'Appreciation for the People' initiative more populist than practical, says S'wak activist
KUCHING (July 23): Social activist Voon Shiak Ni has criticised the federal government's recently announced 'Appreciation to the People' initiative, calling it a populist move that raises more concerns than confidence among small business owners and taxpayers.
She said the RM100 one-off cash handout for all adult Malaysians, along with the declaration of a public holiday on Sept 16, may have been welcomed by some, but lacked strategic value and long-term economic rationale.
'From the perspective of business operators and taxpayers, it is not just about the cost – it is about the principle.
'It reportedly took several days for the government to reach this decision following public anticipation of a salary adjustment for civil servants.
'What emerged instead was a populist substitute ― quick to please, but lacking in meaningful substance,' she said in a statement today
Voon noted that while RM100 may seem minor to individuals, the overall payout amounts to hundreds of millions of ringgit from public funds – resources largely underwritten by the business community.
'To many of us, it appears more like a political gesture to boost popularity than a targeted policy aimed at addressing real economic needs,' she said.
She also questioned the abrupt announcement of the public holiday, citing the hidden costs borne by small and medium enterprises (SMEs), particularly those operating on tight schedules or dependent on daily wage earners.
'For these businesses, the impact is real – lost productivity, disrupted workflows, and increased overtime costs. These are not theoretical burdens; they are everyday realities,' she said.
While voicing support for people-centred policies, Voon urged the federal government to pursue initiatives that are inclusive, sustainable and grounded in long-term planning rather than short-term populism.
As an example, she pointed to the Sarawak government's Senior Citizens Health Benefits programme, which she described as a more inclusive and dignified model.
'This initiative benefits all Sarawakians aged 60 and above, regardless of race or background. It reflects a model of universal dignity without side-lining any group.
'We hope Putrajaya can learn from such models and shift its focus toward sustainable reform instead of fleeting applause,' she said.
Earlier, Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim announced that the RM100 cash aid – to be distributed via MyKad — is part of the Sumbangan Asas Rahmah (Sara) programme in conjunction with Merdeka Day.
The RM2 billion initiative is expected to benefit 22 million Malaysians and can be used at over 4,100 participating retail outlets from Aug 31 to Dec 31.
With this latest rollout, total spending for the Sara and Sumbangan Tunai Rahmah (STR) programmes this year will reach RM15 billion, up from RM13 billion in 2024. Appreciation to the People Voon Shiak Ni
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
25 minutes ago
- New Straits Times
EPF monthly payouts a step towards retirement security, say experts
KUALA LUMPUR: The government's proposal to introduce monthly pension payouts under the Employees Provident Fund (EPF) has been welcomed by financial and aged care experts as a much-needed reform to address retirement insecurity among Malaysians. Unveiled under the 13th Malaysia Plan (13MP), the proposed mechanism seeks to ensure a steady post-retirement income by splitting EPF contributions into two components: one for lump-sum savings and another for monthly pension payouts. The new structure aims to provide Malaysians with greater financial stability in retirement, especially as life expectancy rises and savings remain inadequate for many. However, a 'one-size-fits-all' monthly payout system may not suit all retirees. Chartered financial consultant and licensed financial adviser Lee Khee Chuan told the New Straits Times that more Malaysians are retiring with inadequate savings, thus a structured monthly payout system will likely help retirees avoid running out of funds too soon. "With life expectancy rising and many Malaysians retiring with inadequate savings, this is a step in the right direction," he said, adding that a monthly disbursement model would mimic a steady salary, encouraging better financial habits among retirees. Lee said this would also indirectly reduce the risk of poor money management among the aged society in Malaysia. "It's not uncommon for retirees to exhaust their lump sum within a few years. A monthly pension provides greater financial discipline and peace of mind, particularly for those without strong financial literacy or family support," Lee said. The proposal also received backing from those working closely with the elderly. Meanwhile, Association of Providers of Aged Care (Agecope) national secretary Fong Muntoh said he fully supported the idea, having personally seen many cases of retirees not having sufficient funds to support themselves after retirement. "As someone deeply involved in aged care for over two decades, I've also seen firsthand how unpredictable health costs and poor financial planning can affect quality of life in later years," he said. He said a well-structured, monthly pension would provide retirees with greater peace of mind and reduce the risk of depleting their savings too early, something he regularly witnesses among elderly individuals and their families. Fong said that flexibility and sustainability must be balanced, calling the hybrid model a step in the right direction if supported by good governance and strong contributor engagement. While experts support the shift, they cautioned against a rigid, one-size-fits-all approach. "Some retirees will still need a lump sum for things like clearing housing loans or paying medical bills. The system must be flexible, perhaps allowing a partial lump sum, with the remainder distributed monthly," he said. Lee also said that public confidence has taken a hit due to multiple policy reversals and pandemic-era EPF withdrawals. "If we're locking in retirement savings, transparency and clear communication are vital to rebuilding trust," he said. Experts argue that a uniform payout may not serve all retirees equally and that cost-of-living differences between regions should be taken into account. "A retiree in Kuala Lumpur faces very different expenses from someone in rural Kelantan. A flat-rate monthly payout won't reflect these realities," Lee said. Both Lee and Fong pointed to Singapore's Central Provident Fund (CPF) Life scheme as a successful model to emulate. "Under that system, retirees receive automatic, lifelong monthly payouts, with options to defer withdrawals for higher monthly income. What sets Singapore apart is the clarity, structure, and public confidence in the system. Malaysia can definitely learn from that," Lee said.
