Astrophysicist Jayant Narlikar passes away: What is the Hoyle–Narlikar theory of gravity?
He was best known for propounding the Hoyle–Narlikar theory of gravity (also known as conformal gravity), which he developed with English astronomer and professor Fred Hoyle in 1964. The theory sought to improve on Albert Einstein's General Theory of Relativity, published in 1915.
Here is a look at the Hoyle–Narlikar theory of gravity.
Link to Mach's principle
At the heart of the Hoyle–Narlikar theory of gravity is the Mach's principle, which says that the mass of every object in the universe is affected by its interaction with every other object. Einstein was greatly inspired by the principle, but could not incorporate it into his theory.
Hoyle and Narlikar took Mach's principle more literally and claimed to have successfully included it in their theory. They said that the inertia of an object, that is the tendency to resist change in its state of motion, arises from its interaction with all other matter in the universe.
'As Hoyle and Narlikar see it, a universe with nothing in it is impossible. There must be at least two particles, each to give mass to the other. The masses, and therefore the gravity, of the sun and the earth are partly due to each other, partly to more distant objects such as the stars and galaxies,' according to a report in Time Magazine.
Concept of C-field
The Hoyle–Narlikar theory of gravity also proposed a 'creation field' (C-field), a hypothetical negative-energy field responsible for the continuous creation of matter. This helped explain the steady-state cosmology, which said that the universe had no beginning and will endure forever.
The steady-state concept of the universe is essentially an alternative to 'Big-Bang' cosmology, which proposed that the universe originated 13 billion years ago with an expansion and has been expanding ever since. Hoyle and Narlikar said that if the universe were this old and always expanding, we would not see anything in the sky.
'Hence, Dr Hoyle and other proponents of a steady‐state situation have proposed that hydrogen atoms are continually being created in space to fill the void resulting from such expansion. It is to account for this that Dr Hoyle has proposed the existence of an unseen force, or C-field. When this field becomes strong enough, at any point in space, a new hydrogen atom appears,' according to a report in The New York Times.
The Hoyle–Narlikar theory of gravity was not widely accepted, especially after the discovery of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) radiation in 1965. CMB — considered as an echo or shockwave of the Big Bang — is the cooled remnant of the first light that could travel freely throughout the universe.
However, the theory continues to draw attention for its attempt to integrate Mach's principle in cosmology.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
IIT Guwahati spearheads national initiative to establish Manekshaw Centres for Defence and Security Research
Indian Institute of Technology Guwahati is leading the initiative to set up nodal centres for defence and national security research throughout the country. Established under the aegis of Ministry of Education, Government of India, and led by Prof. Devendra Jalihal, Director, IIT Guwahati , the 'Manekshaw Centre' is working towards next-gen education, innovation, productization, manufacturing and research-based consulting/operations. To support the initiative, a high-level delegation recently briefed Education Minister, Dharmendra Pradhan on the establishment of a Nodal Centers in Indian Premier Institutes dedicated for Defence and National Security Research. Speaking about the initiative, Prof. Devendra Jalihal, Director, IIT Guwahati, said, 'Manekshaw Center will act as an interface between Indian Academia and defence forces. IITs, IISc, IIITs and NITs will be the members of the centre. The centre will periodically carry out dialogs with defense agencies and will participate actively to define and design systems for Indian security needs. It will work towards finding Indian solutions thus fulfilling the aspiration of Atmanirbhar Bharat .' Highlighting the need of inter-institutional collaborations, Education Minister, Dharmendra Pradhan expressed strong support for the initiative. He underlined the Ministry's commitment to supporting the Manekshaw Centre in building a robust innovation ecosystem that brings academia, defence, armed forces, security agencies and industries together to address the evolving challenges of national security. Aligning with the Government of India's Atmanirbhar Bharat mission, this visionary initiative