Lisa Nandy trying to bully BBC over its Gaza coverage, says Wolf Hall director
Peter Kosminsky, the writer and director of the BBC drama Wolf Hall, claimed the government was acting like a 'tinpot dictatorship' in heaping political pressure on Davie.
In his letter, seen by the Guardian, Kosminksy cited the 'ignominious history' of political interference in the BBC. He evoked the death of Dr David Kelly, the government weapons expert, who died in 2003 shortly after being revealed as the source for a BBC story stating the government 'probably knew' a claim about Iraq's weapons capabilities was not true.
'Could I respectfully suggest that you stop trying to bully the BBC, the nation's primary public service broadcaster, over its coverage of the war in Gaza,' wrote Kosminsky, who made a docu drama about Kelly's death in 2005.
'The last time Labour was in power, it picked a public fight with the BBC over an editorial matter. It didn't end well for either party and a man – David Kelly – tragically died.
'I have been a Labour supporter for most of my life. It gives me no pleasure to watch this government behaving like a tinpot dictatorship, trying to pressurise a broadcaster for which it holds the purse strings. You are the current custodians of the 100-year tradition of public service broadcasting in this country. This is not the way to discharge that obligation.'
Nandy has repeatedly criticised the BBC over a Gaza documentary that failed to disclose that its child narrator was the son of a Hamas official. She also criticised its livestreaming of the punk rap group Bob Vylan at the Glastonbury festival. Bobby Vylan, whose real name is Pascal Robinson-Foster, was shown leading chants of 'death, death to the IDF', referring to the Israel Defense Forces.
Nandy personally targeted Davie in the House of Commons, warning of 'a problem of leadership'. She then gave an interview questioning why no one had been fired over the failings.
Kosminksy warned Nandy about the historical precedent of political interference, pointing to the Thatcher government's attempt to pull a 1985 documentary about Northern Ireland.
'It is not the government's job or responsibility to police the individual editorial decisions of the BBC, or to call for the sacking of its editorial staff,' he wrote. 'For its part, the BBC must ensure that its output is balanced. But this means balanced across the totality of its output.
'As a programme maker with 45 years' experience of making controversial programmes – for all our public service broadcasters – I know it is impossible to completely balance all arguments within every individual programme. Sometimes it is a programme's responsibility to ask awkward questions, to raise hackles.'
The strength of Nandy's attacks has been noted by others. Richard Ayre, a former controller of editorial policy and deputy chief executive of BBC News, said last week it was 'outrageous that the secretary of state lifts the phone and demands answers from the director general'.
'Maybe she'll start lifting the phone, asking for answers from the editor of individual programmes,' he told the Beeb Watch podcast. 'Governance is important. Parliament has put in place governance procedures to govern the BBC independently and fairly – and it shouldn't be governed by politicians.'
Supporters of the BBC are concerned the corporation is running out of allies as it enters crucial talks over the renewal of its charter with the government. After a series of recent crises, Davie said last week he remained the right person to lead the broadcaster.
A Department for Culture, Media and Sport spokesperson said: 'There have been a number of serious failures at the BBC in recent months. The secretary of state has raised these on behalf of licence fee payers who rightly expect action to be taken so that these cannot happen again.
