South Korean woman who bit off attacker's tongue during 1964 rape attempt may finally be cleared
Prosecutors at the Busan District Court issued a formal apology to 78-year-old Choi Mal Ja on Wednesday, saying that they had failed her legally and morally. They urged the court to overturn her 1964 conviction for inflicting serious injury by biting off a part of her attacker's tongue as he allegedly tried to rape her.
'This was a justified defensive act. It was not excessive, nor was it unlawful,' Korea Times reported the prosecutors as saying. 'We sincerely apologise to Choi Mal Ja, a victim of a sex crime who should have been protected as one.'
Choi, then a teenager, was assaulted by a 21-year-old man surnamed Noh who forced his tongue into her mouth after pinning her down in the southern town of Gimhae. In an effort to escape, she bit off about half an inch of his tongue.
Rather than being recognised as a survivor, Choi was charged with aggravated bodily harm and sentenced to 10 months in prison, suspended for two years. Her claim of self-defence was dismissed.
Her assailant was sentenced to just six months in prison, also suspended, for trespassing and threatening her with a weapon. He was never convicted of attempted rape.
The original prosecution had argued that Choi's response to the attacker 'exceeded the reasonable bounds of legally permissible self-defence'.
She was accused of causing permanent injury, though records showed that the attacker did not suffer a lasting disability. Prosecutors reportedly even tried to persuade her to marry him.
Choi later revealed that the litigation caused significant financial strain on her family and that the assailant continued harassing them during the proceedings. She lived for decades with the stigma of a criminal record while he avoided public scrutiny.
'For 61 years, the state made me live as a criminal,' Choi said outside the court on Wednesday. 'If I have any hope or dream left, it is that future generations will live in a world free of sexual violence.'
After South Korea's MeToo movement gained ground, Choi was inspired to demand a retrial in 2020.
Her initial petition in 2020 was rejected, with the Busan court citing lack of "clear evidence" and arguing that social and cultural shifts alone did not justify overturning the ruling.
She appealed to the Supreme Court, which, in December 2023, ordered the case to be reopened.
In February this year, the Busan High Court upheld Choi's appeal, paving the way for a retrial.
In court, Busan's chief prosecutor Jeong Myeong Won said: 'We have caused Choi Mal Ja, a victim of a sex crime who should have been protected as one, indescribable pain and agony.'
Choi's lawyer argued the 1964 order was a miscarriage of justice even by the standards of that time.
'This is not about evolving social values. This was a wrongful judgment from the start,' the counsel said.
The final ruling is scheduled for 10 September.
Legal observers expect the court to acquit Choi.
She embraced campaigners and supporters from civic groups who had rallied behind her.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
43 minutes ago
- Times
Thomas Partey to appear in court on rape charges as he finalises Spain move
Thomas Partey is due to appear before magistrates in London on Tuesday on rape and sexual assault charges at the same time that the former Arsenal midfielder finalises a transfer to the Spanish club Villarreal. The 32-year-old is set to appear in person for the first time before Westminster Magistrates' Court. He was charged last month with five counts of rape and one of sexual assault, a few days after he left Arsenal once his contract had expired. He denies the charges. Any charges will have to be dealt with at a Crown Court, so the magistrates will set any bail conditions. Partey's lawyer is expected to ask for the conditions to be set so that he can continue with his football career in Spain. The Ghana international is understood to have agreed a two-year contract after completing a medical with Villarreal, who finished fifth in La Liga last season. The Spanish club are due to play Arsenal in a friendly at the Emirates Stadium on Wednesday. Partey was charged with two counts of rape against one complainant, three counts of rape against a second complainant and one count of sexual assault against a third complainant. The allegations relate to three women who reported incidents which took place between 2021 and 2022. Partey was first arrested on suspicion of rape in July 2022, but continued to play for Arsenal while he remained under investigation. The Arsenal manager, Mikel Arteta, who had previously said he was keen for Partey to stay at the club and sign a new contract, said last month he was '100 per cent sure' the club had followed the correct protocols over allowing him to continue to play. Lisa Nandy, the culture secretary, said last month she was concerned that clubs do not have a 'standard approach' when 'very, very highly paid' players face claims of sexual assault, and has set up a working group to look at the issue.
