logo
Debate on forced mental health treatment continues as one woman's costs top $800K

Debate on forced mental health treatment continues as one woman's costs top $800K

Yahoo18-07-2025
In the fight to better help people with severe and persistent mental illness in Ontario — which can sometimes result in costly detention in jails and hospitals — two opposing camps are lobbying the Ministry of Health in very different directions.
On one side are those who think unwell patients are given too much freedom to reject treatment, putting them at risk of having their mental illnesses progress and become entrenched.
On the other side are the patient advocates who say there are already enough mechanisms to force treatment on people, that giving patients the help they ask for leads to better outcomes, and that insufficient community support is the real problem.
Meanwhile, health and justice systems as they exist today can spend much to achieve little. In one woman's ongoing case, a CBC News analysis estimates the costs since 2018 at $811,600 — and counting. She has bipolar I disorder, characterized by episodes of extreme emotional highs that last at least a week, followed by depression.
Click here for source data
Yet despite Barbara Cleary's dozens of stints in hospital psychiatric wards, emergency housing, jail cells and living rough — as well as brief periods of stability and several months in an assisted living facility last year — today the 76-year-old is again unhoused, living in a tent encampment in Cornwall, Ont., continuing the cycle.
'An extremely high cost to the system'
"It is an extremely high cost to the system when people are unwell," said Dr. Karen Shin, chief of psychiatry at St. Michael's Hospital for Unity Health Toronto and chair of the Ontario Psychiatric Association.
"And you have to remember, she's one person. If you went in and reached out to any psychiatrists in the system that are working in a hospital, they can tell you numerous people they care for that have a similar story."
Cornwall police say they're dealing with 20 people like Cleary on a daily basis. The force picked five individuals from that group and found each averaged 53 occurrences requiring police response in 2024.
So, what to do?
Shin founded and co-leads the Ontario Psychiatric Association's mental health and law reform task force, which is calling on the province to expand forced treatment in certain circumstances. From her organization's perspective, some forced care protects the right to health for vulnerable people whose illnesses can cause delusional thinking.
"Choice is extremely important, but that choice has to be a capable choice, and a capable choice needs to include that there's an understanding of the symptoms of the illness and the consequences of saying, 'No, I don't want treatment,'" Shin said.
The task force wants the province to:
Permit treatment during a patient's court appeal after the Consent and Capacity Board upholds a finding that they're incapable of making a decision.
Remove the requirement that people have had to respond to treatment in the past from involuntary admission criteria under the Mental Health Act.
Extend a first involuntary admission from 14 days to up to 30 days.
An organization called the Empowerment Council takes an opposing view. It says medication comes with risks that not every patient can tolerate, including the possibility of neurological damage, and that the trauma of having something forced into the body and mind can interrupt therapeutic relationships and scare people into avoiding it altogether.
"Why not exhaust providing the services that evidence shows help people, rather than spending a half a million dollars on your more carceral responses?" said Jennifer Chambers, the council's executive director.
"Instead, people are just in and out, in and out, and it makes no sense."
Cleary spent a few months in an assisted living facility last year after CBC first covered her story. She was removed last August by police after her illness deteriorated. In late October she was arrested and charged by Cornwall police for the 23rd time, according to court records — this time for breaching probation and trespassing at her former apartment building.
She spent a month and a half in jail getting back on medication before she pleaded guilty in December. She was sentenced to the time she had already served, bringing her total time in jail since 2018 to about 347 days.
Near her tent encampment on Wednesday, she recalled being removed from the assisted living facility and being strapped down on a bed in an anteroom of the hospital's emergency department for half a day.
"Then they admitted me for 12 days. The doctor released me onto the street again," she said.
Asked what she thinks she needs, Cleary said Cornwall has only one psychiatrist and requires more, and that she needs to live with someone who can help her with things like getting around and getting dressed. Many people in the unhoused community help her out on a daily basis, she said, though in the past she has been taken advantage of by some. She wants housing, but in light of her history since 2018 it's unclear how long it would last.
Chambers said Ontario used to be a leader in peer support, but that it's been first on the chopping block with funding constraints. And a transitional support system would help people adjust after being released from institutions like hospital and jail.
"Peers can be really creative and supportive with just where people are, rather than concentrating so much on wrenching them into a different space against their will," she said.
'So much has changed'
Shin agrees that more wrap-around social supports and services are necessary. But she also thinks Ontario's Mental Health Act needs beefing up.
"So much has changed with our knowledge of mental health care, the importance of access to treatment, the concerns around repeated episodes of illness and how that leads to more intractable illness, how it can lead to medications not working as well," she said.
"Most jurisdictions consider the potential risks and harms related to treatment refusal. They have legislative safeguards to ensure involuntary admission is with treatment, so that people get the treatment they need and are not indefinitely detained untreated."
The provincial ministries of health and the attorney general, which oversees the justice system, have not responded to repeated requests for comment.
Where our numbers come from
According to figures provided by the Cornwall hospital about how much it costs to run its short-term crisis housing program ($100,000 per bed, per year), it cost about $14,600 to fund her bed for seven weeks this past winter.
Mental health resources
Do you need help, or does someone you know need help? Here are some mental health resources in the province, which differ depending on where you are:
211 Ontario maintains a database of services. You can search by topic (mental health/addictions) and your specific location. Live chat is available Monday to Friday from 7 a.m. to 9 p.m. ET, and a chatbot is available 24/7. You can also text 211, call 211 or email gethelp@211ontario.ca.
ConnexOntario is a directory of community mental health and addictions services in Ontario. You can connect with someone for information and referrals to services in your community 24/7 via 1-866-531-2600, texting "CONNEX" to 247247, live web chat or email.
The Suicide Crisis Hotline can be reached 24/7 by calling or texting 988.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Wildfire smoke chokes northern Manitoba air, while hot, humid weather plagues the south
Wildfire smoke chokes northern Manitoba air, while hot, humid weather plagues the south

