logo
Former PC minister hopes party learns from conflict-of-interest ruling on 'egregious actions'

Former PC minister hopes party learns from conflict-of-interest ruling on 'egregious actions'

CBC22-05-2025
An ex-Manitoba cabinet minister welcomes an ethics commissioner's findings that former Tory colleagues, including the one-time party leader and premier, violated the province's conflict-of-interest law and should be fined.
"I thank the ethics commissioner for his thorough investigation and report. I hope lessons are heeded from his wise counsel, and the egregious actions outlined in his report are never repeated," Rochelle Squires told CBC News in an email.
"Politicians are rightfully held to higher moral and ethical standards; everyone loses when our elected officials don't adhere to these principles."
Squires, who held several cabinet portfolios during her time as Progressive Conservative MLA for the south Winnipeg riding of Riel from 2016 to 2023 — including a brief tenure as deputy premier — lost her seat in the October 2023 election when the NDP regained power in Manitoba and formed a majority government.
She previously decried her former party's actions as "unconventional and unconscionable."
In a 100-page report released Wednesday, ethics commissioner Jeffrey Schnoor said then-premier Heather Stefanson, deputy premier Cliff Cullen and economic development minister Jeff Wharton acted improperly by pushing for the approval of a mining project after the Tories lost the 2023 election.
Sio Silica had, when Stefanson's party was still in power, proposed to drill as many as 7,200 wells in southeastern Manitoba over 24 years in an effort to extract up to 33 million tonnes of ultra-pure silica sand.
Days after the PCs' loss and before the new NDP government was sworn in, the three Tories tried to get the Alberta mining company's project approved, Schnoor wrote.
Their actions violated the Conflict of Interest Act and contravened the caretaker convention, a long-standing parliamentary principle that forbids outgoing governments from making major decisions, Schnoor wrote.
The conflict first came to light after Squires and Kevin Klein, another PC cabinet minister who lost his seat in October 2023, said they were called by Wharton after the election and pressured to award the project an environmental licence. They both said they refused because of the caretaker convention.
The NDP government rejected the project in February 2024, citing the potential impact on drinking water, among other concerns.
Cullen and Stefanson have both since left politics, but Wharton is still a PC MLA for Red River North. He denied trying to push the project through in December 2023, saying he was simply gathering information about the mining project to pass on to the incoming government.
On Wednesday, in a written statement, Wharton apologized for any conduct that "was found to fall short of my parliamentary obligations or personal standard of ethics."
In her email to CBC News, Squires said she has not spoken to Wharton but is pleased that he apologized.
"Change begins with accountability," she wrote.
Current PC Leader Obby Khan, who was a cabinet minister under Stefanson, accepted Schnoor's findings but said there needs to be more clarity on what can be done under the caretaker convention.
Brandon University political science Prof. Kelly Saunders said the rules are clear and Stefanson, Cullen and Wharton knew them.
"These are seasoned politicians. The caretaker convention is straightforward," she said. "I explain it to my second-year students and they understand it. It's not that complicated. It's a straightforward issue that makes sense."
It's also not something new for which a minister could be excused for not being aware.
"The caretaker convention is a really well-established, well-respected, long-standing principle of the Westminster parliamentary system and has been with us ever since Canada officially became a country," Saunders said.
PC leader 'missing an opportunity'
Stefanson, in a written statement from her lawyer on Wednesday, said she reached out to the incoming NDP government and fully considered their views before deciding what to do, and ultimately, no licence was issued to Sio Silica.
Schnoor thought differently, Saunders said.
"If we go by his findings or his conclusions, certainly the former premier did way more than simply reach out to the NDP," she said.
"She along with two former high-profile MLAs and cabinet ministers … not only were talking to the NDP, but they were also pressuring, it appears, some of their own caucus members."
Saunders is not only disappointed with Stefanson's response; she feels Khan's also fell short.
"There was a moment there where he could have really owned the issue as the new leader. He has to take responsibility for actions of his party, even though he was not the premier at the time," she said.
"People are human and make mistakes, but it's the lack of accountability and taking responsibility from politicians, I think, that really frustrates voters.
"With the PC party really trying to reboot themselves with the new leader … they're really missing an opportunity here to show Manitobans that they are new and different and moving forward. This is just going to continue to dog them, I think."
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Canada Post heads back into bargaining with union after delay
Canada Post heads back into bargaining with union after delay

