The Irish Times view on insourcing in the health service: not a longer-term solution
third-party insourcing
to cut waiting lists. It follows a review of the practice by the chief executive of the Health Service Executive, Bernard Gloster, who has recommended that it be phased out by the end of the year.
What appeared to be a novel solution to reducing waiting times in the wake of the Covid epidemic has come to be seen as a costly problem. Under the initiative, introduced by then health minister Stephen Donnelly, private companies were encouraged to use spare capacity – in terms of trained staff and equipment – at public hospitals to provide services to patients on public waiting lists.
The underutilisation that the initiative capitalised on was due in part to working hours and rostering limitations at public hospitals. The services were provided on a commercial basis and followed the precedent set by the outsourcing by the HSE of the treatment of public patients to private hospitals.
The initiative succeeded in its primary objective of reducing waiting times, but its cost has proved problematic. Over ¤100 million was paid out in the 27 months to March to third party outsourcing companies, many of which are run by or employ existing HSE staff.
READ MORE
Concerns were raised at the outset about the possibility of conflicts of interest and the creation of perverse incentives whereby doctors and staff involved with third-party insourcing businesses stood to benefit from long public waiting lists. Some of these concerns appear to have been borne out, with a number of controversies prompting the review by Gloster.
The Minister's dilemma is that while there may be political pressure to wind down the third-party insourcing initiative, there is even greater pressure to address waiting lists which are being driven ever upwards by demographic trends. The insourcing initiative is generally accepted to have made a material difference to waiting times.
The HSE has agreed to new rostering arrangements for staff and hospital consultants which should see equipment and facilities used more efficiently, particularly over weekends and in the evening. However, this is unlikely to be sufficient to plug the gap created by abandoning third party insourcing. The existing reliance on private hospitals will most likely be exacerbated.
The decision facing the minister is not a simple accounting exercise in which costs and benefits can be traded off. The HSE has clearly lost confidence in the initiative, and it is increasingly becoming a political liability for the Government. It may well have run out of the road, though phasing it out without adding to waiting list pressures will not be easy.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Cocaine users are now older, better educated and more likely to be working
People accessing treatment for drug use are older, have a higher level of education and are more likely to be in employment than they were seven years ago, according to a new report published by the Department of Health . On Monday, the department will publish an independent evaluation of the National Drugs Strategy, which sought to treat drug use and addiction with a health-led approach. According to the report, which was conducted by Grant Thornton, there is a changing demographic of drug users in Ireland. The median age of those in treatment increased from 30 in 2017 to 34 years in 2024, the report said, while the proportion of all cases in paid employment increased from 14.3 per cent in 2017 to 21.8 per cent in 2024. READ MORE The proportion of cases who ceased education for the first time before the age of 16 decreased from 34.9 per cent in 2017 to 30.3 per cent in 2024. In 2024, 13,295 cases were treated, the highest annual figure to date, representing a 48 per cent increase since 2017. Cocaine surpassed opioids as the main problem drug reported by people seeking treatment, according to the review. In terms of overall drug prevalence, the proportion of adults who used drugs within the last year has remained stable at 7.3 per cent. The most commonly used drugs in the previous 12 months in order of prevalence were: cannabis, cocaine, ecstasy, magic mushrooms and ketamine. Males and young people aged 15-24 years were most likely to use drugs over the past year. Higher rates of drug use were associated with being unemployed, having completed secondary level education only, being single and being Irish. The review of the Government's strategy was largely positive, highlighting how its implementation has improved data collection, expanded harm-reduction initiatives and allowed for Ireland to contribute to international research and co-operation. However, the report also highlights a number of challenges within the sector. There are disparities in access to harm-reduction services, particularly in rural areas and among marginalised groups, the report said. [ Ireland is becoming a country of moderate drinkers and voracious cocaine users Opens in new window ] Additionally, declining pharmacy engagement threatens the sustainability of needle exchange services, it added. The review team made 10 recommendations to overcome these challenges and guide 'the next phase of strategic development'. Minister of State Jennifer Murnane O'Connor, with responsibility for the National Drugs Strategy, said Ireland has 'made significant progress' in this area. 