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Wildfire smoke chokes northern Manitoba air, while hot, humid weather plagues the south

As a large swath of Manitoba deals with heavy wildfire smoke polluting the air, others in the province are starting the weekend amidst suffocating heat and humid conditions. Environment and Climate Change Canada has issued an air quality warning for much of northern Manitoba including Thompson, The Pas and Flin Flon on Saturday morning. With relatively light winds, smoke is expected to concentrate especially over the area near active wildfires, causing poor air quality and reduced visibility throughout the day. Everyone's health is at risk, regardless of age or health status, during heavy smoke conditions, the federal agency said. But pregnant people, children, seniors and those with underlying health conditions are more likely to be impacted. Environment Canada is advising people to reschedule or cancel outdoor sports and activities. People who work outdoors should avoid extraneous activities and seek medical attention if experiencing symptoms. Those may include eye eye, nose and throat irritation, headaches or a mild cough. More less common symptoms include wheezing, chest pains or severe cough, Environment Canada said. According to the province's latest fire bulletin, issued Friday, the Manitoba Wildfire Service was responding to 121 active wildfires across the province, which has seen a total of 337 wildfires to date, well above the average for this time of year of 260. Heat warning Meanwhile, pockets of southern Manitoba, including the cities of Winnipeg, Brandon and Portage la Prairie, are under a heat warning. Humid and hot conditions are expected to remain throughout Saturday with temperatures reaching the low 30's C and humidex values nearing 38, Environment Canada said. Conditions are expected to improve with a cold front moving overnight Saturday, but in the meantime the weather agency is advising people to watch for signs of early heat exhaustion including headache, dizziness and intense fatigue. Extreme heat can affect everyone's health, but the risks are greater for older adults and other vulnerable people, Environment Canada said. To reduce the health effects of heat, stay out of direct sunlight, drink plenty of water and stay in a cool space, closing blinds and open windows if it is cooler outside than inside or turning on air conditioning. The weather agency also advises people to ensure children and pets are never left alone in closed vehicles.

Major Health Insurers Slash Prior Authorization Requirements, Transforming the PA Technology Landscape
Major Health Insurers Slash Prior Authorization Requirements, Transforming the PA Technology Landscape

Yahoo

time3 hours ago

  • Yahoo

Major Health Insurers Slash Prior Authorization Requirements, Transforming the PA Technology Landscape

