Dublin firefighter thought he could ‘rape with impunity' in Boston, trial told
A Dublin firefighter accused of rape during the St Patrick's Day weekend last year 'thought he could come to Boston and rape with impunity', a prosecutor told his trial in closing arguments on Monday.
Terence Crosbie (38) is charged with raping a 29-year-old woman in a hotel bedroom while his Dublin Fire Brigade colleague Liam O'Brien was asleep in a separate bed.
The woman says she had consensual sex with Mr O'Brien at the Omni Parker House hotel after meeting him at The Black Rose bar in Boston on March 14th, 2024. She later fell asleep in a separate bed but awoke to find Mr Crosbie raping her, the trial has heard.
Mr Crosbie denies the charges.
READ MORE
Closing arguments came after five days of testimony during the trial at Suffolk superior courthouse in Boston in which both Mr Crosbie and the alleged victim gave evidence.
On Monday, defence counsel Daniel C Reilly told the court that because Mr O'Brien 'was supposedly asleep' and declined to participate in the trial, 'there are only two people who can know what happened'.
He said the woman was a 'less-than-reliable reporter due to intoxication and memory lapses'.
Mr Reilly told the court the woman could not remember Mr O'Brien's first or last name or that Mr Crosbie had been in the Omni Parker House hotel room when she and Mr O'Brien first arrived.
He also said she did not recall Mr Crosbie having tattoos, did not cry out to Mr O'Brien for help and initially claimed her alleged assailant was about her height. Mr Reilly pointed out that Mr Crosbie is taller than the woman.
Mr Reilly also sought to discredit the DNA evidence taken from the complainant revealing two male profiles.
Expert witnesses testified during the trial that there was
an insufficient amount of DNA to conclusively identify the second male contributor
from the samples.
Mr Reilly suggested the second male profile could have been someone other than Mr Crosbie.
Prosecutor Erin Murphy argued that Mr Crosbie's testimony was 'rehearsed and insincere'.
'Didn't it seem a bit scripted until he got caught fudging it?' she asked.
When Mr Crosbie took the stand previously, Ms Murphy played a portion of his interview with police in which he told detectives he had masturbated in the hotel room and questioned whether his DNA could have gotten on the complainant that way.
In cross-examination, Ms Murphy said Mr Crosbie would not have had time to masturbate alone in his room until after the alleged assault.
'He tried to come up with some bogus lie to explain why his DNA might be found later,' Ms Murphy told the jury on Monday.
She said Mr Crosbie 'thought he could come to Boston and rape with impunity and then skip town like it never happened. But that's not how it works here.'
The prosecutor said the complainant's 'nightmare was real'. She was a 'human being' who was questioned repeatedly about the alleged events.
'She didn't fabricate or hallucinate a highly detailed and very specific account of a stranger raping her just because she drank some alcohol,' Ms Murphy said.
'If she was so drunk and she was making up a story, how did she get so much right?' she asked, noting that details of the woman's account were supported by CCTV footage.
The trial continues before a jury of eight men and four women.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Irish-based French father and daughter dead after stabbing in Iceland
Icelandic police are investigating the killings of a man and his adult daughter, who had been living in Ireland, in a Reykjavik hotel at the weekend. Both victims, who were found dead at the Edition Hotel on Saturday, appear to have sustained stab wounds. A woman, who is also a member of the same Irish-based family, has been arrested for questioning. She had also sustained wounds but they are not believed to be life-threatening. All three are French nationals. READ MORE The victims are the arrested woman's husband and daughter, all of whom were due to fly back to Ireland on Saturday. It is understood the dead man was in his late 50s or early 60s and that his daughter was about 30 years old. The arrested woman is also in her late 50s or early 60s. The Metropolitan Police in Reykjavik released a statement to the media confirming it was investigating the double killing. 'A French woman in her 60s was remanded in custody by the Reykjavík District Court until Friday, June 20th,' it said. This was done 'on the basis of investigative interests at the request of the Metropolitan Police in the interest of their investigation into the deaths of two French tourists at a hotel in the city centre'. It added 'the woman in custody was travelling with the deceased when the case arose', adding that 'no further information can be provided at this time'. In reply to queries, Garda Headquarters in Dublin said: 'An Garda Síochána typically does not comment on criminal investigations taking place in another jurisdiction.' The double murder is a very rare event in Iceland where the number of murders has traditionally been in low single digits annually. Ævar Palmi Palmason, assistant chief of the Central Investigation Department of the Metropolitan Police in Reykjavik, confirmed to local media that though the victims, and suspect, were French they were living in Ireland. Their relatives had been contacted with the help of the French embassy in Iceland and French police had also been contacted about the case. Police were called to the hotel just before 7.15am on Saturday, the day the family had been due to fly back to Ireland after spending a week in Iceland. The fourth floor of the hotel, where the victims' remains were discovered, was sealed off and other guests were restricted in their movements as the scene was examined.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Man serving 10-year sentence for raping student removed from teachers' register
