Pizza Week 2025: Mario's Pizza in Owego
34 alum and now special pizza correspondent Mike Tanzini is resuming his tour of local pizzerias.
First, Mike takes us out to Owego to learn about a familiar family recipe.
'It's just an ongoing tradition and a family-run business,' said Mario's Owner Jerry Pettinato.
A staple in Owego, Mario's Pizza has been in business for over 45 years. A lot can change in four and a half decades. But if you ask Jerry Pettinato, if something ain't broke, you don't fix it.
'It hasn't been tweaked, it has not been changed, it's been the same recipe,' said Pettinato.
Jerry knows a thing or two about the pizza business. His father and family managed an Italian restaurant in the Scranton area that's been in operation since the 1920s. Meanwhile, Jerry's father-in-law opened Mario's Pizza in the late 1970s. It wasn't long before Jerry jumped into the pizza biz to continue the family tradition.
'Between my wife being in the business, me being familiar with that, it seemed like a natural progression with me to get into this,' said Pettinato.
It's a full family effort as Jerry, Amanda, Vinny, and Gina all work together to make the signature Mario's pizza, which starts with dough made fresh each day using a blend of flour, water, sugar, salt, and a special yeast.
'Fresh yeast is extremely fragile. It can't sit for a long time, or it will lose its potency,' said Pettinato.
The dough will ferment for 24 to 36 hours, which enhances its flavor and makes it light, airy, and easy to work with.
'You go all the way around. Give it a little tug and pull. Let gravity stretch it out. Give it a little tug and a little turn. Unfortunately, it took me a little while to really get the technique. It's not about speed…oh there it goes. I jinxed myself here. Is this fixable? This is the magic of television. When this comes out, you probably won't be able to tell there was a hole in it,' said Pettinato.
Next, it's time to drop down the sauce.
'One scoop of sauce dead center – kind of like target practice here,' said Pettinato.
Mario's utilizes fresh California tomatoes.
'You want the best that you can possibly get. It's been the same brand of tomato for 45 years. That company is strict with their tolerances, and everything is perfect' said Pettinato.
Along with a special blend of Italian seasonings, which packs a punch of fresh flavor.
As with any loyal family business, Jerry isn't budging on revealing the family recipe.
'There are some traditional Italian seasonings. A little bit of TLC, a little bit of love, and we'll… just leave it at that,' said Pettinato.
Now, time for the 100% whole milk, full cream mozzarella cheese that's going to melt beautifully and blanket our pie. After spreading what I'd consider a perfect layer of cheese, I feel like it might be time for a promotion!
'I'm in charge. My first order of business is giving everyone a half day. Jim is going to stay and make pizza with me.'
After several minutes in the oven, we take it out, cut it up, and get ready to enjoy a meal as a family – the same meal that Mario's has been serving to customers, both young and old.
'They've been with us for generations. It's more than 45 years that we've been here. We're on second and third generations now coming up and seeing their kids and grandkids come in and have that same smile on their face when they take that first bite of pizza,' said Pettinato.
I want to thank everybody at Mario's for helping me be a part of the family and for creating their signature Mario's pizza. There are some places out there that say, 'When you're here, you're family.' I can tell you firsthand that when you're down at Mario's, you're part of La Famiglia.
Mario's is located at 51 Fox Street in Owego, which is the only location owned by the Pettinato family.
Next, Mike heads to Vestal to learn about another long-time pizza staple in our community.
Meanwhile, you can vote for your favorite local pie in our pizza poll by clicking here.
Pizza Week 2025: Mario's Pizza in Owego
'Hurlyburly' at KNOW Theatre
Demolition of IBM Old Building Group nears completion
Van Cott Jewelers announces official closing date
Hanagan's Heroes monument to be relocated to Southside Veterans Park
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Los Angeles Times
19 hours ago
- Los Angeles Times
Jimmy Kimmel secures Italian citizenship in case he needs to escape Trump's second term
Jimmy Kimmel revealed he has his Italian passport ready, just in case. During an interview with comedian Sarah Silverman on her podcast, the 'Jimmy Kimmel Live!' host discussed how 'much worse' the president's second term has been for the country, without getting into specifics. He said he has obtained Italian citizenship as a result. Kimmel's Italian heritage from his mother's side gave him the option to double up his citizenship. 'What's going on [with Trump] is as bad as you thought it was gonna be,' Kimmel told his ex-girlfriend. 'I feel like it's probably even worse than [Trump] would like it to be,' he added. Kimmel has criticized Trump pretty much nonstop on his late-night show since before the president first won the White House in 2016. Trump has previously called Kimmel 'stupid' and recently said the ABC host would be the next to lose his job after CBS announced in July that it wasn't renewing Stephen Colbert's contract. Trump celebrated the news that 'The Late Show' would end soon and predicted Kimmel would face the same fate. '[Kimmel] has less talent than Colbert,' the president posted on Truth Social. Trump doubled down during a press conference last week, saying anyone off the street could do a better job than Kimmel and other mainstream late-night hosts. Since Trump won in 2020, comedians Rosie O'Donnell and Ellen DeGeneres have re-settled in Ireland and England, respectively. Kimmel has been on a summer hiatus from his show and will return to his hosting duties in September.
