enthusiastically, 'I love Bhai. Bhai is…' Before she could finish, Farah interjected, 'Can you not call him Bhai? Just say SK.' Radhika folded her hands in mock reverence, 'Salman sir.'

What was Sandeep Reddy Vanga's biggest regret for Ranbir Kapoor's Animal? Director says 'I came under pressure...'
What was Sandeep Reddy Vanga's biggest regret for Ranbir Kapoor's Animal? Director says 'I came under pressure...'

Pink Villa

time16 minutes ago

  • Pink Villa

What was Sandeep Reddy Vanga's biggest regret for Ranbir Kapoor's Animal? Director says 'I came under pressure...'

Ranbir Kapoor starrer Animal may have broken several box office records after its release, but director Sandeep Reddy Vanga still has some regrets. The film, which also starred Bobby Deol and Rashmika Mandanna in pivotal roles, went on to become one of the most talked-about films of 2023. But in a recent interview, the director confessed regretting its final cut, which he had to make just a week before the theatrical release. Sandeep Reddy Vanga on editing Animal's final cut During a candid chat with Vijay Deverakonda and the director of his upcoming film Kingdom, Gowtam Tinnanuri, Sandeep Reddy Vanga revealed that he was pressurized into trimming Animal's runtime. It was just days before the Ranbir Kapoor starrer's theatrical release, and he continues to feel the loss of the moments that did not make it to the big screen. Talking about the entire process, Vanga revealed that the first cut of Animal was 3 hours and 45 minutes long. Later, the next cut, which he found satisfactory, was 3 hours and 30 minutes. But he came under pressure 7 days before the release, and had to edit out 7 minutes. While the theatrical release of Animal is over 3 hours, Sandeep revealed that after watching the film in theaters for a week, he realized what he had sacrificed in the final few moments that he had to cut. 'It was a good cut, but I regret it.' Sandeep Reddy Vanga also went on to add that when Animal was about to be released on OTT, he wanted to add the 7 edited minutes in the Netflix version. 'Even if I didn't finish it in 3.45, I finished it in 3.30. But when the film was released on the OTT platform, it was exactly the same length as its theatrical release.' Animal became a topic of discussion after its release. The film went on to become a turning point for all the actors, including Triptii Dimri, who played a small role. Well, now, the director is working on its sequel Animal Park, and we bet fans cannot wait for more updates.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store