Dispute between Sandie Peggie and transgender doctor posed ‘no risk to patients'
Nurse Sandie Peggie was suspended after she complained about having to share a changing room with trans medic Dr Beth Upton at the Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife, on Christmas Eve 2023.
She was placed on special leave and then suspended after Dr Upton made an allegation of bullying and harassment and cited concerns about 'patient care'.
Ms Peggie has lodged a claim against NHS Fife and Dr Upton, citing the Equality Act 2010, including sexual harassment; harassment related to a protected belief; indirect discrimination; and victimisation.
The tribunal resumed in Dundee on July 16 after an initial set of hearings in February.
On Monday at the tribunal, service manager Lottie Myles said she perceived the dispute which led to Ms Peggie being suspended as a 'she said/she said' situation, and there was 'nobody who could provide evidence'.
Ms Myles said she was tasked with conducting a suspension review on February 27 2024, and was told by the nurse's manager, Esther Davidson, that Ms Peggie was 'anti-trans', and 'had transphobic views because of an incident that occurred in the changing room'.
She said that Ms Davidson alleged Ms Peggie had 'some gender critical beliefs, and some other beliefs which she has which may not be everybody's belief', an hour before a suspension review meeting, but Ms Myles said she was not given any documentation to examine prior to the review.
During the tribunal, counsel for NHS Fife, Jane Russell KC, asked about these 'other beliefs'.
Ms Myles said: 'There was views that Sandie was homophobic and there were elements of racism in her beliefs. It's hearsay. I try to disregard views which haven't been documented or there's little evidence of.'
She noted that Ms Peggie referred to Dr Upton using 'male terminology', but said that she believed Ms Peggie's feelings about Dr Upton were 'circumstantial', and later challenged why allegations she branded 'hearsay' had not been documented or escalated, the tribunal heard.
Ms Russell said: 'Arising out of this meeting, what was your opinion about how Sandie Peggie really felt about Dr Upton?'
The witness said: 'I think Sandie probably wasn't too happy with Dr Upton but I think that was more from the incident which had happened. In summary notes, I had asked if she was to treat a patient who was transgender, would she treat them differently?
'I was reassured she said she wouldn't treat anyone trans differently; I felt that it was circumstantial.'
Ms Russell asked for the witness's views on how Ms Peggie 'might deal with transgender patients' after a suspension review meeting on March 7 2024.
Ms Myles said: 'I felt reassured she wouldn't treat them differently. Sandie has been a nurse for 30 years, I'm sure in that time she has dealt with transgender patients. I felt there were no safety concerns.'
She said she referred to the Nursing and Midwifery Council code, including on freedom of expression, and the Equality Act 2010 which she described as a 'grey area in a lot of workplaces', and said there were 'several reasons' why she lifted the suspension, the tribunal heard.
Ms Myles said: 'I wanted to be sure I wouldn't be treating either party in breach of the Equality Act. I wanted to have Dr Upton and Sandie Peggie treated fairly and equally.'
She said that a meeting between herself, Ms Peggie and Royal College of Nursing rep Stuart Fraser was 'very difficult' and 'emotional' for Ms Peggie, who was determined to return to the Emergency Department rather than be moved to another department managed by Ms Myles, the tribunal heard.
Ms Myles said: 'I wanted both parties to be treated fairly and equally. The situation was 'she said/ she said', we were limited on witnesses and things being documented.'
The witness said that a return to work would be 'beneficial' for Ms Peggie, and that she wanted to 'make it as seamless as possible', after discussions about moving departments and moving onto dayshifts were both rejected, the tribunal heard.
Giving evidence, Ms Myles said she was aware of reports of 'negative interactions', which she branded 'hearsay'.
Ms Myles said: 'I actually challenged that by saying: 'Why wasn't this documented? Why wasn't it escalated?' Nobody could confirm, but I felt that was hearsay. I felt that to try to prevent any other allegations from happening having a senior team member on duty would be supportive for her.'
