Andy Mukherjee: Digital payments competition may help India reduce bank frauds
Bank frauds in India have tripled in value. But that's only because some of the cases reported previously were re-investigated and appeared in the new data. More worrying than the surge in the amount, however, is the rise in the number of payment scams over the past couple of years. The solution lies in rewarding better security.
Most of the stealing from banks occurs the traditional way: via loans obtained with the help of forged documents or bribes. Customers, though, are increasingly at risk of being cheated when they make payments. According to the central bank's latest annual report, more than half of frauds took place in digital or card-based transactions, even though they accounted for only 1.4% of the $4 billion in scams.
Also Read: Banking on trust, losing billions: India's bank fraud epidemic needs urgent answers
And these are just the situations where the sums involved were ₹1 lakh ($1,160) or more. Thanks to a wildly popular smartphone-based payments network, much smaller values are being exchanged online for person-to-person and person-to-merchant transactions. The so-called Unified Payments Interface (UPI) is instantaneous, available 24/7 and mostly imposes no cost on users.
It's logging more than a million cases of hustle and con annually, according to separate government data. And this is just what's getting reported. Unless they are extremely careful, the more affluent depositors don't even come to know that they're being slowly bled.
The growth of UPI, which handles more than $3 trillion a year, puts enormous pressure on the system. It was bound to attract criminals. Payment intermediaries have warned customers of the various ways— from simple phishing attacks to sophisticated cloning of SIM cards—in which they may fall prey to swindlers.
Yet, the Indian banking system can't shrug off its responsibility with a 'buyer beware.' It needs stronger guard-rails. Anyone can set up a virtual ID to ask customers for money online. That freedom is welcome. But not when it turns out that the bank account linked to 'amazon@pockets' belongs to Ckjxh Fiddbh, which doesn't appear to be a real name.
Payment frauds happen everywhere. Brazil's PIX, which ranks alongside India's UPI as among the fastest-growing account-to-account transfer systems worldwide, is notorious for its 'PIX gangs.'
Also Read: Vivek Kaul: Fast thinking is the great enabler of digital fraud
What makes India's case problematic is that scamsters have learned to coexist alongside a vast digital identity database, a biometrics-based unique number and card through which 1.4 billion people establish who they are. It hasn't stopped identity theft. India's banks are constantly bombarding customers with 'know-your-customer' checks, asking for the same documents again and again.
Yet, 'mules' continue to thrive. Accounts of unsuspecting customers are used by, among others, online bookmakers located overseas to provide illegal access to casinos and cricket betting via cryptocurrencies.
The Reserve Bank of India's innovation hub has come up with an artificial-intelligence tool called MuleHunter.ai. It's now building a prototype for an intelligence platform covering all digital payments. However, it isn't enough to merely identify suspicious transactions. As analysts have pointed out, the local money-laundering laws do not allow banks to take prompt preventive action, or to restore funds to their rightful owners.
Also Read: UPI fuels rural women's digital leap—but few own their phones
Critical sectors of the economy can't wait for legal changes. The stock market regulator has decided to add a layer of security to investment funds changing hands online. From October, a @valid suffix on virtual payment handles will be mandatory for brokers, investment advisers, research analysts, merchant bankers and mutual funds to collect payments from investors.
These are all stopgaps. Ultimately, New Delhi must put the payment industry on a sustainable footing. Five years ago, it decided that UPI transfers to merchants should be free for users to encourage digitization. The goal has been realized. Although the government denied just last week that it has any such plans, it's time to allow banks and apps like Google Pay and PhonePe to recoup their costs.
National Payments Corporation of India, the special monopoly that runs the network, should now face competition. Let private operators charge a basic transaction fee to offer institutional-grade security. The government can keep its incentives to promote low-value cashless payments at the bottom of the pyramid. As for other customers, a high-volume, competitive market would keep a lid on fees, while offering them greater peace of mind.