'The BBC is operationally and editorially independent of government, and we will always defend this principle. However, there is an important distinction between being independent and being accountable.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
12 minutes ago
- Daily Mirror
Dannii Minogue set to make huge acting comeback alongside Coronation Street icon
Dannii Minogue started her career working on one of Australia's biggest soaps - and now she is teaming up with other soap legends for a brand new four part drama Dannii Minogue is set to make a triumphant return to acting - decades after walking away from her breakout soap role. The 53-year-old Australian may be known to millions for her music and TV judging career. Dannii has enjoyed chart success with smash singles including Put the Needle on It, All I Wanna Do, and I Begin to Wonder. And she won over even more fans when she served as a judge on hit series The X Factor from 2007 until 2010. More recently, Dannii has been playing cupid for boys and girls looking for love on the dating shows I Kissed A Boy and I Kissed A Girl on the BBC. But before any of these career achievements were made, Dannii enjoyed a career as an actress - breaking into the spotlight before her older sister, chart superstar Kylie Minogue, 47. Back in 1989, Dannii drew attention for playing Emma Jackson in the Aussie soap Home and Away. She landed the role after playing smaller roles on an array of TV shows - and she remained on Home and Away until 1990. Now, 35 years later, the star is to make a return to acting in a new Channel 5 drama called Imposter. She will appear in the show opposite ex-Corrie actress Kym Marsh, 49. The four part drama is already filming in Victoria, Australia, and follows a family that is torn apart by betrayal and murder. Neighbours icon Jackie Woodburne, 69, who has played Susan Kennedy since 1994, also features as the leader of the family. A source told The Sun:"Bosses have spent weeks trying to get Dannii and she finally put pen to paper just days before filming started. It's been decades since she's acted on the small screen and everyone at the channel is over the moon that she was able to make the dates work because she loved the script. "She started filming last week after meeting her fellow cast members." The Mirror has contacted representatives of Dannii and Channel 5 for comment. Imposter was announced earlier this month - with TV fans already excited by the news that Kym and Jackie would be united together on screen by the show. And the new series was announced alongside news that a string of other shows are being made; Number One Fan, Missed Call and The Family Secret, to returning shows The Hardacres and The Teacher. Deputy Chief Content Officer and Head of Scripted at Paramount UK, Sebastian Cardwell, said last week: "This new slate of scripted commissions showcases the breadth and ambition of 5's storytelling. "From brand new thrillers and character-driven mysteries to the much-anticipated return of audience favourites, we're continuing to build a rich and distinctive drama offering. "These titles reflect our commitment to delivering compelling, accessible British drama that resonates with viewers across the UK. We look forward to announcing further titles in the coming months."
Telegraph
12 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Elite police unit to monitor online critics of migrants
An elite team of police officers is to monitor social media for anti-migrant sentiment amid fears of summer riots. Detectives will be drawn from forces across the country to take part in a new investigations unit that will flag up early signs of potential civil unrest. The division, assembled by the Home Office, will aim to 'maximise social media intelligence' gathering after police forces were criticised over their response to last year's riots. It comes amid growing concern that Britain is facing another summer of disorder, as protests outside asylum hotels spread. On Saturday, crowds gathered in towns and cities including Norwich, Leeds and Bournemouth to demand action, with more protests planned for Sunday. Angela Rayner warned the Cabinet last week that the Government must act to address the 'the real concerns that people have' about immigration. But critics on Saturday night branded the social media plans 'disturbing' and raised concerns over whether they would lead to a restriction of free speech. Chris Philp, the shadow home secretary, said: 'Two-tier Keir can't police the streets, so he's trying to police opinions instead. They're setting up a central team to monitor what you post, what you share, what you think, because deep down they know the public don't buy what they're selling. 'Labour have stopped pretending to fix Britain and started trying to mute it. This is a Prime Minister who's happy to turn Britain into a surveillance state, but won't deport foreign criminals, won't patrol high streets, won't fund frontline policing. 'Labour are scared of the public, Labour don't trust the public, Labour don't even know the public.' Nigel Farage, the Reform UK leader, said: 'This is the beginning of the state controlling free speech. It is sinister, dangerous and must be fought. Reform UK will do just that.' In a further sign of dissent over the Government's approach to social media, campaigners claimed on Saturday that posts about anti-migrant protests in the past week had been censored because of new online safety laws.