'I welcome the strong endorsement in the evaluation of the health-led response to drug use, including the proposed health diversion scheme for people found in possession of drugs for personal use,' she said. Ms Murnane O'Connor said there is a need to 'move forward with new policies and better services to address the ever-changing drugs situation'. As such, she has established a steering group to prepare a new national drugs strategy, with a deadline of the end of this year. [ Six months ago, he started taking cocaine in a more dedicated way. Things spiralled rapidly Opens in new window ]
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Twenty new beds to tackle 33% rise in eating disorder referrals
A total of 20 new specialist eating disorder beds will be opened around the country, under new plans being devised by the Health Service Executive to cope with growing demand for services. More than 500 people in Ireland were diagnosed with an eating disorder last year – more than 100 cases more than in 2023. There were also 894 referrals for treatment, up 33 per cent on the previous year. Currently, the State has just three public inpatient eating disorder beds for adults who are acutely unwell, all of which are in St Vincent's hospital in Dublin. To be treated in these beds, patients are required to fall within the catchment area of the hospital. People with eating disorders outside of this catchment order who go into public hospitals for treatment are typically referred to a general psychiatric unit, where they often are unable to access specialised care. READ MORE The HSE has begun a review of the model of care for eating disorders on a phased basis. Its first report on future eating disorder bed provision has been finalised and was recently submitted to the Minister for Health. The Irish Times understands that the plan sets out a need for between eight and 10 specialist beds in Dublin, as well as between 10 and 12 specialist beds outside of the capital, with a national spread. All of these beds will have a national catchment area. Under the proposals, these beds will be specialised for eating disorder treatment. However as demand for such services ebbs and flows, they will also be used for other psychiatric illnesses, The Irish Times understands. These beds will mostly be new provision in new units, with their establishment to take place over a number of years. However, there is potential for interim plans to increase provision until the planned number is up and running. This is not the first time such a move was proposed. Under the previous model of care, an additional 20 eating disorder beds were to be opened between 2018 and 2023, however no funding was allocated and the beds were never opened. Harriet Parsons, chief executive of BodyWhys, the national eating disorder association, says in recent years work has been on developing the community services, but inpatient beds are also required – particularly outside of Dublin. 'We need to make sure that geographical spread is there so that it doesn't matter where you are in the country, you will have access to the same kind of services,' she said. 'People who require inpatient care, they are acutely unwell. They don't come out of hospital better; they come out of hospital well enough to start the real process of getting better in the community.' She added: 'You don't want to have a huge difference between that inpatient stay and going out [into the community]. It is much more likely they will struggle to improve. That is the story that is repeated over and over again.' Meanwhile, a recent report from the Health Research Board found eating disorders were the main reason why children were admitted to psychiatric hospitals and units last year for the second year in a row. Just over a quarter (26 per cent) of children admitted had a primary diagnosis of an eating disorder, up from 24 per cent the previous year. There has been a gradual increase in the percentage of child admissions being linked to eating disorders, rising from 18 per cent in 2020 to 26 per cent last year. The researchers conducted a 'census night' on December 31st, 2024, which found there were 52 patients in Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services , of whom 38 per cent had an eating disorder.