A secondary schoolteacher serving a 10-year sentence for the oral rape of one of his students has been removed from the teachers' register. The decision was made on Monday at a Teaching Council fitness-to-teach inquiry, where the Disciplinary Committee Inquiry Panel also ruled that Patrick Joseph Bardon could not apply to be readmitted to the register for 20 years. Bardon is serving a 10-year sentence in the Midlands Prison for the oral rape of one of his then student, a male, between October 1992 and March 1994. Bardon was convicted of 11 charges of orally raping the then teenager on dates between October 1992 and March 1994 and was sentenced in October 2023 by Mr Justice David Keane. READ MORE The panel found that Bardon's rape convictions are 'fundamentally incompatible' with the teaching profession and its core values and that his conviction affected his fitness to teach. It also said his offences constituted 'an egregious breach of trust'. The panel noted that Bardon had engaged in grooming behaviour of his male victim over 20 months. Joanne Williams, barrister for the council, outlined some of the evidence from Bardon's criminal trial, including that the victim would regularly go to his house after school, where they would watch pornography together. The inquiry also heard that the victim corrected exam papers for Bardon for which the teacher gave him money. In its ruling, the panel said there was a risk of lifelong implications for the victim as a result of Bardon's behaviour. The offences took place at Bardon's home between October 1992 and March 1994, starting when he was 23 and his victim was 15. Bardon is serving his sentence in the Midlands Prison. In imposing the 20-year prohibition on teaching, the panel said this was necessary to protect the public. It also noted Bardon's probation report, which said that there was a moderate chance of reoffending. Mitigating factors that the panel took into account included that Bardon's short teaching career was blemish-free until the point the offences occurred and that he was in his early 20s at the time.
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Dublin firefighter thought he could ‘rape with impunity' in Boston, trial told
A Dublin firefighter accused of rape during the St Patrick's Day weekend last year 'thought he could come to Boston and rape with impunity', a prosecutor told his trial in closing arguments on Monday. Terence Crosbie (38) is charged with raping a 29-year-old woman in a hotel bedroom while his Dublin Fire Brigade colleague Liam O'Brien was asleep in a separate bed. The woman says she had consensual sex with Mr O'Brien at the Omni Parker House hotel after meeting him at The Black Rose bar in Boston on March 14th, 2024. She later fell asleep in a separate bed but awoke to find Mr Crosbie raping her, the trial has heard. Mr Crosbie denies the charges. READ MORE Closing arguments came after five days of testimony during the trial at Suffolk superior courthouse in Boston in which both Mr Crosbie and the alleged victim gave evidence. On Monday, defence counsel Daniel C Reilly told the court that because Mr O'Brien 'was supposedly asleep' and declined to participate in the trial, 'there are only two people who can know what happened'. He said the woman was a 'less-than-reliable reporter due to intoxication and memory lapses'. Mr Reilly told the court the woman could not remember Mr O'Brien's first or last name or that Mr Crosbie had been in the Omni Parker House hotel room when she and Mr O'Brien first arrived. He also said she did not recall Mr Crosbie having tattoos, did not cry out to Mr O'Brien for help and initially claimed her alleged assailant was about her height. Mr Reilly pointed out that Mr Crosbie is taller than the woman. Mr Reilly also sought to discredit the DNA evidence taken from the complainant revealing two male profiles. Expert witnesses testified during the trial that there was an insufficient amount of DNA to conclusively identify the second male contributor from the samples. Mr Reilly suggested the second male profile could have been someone other than Mr Crosbie. Prosecutor Erin Murphy argued that Mr Crosbie's testimony was 'rehearsed and insincere'. 'Didn't it seem a bit scripted until he got caught fudging it?' she asked. When Mr Crosbie took the stand previously, Ms Murphy played a portion of his interview with police in which he told detectives he had masturbated in the hotel room and questioned whether his DNA could have gotten on the complainant that way. In cross-examination, Ms Murphy said Mr Crosbie would not have had time to masturbate alone in his room until after the alleged assault. 'He tried to come up with some bogus lie to explain why his DNA might be found later,' Ms Murphy told the jury on Monday. She said Mr Crosbie 'thought he could come to Boston and rape with impunity and then skip town like it never happened. But that's not how it works here.' The prosecutor said the complainant's 'nightmare was real'. She was a 'human being' who was questioned repeatedly about the alleged events. 'She didn't fabricate or hallucinate a highly detailed and very specific account of a stranger raping her just because she drank some alcohol,' Ms Murphy said. 'If she was so drunk and she was making up a story, how did she get so much right?' she asked, noting that details of the woman's account were supported by CCTV footage. The trial continues before a jury of eight men and four women.