CTV News

time2 hours ago

  • CTV News

Canada Post heads back into bargaining with union after delay

A Canada Post truck is seen at a distribution centre in Montreal on Friday, Dec.13, 2024. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Christinne Muschi OTTAWA — Canada Post and the union representing postal workers are set to return to the bargaining table today. Plans to rekindle talks late last week were delayed due to a lack of federal government mediators. The Canadian Union of Postal Workers claimed labour unrest at Air Canada was pulling attention from the postal service's dispute, which has stretched on for more than a year and a half. A few weeks ago, unionized postal workers rejected the Crown corporation's latest offer that would have included wage hikes of around 13 per cent over four years and added part-timers to the workforce. Canada Post is seeking a formal response from the union on those proposals and has warned the postal service is bleeding millions of dollars in business daily tied to uncertainty around collective bargaining. The union says it has prepared offers that meet members' demands and is upholding a ban on overtime work in the meantime. This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 20, 2025.

After Air Canada strike, Section 107 of labour code is ‘dead,' says union leader
After Air Canada strike, Section 107 of labour code is ‘dead,' says union leader

CTV News

time2 hours ago

  • CTV News

After Air Canada strike, Section 107 of labour code is ‘dead,' says union leader

What could CUPE's defiance of Section 107 mean for future strikes in Canada? Rachel Aiello has the latest. OTTAWA — A rare show of defiance by Air Canada flight attendants in the face of a back-to-work order from the government has proven the ineffectiveness of the section of Canada's labour code that allows a minister to order the end to a strike or lockout, the president of the Canadian Labour Congress said. On Aug. 16, just hours after flight attendants hit the picket line after failing to reach a new contract deal with the airline, Jobs Minister Patty Hajdu invoked section 107 of the Canada Labour Code to order binding arbitration and get the flight attendants back on the job. The section grants the minister the power to act to 'maintain or secure industrial peace.' Flight attendants ignored the order and remained on strike until a deal was finally reached early Tuesday, a move Canadian Labour Congress President Bea Bruske lauded as effective. 'It sets a precedent (that) you can defy, and you will find a solution at the bargaining table,' Bruske said Tuesday in an interview with The Canadian Press. 'It sets a precedent for the reality that (section) 107 is no longer effective, it is effectively dead.' 'The best way to deal with it is to remove it entirely because unions, workers, the labour movement has been emboldened by this and we're not going to turn around.' Section 107 has been in the Canada Labour Code for more than 40 years but using it has become more common particularly in the last year. The Canadian Labour Congress says the Liberals have resorted to section 107 eight times since June 2024, including to prevent a strike by WestJet mechanics, and to end strikes or lockouts at the country's two main railways, ports in Montreal and Vancouver and temporarily a strike and lockout at Canada Post. Before then, section 107 was only used a handful of times, says the Canadian Labour Congress, including four times between 1995 and 2002. In 2011, the CLC says then-labour minister Lisa Raitt used section 107 after flight attendants rejected two tentative agreements, though the parties ultimately voluntarily agreed to send their dispute to binding arbitration. The CLC says it was used one other time between 2011 and 2024. Initially the government didn't seem willing to turn to it quickly to end the Air Canada work stoppage. On Aug. 17, a few hours before the deadline set by the union representing flight attendants to reach a new contract deal, Hajdu urged the airline and the union to go back to the negotiating table, and suggested she wasn't ready to intervene in the dispute. Hajdu told The Canadian Press that day that it was 'critical' the two sides return to the table to forge a deal on their own. The strike officially began just before 1 a.m. ET on Saturday and in turn, Air Canada locked out its agents about 30 minutes later due to the strike action. Hajdu announced just after 12 p.m. on Saturday that she was invoking the labour code section and directing the Canada Industrial Relations Board to order Air Canada and the Canadian Union of Public Employees to resume operations and resolve the dispute through binding arbitration. The minister said