The Sun
2 hours ago
- The Sun
I hunted down my dad's ISIS killers & stared evil jihadi brides in the eye – one smirking monster still haunts my dreams
WHEN a grizzly video of her father being brutally beheaded by IS terrorists was broadcast to the world, Bethany Haines made it her life's mission to get answers. Brave Bethany, whose aid worker dad David was publicly murdered in 2013, dedicated her life to confronting the monsters who played a part in his torture, captivity and death. 14 In an exclusive interview she reveals how she has travelled the world to confront ISIS's most evil men and women. Bethany tells how she had a two-and-a-half-hour showdown with one of her dad's evil torturers, gave the middle finger to one of IS's most dangerous men in Paris after he glared at her throughout a six-week trial and even travelled to Syria to meet IS brides who acted as recruiters for the terror group. She became obsessed with getting answers about her dad's final months and gained a unique insight into each evil members' psyche. Speaking to The Sun for our Meeting a Monster series, mum-of-one Bethany, 27, said: 'I have met some of the most evil people imaginable. I've been to France, Syria and the US on numerous occasions to understand why they did what they did to my dad. 'Every meeting takes a piece of me away but I can't stop trying to find out answers as to why they did that to my father. 'After every meeting I have had to rebuild, and it takes me months. 'But I know that if my dad was here he would be doing the same, going to every court case, taking up every opportunity to meet anyone connected to the murder and showing them but they're not going to get away with that evil.' Today Bethany recalls the chilling meetings with two of her father's IS captors. Bethany reveals how Brit terrorist Alexander Kotey tried to goad her as she pressed him for answers in a terrifying one-on-one meeting while fellow IS member El Shafee Elsheikh snarled at her as she called out his abhorrent treatment of her father. But she says one terror attack mastermind "was the worst kind of monster that you can imagine hiding under your bed,' and left her haunted by "the deadest eyes I've ever seen". Hamas vows no peace unless key demand is met as thugs share sick clip of hostage David, 44, from Perth, was abducted while working at a refugee camp in Syria in 2013. He was held hostage by West London-raised quartet Elsheikh, Kotey, Mohammed Emwazi and Aine Davis – nicknamed The Beatles. In 2014, a video of gaunt and pale David, wearing an orange jumpsuit and kneeling next to knife-wielding British-born Emwazi - dubbed Jihadi John - horrified the world. It ended with his beheading - one of 27 the group are believed to have carried out. Emwazi died in a drone strike in Syria in 2015 while Davis, 38, was captured in Turkey in 2017 and sentenced to seven and a half years for being a member of a terrorist organisation. In 2022, Elsheikh was found guilty of hostage taking and conspiring to murder after a two-week trial in the US, while Kotey pleaded guilty to terror charges and was sentenced to life in prison. One of the conditions of Kotey's sentence was that he had to meet the loved ones of those he tormented. 'You can't inherit an apology' 14 14 14 Bethany, who is from Perthshire, flew back to the US for the showdown with Kotey, who was being held at a super-max jail and was transported to a high-security Virginia justice building for the meeting. Bethany said: 'I was very nervous. I was about to sit opposite and look into the eyes of the man who had done so much harm to my dad. I needed answers. I needed an apology but what I got was a game from Kotey. "When I got in the room, he was so relaxed, like nothing had happened. It was like chatting with someone in a café not someone who had tormented your dad. He doodled and drew spirals with a pen as I talked to him. 'He acted like it was a game. He told me things I didn't know. He said my dad was abducted after he spotted him outside a kebab house. "He said they took dad to hospital dressed as an IS fighter as he had become very ill and he blamed the other terrorists for driving the violence and torture. I took it all with a pinch of salt. 'He told me that before his beheading my dad accepted his fate and smiled. He wanted a reaction from me. He said my dad said to Mohammed Emwazi, the terrorist who beheaded him, 'make it quick'. "I could see that he was trying to make me uncomfortable and get a rise out of me. I asked him if he felt any remorse. He just came back and said, 'you can't inherit an apology'. 'I asked Kotey four times if he was sorry for abducting and torturing my dad and he just skirted around the answer. It was like getting blood out of a stone. He eventually said, 'ok, I'm sorry for kidnapping and hurting your dad'. 'That was all I needed. I told him to 'rot in hell', slammed my notes and folders down in front of him and walked out the room. I didn't want to give him another second. I wanted those words to be the last he heard from me.' 'Look of a little boy' That same year, she flew over to the US to see fellow 'Beatle' – El Shafee Elsheikh - jailed for torturing and holding hostages, including her father, captive. She sat through every day of his trial. She said: 'I made a point of looking at him when speaking to him across the courtroom in my victim impact statement. He had the look of a little boy - someone who had done something naughty rather than being involved in the most evil of beheadings. "When I read my statement, he looked broken to start with, but I told him that there is nothing in the Quran that justifies the violence meted out to my father. I even quoted a passage back to him. I vividly remember that he just looked at me and snarled.' But in February this year, she met the most evil of her father's foes. 'Dark, dead eyes' Bethany had been tormented by the knowledge that other unknown men who had horrifically tortured and enslaved her dad had never been brought to justice. One of them was Mehdi Nemmouche, who had already been convicted of the Brussels Jewish Museum terror attack which killed four in 2014. For six weeks, she sat through every day of his Paris trial in which he was eventually found guilty of kidnapping, acts of torture, and barbarism of seven hostages – including her father - in Syria. 