Ofcom boss: Tech firms not given much power over how to protect children online
Ian Russell, who has been campaigning for improved online safety since his 14-year-old daughter Molly took her own life after viewing harmful content on social media, said Ofcom needs to 'act within the bounds of the Act in the strongest possible way' and communicate weaknesses in the legislation to the Government.
Ofcom's chief executive Dame Melanie Dawes told BBC's Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg: 'We've set out about five or six things that we think can work, like facial checks and using things where you've already been checked for your age, like credit cards or open banking.
'We said (to tech companies) you decide what works for your platform but we will be checking whether it's effective and those that don't put in those checks will hear from us with enforcement action.'
Responding to the suggestion that Ofcom is giving companies a lot of power over how they implement measures, Dame Melanie said: 'No, we're not giving them that much power actually. What I'm saying is that when they're putting in age checks they need to work out what's going to work on their service.
'But, let me be really clear, what we are demanding to protect children and what does come in force at the end of this month they're going to need to tame those algorithms so that not just porn and suicide and self-harm material must not be shown but also violent content, dangerous challenges, misogyny, all of that must not be fed actively to kids on their feeds.'
Pressed on why those types of content are not being blocked altogether, the chief executive said: 'What Parliament decided was that there should be an absolute block on suicide and self-harm material and pornography for under-18s and, then, what we've done is also add to that other types of content that we think is really harmful for children.'
She added: 'I'm not a politician and I think it's incredibly important that Ofcom respects the role that we have which is to implement the laws that we've been given.
'If Parliament decides to widen those towards mis- and disinformation, or wider issues around addiction for the kids, for example, then of course, Ofcom stands ready to implement that.'
Mr Russell said on the programme that it 'sounds promising' but the proof will be in what happens in practice.
He said: '(Ofcom) need to act within the bounds of the Act in the strongest possible way.
'They're sitting in the middle pushed on one side by families who've lost people like me and pushed on the other side by the power of the big tech platforms.
'I also think it's really important that Melanie starts to talk back to Government because Ofcom is clear about where the act is weak and she needs to push back and communicate those weaknesses to the Government so that we can make change where necessary.'
He said the charity he set up in his daughter's name, the Molly Rose Foundation, will be monitoring how harmful content online is reduced.
Any company that fails to comply with the checks by July 25 could be fined or could be made unavailable in the UK through a court order.
Transport Secretary Heidi Alexander said those changes in the law are 'really important', adding it was now up to technology companies to put in 'robust safeguards' for children using their platforms.
But she suggested it was not the end of ministers' plans, telling the BBC's Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg: 'We are very clear as a Government that this is the foundation for a safer online experience for children, but it is not the end of the conversation.
'Peter Kyle, the Technology Secretary, has been clear that he wants to look at things such as addictive habits and how we create healthier habits for children online in the same way as we talk about healthier physical habits for children.'
Ministers 'will keep under review what is required', Ms Alexander added.
Ofcom research found that 8% of eight to 14-year-olds in the UK had visited an online porn site or app on smartphones, tablets or computers in a month.
Last month, the regulator said it had launched a string of investigations into 4chan, a porn site operator and several file-sharing platforms over suspected failures to protect children, after it received complaints about illegal activity and potential sharing of child abuse images.
A report looking into the use and effectiveness of age assurance methods will be published by Ofcom next year.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Guardian
an hour ago
- South Wales Guardian
Starmer defends Palestine recognition plan but hits out at Hamas
Sir Keir Starmer has said the UK will recognise a Palestinian state in September unless Israel agrees to meet certain conditions, including addressing the humanitarian crisis, implementing a ceasefire and reviving the prospect of a two-state solution. But he insisted the move was not a propaganda boost to Hamas, saying the 'terrorist organisation' could play 'no part in any future government'. The Prime Minister's approach has been criticised by the Israeli government and a protest over his stance is due to take place in London at the weekend. Demonstrators, including some British family members of hostages still held by Hamas, will march on Downing Street calling for the release of the remaining hostages before any talk about the recognition of Palestine. Asked if he had given Hamas a public relations boost by talking about recognition, Sir Keir told Channel 5: 'They should release the hostages straight away and they should play absolutely no part in the governance of Palestine at any point.' He said the hostages taken during the October 7 2023 attacks had been held for a 'very, very long time in awful circumstances, unimaginable circumstances, and Hamas is a terrorist organisation, and that's why I'm really clear about Hamas'. Sir Keir added: 'We do, alongside that, have to do all that we can to alleviate the awful situation on the ground in Gaza. We need aid in volume and at scale.' People have seen the 'images of starvation' in Gaza, he said, adding that 'the British public can see it and there's a sense of revulsion of what they're seeing'. The Government had to do 'everything we can' to get aid in, working with other countries 'and it's in that context that I set out our position on recognition'. Tory leader Kemi Badenoch said on Tuesday that 'Keir Starmer has made a mistake' and 'what we need to focus on now is a ceasefire and getting the hostages home'. Tzipi Hotovely, Israeli ambassador to the UK, said the actions of Hamas 'must never be rewarded'.