She said it was agreed to put the pair on 'opposite shifts' and for Ms Peggie to be supervised during a phased return, describing it as a 'compromise', the tribunal heard.
Ms Myles said that her involvement ceased around April 19 at the request of head of nursing Gillian Malone, and she had no role in the investigation.
The tribunal continues.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Leader Live
15 minutes ago
- Leader Live
Nurses threaten industrial action ballot after pay offer rejected
It comes after members of the union rejected a 3.6% pay increase for 2025/26 in England. Professor Nicola Ranger, general secretary and chief executive of the RCN, said nurses feel 'deeply undervalued'. The Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) said the Government 'hugely' values the work of nurses, but stressed the profession has had 'two above-inflation pay rises'. The RCN represents hundreds of thousands of nurses across the NHS in England. According to the union, 91% of members voted to reject the pay award on a 56% turnout, with more than 170,000 staff taking part. It warned that the profession faces widespread vacancies, stunted career progression and years of pay erosion, and urged ministers to use the summer to agree an investment plan or face a formal escalation to a dispute and a ballot on industrial action. Prof Ranger said: 'My profession feels deeply undervalued and that is why record numbers are telling the Government to wake up, sense the urgency here and do what's right by them and by patients. 'Record numbers have delivered this verdict on a broken system that holds back nursing pay and careers and hampers the NHS. 'As a safety-critical profession, keeping hold of experienced nursing staff is fundamentally a safety issue and key to the Government's own vision for the NHS. 'Long-overdue reforms to nursing career progression and the NHS pay structure aren't just about fairness and equity but are critical for patient safety.' Nurses in Wales and Northern Ireland were consulted on the same pay award and voted to reject it, according to the RCN. Prof Ranger added: 'We deliver the vast majority of care in every service and deserve to be valued for all our skill, knowledge and experience. 'To avoid formal escalation, the Government must be true to its word and negotiate on reforms of the outdated pay structure which traps nursing staff at the same band their entire career.' A DHSC spokesperson said: 'After receiving two above-inflation pay rises from this Government, new full-time nurses will earn £30,000 in basic pay for the first time this year, so it's disappointing that RCN members are dissatisfied with this year's pay rise. 'We hugely value the work of nurses, and through our 10 Year Health Plan, we are rebuilding the NHS for the benefit of patients and staff, and ensuring nursing remains an attractive career choice. 'This Government is clear we can't move any further on headline pay but will work with the RCN to improve their major concerns, including pay structure reform, concerns on career progression and wider working conditions.' Nurses staged unprecedented industrial action over pay in 2022 and 2023. In June 2023, the threat of more strikes ended because a ballot on further walkouts failed to meet the legal threshold of 50%. A poll published earlier this week found that Britons are split on the idea of nurses striking over pay. The YouGov survey found that 19% of 4,300 British adults 'strongly support' nurses going on strike, while 28% 'somewhat' supported it. Meanwhile 23% said they 'strongly oppose' strike action while one in five (20%) 'somewhat oppose' it. The RCN warning over a potential ballot for industrial action follows a five-day walkout by resident doctors in England, with medics returning to work at 7am on Wednesday. Health Secretary Wes Streeting has since written to the British Medical Association (BMA) saying he is willing to meet the union's resident doctors committee to resume talks. However, he warned that resident doctors have squandered the 'considerable goodwill' they had with Government after the strike.