she made the call after meeting with both sides Friday night, finding that talks had broken down and the parties remained too far apart to resolve the conflict quickly enough. But CUPE defied the order, flight attendants stayed on the picket line and the union launched a legal challenge of the government's move. On Monday, the Canada Industrial Relations Board board declared the strike unlawful and ordered the union's leadership to tell its striking workers to go back to work. The federal government also announced that it was launching a probe into allegations of unpaid work in the airline sector. The union and Air Canada met late Monday night and very early Tuesday morning announced a tentative agreement had been reached, ending the work stoppage. Bruske acknowledged that Air Canada workers' defiance of back-to-work orders could set a precedent for future strikes. She said that, while the government was under 'a lot of pressure' from business groups and customers to avoid a disruption, their interference 'caused more of a problem than it solved.' 'It really gave the employer a way to avoid having to get serious at the bargaining table,' Bruske said. When the union decided to defy the return-to-work order, Bruske said it sent a 'strong message' that the only way to resolve the issue is at the bargaining table, 'which is where it needed to be found all along.' Bruske noted that the government used the labour code to force the Canadian Union of Postal Workers to vote on an offer from Canada Post, an offer the workers rejected. Canada Post and the union are returning to the bargaining table Wednesday. 'The labour movement is going to be with them no matter what they choose to do,' Bruske said. She said CLC and its affiliate unions, including the Canadian Union of Postal Workers, met on Sunday and labour leaders were unanimous that they supported CUPE in defying back-to-work orders and that they will 'do whatever' to support them. CUPE national president Mark Hancock said that, given the availability of Section 107, it seemed like the company felt that they didn't need to negotiate and were instead preparing to go to binding arbitration. Once it was 'pushed to the side,' Hancock said the company 'got serious' at the bargaining table and a tentative deal was reached. 'Hopefully this has sent a message to government and to everybody that the way to get a deal and a collective agreement is at the bargaining table,' Hancock said. 'Section 107 is just an impediment that makes it much more difficult to get an agreement on the table.' While he doesn't agree with forcing workers back in a dispute, Hancock said other options, like back-to-work legislation debated in Parliament, are more democratic. 'We're gonna continue talking about 107 and I'm hoping the government never, ever, ever uses it again because it's not a helpful tool,' he said. Hancock encouraged future unions that have to face Section 107 to 'respond appropriately.' He also said it's still unclear if there will be any consequences for the union or its members as a result of the strike but that CUPE will protect and defend workers and their jobs. 'Hopefully Air Canada has learned a lesson that we're not going to back down when it comes to bargaining and that we'll be there to support our members every step of the way,' Hancock said. 'I'm sure Air Canada wants to put this behind them and move forward and if they start disciplining or attempting to discipline people, that's not gonna be helpful for them or anybody.' Daniel Safayeni, president and CEO of FETCO, an employers' association comprised of federally regulated firms within the transportation and communications sectors, said CIRB and the Supreme Court have affirmed the constitutionality of Section 107, recognizing that the right to strike can be limited in exceptional circumstances when justified by threats to national economic stability. 'There is a time and place for the usage of this,' Safayeni said, adding that something like a special mediation process could be used before the invocation of Section 107. 'At the end of the day, the government is going to need a tool to keep particularly critical industries, critical supply chains moving, if a deal can't be reached.' He said unions are entitled to challenge decisions in court but can't just ignore orders because that 'sets a dangerous precedent.' 'That is normalizing behaviour that frankly, I think when we look south of the border, we see it and we are shocked and disappointed to see it, and I don't think we want to replicate those same norms here,' Safayeni said. With files from Kyle Duggan and Craig Lord This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 20, 2025. Catherine Morrison, The Canadian Press

