Vanguard ETF poised to overtake State Street's fund as world's biggest
By Suzanne McGee
(Reuters) - Vanguard Group's Standard & Poor's 500 ETF is on the edge of finally seizing the title of the world's largest exchange-traded fund from rival State Street Global Advisors' product, the SPDR S&P 500 Trust, according to data from FactSet, LSEG and other sources.
As of late Friday, the State Street fund was still clinging to the lead, with $633.1 billion in assets compared with $631.8 billion for the Vanguard ETF.
That gap, however, has been narrowing consistently in recent months. Final data for inflows into both ETFs will not be available until later on Tuesday or Wednesday morning, FactSet and others said.
Analysts at Citi Research tracking monthly flows into and out of exchange-traded funds reported earlier this month that SPY had $19.4 billion in outflows, accounting for 25.7% of all U.S. equity ETF outflows. Meanwhile, the Vanguard ETF raked in 12.9% of all inflows in January, for a total of $21.3 billion.
The SPDR ETF, launched in 1993, was the first U.S. exchange-traded fund. It has reigned as the largest U.S. stock ETF ever since and remains the first choice of hedge funds and traders who prize its liquidity and tight trading spreads.
But Vanguard's lower-fee challenger, launched in 2010, won admirers among financial advisors and retail investors interested in paring costs to the bone.
"SPY's transition from being primarily an investment tool to more of a trading vehicle has made flows more volatile," said Ryan Jackson, senior analyst of passive strategies at Morningstar.
The ETF industry has also undergone massive changes, with the three biggest firms in the U.S. industry - BlackRock, Vanguard and State Street - coming under siege from relative newcomers.
"There is now more of a fight for market share," said Anna Paglia, who last year left her post as global head of ETFs at Invesco to join State Street as executive vice president and chief business officer.
"SPY does keep growing in size because it's still the most traded ETF in the world," Paglia told Reuters.
She added that flows into and out of SPY tend to be seasonal in nature and that outflows early in the year are "not unforeseen."
Moreover, Paglia said flows into a retail-focused S&P 500, the SPDR Portfolio S&P 500 ETF remain robust.
According to the recent Citi Research report, this ETF - a "mini" version of SPY launched in 2005 designed to appeal to retail investors and with fees of only 0.02% - was the fifth-largest ETF in terms of inflows for January, attracting $3.2 billion.
"We don't look at SPY in isolation," Paglia told Reuters. "We look at the ecosystem."
That does not alter the reality that Vanguard's ETF may have finally toppled its State Street rival, said Todd Rosenbluth, head of research at VettaFi.
"State Street remains a dominant player in the ETF universe, but these are two different products."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CNBC
33 minutes ago
- CNBC
Stock futures are little changed after Dow snaps four-day winning run: Live updates
Traders work at the New York Stock Exchange on June 4, 2025. NYSE Stock futures are near flat Wednesday night after the Dow Jones Industrial Average snapped a four-day win streak. Futures tied to the Dow lost 44 points, or 0.1%. S&P 500 futures slipped 0.1%, while Nasdaq 100 futures fell nearly 0.2%. In after-hours trading, shares of Five Below and MongoDB jumped 4% and 13%, respectively, after both companies reported beats on the top and bottom lines for the first quarter. In regular trading, the Dow slid 0.22%, posting its first loss in five sessions. The S&P 500 advanced 0.01%, and the Nasdaq Composite rose 0.32%. Private sector payrolls rose by just 37,000 in May, coming in sharply below the Dow Jones forecast for 110,000 and raising investors' worries about the softening job market and the impact on the economy. Those worries weighed on the major averages during the session, too. Still, the market's recent gains — which have been powered by a surge in technology stocks — coupled with a blowout first-quarter earnings season have revived sentiment on Wall Street. Still, investors remain cautious that further pain could be ahead due to the Trump administration's tariffs. "The impact of tariffs is still going to be substantial in the second and maybe the third quarter as well. The surprise so far seems to be we're not getting that much inflationary pressure," Ed Yardeni, Yardeni Research president, said on CNBC's "Closing Bell." "I think we got a couple of quarters where at least on the short-term basis, tariffs are going to hurt the profits." The three major U.S. indexes are tracking for gains so far this week. The S&P 500 is up 1%, while the Dow has added 0.4%. The tech-heavy Nasdaq has jumped 1.8% week to date.