Daily Mail
12 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Tragic reason why £3m overgrown mansion was left abandoned with TWO sports cars and rooms full of luxury belongings still inside
An abandoned mansion which went viral after YouTubers broke in is owned by a grieving and reclusive multi-millionaire, MailOnline can reveal. Dozens of urban explorers and ghost hunters posted videos inside the £3.3 million property after word spread the house and all its contents had been 'frozen in time' for a decade. After influencers peddled unverified theories about the owner, it can be revealed the once-jet set executive, who we are not naming, lives a solitary existence in a multi-million pound mansion in London as he struggles to come to terms with a family death. A neighbour told MailOnline: 'He had a partner, she passed away. There was a child, but she is now gone. He doesn't want anyone to understand what has happened to him. 'He is a rich person, he never gets visitors. He is very intelligent and well educated but he sleeps until three in the afternoon, the blinds spend most of their time closed. 'His house here is full of papers, letters, we believe he is in a deep depression, great sadness. In almost three years he has not had any person visit, we have barely seen him. If you don't know him, he won't open the door. He doesn't care.' When we visited the abandoned mansion an hour's drive outside London, the driveway was totally overgrown and a vintage BMW 3 series was covered in vegetation. The grand entrance at the top of the driveway is sealed with a chain lock and high brick walls make it impenetrable. Neighbours claim YouTubers broke down a fence on a nearby footpath and trespassed across private land in order to access the mansion. They alleged the content creators prized open a downstairs window to enter the home. One group allegedly 'had their van towed', a neighbour said. Videos of the property have been made by influencers including 'The Bearded Explorer', who, with 231,000 subscribers, boasts of exploring 'anything abandoned & derelict across the world'. Once inside, the home has a frozen-in-time feel to it with its contents such as furniture, TVs, clothes and bed linen still in situ. There is food and wine still in the working fridge and YouTubers note how it is as if the owner 'left in a rush'. Some rooms such as the lounge, kitchen and dining room appear to be in surprisingly good and dust-free condition, albeit with the odd bit of ivy pushing through cracks in the windows, yet an upstairs bedroom has a caved-in ceiling and mould throughout. The property's interior is of late 2000s or early 2010s style and is packed with trinkets like oil samples and a BP-branded coat which evidence a successful career in deep sea oil prospecting. There is also an impressive film poster collection including James Bond's From Russia with Love starring Sean Connery and James Dean's The Great Escape. Some items offer a glimpse into the owner's interests, including several 2007/08 Chelsea season tickets for the Harris Suite hospitality section when the club was managed by José Mourinho and later, Avram Grant. There are also vintage Chelsea kits alongside Boston Red Sox baseball replica shirts in an upstairs bedroom. The owner also owns an impressive war time memorabilia collection including a poem written by a WW2 RAF pilot while a didgeridoo is propped up against the fireplace. Standouts in the home include a dust covered Jaguar XJ sports car in a garage. Strangely, its tires have not deflated. A door into the garage has had a hole cut out of it. But shameless urban explorers, who partake in 'Urbex', have gone a step further by brazenly filming deeply personal items like compensation documents which reveal the owner's name. They even gawk at old family holiday snaps, school photos of young children and even a framed handwritten note from a child clearly learning to write. With power still feeding the home, trespassers are able to turn on lights and even a kitchen radio which ghost hunters have used in lowlife videos to pretend the home is haunted. One neighbour of the mansion, who said the home has been ransacked by burglars thanks to videos posted online, said they believe the home was abandoned in around 2013 but a calendar which features in one video dates to around 2015. The neighbour said they do not know why the home was abandoned and noted how the alarm never goes off, but revealed: 'He continues to pay his subs for the road, we have tried to contact him but he doesn't reply. 'Several people have tried to buy it from him and he's just not been interested or responded in any way. 'It's not a cheap property, it will be worth something to him to sell it. 'It's huge, it goes from here all the way down to the main road. His is a nice house, he paid £2million for it in around 2011. 'His email he doesn't respond to, I've sent him registered post with a forward and it's never come back. He just doesn't seem to want to do anything about it. 'When we moved in he had this other half with a daughter and then she left.' Neighbours paint a picture of a successful and wealthy man who used to jet around the world to New York, Australia and the Far East on work. Hotel cards from across the world found in the abandoned property corroborate this. The executive has held senior roles in London and Boston, USA, according to his LinkedIn, and neighbours say he 'always travelling' up until 2021 when his partner became ill with a terminal condition. They say he plunged into a deep depression after her death in 2023, which he notes on his LinkedIn profile. He is said to now rarely leave his house and has few visitors. Those that do knock on his property, his neighbours say, are not answered to. His garden is overgrown and the home, is a mess, with letters in the hallway piled high. Locals believe the owner will not have a clue what has happened to his property. Another said: 'Shame on those who have exploited him. This will come back to bite them, I can assure you, he is not someone to mess with.'