Black Book Research identifies Cohere Health, Innovaccer, and Waystar among leading vendors rapidly adapting to new industry rules. NEW YORK CITY, NY / / July 26, 2025 / U.S. healthcare is undergoing a pivotal shift as major insurers-led by UnitedHealthcare and Humana-begin to significantly reduce or eliminate prior authorization (PA) requirements for hundreds of routine procedures. Accelerated by federal policy, provider frustration, and consumer demands for timely access to care, these sweeping changes signal a new era in PA technology and operations, according to a July 2025 flash survey conducted by Black Book Research. Industry Drivers: Regulatory Action Meets Provider and Consumer Pressure Insurers covering over 250 million Americans have committed to streamlining or removing PA burdens by the end of 2026. This is partly driven by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), which is launching a pilot program in six states in January 2026 requiring faster, more transparent prior authorizations for select Medicare services. CMS has also announced national response time standards for Medicare Advantage plans, further intensifying the need for automation and interoperability in PA processes. Key Survey Insights from the Field Black Book Research's flash survey compiled viewpoints from: 24 IT leaders representing the top 10 PA vendors; 108 managed care and health plan IT and operational decision-makers; 142 healthcare providers and administrative leaders; and 100 healthcare consumers with recent PA experiences. Notable Findings: 84% of managed care executives support reducing PA requirements 96% of healthcare providers report improved workflows and lower administrative burdens 99% of consumers favor eliminating PA for routine care; 83% say they've experienced harmful care delays 67% of health plans expect to reevaluate or end contracts with existing PA vendors by 2026 Additional Observations: 90% of providers foresee broad adoption of interoperable PA tools by 2027 94% of payers plan substantial investment in AI-based PA platforms 100% of consumers prefer providers with automated and transparent PA processes 96% of PA vendor executives acknowledge their current solutions require modernization within two years __________ Vendors Rapidly Adapting and Leading the Innovation Curve: Client Top KPI Scores Black Book highlights the top-performing vendors already making critical advancements to align with industry shifts: Cohere Health - Excels in AI-based automation, payer-provider integration, and CMS-aligned interoperability Innovaccer - Offers strong EHR integration and regulatory compliance dashboards for PA workflows Waystar - Enhancing its Auth Accelerate platform for real-time eligibility checks and exception handling ScribeRunner - Developing dynamic auto-approval rulesets and real-time tracking modules CoverMyMeds - Expanding AI-powered real-time authorizations for both pharmacy and medical benefits Change Healthcare - Transitioning legacy infrastructure with modular FHIR APIs for automated decision-making Availity - Driving advanced API adoption and digital submission channels PriorAuthNow (Rhyme) - Connecting providers and payers through real-time electronic submission with limited manual effort Black Book's Q1-Q2 client satisfaction rankings show these vendors excelled across 18 qualitative KPIs for PA technology. Cohere Health earned the highest overall honors, with MCG Health, eviCore Healthcare, Agadia, Infinx, and Availity also receiving good marks. Onyx led in FHIR-based PA platform innovation. Detailed competitive intelligence reports are available in the Black Book research store. __________ Vendors Facing Existential Threats in the New Era Not all companies are poised for success. Several previously top-rated PA vendors now face considerable risk due to outdated systems and slow adaptability: eviCore Healthcare - Still dependent on manual review processes, with limited AI capabilities HealthHelp (WNS) - Lagging behind in interoperability and modern payer integration PriorAuthNow (Rhyme) - Despite innovation efforts, struggles with scalable real-time API integration threaten its long-term viability _________ Looking Ahead: A Positive Outlook for Adaptive Vendors While legacy vendors must evolve rapidly or risk market exit, the broader outlook for PA tech is optimistic. Companies investing in automated, intelligent, and interoperable systems are well-positioned to thrive. "The future of prior authorization is transparent, automated, and fully integrated into clinical workflows," said Doug Brown, Founder of Black Book Research. "Vendors delivering real-time, AI-powered solutions will define the next generation of care access efficiency for providers, payers, and patients alike." About Black Book Research Black Book Research is a leading healthcare IT research firm known for its independent, vendor-agnostic approach. Over the past 15 years, Black Book has collected over 3 million survey responses from nearly 500,000 healthcare professionals. The firm's flash surveys and long-form evaluations provide real-time, unbiased insights that support strategic decision-making across the healthcare ecosystem. Visit or contact research@ for full survey results and vendor-specific performance details. Contact Information Press Office research@ SOURCE: Black Book Research View the original press release on ACCESS Newswire Error while retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data Error while retrieving data

This Small Town Greek Doctor on How He Uses AI: ‘'Without AI, Q Fever Might Not Have Been on Our List'
This Small Town Greek Doctor on How He Uses AI: ‘'Without AI, Q Fever Might Not Have Been on Our List'

Gizmodo

time4 hours ago

  • Gizmodo

This Small Town Greek Doctor on How He Uses AI: ‘'Without AI, Q Fever Might Not Have Been on Our List'

