logo
‘The system is so broken': Privacy restrictions helping alleged child abusers, says safety advocate

‘The system is so broken': Privacy restrictions helping alleged child abusers, says safety advocate

A privacy loophole is allowing alleged child abusers to game the working with children's check system, a leading child safety advocate says.
The warning comes after it emerged alleged paedophile Joshua Dale Brown was able to keep his working with children check despite two internal investigations that substantiated his having 'forcibly' grabbed children.
The 26-year-old former childcare worker is facing 70 charges including child sex abuse that allegedly occurred where he worked.
Child safety advocate Hetty Johnston said she knew of three individuals in Queensland who made complaints about a worker in youth care and received compensation through a redress scheme.
'He still maintained a Blue Card [Queensland's working with children check] ... and it was because information wasn't shared with relevant authorities,' she said. 'That's because of government restrictions around privacy.'
Johnston, is the founder of Safeguarding People Australia and previously founded Bravehearts, a charity dedicated to preventing childhood sexual abuse.
She said the alleged Queensland victims did not go to police, which is not uncommon for survivors of abuse, but each of their complaints was found credible.
Johnston said that under the Northern Territory's scheme, complaints made to police were included in the considerations undertaken for working with children checks, whereas in other jurisdictions such as Victoria and NSW only recorded convictions were taken into account.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

‘The system is so broken': Privacy restrictions helping alleged child abusers, says safety advocate
‘The system is so broken': Privacy restrictions helping alleged child abusers, says safety advocate

Sydney Morning Herald

time12 hours ago

  • Sydney Morning Herald

‘The system is so broken': Privacy restrictions helping alleged child abusers, says safety advocate

A privacy loophole is allowing alleged child abusers to game the working with children's check system, a leading child safety advocate says. The warning comes after it emerged alleged paedophile Joshua Dale Brown was able to keep his working with children check despite two internal investigations that substantiated his having 'forcibly' grabbed children. The 26-year-old former childcare worker is facing 70 charges including child sex abuse that allegedly occurred where he worked. Child safety advocate Hetty Johnston said she knew of three individuals in Queensland who made complaints about a worker in youth care and received compensation through a redress scheme. 'He still maintained a Blue Card [Queensland's working with children check] ... and it was because information wasn't shared with relevant authorities,' she said. 'That's because of government restrictions around privacy.' Johnston, is the founder of Safeguarding People Australia and previously founded Bravehearts, a charity dedicated to preventing childhood sexual abuse. She said the alleged Queensland victims did not go to police, which is not uncommon for survivors of abuse, but each of their complaints was found credible. Johnston said that under the Northern Territory's scheme, complaints made to police were included in the considerations undertaken for working with children checks, whereas in other jurisdictions such as Victoria and NSW only recorded convictions were taken into account.

‘The system is so broken': Privacy restrictions helping alleged child abusers, says safety advocate
‘The system is so broken': Privacy restrictions helping alleged child abusers, says safety advocate

The Age

time12 hours ago

  • The Age

‘The system is so broken': Privacy restrictions helping alleged child abusers, says safety advocate

A privacy loophole is allowing alleged child abusers to game the working with children's check system, a leading child safety advocate says. The warning comes after it emerged alleged paedophile Joshua Dale Brown was able to keep his working with children check despite two internal investigations that substantiated his having 'forcibly' grabbed children. The 26-year-old former childcare worker is facing 70 charges including child sex abuse that allegedly occurred where he worked. Child safety advocate Hetty Johnston said she knew of three individuals in Queensland who made complaints about a worker in youth care and received compensation through a redress scheme. 'He still maintained a Blue Card [Queensland's working with children check] ... and it was because information wasn't shared with relevant authorities,' she said. 'That's because of government restrictions around privacy.' Johnston, is the founder of Safeguarding People Australia and previously founded Bravehearts, a charity dedicated to preventing childhood sexual abuse. She said the alleged Queensland victims did not go to police, which is not uncommon for survivors of abuse, but each of their complaints was found credible. Johnston said that under the Northern Territory's scheme, complaints made to police were included in the considerations undertaken for working with children checks, whereas in other jurisdictions such as Victoria and NSW only recorded convictions were taken into account.