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Writing about my trauma helps me - and my spinal cord recovery
After Tadhg Paul was left with no movement or feeling below the neck following a fall, there was a stage during nine months in hospital when he made peace with the prospect of dying. Staring up at the ceiling, he thought 'you have a lot of time to contemplate your life and the universe'. It prompted him to return to writing , which he had practised from childhood before a tech career took over. He has no doubt now that writing helped him embrace life again and regain mobility from his spinal cord injury, classed as grade B quadriplegia . Three years later, the 45-year-old man uses just a walking cane to make his way to an outdoor table at a south Co Dublin cafe on a hot July afternoon for this interview. READ MORE Dressed all in black, from sunglasses down, he talks about how the psychological journey back from injury has been bigger for him than the physical journey. Studies have shown that writing about stressful and traumatic events can significantly improve physical and emotional health. As a believer in the power of words, he found spinning them into poetry particularly therapeutic. 'Assistive technology was a liberator for me,' Tadhg says, 'just with the little Alexa in the corner, I was able to consume podcasts and audiobooks. 'Eventually I was able to, with voice control initially, use my phone and then the computer.' Therapists talk about the value of 'journaling' but, as somebody diagnosed in adulthood with ADHD, Paul says it does not work for him. He prefers writing poetry. Tadgh Paul, in Greystoneshas regained partial mobility and was greatly helped, he says, by the therapy of writing. Photograph: Nick Bradshaw 'It's been very healing for me. It's almost like I picked [my trauma] up, grasped it, examined it, brought it into the light and sort of declared it to the world.' Initially, he was writing it for himself, but he believes bringing it to a wider audience is part of the healing process. Using Paul as a pen surname, he joined the SeaScribes writing group, which meets weekly in the Mermaid County Wicklow Arts Centre in Bray . He is one of eight writers who contributed to their first anthology launched in July, Cargo of the Soul. All six of his pieces concern issues, which he says were 'put inside a box', repressed rather than dealt with. These include an early realisation about being gay, grief at the death of a soul mate and facing his own mortality. 'You kind of bare all to the world and you say, 'this is my trauma and here's what it means to me'.' While still in hospital, he created a website to post his poetry. 'Even if I was stuck in a bed, I could have a very imperfect digital engagement with the world,' he says. After six months in acute hospital care, he was transferred to the National Rehabilitation Hospital where his days were much busier as staff worked over three months to get him back on his feet. Occasionally, he still uses a wheelchair, so has moved in with his parents in Greystones , Co Wicklow , due to not being able to find suitable private rental accommodation. He was able to return to work last November but on reduced hours. Now, he also has to cope with fluctuating pain. 'I really struggle with the weather changes. It used to be that I needed two painkillers to get out of bed in the morning. I'm managing that with a different pain therapy at the moment.' As well as SeaScribes, Paul participates in an online writing group, Strange Birds. Both spaces have been important, he says, in allowing to him to 'share something quite personal and intimate' and to 'hone the quality'. It also gives him a chance 'to see how it lands – and it lands differently with everybody'. SeaScribes was founded, post-Covid, by psychologist Rita Wall, who writes under the pen name Mairead de Bhal. Keen to set up an emerging writers' group in the area, the Mermaid Arts Centre proved to be a perfect meeting place. [ Write now: Nine writers share advice on how to get started Opens in new window ] The centre's artistic director and CEO, Aoife Demel, says 'creativity for all' and 'the power and value of the arts for wellbeing' are among their core beliefs. Mermaid Arts Centre runs a programme of 'take part' events to allow people of all ages 'to engage with their creative sides, fostering wellbeing, connectivity and relevance'. When she was setting up the group, de Bhal says prospective members just had to have an interest in writing. Members critique each other's work and support the pursuit of publication, whether it is in a local newspaper or more highbrow journals – and now their self-published book. Taking up the anthology's theme of cargo, de Bhal wrote two stories from long-forgotten childhood memories from living in the North. Her father, a bank manager transferred from Dublin, was held up at gunpoint when travelling to a sub-office with cash; the family then had to leave their home above the bank in Strabane , Co Tyrone , which was later blown up. She wouldn't call the resulting story therapy, but says it was certainly a way of processing childhood memories. Fellow SeaScribe Lesley Smith describes her writing, mostly poetry, as 'a way of sharing things without having to say [them] verbally'. Amongst its uses, she she said she values it as a mental health support. 