logo
This author 'fixed' 'The Giving Tree' with a new ending. Some say it's long overdue.

This author 'fixed' 'The Giving Tree' with a new ending. Some say it's long overdue.

Yahoo27-05-2025
What if the Giving Tree said "no" to the boy?
Thousands of adults online are resonating with alternate endings to classic children's books that may not have aged well in light of modern-day gentle parenting.
In his series 'Topher Fixed It,' Atlanta-based playwright and screenwriter Topher Payne reimagines "The Pout-Pout Fish," "Love You Forever," "The Rainbow Fish" and "The Giving Tree."
In the original 'Giving Tree,' the tree gives away her apples, branches and trunk for the boy who keeps returning and asking for more. It's been the subject of some criticism for portraying an unhealthy, one-sided relationship.
But in Payne's reimagined 'The Tree Who Set Healthy Boundaries,' the Giving Tree stops at the apples. Instead, the tree shares how she feels about their friendship changing and explains why she doesn't want to give everything away. The boy practices empathy and the tree remains strong and tall for generations to come.
The internet is divided: A Facebook user roasted the popular kids book 'Love You Forever'
'Setting healthy boundaries is a very important part of giving. It assures you'll always have something left to give,' the book ends. 'And so the tree was happy. Everyone was.'
Many Instagram users applauded the alternate ending, which was shared recently by both Payne and podcaster Adam Grant. Grant's post about the ending on May 4 has racked up 129K likes on Instagram.
'Reading your ending to 'The Giving Tree' healed a little piece of me tonight!' commented one Instagram user.
"Thank you for this − I always loathed the message in this book," another wrote. "The original is one of my favorite books," another person replied. "I've read it a hundred times and cry each and every time... I think reading both versions to our kids is key so they can see how the two options play out. Thank (you) for this."
Payne says he's also received backlash since he began the series during lockdown in 2020. But he emphasizes the alternate endings are meant to inspire thought, not criticize the originals. He first started the 'Topher Fixed It' series in hopes of prompting nuanced conversations that he remembers having with his aunt when he first read the books as a child.
'What I found in a lot of people's relationship with the book is that maybe that conversation doesn't always happen and so the messaging in 'The Giving Tree' can go off in some pretty wild directions,' Payne said.
He wrote the alternate endings to stand alongside the original text to compel conversation, whether that happens when reading to a child or returning to the text as an adult.
Other classics: 'Love You Forever' is being called 'unsettling'. These books are just as questionable.
'The stories we're told as children are often one of the few things we all have in common,' Payne said. 'The originals are a classic for a reason. I celebrate them and the (reimagined) stories are meant to stand alongside them, not in place of them.'
The 'Topher Fixed It' stories are available for free download from Payne's website. He does not receive monetary compensation for his alternate endings and is not seeking to publish them.
Readers have suggested other titles for him to reimagine, but Payne doesn't have any immediate plans to recreate another story. Instead, he encourages others to give it a try.
'If there is a story that you've been told that you would love to consider another option, put that to paper and see what it looks like,' he said. 'It can be really cathartic for you to resolve that story for yourself in that way.'
Adrianna Rodriguez can be reached at adrodriguez@usatoday.com.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Author 'fixed' 'The Giving Tree.' Some say it's long overdue.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Sandwich Trivia Quiz — BuzzFeed Quizzes
Sandwich Trivia Quiz — BuzzFeed Quizzes

Buzz Feed

time20 minutes ago

  • Buzz Feed

Sandwich Trivia Quiz — BuzzFeed Quizzes

I love me a good sandwich — What's better than a packed sammy after a long day of swimming? I swear, that's an unmatched feeling. I'll always feel accomplished after stacking an extravagant sandwich and finishing it off with a perfect parchment paper wrap. 🥪🥪 Fun fact: the word "sandwich" was first coined way back in 1762! Since then, sandwiches have become a universal staple — from Western classics to international delicacies everyone must try at least once in their life (bánh mì will change your life, I swear). So now I have to ask, how well do you know your sandwiches? I'll show you a photo of a sandwich, and you'll have to guess its name. Let's get into it! So, how'd it go? Be sure to share your score in the comments, and throw in your go-to sandwich for an extra point! 🍞🥖 Want more fun food trivia? Take a look at BuzzFeed Canada's TikTok and Instagram socials!