will unite IITs, IISc, IIITs, and NITs on a collaborative academic and research platform focused on defence technology and national security. The idea of setting up this nodal centre for collaboration among IITs was conceived by Lt. Gen. Dr. Subrata Saha (Retd.), and Prof. Sukumar Nandi, Dean of Administration, IIT Guwahati. Currently the Manekshaw Centre includes, IITs: Guwahati, Madras, Kanpur, Jodhpur, Dharwad, Delhi, Bombay, Kharagpur, BHU-Varanasi, ISM-Dhanbad, IISc Bangalore and IIIT Delhi. Established in March 2025, IIT Guwahati's MCoENSSR is working towards bridging the gap between Defence Forces, Security Agencies, and Academic & Research Institutions that can enable convergence of strategic vision, operational excellence, and technological expertise to strengthen national security. Other key objectives of the centre include, create a new-age Security Industrial Complex/Ecosystem to promote Govt. of India's Atmanirbhar Bharat initiative to 'win India's wars with Indian solutions'. Collaborate with start-ups, industry partners, foreign institutes to achieve higher technology readiness level and cater the requirements of the Indian Armed Forces and Security Agencies and Organise Dialogue Series, Workshops, Seminars, Ideathons, Conference with Indian Armed Forces and other key national security stakeholders on new-age national security challenges, next-gen asymmetric hybrid non-contact warfare, futuristic technologies.
Indian Express
2 hours ago
- Indian Express
Hidden Stories: this historic garden rests in isolation in Pune's Aundh, yearning for visitors
A towering mango tree with a wide, scaly trunk and regal foliage stands beside an uneven track, almost appearing to be surveying its surroundings like the Peshwas who had planted it back in 1799. Sheltered in its shade, one is barely aware of the roar of the Pune traffic from Ganeshkhind Road as vehicles hurry past a key biodiversity heritage site in the country. Instead, the breeze carries the smell of leaves and the chatter of mynas, parakeets, and kingfishers. Ganeshkhind Garden, located at the Ganeshkhind Research Center behind Savitribai Phule Pune University and a stone's throw from Spicer College, is a 145-acre expanse where history intertwines with botany, and trees serve as important landmarks. In fact, there are more than 4,500 trees here. 'Even the people who live in the Aundh neighbourhood don't know that they have such a beautiful site nearby. They could come more often, have their walks here, and conduct visits for nearby schools,' says Meghna Bhandari, a citizen who is involved in protecting and raising awareness about natural resources. Ganeshkhind Garden was established as a Centre for Taxonomic Studies by botanist George Marshall Woodrow in 1872. It was intended as a site for scientific research into horticulture. To this day, the garden contains tracts of mango and guava orchards, an avenue of legacy mahogany trees, and dense fields of crops, besides populations of insects and other biodiversity. When British forces needed medicinal plants The interest of the British in setting up such gardens goes back to the 17th and 18th centuries, when Pune was a seat of the Marathas that controlled the central and southern parts of the Indian sub-continent and was, consequently, a formidable power against the East India Company, whose garrison was in Khadki. European officers of the company trained 'natives' in military tactics to form a force. This led to a demand for a botanical garden that would provide medicinal plants, among others, required by the British and native forces. The Dapodi Garden was established in 1827 by Sir John Malcolm, the Governor of the Bombay Presidency. Over almost the next four decades, the garden encouraged innovations and planted the seed for scientific research, paving the way for Ganeshkhind Garden. Ameet Singh, an economist and researcher, says that Pune, even a few decades ago, 'had so much biodiversity by the riverside that Ganeshkhind Garden, by itself, wasn't a very unique place'. 'We had the Salim Ali Bird Sanctuary, where the river became a flood plain, and the Ram-Mula confluence. Slowly, the riverside began to be encroached by a lot of people, including the Pune Municipal Corporation (PMC). Gradually, all the green cover of Pune started to disappear. Today, the Ganeshkhind Garden is among the few such green spaces remaining in the city,' he says. The garden was accorded the status of a Biodiversity Heritage Site in 2020. Singh adds that several plant types have been developed in the garden through genetic breeding programmes. These include at least 21 varieties of 11 crops. 