Yahoo
20 hours ago
- Yahoo
Jimmy Kimmel obtained Italian citizenship in case he needs to flee second Trump administration: 'It's so much worse'
Rosie O'Donnell and Ellen DeGeneres previously revealed that they left the U.S. for the U.K. after Donald Trump's reelection. If worse comes to worst, Jimmy Kimmel definitely has options. The late-night host, who has been a vocal detractor of President Donald Trump throughout his first and second term in office, recently shared that if he ever needs out of the country, he already has an exit plan. While joining his ex-girlfriend, Sarah Silverman, on her podcast last week, the comedian discussed the drastic reaction that some have had to Trump's return to the White House. "A lot of people I know are thinking about, where are they going to get citizenship?," Silverman observed. "I did get Italian citizenship," Kimmel replied. "I do have that." Addressing Trump's presidency, he continued, "What's going on is... as bad as you thought it was gonna be, it's so much worse. It's just unbelievable. I feel like it's probably even worse than [Trump] would like it to be." According to the Italian news agency Ansa, Kimmel secured Italian citizenship earlier this year after proving his ancestral lineage (his maternal great-grandparents emigrated to New York from Naples after an 1883 earthquake devastated their hometown, Ischia). Should he actually put that citizenship to use by relocating to Italy, Kimmel would join a growing list of celebs who have opted not to live in the U.S. now that Trump is back in office. Rosie O'Donnell, who famously has an acrimonious relationship with the president, revealed earlier this year that she fled the country for Ireland ahead of Trump's inauguration. "I knew after reading Project 2025 that if Trump got in, it was time for me and my non-binary child to leave the country," she told CNN in April. "It's as bad as they promised and even a little bit worse, and it's been heartbreaking and personally very sad to watch." Trump has since threatened to revoke O'Donnell's citizenship. (According to a Harvard analysis, Trump has no constitutional authority to do so.) In addition to O'Donnell, former daytime host Ellen DeGeneres and wife Portia de Rossi have relocated to the U.K. countryside. "We got here the day before the election and woke up to lots of texts from our friends with crying emojis," DeGeneres revealed in July. "And we're like, 'We're staying here.'" Much like O'Donnell, Kimmel's tendency to question and bash the President have not gone unnoticed. Following news that CBS would be axing The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, Trump boasted that Kimmel would be next on the chopping block. "The word is, and it's a strong word at that, Jimmy Kimmel is NEXT to go in the untalented Late Night Sweepstakes and, shortly thereafter, Fallon will be gone,' Trump wrote on TruthSocial last month. "These are people with absolutely NO TALENT, who were paid Millions of Dollars for, in all cases, destroying what used to be GREAT Television. It's really good to see them go, and I hope I played a major part in it!"Kimmel responded to Trump on Instagram: "I'm hearing you're next. Or maybe it's just another wonderful secret," he wrote, referencing a Wall Street Journal story, published July 17, which claims Trump sent a letter to Jeffrey Epstein in 2003 that was included in a birthday album of well-wishes. Read the original article on Entertainment Weekly
Yahoo
20 hours ago
- Yahoo
Jimmy Kimmel Says He Obtained Italian Citizenship to Flee ‘Unbelievably' Bad Trump Administration
Jimmy Kimmel's dislike of President Donald Trump seems to have reached an inflection point. The late-night host has felt so dismayed by the administration's fascist policies that he's set up a bit of a contingency plan to flee the country altogether if need be. During a recent appearance on The Sarah Silverman podcast, Kimmel informed his ex and fellow comedian that an intercontinental move may be in store after he obtained his Italian citizenship. 'A lot of people I know are thinking about where are they going to get citizenship?' Silverman said. Kimmel replied, 'I did get Italian citizenship,' noting, 'What's going on [with Trump] is as bad as you thought it was gonna be. It's so much worse; it's just unbelievable. I feel like it's probably even worse than he would like it to be.' More from Rolling Stone 'Diversion': Judge Tears Apart Trump Admin Order to Unseal Ghislaine Maxwell Grand Jury Records D.C. Police Put Under Federal Control, Are Now 'Allowed to Do Whatever the Hell They Want' John Oliver Takes Aim at Dean Cain's Plan to Join ICE Kimmel has been a vocal detractor of Trump during both of his terms. Following Trump's first 100 days in office, the comedian dedicated an opening monologue on his show to roasting the inefficiency of the government. 'It's difficult to give Trump's first 100 days a grade, but if I had to I'd say it falls somewhere between F and U,' he said. 'Don't get me wrong, there have been some positives. Unfortunately, they have all been pregnancy tests for women who slept with Elon Musk.' Noting how little Trump got done, he said, 'None of those achievements are achievements,' he said. 'The penny is gone and straws are back. Wow, America really is great again, isn't it? This tells you all you need to know about how things are going for Trump.' If Kimmel leaves the United States, he would join Rosie O'Donnell and Ellen DeGeneres as celebrities who fled the United States after Trump defeated Vice President Kamala Harris in last November's presidential election. Best of Rolling Stone The 50 Best 'Saturday Night Live' Characters of All Time Denzel Washington's Movies Ranked, From Worst to Best 70 Greatest Comedies of the 21st Century