Comedian Matt Rife's new e.l.f make-up ad becomes latest celebrity ad generating outrage online
Comedian Matt Rife's new e.l.f make-up ad becomes latest celebrity ad generating outrage online

Fox News

time43 minutes ago

  • Fox News

Comedian Matt Rife's new e.l.f make-up ad becomes latest celebrity ad generating outrage online

Comedian Matt Rife's new ad campaign for cosmetics brand e.l.f. is the latest celebrity-starring commercial that has caused social media users to melt down. The make-up brand published their ad online on Tuesday, featuring Rife and drag queen "Heidi N Closet" portraying lawyers in a spoof legal commercial promoting inexpensive e.l.f cosmetic products. A slew of comments on the post took issue with Rife being in the ad, with many pointing to a domestic violence joke he told in 2023 as the reason he should've never been chosen for the ad campaign. "You didn't have the budget for a comedian who doesn't joke about abuse?" one user asked on the Instagram post. Make-up influencer account "kristians_makeup" wrote, "ELF IMMA HOLD UR HAND WHEN I SAY THIS…just cuz u got a drag QUEEN in the mix DOES NOT MEAN ITS A GREEN LIGHT FOR MATT RIFEEEGEE??!?" The comment received over 8,600 likes in less than a day. Another said, "I thought you guys were cruelty free?!" These and similar comments reflected a renewed backlash against the comedian for joking about a woman who had a black eye during his 2023 special, "Natural Selection." In the set, Rife told the story of eating at a Baltimore restaurant with a friend when they noticed their female server had a black eye. They questioned why the restaurant owners wouldn't have the employee work in the kitchen to avoid customers asking questions. "Yeah, but I feel like if she could cook, she wouldn't have a black eye," Rife joked. In response to the backlash he received from the joke, Rife doubled down, putting out a statement that directed social media users to a link offering an "apology" if they had ever been offended by a joke he told. The link brought users to a website where they could purchase special-needs helmets. On e.l.f.'s TikTok page, bitterness towards Rife's domestic abuse joke was on full display, with more users demanding the makeup brand drop him from the campaign. "Nikkietutorials," a cosmetics influencer with almost 9 million followers commented, "aaaaaaandddd you lost me... Matt Rife out of ALL people? 😟 so disappointed." Maddy Lucy Dan, a TikTok user with 1.4 million followers, rehashed the Rife controversy in the comments section, writing, "In Matt Rife's Netflix stand-up special Natural Selection he opened with a domestic violence joke, implying a woman wouldn't have a black eye if she could cook." Another user added, "So y'all saw American Eagle and said… hold up, I can do that." The comment referenced actress Sydney Sweeney's American Eagle jeans ad campaign that took heat online in recent days for its tagline, "Sydney Sweeney Has Great Jeans." Social media users and legacy media outlets alleged the tagline had a link to the "eugenics" movement. Yet another celebrity-starring ad has also taken heat in recent weeks. Dunkin' Donuts released a short spot for its new summer Refresher drinks on Tuesday featuring "The Summer I Turned Pretty" star Gavin Casalegno. During the 35-second ad, the actor credited his summer tan to his "genetics." TikTok users hammered the ad on the platform for mentioning genetics, with many linking it to Sweeney's ad. Rife and e.l.f. did not immediately reply to Fox News Digital's request for comment.

'The Office' Star, 58, Stuns with Ageless Beauty While Teasing Exciting News
'The Office' Star, 58, Stuns with Ageless Beauty While Teasing Exciting News

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

'The Office' Star, 58, Stuns with Ageless Beauty While Teasing Exciting News

'The Office' Star, 58, Stuns with Ageless Beauty While Teasing Exciting News originally appeared on Parade. Actress Melora Hardin has never looked better. The 58-year-old Hollywood veteran is best known for her breakout role as Michael Scott's dysfunctional boss and girlfriend Jan Levinson on The Office. Now the stunner is teasing a new project while showing off her ageless a social media post shared to Instagram on July 26, Hardin shared a stunning photo of herself wearing a white blazer with a deep V, coupled with a pair of skinny black pants. The actress's blonde locks glow in the photo as she beams her megawatt smile for the camera. The photo is captioned, 'Got to work on something exciting yesterday. Can't wait to causing fans to speculate Hardin might be making an appearance in The Office spinoff titled Paper. While fans will have to patiently await details on Hardin's latest project, they rushed to the comment section to discuss her effortless looks and talent.'Simply stunning! 🤩 Incandescent 🕯️🔥😍,' wrote one fan. Another added, 'Mamma mia! 'Growing old gracefully' doesn't begin to cover it!' 'Forever stunning and beautiful!' shared another fan. 🎬SIGN UP for Parade's Daily newsletter to get the latest pop culture news & celebrity interviews delivered right to your inbox🎬 'The Office' Star, 58, Stuns with Ageless Beauty While Teasing Exciting News first appeared on Parade on Jul 26, 2025 This story was originally reported by Parade on Jul 26, 2025, where it first appeared. Solve the daily Crossword

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store