Glasgow Times
16 minutes ago
- Glasgow Times
Nurses threaten industrial action ballot after pay offer rejected
It comes after members of the union rejected a 3.6% pay increase for 2025/26 in England. Professor Nicola Ranger, general secretary and chief executive of the RCN, said nurses feel 'deeply undervalued'. The Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) said the Government 'hugely' values the work of nurses, but stressed the profession has had 'two above-inflation pay rises'. The RCN represents hundreds of thousands of nurses across the NHS in England. According to the union, 91% of members voted to reject the pay award on a 56% turnout, with more than 170,000 staff taking part. It warned that the profession faces widespread vacancies, stunted career progression and years of pay erosion, and urged ministers to use the summer to agree an investment plan or face a formal escalation to a dispute and a ballot on industrial action. Prof Ranger said: 'My profession feels deeply undervalued and that is why record numbers are telling the Government to wake up, sense the urgency here and do what's right by them and by patients. 'Record numbers have delivered this verdict on a broken system that holds back nursing pay and careers and hampers the NHS. 'As a safety-critical profession, keeping hold of experienced nursing staff is fundamentally a safety issue and key to the Government's own vision for the NHS. 'Long-overdue reforms to nursing career progression and the NHS pay structure aren't just about fairness and equity but are critical for patient safety.' Nurses in Wales and Northern Ireland were consulted on the same pay award and voted to reject it, according to the RCN. Prof Ranger added: 'We deliver the vast majority of care in every service and deserve to be valued for all our skill, knowledge and experience. 'To avoid formal escalation, the Government must be true to its word and negotiate on reforms of the outdated pay structure which traps nursing staff at the same band their entire career.' A DHSC spokesperson said: 'After receiving two above-inflation pay rises from this Government, new full-time nurses will earn £30,000 in basic pay for the first time this year, so it's disappointing that RCN members are dissatisfied with this year's pay rise. 'We hugely value the work of nurses, and through our 10 Year Health Plan, we are rebuilding the NHS for the benefit of patients and staff, and ensuring nursing remains an attractive career choice. 'This Government is clear we can't move any further on headline pay but will work with the RCN to improve their major concerns, including pay structure reform, concerns on career progression and wider working conditions.' Nurses staged unprecedented industrial action over pay in 2022 and 2023. In June 2023, the threat of more strikes ended because a ballot on further walkouts failed to meet the legal threshold of 50%. A poll published earlier this week found that Britons are split on the idea of nurses striking over pay. The YouGov survey found that 19% of 4,300 British adults 'strongly support' nurses going on strike, while 28% 'somewhat' supported it. Meanwhile 23% said they 'strongly oppose' strike action while one in five (20%) 'somewhat oppose' it. The RCN warning over a potential ballot for industrial action follows a five-day walkout by resident doctors in England, with medics returning to work at 7am on Wednesday. Health Secretary Wes Streeting has since written to the British Medical Association (BMA) saying he is willing to meet the union's resident doctors committee to resume talks. However, he warned that resident doctors have squandered the 'considerable goodwill' they had with Government after the strike.
Telegraph
16 minutes ago
- Telegraph
I'm facing paralysis at 29 but the NHS won't operate
My left side is numb and almost impossible to move and my hands feel so weak I can't even hold a phone. I have nerve pain all over my body that feels like it's being constantly rubbed with nettles or having acid thrown on me. I am 29 years old and have Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome, a rare but under-diagnosed condition that affects as many as 268,000 people in the UK – up to 90 per cent of them women. There is an operation that I could have to address my symptoms but it isn't available on the NHS or anywhere in the UK. I wouldn't wish this on anybody – the pain I feel is exhausting, constant and often terrifying. Most people have never heard of EDS but it's a genetic condition that affects the collagen in your body, making connective tissues like skin, ligaments and blood vessels very soft. The connective tissues are so weak that my neck is no longer able to support my head. My skull presses on the brainstem at the top of my spine causing severe neurological symptoms. Brainstem compression like mine can lead to paralysis because it disrupts vital signals between the brain and the body – which terrifies me. When the pain gets really bad, especially in my face and my head, my left eye hurts so much that I almost want to tear it out. It affects my vision too. Coping with the pain Despite my disability, I was working until a few months ago. I was an administrator at the Royal Hospital for Neuro-disability, close to where I live with my