Yahoo
35 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Stablecoin issuer Circle raises $1.05 billion in upsized US IPO
(Reuters) -Circle Internet on Wednesday priced its upsized U.S. initial public offering at $31 apiece raising $1.05 billion, adding fresh momentum to a growing pipeline of late-stage cryptocurrency firms eyeing public markets. Circle and its shareholders sold 34 million shares at $31 apiece, valuing the company, which issues the USDC stablecoin, at roughly $8 billion on a fully diluted basis. The IPO had been marketed in a range of $27 to $28 per share. The company's flotation would be one of the biggest of the year after the Trump administration's trade policies rattled markets and pushed firms planning to go public to adopt a wait-and-see approach. However, market debuts of companies such as Israeli fintech eToro have offered some respite to investors tracking fresh public offerings. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
36 minutes ago
- Yahoo
US State Department's planned layoffs may violate court order, judge says
By Daniel Wiessner (Reuters) -A federal judge in California on Wednesday said her recent ruling barring President Donald Trump's administration from laying off tens of thousands of federal employees likely blocks the U.S. State Department's reorganization plan that includes 2,000 job cuts. U.S. District Judge Susan Illston in San Francisco during a virtual meeting in a lawsuit by unions, nonprofits and municipalities said she was concerned that the State Department is flouting her May 22 order that broadly blocked government-wide mass layoffs. Illston temporarily blocked about 20 agencies, including the State Department, from carrying out plans to downsize and restructure federal agencies at Trump's direction. But the department told Congress last week that it still planned to notify about 2,000 employees this month that they were being laid off and would reorganize or eliminate more than 300 bureaus and offices. 'At this point there are some semantics being bandied about, but it appears to me that what is being implemented at the State Department now is covered by the injunction,' said Illston, an appointee of President Bill Clinton, a Democrat. Illston ordered both sides to file briefs on the matter next week and said she would hold a hearing by June 13, the earliest date that State can issue layoff notices after it submitted its plan to Congress. In her May ruling, Illston said the White House cannot order the restructuring of federal agencies without authorization from Congress. The Trump administration has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to pause Illston's decision while it appeals, after a San Francisco-based federal appeals court refused to permit the pause. Illston's ruling was the broadest of its kind against the government overhaul that was spearheaded by Trump ally Elon Musk, the world's richest person and CEO of electric vehicle maker Tesla. Musk last week said he was ending his stint with the administration, raising questions about the future of his Department of Government Efficiency. During Wednesday's 30-minute meeting, U.S. Department of Justice lawyer Andrew Bernie argued that the State Department's reorganization plan predated a February executive order and subsequent White House memo directing mass layoffs, placing it outside the scope of Illston's decision. 'We of course recognize and take with the utmost seriousness our obligation to comply with the injunction, and we are complying,' Bernie said, adding that 17 federal agencies have halted planned layoffs. But Danielle Leonard, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, countered that State Department documents and statements regarding the planned layoffs specifically reference orders from the White House. 'We've heard some things from Mr. Bernie today, but we haven't seen anything sworn under penalty of perjury saying this was … independently done,' she said. Illston had convened Wednesday's meeting after the plaintiffs in a filing late Tuesday accused the State Department and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development of not complying with her decision. They said that HUD had fired about 80 employees who had not completed a probationary period, which Bernie on Wednesday confirmed. But he said that agencies have broad latitude to fire probationary workers, and those terminations were not the same as the mass layoffs of tenured employees that were blocked by Illston. Probationary workers typically have less than a year or two in their current roles, though some are longtime federal employees in new positions. Illston said it was not clear to her whether the firings at HUD were covered by her injunction.
