An AI-generated band got 1m plays on Spotify. Now music insiders say listeners should be warned
The episode has triggered a debate about authenticity, with music industry insiders saying streaming sites should be legally obliged to tag music created by AI-generated acts so consumers can make informed decisions about what they are listening to.
Initially, the 'band', described as 'a synthetic music project guided by human creative direction', denied they were an AI creation, and released two albums in June called Floating On Echoes and Dust And Silence, which were similar to the country folk of Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young.
Things became more complicated when someone describing himself as an 'adjunct' member told reporters that the Velvet Sundown had used the generative AI platform Suno in the creation of their songs, and that the project was an 'art hoax'.
The band's official social media channels denied this and said the group's identity was being 'hijacked', before releasing a statement confirming that the group was an AI creation and was 'Not quite human. Not quite machine' but living 'somewhere in between'.
Several figures told the Guardian that the present situation, where streaming sites, including Spotify, are under no legal obligation to identify AI-generated music, left consumers unaware of the origins of the songs they're listening to.
Roberto Neri, the chief executive of the Ivors Academy, said: 'AI-generated bands like Velvet Sundown that are reaching big audiences without involving human creators raise serious concerns around transparency, authorship and consent.'
Neri added that if 'used ethically', AI has the potential to enhance songwriting, but said at present his organisation was concerned with what he called 'deeply troubling issues' with the use of AI in music.
Sophie Jones, the chief strategy officer at the music trade body the British Phonographic Industry (BPI), backed calls for clear labelling. 'We believe that AI should be used to serve human creativity, not supplant it,' said Jones.
'That's why we're calling on the UK government to protect copyright and introduce new transparency obligations for AI companies so that music rights can be licensed and enforced, as well as calling for the clear labelling of content solely generated by AI.'
Liz Pelly, the author of Mood Machine: The Rise of Spotify and the Costs of the Perfect Playlist, said independent artists could be exploited by people behind AI bands who might create tracks that are trained using their music.
She referred to the 2023 case of a song that was uploaded to TikTok, Spotify and YouTube, which used AI-generated vocals claiming to be the Weeknd and Drake. Universal Music Group said the song was 'infringing content created with generative AI' and it was removed shortly after it was uploaded.
It is not clear what music the Velvet Sundown's albums were trained on, with critics saying that lack of clarity means independent artists could be losing out on compensation.
Pelly said: 'We need to make sure that it's not just pop stars whose interests are being looked after, all artists should have the ability to know if their work has been exploited in this way.'
For some, the appearance of the Velvet Sundown is the logical next step as music and AI combine, while legislation is fighting to keep up with a rapidly changing musical ecosystem.
Sign up to Sleeve Notes
Get music news, bold reviews and unexpected extras. Every genre, every era, every week
after newsletter promotion
Jones said: 'The rise of AI-generated bands and music entering the market points to the fact that tech companies have been training AI models using creative works – largely without authorisation or payment to creators and rights-holders – in order to directly compete with human artistry.'
Neri added that the UK has a chance to lead the world in ethical AI adoption in music but said there needed to be robust legal frameworks that 'guarantee consent and fair remuneration for creators, and clear labelling for listeners'.
'Without such safeguards, AI risks repeating the same mistakes seen in streaming, where big tech profits while music creators are left behind,' he added.
Aurélien Hérault, the chief innovation officer at the music streaming service Deezer, said the company uses detection software that identifies AI-generated tracks and tags them.
He said: 'For the moment, I think platforms need to be transparent and try to inform users. For a period of time, what I call the 'naturalisation of AI', we need to inform users when it's used or not.'
Hérault did not rule out removing tagging in future if AI-generated music becomes more popular and musicians begin to use it like an 'instrument'.
Deezer recently told the Guardian that up to seven out of 10 streams of AI-generated music on the platform are fraudulent.
At present, Spotify does not label music as AI-generated and has previously been criticised for populating some playlists with music by 'ghost artists' – fake acts that create stock music.