New Straits Times
an hour ago
- New Straits Times
Mandatory retirement age review gains support from employers, ageing advocates
KUALA LUMPUR: The proposal to review Malaysia's mandatory retirement age has gained support from employers and ageing advocacy groups, who are calling for a flexible, sector-sensitive approach with adequate safeguards for both older and younger workers. Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim, when tabling the 13th Malaysia Plan (13MP) yesterday, said the government would review the retirement age as the nation transitions towards an ageing society. Senior Citizens Advisory Council member Tan Sri Lee Lam Thye said the review was timely and necessary, given Malaysia's increasing life expectancy and a growing number of older citizens who remain active and capable. "Sixty is too young to retire in this day and age. With the average lifespan now exceeding 75, people still want to contribute, and many need to continue working to support themselves or their families," he said. Lee said the government should consider raising the age gradually, for instance, to 63 first, and then move towards 65 with proper study and stakeholder input. He also advocated for a flexible retirement model where those who wish to retire can do so, while those willing and able to work may continue. "Many seniors are still fit, of sound mind, and eager to stay productive. They bring years of experience that can be channelled through roles like mentorship or advisory work," he said. Addressing concerns that an extended retirement age may affect youth employment, Lee said the government must focus on expanding job creation to avoid intergenerational friction. "If the government can generate the 1.2 million jobs projected under the plan, both older and younger Malaysians can be meaningfully absorbed into the labour force," he said. He also urged the swift introduction of the long-proposed Senior Citizens Act to enshrine protections for elderly Malaysians, including employment rights, healthcare access, and public mobility. Meanwhile, Malaysian Employers Federation (MEF) president Dr Syed Hussain Syed Husman said the move was "sound and forward-looking" but must not be implemented as a blanket policy. He said MEF supports retaining capable older workers, especially in knowledge-based or strategic roles, but warned that physically demanding jobs in sectors such as construction, agriculture, and manufacturing may not be suitable for employees beyond 60. "Without proper structure, extending the retirement age could lead to safety risks, productivity losses, and higher medical claims," he said. He added that older workers may also face challenges in adapting to fast-paced technological changes without sustained, accessible upskilling initiatives. Syed Hussain said while the extension could reduce dependency on retirement savings and preserve medical coverage, it might also slow promotion pipelines and limit wage growth for younger workers. "To move forward, we recommend a flexible policy based on health, performance, and job suitability — not a blanket extension," he said. MEF also called for structured role transitions, such as fixed-term contracts and mentorship roles, alongside tax relief incentives for seniors who remain employed. "With the right safeguards and support, this policy can help Malaysia harness the full potential of its ageing workforce without compromising youth employment or business competitiveness," he said.
New Straits Times
2 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Appeals court orders return of Port Dickson land after fraudulent sale
PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal has affirmed a High Court decision to return a parcel of land in Port Dickson to its rightful owner, after it was transferred through a series of fraudulent transactions. A three-judge panel led by Datuk S. Nantha Balan ruled that both Top ATC Industries Sdn Bhd and businessman Lee Kok Chian had failed to prove they were bona fide (genuine) purchasers of the land, which had been fraudulently transferred by an imposter posing as the registered trustee. The appellate court also upheld the High Court's order for the land to be re-registered in the name of its rightful owner, Cheok Lam Chuan, who filed the suit after discovering the illicit transfer in 2018. On Jan 21, 2016, the subject land was fraudulently "transferred" to Fu Zhi Mao Group Sdn Bhd before the latter entered a Sale and Purchase Agreement with Top ATC Industries on Feb 24, the same year. On March 29, 2016, (barely 6 days after the transfer of the land), Top ATC Industries entered into a Sale and Purchase Agreement with Lee. The transfer of the subject land took place on Nov 1, 2016. "Apart from the sinister conclusions that are to be derived from the suspicious timing of the transaction between Fu Zhi Mao Group and Top ATC Industries, there is the added fact that the latter had failed to prove that it had made any payment to the former. "Lee ought to have suspected that the previous transaction could be fraudulent due to the short timeline of sale of the land. "He should have undertaken the ordinary precautions and investigations as a reasonable and prudent purchaser. "However, Lee deliberately shut his eyes to the obvious and refrained from checking or making further inquiries about the earlier land transfer," he said in his ground of judgment yesterday. The court also upheld the lower court's finding that neither Top ATC Industries nor Lee had acted in good faith in their dealings over the land transaction. The court also held that the Negri Sembilan Registrar of Titles and Director of Lands and Mines were negligent for failing to detect or prevent the fraudulent registration. The appellate court affirmed all the lower court's orders, including: -Cancelling the registration of the land in Lee's name and restoring it to Cheok. -The award of RM100,000 in aggravated damages against Top ATC and Lee. -An order for both parties to pay RM50,000 each in legal costs to Cheok. -A cost order of RM10,000 against the two land officers.
