New Criticism Says ‘The Salt Path' Isn't The True Story It Claims To Be
Gillian Anderson and Raynor Winn attend the premiere of the movie "The Salt Path" during the 2025 ... More Munich Film Festival. Getty Images
In her book, Raynor Winn claims she and her husband, Moth Winn, invested in the business of a childhood friend and ultimately lost their beloved 17th-century Welsh farmhouse when the friend took them to court to recoup their debt after the business failed.
Suddenly homeless, and coping with her husband's unexpected diagnosis of corticobasal degeneration, a terminal illness, the couple decides to hike the 630-mile South West Coast Path in England that Winn says "transformed us completely and altered the course of our lives."
But the Observer investigation claims the Winns, whose legal names are Sally and Tim Walker, lied about the reality of their financial situation and questions the veracity of his diagnosis.
Several named sources claimed Raynor Winn actually embezzled £64,000 (about $87,000) from her employer years before writing her memoir, dodged related criminal charges and lost the family home after failing to repay one of many significant debts.
The woman who moved into the Winn's home after it was repossessed said she received a stream of letters addressed to them with unpaid bills and credit card statements, letters from debt collection agencies and an unpaid speeding fine, and a local business owner in their town said he, too, is owed money from the couple.
The Observer article also calls into question the diagnosis of corticobasal degeneration, a progressive brain disease similar to Parkinson's with a life expectancy of six to eight years, considering Moth Winn 'has been living with the condition for 18 years and he seems to have no visibly acute symptoms.'
Get Forbes Breaking News Text Alerts: We're launching text message alerts so you'll always know the biggest stories shaping the day's headlines. Text 'Alerts' to (201) 335-0739 or sign up here : joinsubtext.com/forbes.
Winn defended her story in a statement to The Observer, calling it "the true story of our journey," and later told BBC the article was 'highly misleading,' without specifically saying why. Winn has canceled a planned book reading tour in the UK, and a statement from her legal team said she was "deeply sorry to let down those who were planning to attend the Saltlines tour, but while this process is ongoing, she will be unable to take part.' Publishing house Penguin on Wednesday said in a statement to BBC that it "undertook all the necessary pre-publication due diligence, including a contract with an author warranty about factual accuracy, and a legal read, as is standard with most works of non-fiction." Penguin also said it had not been notified of any concerns about the book before hearing from The Observer. Number 9 Films and Shadowplay Features, which made "The Salt Path" movie, told the BBC Monday the film is "a faithful adaptation of the book that we optioned" and "we undertook all necessary due diligence before acquiring the book.'
The Observer suggests Raynor Winn embezzled tens of thousands from her former employer Martin Hemmings' family-run business. Hemmings' widow, Ros, spoke to the paper and said she was glad her husband, who died in 2012, didn't live to see the book and film. Ros said her daughter has spoken before about the parts of the story she says are fabricated, and that, 'when she found any of the books in charity shops, she would write a little homily in the front about what Sally's really like.' Big Number
More than 2 million. That's how many copies the book, a Sunday Times bestseller, has sold since its publication in March 2018 as one of Britain's most successful nonfiction books in recent years, according to The Observer. Tangent
PSPA, the UK charity dedicated to people affected by CBD, told BBC it has "made the decision to terminate our relationship with the family' and a video of Moth Winn talking about his condition has been removed from its website. What We Don't Know
If 'The Salt Path' film will be released in the United States. The movie released in England on May 30 and has grossed about $16 million so far. It's set to premier in Germany and France, and a deal is reportedly underway for US release.
The real Salt Path: how a blockbuster book and film were spun from lies, deceit and desperation (The Observer)
Penguin says it did 'all necessary due diligence' with The Salt Path (BBC)
5 Of Europe's Set-Jetting Destinations Now Trending In 2025 (Forbes) Further Viewing
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Los Angeles Times
5 hours ago
- Los Angeles Times
Go behind the scenes with the ‘Alien: Earth' cast at Comic-Con 2025
SAN DIEGO — Sydney Chandler has wanted to attend San Diego Comic-Con as a fan for years. So it's 'surreal' that the actor's first experience with the annual pop culture expo is to promote her upcoming FX series 'Alien: Earth.' Chandler stars in the 'Alien' prequel as Wendy, a young girl whose consciousness has been transferred to an android. 'To be able to do it in this capacity is just mind-blowing,' she tells The Times in advance of the show's Hall H premiere on Friday. 'It's emotional because we worked on this for so long and I learned so much. … I'm kind of at a loss of words.' She does have words of appreciation, though, including for what she's learned from her character. 'Her journey of finding out how to hold her own and stand on her own two feet taught me so much,' says Chandler. 'I'm an overthinker. I'm an anxious person. I would have run so fast. I would not be as brave as her, but she taught me … that it's OK to just stand on your own two feet, and that's enough. That's powerful.' Even before the show's Hall H panel, fans have gathered on the sidewalk outside of the Hard Rock Hotel San Diego to catch a glimpse of Chandler and her 'Alien: Earth' cast mates Timothy Olyphant, Alex Lawther, Samuel Blenkin and Babou Ceesay, along with creator Noah Hawley and executive producer David Zucker, on their short trek to the bus that would transport them to the convention center for the show's world premiere. On the ride over, Hawley betrays no nerves about people seeing the first episode. 'I really think, in a strange way, it plays for all ages because it is about growing up on some level,' says the showrunner. 'But it's also 'Alien,' and it is a meditation on power and corporate power. ' Huddled together on the bus with Lawther and Blenkin, Ceesay is surprised to learn that this is the first time attending San Diego Comic-Con for all three. There's plenty of good-natured ribbing as they talk about the early interviews they've completed at the event. 'I just sort of want to make jokes with you all the time,' says Lawther as he looks towards his cast mates. 'I find it quite giddy in the experience, and I had to remind myself that I'm a professional.' 'Sometimes the British sarcasm instinct just kicks in,' Blenkin adds. Their playful dynamic continues as they joke about crashing Ceesay's other panel, and also backstage at Hall H as they try to sneak up on each other in the dark. After the panel, the cast is whisked away for video interviews and signing posters at a fan meet-and-greet at a booth on the exhibit floor. ('Timothy, you're the man!' shouts a fan passing by.) Later, Hawley, Chandler and Ceesay will hit the immersive 'Alien: Earth' activation where they will explore the wreckage of a crashed ship. 'It's such a safe space for people who just enjoy cinema and enjoy film,' Chandler says of Comic-Con. 'And that's me. I'm a complete nerd for all this stuff, so just to be around that group — it reminds me of why I love film so much in the first place.'