Banks will also heave a sigh of relief. Payment is a utility they must offer depositors so they have funds to lend. Frauds are a costly distraction. ©Bloomberg
The author is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering industrial companies and financial services in Asia.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
13 minutes ago
- India Today
US family shares video of being secretly filmed at Gurugram hotel
A family of American tourists accused a man of secretly filming them while they were sunbathing at a hotel in Gurugram. The incident, which the family documented in a video, has left social media users calling for swift Rory and Sage, who have been travelling the world with their parents, shared the video from their recent stay in India on Instagram. The clip showed the man standing at a hotel window, allegedly recording them as they lay sunbathing within the hotel the sisters looked visibly distressed in the footage, their mother could be heard addressing the situation on camera. 'Someone is filming us, and they are not being discreet,' one of the sisters says, before alerting her husband that they were being watched from a hotel room the caption of their post, the family didn't hold back from expressing their discomfort. 'If you're a female planning on coming to India, I wouldn't come without a bodyguard of a man. Whether you are sunbathing or fully clothed, we are finding this behaviour very common in India,' the caption the video here: advertisement View this post on Instagram A post shared by Rory And Sage World Class (@roryandsageofficial)Since being shared online, the video has clocked over 9 million views. The clip has raised serious concerns about women's safety and post also saw an outpouring of support and anger from users across the platform, with many urging the family to escalate the matter.'Please report it to the hotel, not just the staff, but senior management. If nothing happens, take it to the police. Foreigners pushing for action will also help locals be taken seriously,' a user user called the man's behaviour what many were thinking: 'Oh my goodness, how creepy!'A few users pointed out the legal route. 'You can submit this to the police. He'll be arrested. This is illegal,' one of the users said, while another added, 'I wish AI was strong enough to find that Indian uncle and send this video to his wife.'While the identity of the man remains unknown, the incident has once again triggered a much-needed conversation around women's safety, a conversation that refuses to be brushed aside.
India Today
13 minutes ago
- India Today
Narayana Murthy says he is using ChatGPT for his lectures, preparation time reduced from 30 hrs to 5 hrs
Infosys founder NR Narayana Murthy has shared that he now uses ChatGPT to prepare for his lectures and speeches. He says the AI tool has helped him save a lot of time, cutting down his preparation hours from around 30 to just five. Speaking to Moneycontrol, Murthy explained that earlier, he would spend nearly 25 to 30 hours preparing each lecture, as he focused a lot on building the right theme, structure, and message. But after his son, Rohan Murty, suggested he try using ChatGPT, things changed. "In a matter of five hours, I could improve the draft. In other words, I improved my own productivity by as much as five times," he believes this is a clear example of how AI can make people more productive rather than replace them. He has always maintained that AI should be seen as a support tool to make work easier and more efficient. He also pointed out that AI is only useful if people ask the right questions. Recalling his son's advice, Murthy said that it's important to define your needs clearly while using AI. Only then can the tool give helpful further said Indian IT companies can take advantage of this technology to speed up tasks like coding, reduce mistakes, and solve more complex problems. With AI handling routine parts of the work, Murthy believes engineers and programmers can focus on smarter and more challenging tasks. To explain his thoughts better, Murthy compared the current AI wave to how computers were first introduced into the banking sector in the UK during the 1970s. He said people were worried that computers would take away jobs, but the reality turned out to be different. As banks started using computers to complete tasks faster, workers got more free time, and the number of jobs actually increased over the feels something similar will happen with AI, where, instead of reducing opportunities, it could help people become better at defining tasks and solving bigger shared his experience while launching a scholarship at IIM Ahmedabad, through his family's investment firm, Catamaran. The scholarship will support the top MBA student each year for 20 years. It will be funded through a mix of equity and fixed income investments and is designed to adjust with inflation.