'I don't declare when I write what's me and what's observation; what's real and what's fiction. There's always a nervousness when you're sharing things that you would be judged, particularly when it's mental health stuff.' Lesley Smith says writing can be a support to mental health At the time of writing for the book, Smith, who is retired from the health service, was coping with several personal challenges. Her poem titled My Cargo reflects the worries she had about losing her memory and watching a family member living with Alzheimer's . Another personal challenge was coping with the decision of her brother, who was living with a terminal illness in Canada, to avail of what she terms ' assisted suicide ', which is legal there. 'I was absolutely stunned at the effect it had on me because I absolutely agree with the concept; I agreed with his decision... but I realised that what it does is it starts the grieving process way before you lose the person.' As it happened, his condition suddenly deteriorated and he died naturally overnight last February. Meanwhile, experience of self-doubt and 'scam' warnings from concerned friends, upon falling for a man, Thomas, whom she met at an airport bus stop, is seared into her short story, Awoken. 'Isn't it a terrible thing in our society that when you get passed a certain age, if there's some sort of romantic attachment, it's seen as being negative,' she says. 'It's like there is a 'date stamp' on love.' Thomas died unexpectedly during a trip home to his native India in May, just as they were arranging to formally live together in Gran Canaria, after having a relationship for more than two years. 'We had all these plans and we were committed to each other. Then, as they say, life took another turn.' Writing truth can indeed be stranger than fiction. Can writing help your mind? Psychotherapist Aine Connaire knows the benefit, both personally and professionally, of writing down thoughts to relieve the torment of a swirling mind. 'It's amazing the mind then, for some reason, feels like it doesn't have to hold on to it any more. And then when we do write it down, we're able to see it from a different perspective.' What is referred to as 'journaling' is a way to explore your inner world and can be done at home alone, or in conjunction with therapy sessions. It is not the same as keeping a diary, which is traditionally recording details of your day, or an event, and creates a finished piece. 'It's like your journal becomes a friend'. Photograph: Getty Images 'Journal writing is very different; you're writing to engage in a process and it is a therapeutic process.' It is convenient, free and you don't need somebody willing to listen, points out Connaire, who runs a counselling practice in Mullingar, Co Westmeath. She also offers an online introductory course to therapeutic journaling, Writing to Heal. 'It's like your journal becomes a friend. Emotions are thoughts that we may find difficult to tolerate and they can be put down in a journal without judgement.' Unstructured journaling involves free flow writing. 'You're opening up a page and beginning to write and just seeing what comes up to the surface and continuing to let that flow.' If that blank page or screen seems too daunting, a structure, such as gratitude journaling, or a letter to anyone or anything, can get you started. Connaire also recommends 'dialogue writing'. Instead of the one-sided nature of a letter, this conversational approach fills in imagined responses from the person or object being addressed. [ Writing can brighten and enlighten – just let it flow Opens in new window ] 'It's really interesting what comes up, because we have these conversations in our mind all the time.' Many people who come to therapy are unsure of why they are feeling a certain way, she says. 'If you dialogue with the emotion it's amazing what can be uncovered.' People can also interact with an illness or pain. Trauma or grief can be held in a particular part of our body, she explains, and that can manifest as physical illness. If clients want to go through their writing with her, that can be helpful. However, it's not something they have to do 'because a journal contains huge vulnerability and raw emotions, thoughts that they might not feel ready to share with me at that time'. For people who are afraid that if they write their thoughts down, somebody else may find them to read, the paper can be burnt afterwards, she suggests, or the words deleted from a screen. Creating notes on a mobile phone has become a popular method of journaling because people tend to have a lock on it. Connaire's note of caution for somebody journaling without seeing a therapist, is to ensure they have access to support if necessary in dealing with trauma. 'You don't want to open up and re-traumatise yourself and not have that support in place.'