Windsor MP says public deserves answers on Gordie Howe bridge opening date
Windsor MP says public deserves answers on Gordie Howe bridge opening date

CBC

time2 hours ago

  • CBC

Windsor MP says public deserves answers on Gordie Howe bridge opening date

'Straight answer' needed on opening date of Gordie Howe bridge, says Windsor West MP 12 hours ago Duration 1:44 The MP who represents the area that includes the Gordie Howe International Bridge in Windsor, Ont., says the public deserves "a straight answer" on exactly when the new border crossing will be open to traffic. "This construction project is more than just a simple bridge, it's a vital economic lifeline for Windsor and Canada – given the volume of trade that flows through our border," Windsor West Conservative MP Harb Gill said in a statement to CBC News. "Our community deserves clear, consistent communication, not conflicting timelines." Despite promises the bridge will open this fall, a firm date has yet to be announced. The opening of the bridge will cap off a highly anticipated megaproject that has been in the works long before construction began in 2018. The bridge will provide a third vehicle crossing between Windsor, Ont., and Detroit, supporting a crucial corridor for Canada-U.S. trade. The cost for the six-lane, 2.5-kilometre crossing was estimated at $6.4 billion as of last year, with the Canadian side footing the bill. On Tuesday, the Windsor-Detroit Bridge Authority (WDBA) — the Crown corporation overseeing the project — said it's too early to provide an opening date but "work is progressing well towards our anticipated completion in fall 2025." "We have an estimated two per cent of construction work remaining," Heather Grondin, chief relations officer for the WDBA, said in a statement. Grondin added that the agency prioritizes infrastructure quality and employee safety. WATCH: What's the best view of the Gordie Howe bridge? What's the best view of the Gordie Howe International Bridge? 9 days ago CBC's Mike Evans went around Windsor, Ont., and neighbouring LaSalle snapping pictures of the Gordie Howe bridge to illustrate unique views of the crossing. He talks about his photo journey with CBC host Amy Dodge. Asked to respond to Gill's comment, the bridge authority said it's "committed to keeping everyone informed as we work toward the opening of the Gordie Howe International Bridge." Gill said he is awaiting a response from agencies and partners on the project regarding the opening date. "We believe that the people of Windsor-Essex deserve a straight answer," he said. CBSA confirms it's ready to take over port of entry The bridge authority has yet to address an April report by ratings agency S&P Global that suggested the opening date could be delayed until sometime in 2026. That report claimed there were delays in handing over ports of entry to border services agencies that could throw the timeline off course. However, a spokesperson for the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) told CBC News on Tuesday that handover of the Canadian port of entry facilities began early this year, and staff are beginning to occupy the space. "The CBSA will be ready to provide services at the Canadian port of entry by the opening date," CBSA spokesperson Jacqueline Roby said in an email. On the U.S. side, Customs and Border Protection did not provide comment. What work is happening now? Though the work at the bridge may be less visible following the completion of the bridge deck connecting the U.S. and Canadian sides last year, there's plenty of activity underway. According to the WDBA, the ongoing work includes: On the bridge itself, the installation of electrical, signage, lighting, fire suppression, lights and more. At the Canadian port of entry, interior work such as installing flooring, light fixtures and cabinets is taking place, as well as exterior work like landscaping and paving. Similar work is happening on the U.S. port of entry. On the U.S. side, the "final steps" are underway for the ramps connecting 1-75 to the U.S. port of entry, such as line painting and signage. Work is also ongoing on local road improvements on the U.S. side and five new pedestrian bridges. Building and testing of the technological systems at the crossing. For example, the technology that allows the toll booth to capture and read an RFID tag on a vehicle.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store