Ioannina, a lakeside town in northern Greece surrounded by mountains, is not the kind of place you expect to find cutting-edge artificial intelligence quietly reshaping medicine. Yet, inside its main public hospital, Dr. Tzimas is doing just that. Dr. Tzimas is quietly reshaping how medicine is practiced. From spotting rare diseases like Q fever to managing conflicts among junior doctors, Dr. Tzimas has woven AI into the rhythm of daily medical life. However, he believes that AI will not be able to replace the essential human interactions that are at the heart of his work. 'You have to listen to lung sounds, palpate the abdomen, look patients into their eyes,' he says. 'AI can't feel pain responses or smell signs of illness.' Dr. Tzimas is the director of the Internal Medicine Department at General Hospital of Ioannina 'G. Hatzikosta.' This interview is part of our series How Do You Use AI, where we ask people one simple question: How do you use AI? No TED Talk nonsense, just real life. Episode 3: Dr. Thomas Tzimas—AI Pragmatist. Gizmodo: How does AI fit into your daily medical practice? Dr. Tzimas: AI acts as an assistant that helps us work faster and more reliably. We feed it solid data, review the output, and proceed if it's okay. This is particularly helpful when we need to respond to insurance companies about a patient's situation or send emails to family physicians. Gizmodo: Can you give a specific example of how AI assists with patient care? Dr. Tzimas: One major area is drug interactions. There are extensive tables of drug interactions, but they're difficult to access quickly when you're with a patient. AI systems can provide this information very easily and without mistakes. It also helps with adjusting dosages for patients with conditions like renal insufficiency or hepatic failure, where normal doses might be harmful. Gizmodo: Are you concerned about AI 'hallucinations' or inaccuracies in the medical field? Dr. Tzimas: An experienced clinician can spot hallucinations right away. If you prompt the AI with very strict protocols, they do not hallucinate. The 'temperature' setting of AI models is crucial; for the medical field, it needs to be set to 0.3, which makes them very strict and prevents them from fantasizing or hallucinating. Normal AI systems often have a temperature of 1, which leads to a lot of fantasizing and hallucinating. Gizmodo: Do you use AI for personal matters? Dr. Tzimas: I use AI for almost all my emails, especially within the communication platform among doctors. I use a 'negotiator GPT' prompt that makes answers very diplomatic. This is particularly useful when there's a conflict among junior doctors, as I have to maintain integrity and prevent conflicts while still being strict. It helps me reply in a way that smooths over potential issues, like an accomplished diplomat would. Gizmodo: Interesting… Dr. Tzimas: I also use AI to create teaching materials very quickly. For instance, I can take a complex clinical case from a journal like the New England Journal of Medicine and ask the system to create multiple-choice questions from it. I then present these questions to the doctors, and I can see who answers correctly or incorrectly. The next day, I provided the correct answer. AI also helps me summarize large articles and complex medical cases from journals for easier discussion. This has freed up a lot of my time. Gizmodo: Does AI assist with diagnosis? Dr. Tzimas: AI tools are really capable for differential diagnosis. If a patient presents with a symptom like fever, it could be a thousand things. With AI, we can narrow down the possibilities to less than 10, and then through clinical examination, imaging, and consultations, we narrow it down to one. The system can even remind you of really rare conditions that might be happening to your patient. Gizmodo: When was the last time AI helped you in a case? Dr. Tzimas: A few hours ago, we completed a difficult case. One patient, a labor worker, had inhaled a lot of dust in a sheep and goat stable and came in with a fever. We used AI to consider what diseases could be contracted from dust in such a stable. One of the highly-ranked differential diagnoses was Q fever, which is very rare. We sent a blood sample to Athens to exclude it. Although it came back negative and the final diagnosis was unrelated, the AI system identified Q fever as a potential possibility, which opened our horizons. Without AI, Q fever might not have even on our list. Gizmodo: Do your patients use AI themselves? Dr. Tzimas: Yes, some patients now use AI, similar to how they used to Google their symptoms. They might come in saying, 'This is what ChatGPT said,' and we have to respond to that. As AI spreads, people with health questions will use it to get analyses of their symptoms. Our job as doctors remains the same: to professionally answer questions and provide credible answers and solutions. This means doctors also need to use AI for support, paperwork, and even creating dietary plans for patients. Gizomo: Does AI replace the need for administrative staff, like a personal assistant? Dr. Tzimas: It reduces the need. For example, my previous boss would write notes on paper for his assistant to type. Now, I dictate notes on my iPhone, copy-paste them into an AI system, and it creates a nice email. Also, I can take pictures of paper documents, and AI can transcribe them into a digital form, saving tons of time and creating digital archives. Gizmodo: Are you worried about AI replacing you? Dr. Tzimas: No, not at all. My job involves experience that AI cannot yet replicate. I need to listen to lung, heart, and bowel sounds, palpate patients, and inspect them. While AI might analyze a digital photograph of a skin lesion, it cannot palpate a patient and feel the intensity of pain or guarding. These are qualities that rely on a doctor's senses, like smelling a patient's breath to detect diabetic ketoacidosis. Human interaction, like looking a patient in the eyes, observing their demeanor, and assessing their hygiene, provides crucial information that AI cannot easily replace. AI helps save time, but it needs an experienced physician to input those essential details. Gizmodo: How does AI affect your work-life balance? Dr. Tzimas: It saves time. Preparing teaching material used to take me hours; now I just spend an hour or a couple of hours and I'm ready. So I have more time for my personal life.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store