A spokesperson for the company said Spotify does not prioritise AI-generated music. 'All music on Spotify, including AI-generated music, is created, owned and uploaded by licensed third parties,' they said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
9 hours ago
- The Sun
Toni ‘gives away' she's landed HUGE US gig with clue on social media, say fans – after £50k Love Island win
LOVE Island fans are convinced winner Toni Laites has landed huge gig as she drops massive clue on social media. The brunette bombshell has sparked rumours she will appear on a popular online web series over in the US. 5 5 Since Toni left the Love Island villa, eagle-eyed fans have kept a keen eye on her Instagram follow list. They noticed Alexandra Cooper, from the Call Her Daddy, has followed Toni and Toni is following her back. Call Her Daddy is one of Spotify's biggest podcasts and has featured celeb guests such as Megan Fox, Kate Hudson and Hailey Bieber. Co-founders Alex and Sofia Franklyn give listeners advice and have a lot of fun and laughs too. The online series covers relationships, dating, sex, and personal stories courtesy of the hosts and guests. The web show also focuses on women's rights, mental health, and the significance of therapy. Fans are speculating that Toni might be making an appearance on the podcast, especially after Love Island USA stars Huda Mustafa and Amaya Espinal were recently featured. Fans shared their thoughts on the possibility on internet forum Reddit, one user said: ' I feel like a call her daddy episode with Toni sounds so entertaining.' ' I think Toni is a good fit for that podcast tbh!' another added. 'Anywhere I can bet on the odds of this? feeling I can leave with my pockets filled! Totally going to happen. Probs just had to wait for the US finale to air on Hulu to avoid spoilers.' chimed a third. Love Island champs Toni and Cach reveal how they'll spend £50k winnings as they beat Shakira and Harry A fourth penned: 'That would be crazyyyy.' Toni became the first international star to win the UK series of Love Island when she was crowned champion alongside Cach Mercer this week. And now it seems she is also lined up to an even bigger prize in the form of her very own spin-off reality show. The Sun previously revealed that the Las Vegas-based pool waitress looks set to be offered her very own fly-on-the-wall programme after impressing ITV bosses and winning over the hearts of the British public. An insider told The Sun: 'It's super early days as she's only just left the villa but there's talk of Toni being lined up for a spin off based around her life in Vegas as a cabana girl. "Shakira and Yas (and Cach!) would feature and her mum would also make appearances. " Love Island fans have been loving Leslie on the show and on TikTok! "ITV bosses love the energy that Toni brings to the table and her one-liners. She's got a bright future ahead of her on TV. "She'll go into talks about future plans this week.' 5 5
Daily Mail
a day ago
- Daily Mail
The Colonel and the King by Peter Guralnick: He discovered Elvis - but also destroyed him
The Colonel and the King by Peter Guralnick (White Rabbit £35, 624pp) Addiction was the glue that held Elvis Presley and his manager 'Colonel' Tom Parker together during the last few years of the singer's life. Twenty years of lonely fame and wild extravagance had meant that by 1977 Elvis was struggling to make ends meet. To pay for his entourage and the compliant doctors who fed him the drugs on which he was hooked, he just had to keep touring. You might think a sensible, caring manager would have committed his client to a hospital to dry out. But the 'Colonel' had an addiction problem, too. When he wasn't on tour with 'my boy', as he would refer to Elvis, he would go on gambling binges at the roulette wheel in Las Vegas. Hundreds of thousands of dollars slipped through his fingers. Elvis had to keep working to pay for his manager's gambling losses, as well as his own profligacy. During his 21-year career, Elvis earned millions, of which, by 1977, the Colonel was taking 50 per cent for himself. Then there were the Colonel's side-deals. Elvis didn't write songs, but to get him to record one the writer would be asked to give up a percentage of his royalty. Thus, as well as his own royalty as a singer, Elvis's music companies got a third of Heartbreak Hotel and hundreds of other songs, with the Colonel always getting a portion of Elvis's slice. Only later in Elvis's career did songwriters begin to dig their heels in. He wanted to record I Will Always Love You, but writer and singer Dolly Parton wouldn't let him. She knew the value of her song. Then there were those 30-odd movies in which Elvis appeared. Although the Colonel had no role in any of the films' productions, his side-deals gave him an office and a further payment in all of them. He was a shrewd man, all right, but who exactly was 'Colonel' Tom Parker? Well, he wasn't a colonel for a start. That honorary soubriquet had been bestowed on him by governors of two states while he was working as a promoter. He liked it. It made him feel important. Neither was he an American. He was, in fact, Dutch. Born Andreas Cornelis van Kuijk in Holland in 1909, he'd entered America as a stowaway in the 1920s, where he soon adopted the identity Tom Parker from Huntington, West Virginia. A short career in the US army followed, which entailed losing his Dutch nationality, and which, as a result, made him stateless as he never took US citizenship. At the height of Elvis's career, it was often wondered why his manager never visited him when he was serving with the US army