'The garden, thus, possesses sensitive genetic material, which includes the germplasm (the genetic material of a plant) of several crop plants, and new crop varieties developed through traditional research tools,' he says. Researchers have found 167 wild plant species, out of which over 67 have medicinal uses. Now, a demand for STP At present, the Ganeshkhind Garden is facing a new threat in the form of a case at the National Green Tribunal (NGT) in Pune. 'The PMC wants 30 gunthas of land from the garden to set up a Sewage Treatment Plant (STP). There are few such biodiversity heritage sites in India like this garden. While we are not opposed to building STPs. On the contrary, we believe that STPs should be built as we need to increase capacity, but this can be done at a different site rather than at Ganeshkhind Garden,' says Bhandari, the main litigant. The others are Singh, Rekha Joshi and Gangotri Chanda. 'Building an STP would require heavy construction work and a road. There will be noise and pollution. In future, the PMC will increase the capacity of the STP. We are opposed to this happening at Ganeshkhind Garden,' adds Bhandari. As the group takes on the authorities in court, she hopes that citizens start enjoying the garden more. Dipanita Nath is interested in the climate crisis and sustainability. She has written extensively on social trends, heritage, theatre and startups. She has worked with major news organizations such as Hindustan Times, The Times of India and Mint. ... Read More
Indian Express
3 hours ago
- Indian Express
From South America to India, how the humble potato swept the world
In most Indian households, the humble potato is a staple in breakfast, lunch, dinner, and all meals in between. This love for the vegetable is shared across continents. According to the Peru-based research-for-development organisation International Potato Center, the potato is the world's most important food crop for human consumption, after rice and wheat. Interestingly, recent research has revealed that the potato originated through natural interbreeding between a wild tomato plant and a potato-like species in South America about nine million years ago. The two plants, according to a team of biologists and genomic scientists, are said to have shared a common ancestor that lived 14 million years ago. Amidst these new revelations, a look at how the unassuming spud travelled the world. What is the potato, and where is its birthplace? A potato is composed primarily of water (about 79 per cent), followed by carbohydrates and protein. It also contains essential vitamins and minerals. 'Just 100 gm of potato provides nearly half the minimum daily requirement of vitamin C…,' notes author John Reader in Potato: A History of the Propitious Esculent (2009). Potatoes are also rich in B-Complex vitamins, calcium, iron, and potassium. According to Reader, the most primitive living relative of the tuber-bearing potato is a small epiphyte called Solanum morelliforme. The plant has leaves, flowers, and small berries and is found growing on the branches of oak trees in southern Mexico. Scholars suggest that ancestors resembling these wild species were present in the south-west United States and Mexico 40 million years ago, and migrated into South America when the Isthmus of Panama was formed 3.5 million years ago. Reader notes, 'Their history thereafter was one of botanical diversification and geographical expansion as the potato advanced and adapted to thrive in the host of ecological niches that South America had to offer.' Many root plants are still grown commercially in South America, but S. tuberosum, the common potato, is globally known. In Potato: A Global History (2020), academic Andrew F. Smith reckons that the domestication of S. tuberosum began around 10,000 BCE by Andean farmers in the Lake Titicaca basin. 'In one of the world's most inhospitable terrains for agriculture, the potato became the chief food of the people,' says Smith. The potato was well suited to the summer heat, which made possible the growth of the above-ground plant, while cooler nights encouraged the growth of the tuber. Once harvested, potatoes last only a few months before they sprout and eventually succumb to mold. Indigenous South Americans, interestingly, developed a method to preserve them in ways that they can be stored for years. The advent of the Inca Empire around 1430, initially a small tribe living around Cuzco, Peru, changed the fate of the potato. The Inca Empire was conquered by the Spanish around 1532. Smith argues that after the conquest, the Spanish encouraged the cultivation of the potato, and to collect taxes in the form of chuno—a freeze-dried potato—which they used to feed construction workers. Historians such as William H McNeill suggest that potatoes paid for Spain's military conquests and political power in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. Smith notes, '…and thus the potato, which fed the workers, had radically changed world history.' Potatoes, consumed by the masses in mid-eighteenth-century Europe, led to massive population growth. 