Time of India
20 minutes ago
- Time of India
India opens bids for 5th gen stealth fighter jet, sets 2029 flight target
India has formally opened the race to build its first indigenous fifth-generation stealth fighter, the AMCA. In a key move to modernise the Air Force and cut foreign reliance, the government has invited Indian defence firms to bid for development. The project will involve a competitive industry partnership model and aims to deliver six squadrons by 2035. With rival China racing ahead in aerial capabilities, the AMCA is central to India's long-term security and defence self-reliance. Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Open competition: Private players now have a shot Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Strict timelines, major investment Who might build it? Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads AMCA: Built in phases, designed for the future What will the AMCA bring to the table? India has launched an open call for domestic defence companies to help build its first home-grown fifth-generation stealth fighter jet, the Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA). The Aeronautical Development Agency (ADA) formally uploaded an expression of interest (EOI) on Wednesday to identify firms capable of co-developing and manufacturing the aircraft's prototypes, and assisting in its flight testing and move comes at a time when the Indian Air Force (IAF) is facing a serious shortfall in operational fighter squadrons. The count has dropped to 31, far below the sanctioned strength of 42. Meanwhile, China has already deployed its fifth-generation J-20 fighters and is reportedly advancing two sixth-generation prototypes, the J-36 and Ministry of Defence has approved a competitive execution model for the AMCA programme, ensuring both public and private companies are eligible. This breaks from the long-standing assumption that Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL), India's state-run aircraft builder, would lead the Minister Rajnath Singh cleared the industry partnership framework on 27 May. 'Reputed Indian companies experienced in aerospace and defence sector with capability to absorb the design of AMCA and have adequate experience in the field of development & engineering, manufacturing, equipping, integration, testing, quality management, customer support etc will be shortlisted,' the EOI document ADA, under the Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO), will oversee the execution. The EOI also confirms that applicants may apply as a single company, joint venture or consortium, provided they are compliant with Indian laws and AMCA contract is set for a maximum duration of eight years from the effective date. The shortlisted entity will need to set up a dedicated manufacturing facility to support eventual mass production.A pre-EOI briefing will be held in the first week of July 2025. The deadline for submissions is 16 August 2025. As per the current roadmap, the first prototype is expected to take flight by 2029. Full development should wrap up by 2034, with production likely to begin a year Cabinet Committee on Security (CCS), headed by the Prime Minister, approved the AMCA's design and development in 2023 at a cost of around ₹15,000 crore. This includes building five twin-engine likely to show interest include Tata Advanced Systems, Larsen & Toubro, Adani Defence and Aerospace, and the Mahindra Group. HAL, though no longer the guaranteed frontrunner, remains in strong AMCA execution model is expected to unlock new opportunities in India's aerospace ecosystem, helping build long-term industrial capacity and reducing import dependency. For the IAF, it offers a leap forward in capability—especially as the regional security environment grows more has already placed its J-20 stealth fighters into active service. It is also producing the J-35, which Pakistan is reportedly considering buying. This gives the India-Pakistan-China theatre a new dimension, with stealth aircraft rapidly becoming the new baseline for air India has been offered foreign fifth-gen fighters—including the US F-35 and Russia's Su-57—New Delhi has chosen to stick with its indigenous plan. 'America is paving the way to provide India the F-35 stealth fighters,' said US President Donald Trump in February. Russia earlier this year proposed joint production of the Su-57 in however, has not taken up either AMCA is being developed in two distinct phases. The initial Mk-1 version will be powered by the American F-414 engine and will form the first two IAF squadrons. The Mk-2 variant will follow, featuring a more powerful engine developed in India with foreign collaboration. This second version will form the remaining four 2035, India plans to deploy six squadrons—roughly 120 aircraft. These jets are expected to become the backbone of the IAF's future force AMCA is envisioned as a 25-tonne swing-role fighter, capable of both offensive and defensive missions. Its stealth features are aimed at reducing radar detection. Internal weapon bays, super-cruise capability, 360-degree situational awareness, advanced avionics, and next-gen mission computers are all part of the ability to fly at supersonic speeds without afterburners will give it both range and endurance. And with all weapons housed internally, the aircraft will have a minimal radar footprint, crucial in modern tender marks one of the biggest openings for Indian aerospace firms to shape the future of national defence. With a defined timeline, significant financial commitment, and a clear roadmap to production, the AMCA programme offers high reward—but demands high AMCA is not just about a jet. It is about building long-term self-reliance, enhancing industrial capacity, and sending a message that India intends to lead in next-generation defence technologies.(With inputs from Reuters)