Mother of child dropped by alleged child sex offender Joshua Dale Brown, says investigation into incident was flawed
Mother of child dropped by alleged child sex offender Joshua Dale Brown, says investigation into incident was flawed

ABC News

time13 hours ago

  • ABC News

Mother of child dropped by alleged child sex offender Joshua Dale Brown, says investigation into incident was flawed

Melbourne mother Helen* says alleged child sex offender Joshua Dale Brown should have been "removed from the sector" two years ago after he was investigated for dropping her one-year-old baby at Creative Garden Early Learning Centre Point Cook. "This individual should not be allowed to work with any children," she told 7.30. The incident with Helen's son occurred in April 2023. The centre's manager at the time told her the incident would be investigated by centre owner G8 Education and that another team member had witnessed the alleged "misconduct". Emails obtained by 7.30 reveal Helen repeatedly sought updates on the progress of the complaint into Mr Brown. Email from Helen: "Has there been any progress re: the incident at the centre yesterday?" Response from centre manager: "I sent off the documentation to the department for notification and currently completing documentation to send to CCYP … (which is the Victorian Commission for Children and Young People) the educator has been removed from the room during the investigation process and is not being left isolated in rooms with other children." Helen believed the centre's response did not go far enough. "They are our most vulnerable in society and yet we are letting, we're allowing someone around them who can only work under supervision. What kind of safeguarding is that?" Helen said. One week after that email Helen followed up again with Creative Garden Early Learning Centre as to why normal reporting protocol wasn't followed. Email from Helen a week later: "Could I please ask why there hasn't been an incident report for what happened?" Response from centre manager: "The educator who witnessed the incident is on annual leave." Helen said there were "constant excuses such as 'a staff member was on holidays', 'we weren't able to conduct this and this review' ... which I think given the seriousness of the incident, is not good enough". After waiting for five months Helen received the outcome of G8 Education's investigation into Mr Brown, in August 2023. Email from centre manager: "An internal investigation was completed internally with permission from the Department of Education, the investigation was found substantiated due to 'recklessness'. The team member has been given an official written warning, is completing a performance improvement plan and will not be left in isolation until the performance improvement plan has been passed. The Department and CCYP have agreed with this outcome and have now closed the case for us to continue disciplinary actions." "'Recklessness' is an empty word," Helen said. "There is little definition to these words, and we still don't really know what happened or why. Last Friday 7.30 requested an interview with G8 Education's CEO Pejman Okhovat to ask about the company's complaints process and employment of Mr Brown. By Saturday afternoon G8 Education had sent a mass email confirming Mr Brown had been the subject of two internal investigations, the first investigation involving Helen's son. In the email G8 Education admitted: "Mr Brown aggressively picked up and put down and did not uphold the dignity and rights of a child in his care by not supporting that child while they were upset." The email also said Mr Brown went on leave for three months between when the incident happened and when they wrapped up the investigation. Helen has not been contacted by Creative Garden Early Learning Centre or G8 Education since August 2023. Creative Garden Early Learning Centre notified Helen in April 2023 the complaint had been referred to the Victorian Department for Education and the Victorian Commission for Children and Young People. The acting Principal Children's Commissioner Meena Singh refused to comment, citing "ongoing investigations". But in statement to 7.30 she went on to justify why incidents may not be referred to the Department of Government Services for a review of Working With Children Checks, saying some incidents "would be better addressed through training or supervision". The Victorian department of education refused to comment on Helen's complaint or 7.30's request for a statement. A spokesperson for the federal department of education said it was "not aware of any complaints made regarding the conduct of Joshua Dale Brown". Mr Brown was arrested on May 12 and has been charged by Victoria Police with 70 offences relating to eight alleged victims at the Creative Garden Early Learning Centre in Point Cook. He is set to appear in Melbourne Magistrates' Court on September 15. "We had this exposure to him in an unpleasant way, and there were these [other] incidents. So to me there were early alarm bells that went off and no one took them seriously," Helen said. *Helen's name has been changed due to legal concerns. Watch 7.30, Mondays to Thursdays 7:30pm on ABC iview and ABC TV Do you know more about this story? Get in touch with 7.30 here.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store