'And it was this massive rise in population [in Northern Europe],' argues Smith, 'that permitted Western European nations to colonize the world.' The potato arrives in Europe The potato arrived in Europe around the 1570s. 'What is unclear is precisely where these potatoes came from,' writes Smith. 'Potatoes were ideal for feeding sailors on long voyages, but when the ships arrived in Spain, excess provisions would have been jettisoned. So it's not surprising that the first record of S. tuberosum outside of South America appears in the Canary Islands [in Spain], a stopping point for ships sailing to and from the Americas,' he adds. Potatoes from Spain were sent to Italy, where they were at first called taratouffli (truffles). When the Spanish engaged in war in the Low Countries (modern-day Belgium, Netherlands, and Luxembourg), they developed a line of supply beginning from Spain through northern Italy, south-western Germany, and south-eastern France. 'The Spanish armies brought potatoes with them, and farmers along the supply line grew potatoes to sell to the military formations and supply trains as they passed by,' Smith notes. He observes that potatoes were grown in Italy by the 1570s, in Germany by 1581, and in Switzerland and France soon after. Smith concludes, 'By the seventeenth century the potato was cultivated as an agricultural crop, especially as a substitute for rye'. However, not all European herbalists were fond of the tuber. Some believed potatoes were poisonous and caused leprosy and other diseases. Some French provincial governments, in fact, forbade their cultivation. Not until the War of the Spanish Succession (1701-1714) did the potato become an essential item. 'This war produced one of the worst famines in European history, and peasants and soldiers alike adopted the potato without hesitation,' writes Smith. When potatoes reached England is debatable. English explorer Francis Drake is believed to have introduced potatoes from Chile into England in 1578. According to Smith, 'In England, Scotland and Ireland, potatoes were mainly grown in gardens until the late seventeenth century.' Although used as horse fodder in England, Scotland and Ireland grew it for human consumption. When the aloo came to India 'The chronology of the potato's early spread across the Indian subcontinent is no clearer than that of its dissemination across Europe,' writes historian Rebecca Earle in Feeding The People: The Politics Of The Potato (2020). By the mid-sixteenth century, Portuguese vessels were sailing regularly to Indian ports and had established themselves in Cochin on India's western coast. 'Edward Terry, who served as a chaplain for the East India Company in the early seventeenth century, reported seeing 'potatoes excellently well dressed' at a banquet in Rajasthan hosted by the Mughal statesman Asaf Khan in 1615,' Earle adds. Later, the British East India Company sent potatoes along its trade routes into the Himalayas, where Sherpas called them 'English potatoes'. Buddhist monks are said to have begun cultivating potatoes in Bhutan and Nepal in the 1700s. Reader points out that 'just as in Europe, the new and prolific food source set the population rising dramatically.' Earle finds that when nutritionists in Europe were denouncing the potato as inferior to bread, Indian nutritionists such as Baneswar Singha called it superior to rice. She adds, 'Potatoes therefore formed part of a larger programme to strengthen the nationalist movement by strengthening Indian bodies'. The potato that the British viewed as a symbol of superiority, according to Earle, became a symbol of protest for the colonised. While colonialism brought the potato to India, Earle says, '…these forces alone did not determine the roles it now plays in Indian culture'. Today, the potato has become an indispensable part of Indian cuisine, and India is the world's second-largest producer and consumer of the starchy staple. Nikita writes for the Research Section of focusing on the intersections between colonial history and contemporary issues, especially in gender, culture, and sport. For suggestions, feedback, or an insider's guide to exploring Calcutta, feel free to reach out to her at ... Read More