14 She said: 'He was by far the most evil man I've ever met. His dark, dead eyes glared at me across the courtroom. He wanted to intimidate me. "It was the first time I felt fear. He used the courtroom as a stage. You could tell that if he had a chance he would kill everyone in that courtroom. 'He gave off an awful vibe, let any remorse, and smirked and rolled his eyes after every comment that I made to him. 'I sat through every second of his six-week trial. I read a statement to him and was very forceful. He looked into my eyes with his dark pools of deadness and kept smirking. He kept rolling his eyes and glaring over me. He was by far the most evil man I've ever met. His dark, dead eyes glared at me across the courtroom. He wanted to intimidate me Bethany Haines "It was so intense that I constantly wanted to leave the room but didn't want to give him the satisfaction. When he was sentenced to life, I hugged the person next to me, looked him in the eye and laughed. As he was taken down, I gave him the middle finger. 'I'd met lots of evil people that did terrible things to my dad but he haunted my dreams for months after seeing him. I would dream about being at Disneyland with my son and he would just be there. "I would wake up in cold sweats. Being in his presence, took months to get over. I hated him.' Nemmouche has since appealed his conviction – a decision Bethany says is 'insulting'. Terror group's brides And it wasn't just the men of ISIS that Bethany has met - she also travelled to Syria in the wake of the fall of IS in 2019. She went to a camp where she met some of the terror group's brides – some of whom had come from the UK. 14 She said: 'It was a real eye-opener. I met a number of IS brides. One was from Tunisia, one was from Belgium and the other British. One felt like she'd been groomed but I later found out that she'd also been a recruiter to try to get other women over there. "She seemed completely indoctrinated, dead behind the eyes. IS had fallen but she was still defending them. It got me so angry. In some ways I felt a tiny bit of sympathy for some but others I really didn't. "Some stood by IS despite them being eradicated in that area at the time and they couldn't really understand the pain and evil they were bringing to the world.' Bethany added: 'I have really seen close up every facet of the evil that IS has within its groups. It has been truly harrowing.'
Sky News
2 hours ago
- Sky News
Chris Brain: Leader of 'cult-like' Nine O'Clock Service denies brainwashing members to satisfy sexual desires
A former priest who led a rave-inspired church group has told a court he had massages from women in his congregation which would "very rarely" lead to sexual contact. Prosecutors say Chris Brain, 68, abused his position as the head of the "cult-like" Nine O'Clock Service (NOS) - named because services were held at 9pm on Sundays - in the 1980s and 1990s to sexually assault a "staggering number of women". Inner London Crown Court has heard the services in Sheffield, which were aimed at 18 to 30-year-olds and shaped by club culture, featuring multimedia, scantily dressed women and a live band, attracted up to 600 people at their peak. Jurors have been told Brain's Church of England ordination was "fast tracked" in 1991, and he wore the same cassock worn by actor Robert De Niro in the movie "The Mission" at the ceremony. Prosecutors say a "homebase" team of "attractive women", wearing lingerie or other revealing clothing, known as "the Lycra Lovelies" or "the Lycra Nuns", was set up to look after Brain, his wife and his daughter at their home. Brain from Wilmslow, in Cheshire, is standing trial accused of committing sexual offences against 13 women. He denies one count of rape and 36 counts of indecent assault between 1981 and 1995. Giving evidence for the first time on Monday, he said he borrowed Robert De Niro's cassock from the film studio because NOS "loathed" the traditional church clothing and denied wearing it because he was "an egomaniac" who wanted to "demonstrate power and control". He said the clothes worn by his homebase team were "completely normal" for that era, comparing outfits to those worn by Soul II Soul, although Judge Freya Newbery pointed out the British pop group didn't dress like that to do a "cleaning job". Brain admitted receiving back massages from some NOS members, which he said started as a way to relieve tension headaches, and asked why he did that when he had a wife and child, he replied: "Why not?" When asked by his barrister, Iain Simkin KC, if the massages ever led to sexual activity, he said: "Very rarely, with very close friends it might edge towards that but both parties knew it shouldn't go there so one of us would pull back and cool down." Brain added: "With some of my closest friends it would be kissing sometimes, occasionally massaging, stroking. Anything more than that we would back off." He told the jury any touching was done with "100%" consent and he would've "instantly stopped" if anyone had indicated they were uncomfortable. Brain admitted his leadership style was at times "overly direct" but denied dressing members down in public, humiliating them, or making them feel small as a method of control. His barrister Iain Simkin KC asked: "Did you exert undue pressure on any member of NOS?" "No," Brain replied. Mr Simkin continued? "Did you bring people close and ostracise them as a method of control? "Did you brainwash them? "Did you turn them into robots in order to allow you to manipulate them for your own sexual desires?" Brain answered "no" to all of the questions. The court has heard some members contributed large sums of money or gave up their inheritances or homes to NOS. But Brain denied "fleecing people" for his own "extravagant lifestyle", saying he did not dress in "designer gear" and wasn't motivated by money. He told the jury members worked ordinary jobs and were free to leave if they wanted. The court has heard Brain resigned from holy orders after allegations first emerged in the mid-1990s.