dad and his partner – who I call my stepmum – in her flat in Putney. I loved being with the patients, being creative, coming up with activities that paralysed people could do, like tie-dyeing and birdwatching. I put a lot of love into that job. But my condition deteriorated and in the end I had to stop working. Now I spend time alone listening to audiobooks – sitting up to read causes too much strain – occasionally seeing a friend and resting. What scares me most is the thought that my life will be just this pain and even paralysis. When it's excruciating, I have dark thoughts but wouldn't act on them because I have family and loved ones, and don't want to hurt them. The diagnosis I was diagnosed with EDS in my early 20s but looking back I've been unwell since my teens. At first my doctors put the pain down to anxiety, saying it was all in my head and that I was overemotional. It's true, I was very stressed as my parents were getting a divorce; I had an eating disorder and was unhappy at school. But if you're in excruciating pain, you're obviously going to be crying and asking for help. As a child my life was pretty normal but I was always hypermobile as a kid, which is common in people with EDS. My left leg would bend inwards but I wasn't in any pain. People with EDS often suffer from dislocated joints and though my joints would partially dislocate, it never really bothered me until I was 16, when I started getting pain in my spine. With EDS, you often become more symptomatic as a teenager and in your early 20s. When I was 20, they finally said, 'Oh, you've got fibromyalgia.' I began subscribing to the magazine of a charity, Fibromyalgia Action UK, which had an article about EDS and how some people with it were being misdiagnosed with fibromyalgia. There was a list of symptoms and an explanation of the Beighton score – an assessment tool used to measure joint hypermobility, or excessive flexibility – and I thought, 'Oh God, that's me!'. I contacted the doctor who wrote the piece, and he advised me to get a referral to an NHS rheumatologist, who confirmed that I did indeed have Ehlers-Danlos. I was then referred to University College London Hospital for pain management and physiotherapy splints, which I wore on my wrists and ankle. My neck pain wasn't so bad then, but I've had to use a neck brace to support my head since the nerve pain started increasing when I was 25. Living with the condition I studied international relations at the University of Sussex, but had to come back to London and study from home with the Open University. It took me six years to graduate. By then I had reconnected with a friend from school and we became a couple. We rented a flat and he looked after me full-time, getting a carer's allowance, because I had to use a wheelchair, and needed help to wash and get dressed. He was amazing and put up with a lot during our seven years together, but it just got to the point where I was too unwell to be in a relationship. Now I live with dad and my stepmum and they have been amazing. Hope for an operation The operation to address it isn't available on the NHS, or anywhere in the UK, for people with EDS because of debate about its effectiveness, even though specialists in Europe and the US are convinced it's very likely to help. My hope is to see one of these specialists in America. My Dad has sold his house at 75, raising £70,000, and my aunt has given me £10,000 of her savings. It's only with their help that I can even think about going to the States for the operation. The surgery will fuse the vertebrae in my neck so it supports my head better, which will ease the pressure on my brainstem, to relieve the nerve pain and stop my other symptoms, including seizures. The surgeon I'm hoping will operate has a 90 per cent success rate. We're still well short of the £150,000 I need for the surgery and travel but I refuse to let this condition ruin me and have set up a GoFundMe page so that I can pay for it. Why the NHS won't operate To be honest, I feel gaslit by the NHS. I was given an MRI lying down, which didn't measure the full stress on my neck. After I paid for a private upright MRI, specialists in the US and in Europe said its results confirm my condition. But the NHS disregards this, even though it did perform this operation on EDS sufferers until about 2017, and a study was being done into its benefits, but all that stopped before the pandemic. Now, no British doctor will give me a diagnosis, even though one referred me to the US surgeon who will now hopefully operate. I'm hoping I can eventually go back to my job, even if it's part-time, and be free of the terror of being paralysed. Despite all I've been through I haven't given up on life – or love. I recently met someone online, who seems to genuinely like me – being unwell filters out insincere people – and we've had a few picnic dates where I've been able to lie down and talk to him. I'll never be a mother because I don't want to pass on the EDS, which there's a 50 per cent chance of, but he has kids so, who knows, maybe one day I can be a stepmum to them? I won't have the life most women my age dream about, but I have hope that I can live a good and happy one if I get this surgery, avoid paralysis and am no longer in this horrendous pain.