New York Post
6 hours ago
- New York Post
US woman with tattoos and nose piercing may be descendent of Queen Victoria's secret lovechild
A Midwestern therapist with a mullet, tattoos and nose piercing may be a descendant of Queen Victoria's secret lovechild, a British historian has claimed. Angela Webb-Milinkovich, a mental-health practitioner from Minnesota, was named as a possible living testament to a scandalous affair between the British monarch and her devoted manservant, John Brown, by historian Fern Riddell. Webb-Milinkovich, who is in her 40s, according to online records, doesn't look like a royal but is prepared to get a DNA test to prove whether she is. 3 Angela Webb-Milinkovich, a healthcare worker in Minnesota, may be a living descendant of Queen Victoria's secret lovechild. bettylooper/Instagram Advertisement 'I feel pretty confident that there's some legitimacy to [the theory],' Webb-Milinkovich told the Times of London. 'It's not something that I myself would ever be able to confirm. 'The story that my family grew up with is that John Brown and Queen Victoria had a romantic relationship,' she said, referring to the loyal aide who the royal matriarch became particularly close to after her husband Prince Albert's death. 'They went on a long boat journey. After that, a child was produced, and from that child came my family's lineage,' Webb-Milinkovich said of Brown and the queen. Advertisement 3 Queen Victoria asked to be buried with a picture of her manservant and suspected lover John Brown. Rumors have swirled that Mary Ann Brown, Webb-Milinkovich's great-grandmother, was their lovechild. Victoria and Brown's closeness sparked rumors in Britain, and in 1866, a Swiss newspaper reported the pair had secretly married. Victoria even dedicated her book on highland life, published after Brown died in 1883, to him and asked to be buried with his picture. Advertisement 3 Brown was suspiciously close to blue-blooded boss Victoria, some historians say. The rumored affair was the subject of the 1997 movie 'Mrs Brown,' which won Dame Judi Dench an Oscar nomination for her portrayal of Victoria. Although the alleged affair has been dismissed by many historians, Riddell said she has unearthed new evidence indicating a relationship. The evidence includes a cast of Brown's hand ordered by the monarch in the days after his death, something she had previously done for her late husband. Advertisement A previously secret diary entry from Victoria also describes how she and her 'beloved John' confessed their love for each other. 'Their relationship has been downplayed and sanitized,' Riddell told the Times of London. 'I hope we give John Brown back his place in history and his legacy, which is that he was Victoria's de facto royal consort for 20 years,' said the researcher, author of the book 'Victoria's Secret.'
New York Post
8 hours ago
- New York Post
She is known as the woman with the ‘world's largest lips'— here's what she looked like before all her surgeries
One too many injections. Spending over $26,000 on lip filler alone will earn you the title of the woman with the 'world's largest lips.' Andrea Ivanova set out in 2018 to alter her appearance by not only getting a wild amount of lip injections — but also chin shaping, enlargement and lengthening, jaw shaping and cheekbone enhancement, according to the Daily Mail. Advertisement 4 Ivanova looks like a real life Bratz doll after all her cosmetic procedures. Jam Press/@andrea88476 By 2022, the Bulgarian woman already had nearly 32 procedures done to make her look like a living Bratz doll. Now, photos of what she looked like prior have surfaced — and the difference is striking. Advertisement 4 Her before pictures are wildly different from what she looks like now. Jam Press/@andrea88476 4 Ivanova before spending thousands on cosmetic procedures. Jam Press/@andrea88476 Although Ivanova is aware that her lack of a love life is most likely due to her overdoing it with cosmetic procedures — that and knowing it's risky doesn't stop her. 'My doctor was afraid to inject more hyaluronic acid into my lips, but I was adamant that I wanted more, and I will not stop,' she said, according to the outlet. Advertisement 'But this time, I wanted to experiment with myself to see how many injections and [amounts of filler] would affect my body.' 4 Doctors once warned the millennial to ease up on all the work she was planning on getting done — but she didn't listen. Jam Press/@andrea88476 Doctors have even warned the social media model that her injection obsession is dangerous — and potentially fatal — but expert advice won't change her mind. In addition to the many alterations to her face — Ivanova has also gone under the knife for a breast augmentation, taking her from a 75C to a 75E bra size. Advertisement As wild as this might sound — Ivanova at least didn't have a procedure gone wrong like one model who claims her butt implants fell out. Chelsea Robinson has apparently spent over $140,000 in total on various cosmetic surgeries. In 2019, the 29-year-old traveled from London to the Dominican Republic to get butt implants. After getting back (and hopefully healed) she was working out in the gym when she felt like something was off. 'My leg went all tingly, and I felt something come out. My implant was hanging,' Robinson told British TV personality Olivia Attwood during a sit-down interview for her UK show 'Olivia Attwood: The Price of Perfection.' The self-procalimed model said she ended up spending $85,567 on corrective surgeries to fix her booty.