in Germany, nor why the singer never toured the UK. Both would have been impossible because Parker never had a passport. For 30 years Parker worked in the touring carnivals in the small Southern towns of the US, before moving into music management with country stars Eddy Arnold and Hank Snow. Then, one day in 1955, he saw an unknown young man of 20 performing in Louisiana and he saw his future. However, it took a while and much crafty schmoozing of the boy's parents. But within a year Elvis was on national television. A year after that he was the most famous young man in the world. When I had breakfast with Parker in Las Vegas in 1968 (he said: 'I won't pick up your tab because I don't want you to be beholden to me') I was puzzled by his slight accent. But, as Guralnick explains in this examination of Parker's relationship with Elvis, the Colonel went to great lengths to hide his past, to the point of never seeing his mother again. What the Colonel did do, however, was to save copies of every contract and every letter he ever wrote, and which were written to him, which for Guralnick, an excellent Elvis historian, was a treasure trove for this book. At a quarter of a million words it's certainly thorough, revealing a man who worked single-mindedly for his client to the point of telling Hollywood producers and record company executives how to do their jobs. To Guralnick this would suggest that the Colonel was a good manager. I would disagree. To me the Colonel comes across as a brilliant promoter, especially in the early days of Elvis's success, but hopeless when it came to guiding an intelligent path through Hollywood. For Parker it was always about million-dollar deals. At no point, in all the letters, do we see evidence of a more thoughtful ambition. Just the opposite. While Parker never interfered with what Elvis sang, he also never read any of the film scripts. When Elvis came out of the army in 1960 he was probably the most popular star in Hollywood. A succession of cheap movies (e.g. Girl Happy, Harem Holiday, and Paradise, Hawaiian Style) in which usually the only things worse than the dialogue and the plots were the songs, led within a few years to Elvis admitting that he was considered a joke in Hollywood. 'I wouldn't be being honest with you if I said I wasn't ashamed of some of the movies I've been in, and some of the songs I had to sing in them,' he told me during an interview in Las Vegas. 'I'd like to say they were good, but I can't. I had to do them. I signed contracts.' But the contracts were about money alone. As Elvis talked to me, the Colonel listened silently. Can you imagine the agents of Paul Newman or Frank Sinatra signing their clients to movies without ever reading the scripts? It's unthinkable. This story doesn't have a happy ending. The man they called the King died, aged 42, in 1977 when his addiction brought on a heart attack in his Graceland bathroom. The Colonel's addiction never left him, though after Elvis's death he was no longer a high-roller. Feeling hurt that he'd been abandoned when a Memphis court took away his management of everything Elvis, he lived for another 20 years in a modest Las Vegas home. But, although he still visited the casinos, $25 bets were his limit.
Scottish Sun
a day ago
- Scottish Sun
Zoe Ball ‘frozen and in tears' after yobs smashed car window and stole bag while she was on The One Show
She instinctively patched up the damage ahead of an emotional drive home SMASH & GRAB Zoe Ball 'frozen and in tears' after yobs smashed car window and stole bag while she was on The One Show Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) ZOE Ball has revealed she had a "massive cry" after a yob smashed her car window and stole her handbag while she was on The One Show. The radio and TV star, 54, was recounting a recent appearance on the prime time BBC show on her Dig It podcast with Jo Whiley. Sign up for the Entertainment newsletter Sign up 2 Zoe Ball was the victim of theft while she was on The One Show Credit: digitpodcast 2 A yob smashed her car window to steal her bag as she appeared on TV Credit: Facebook After fun catching up with pal Vernon Kay, the good vibes from the studio quickly faded when Zoe returned to her shattered window. She explained: "Someone had smashed the front window of my car, that's never happened to me before." Initially left "frozen" by the upsetting find, Zoe used a festival poncho in the car to cover the damaged window. She then blasted the Radio 2 country show at ear-splitting volume as she carefully drove the 64 miles home to Brighton. Zoe was relieved nothing of value was taken, though she admitted: "I got in and I had a massive cry." "It was good, I love a big blub. The ones where you wake up in the morning and your face is a bit swollen and you're like, 'Well, I'm glad I got that out'." She partly blamed herself for the theft, having left her bag on display. She explained: "Do you know what I did? I did a stupid thing, I was so busy running into The One Show with my suits and my bag and everything. "And we were going to do a picture with our Spotify picture, which was amazing, and I left a bag on the front seat. Big no, no in London, idiot. Luckily, nothing in it except my diary." In solidarity, Jo then shared how she had a phone pinched from her hand in a street mugging. EXCL Zoe Ball finds love again with Fatboy Slim lookalike as new couple are spotted holding hands at Glastonbury She said: "Just a boy on a bike just literally snatched it from my hand. "And then you having something like this, it's just so disappointing that people would do that to another person."