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
ICE wants to target Gen Z in PR blitz including ads on YouTube, HBO and X to fill 14,000 roles
Donald Trump's administration is urgently trying to launch an ad campaign to help recruit more than 14,000 immigration officers who can rapidly remove people from the country, government documents say. Immigration and Customs Enforcement specifically wants to target 'Gen Z and early-career professionals,' as well as former law enforcement officers, military veterans and people from legal fields, according to the agency's request for information, the first step in a government procurement process to begin contracting with eligible firms. ICE wants to reach more than 42 million people in those 'target audience groups' across social media platforms as well as through ads on Hulu, HBO Max and Amazon Prime, among other networks, the pitch says. 'This is a critical priority,' the agency wrote on the government's procurement website. 'ICE has an immediate need to begin recruitment efforts and requires specialized commercial advertising experience, established infrastructure, and qualified personnel to activate without delay.' Marketing firms should be able to zero in on potential recruits through 'geofencing,' which delivers ads based on a viewer's location, as well as 'behavioral' practices, according to the documents, first reported by 404 Media. The effort ties together with the Trump administration's 'national launch and awareness saturation initiative aimed at dominating both digital and traditional media channels with urgent, compelling recruitment messages,' according to the pitch. The Independent has requested comment from ICE. Republicans in Congress earmarked $30 billion for the hiring spree, alongside $45 billion in new funding for ICE detention centers. Altogether, Trump's 'big, beautiful' domestic policy bill sets aside more than $170 billion for immigration enforcement over the next decade. That injection of taxpayer cash makes the law enforcement agency one of the most expensive police forces in the world, outpacing most foreign military budgets. Homeland Security is also advertising a 'maximum $50,000 signing bonus' and student loan forgiveness for new recruits. Secretary Kristi Noem announced Wednesday that she is dropping age limit requirements and allowing people older than 40 to apply, 'so even more patriots will qualify to join ICE in its mission to arrest murderers, pedophiles, gang members, rapists, and other criminal illegal aliens from America's streets,' according to DHS. And people as young as 18 years old can apply, Noem told Fox News Wednesday. ICE is looking to hire more removal officers, Homeland Security Investigations agents, attorneys and other personnel. The pace of daily immigration arrests fell by nearly 20 percent in July following a wave of court challenges, mass protests, and reports suggesting that morale within ICE ranks has been plummeting with officers spending more time 'arresting gardeners' than investigating major crimes. 'It's miserable,' one ICE official told The Atlantic last month. 'It became a contest of how many deportations could be reported to Stephen Miller by December,' added Adam Boyd, an attorney who resigned from the agency's legal department in June. In May, White House adviser Stephen Miller announced on Fox News that the administration had set a goal of arresting 3,000 people a day, and that Trump 'is going to keep pushing to get that number up higher each and every day.' But in court filings, government lawyers have denied any such arrest targets. ICE has not been directed to 'meet any numerical quota or target for arrests, detentions, removals, field encounters, or any other operational activities that ICE or its components undertake in the course of enforcing federal immigration law,' they wrote to a federal appeals court last week. Between July 1 and 27, ICE averaged 990 daily arrests, down from 1,224 the previous month, according to government data analyzed by the Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse, a nonpartisan research project at Syracuse University. ICE is likely to face significant roadblocks in reaching 14,000 new recruits, according to analysts and former law enforcement officials. Without effective guardrails to screen how those agents are hired and who exactly is filling those roles, the government may be setting itself up to repeat critical past mistakes the last time there was a surge in new recruits, experts said. But the agency is growing at such a rate that 'we're going to see an ICE that it is going to be hard for any future administration to shrink,' former acting ICE director Josh Sandweg said earlier this year. The agency's 'capacity to deport will certainly be at the highest level it's ever been in the history of the United States,' he added.
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Gordon Brown backs gambling tax reform to tackle child poverty
Online casinos and slot machines should be taxed more to raise some of the money needed to cover the cost of lifting children out of poverty, according to a new report backed by a former prime minister. Reforms to gambling taxes could generate the £3.2 billion needed to scrap the two-child limit and benefit cap, the Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR) said. The think tank said axing the policies could lift half a million children out of poverty and 'reverse years of rising hardship for low-income families'. The two-child limit restricts child tax credit and universal credit (UC) to the first two children in most households, while the benefit cap sees the amount of benefits a household receives reduced to ensure claimants do not get more than the limit. The Government is expected to publish a child poverty strategy in autumn, and a multitude of campaign groups have said it must contain a commitment to do away with the two-child limit. The IPPR argued that, in the face of covering the costs of scrapping the policy, it feels 'fair' to ask the 'highly profitable' gambling industry to contribute more. Echoing this, former prime minister Gordon Brown said: 'Thanks to IPPR's report, we now know that taxing gambling more fairly would fully fund the first crucial step in the war we must wage against child poverty: ending the two-child limit and lifting the benefit cap. 'There are many reasons why the highly profitable betting and gaming industry should pay a fairer share towards the cost of UK's unmet needs. Most important is that it would enable half a million children to be lifted out of poverty in this autumn's budget, and so help to build our country for the next generation.' The IPPR suggested increasing taxes on online casinos from 21% to 50% and raising those on slots and gaming machines from 20% to 50%. The organisation also proposed raising general betting duty on non-racing bets from 15% to 25% which it said would bring other sports in line with the rates paid by horseracing. The IPPR said raising gambling taxes in the way they suggested would be unlikely to reduce overall government revenue. Henry Parkes, principal economist and head of quantitative research at IPPR, said: 'The gambling industry is highly profitable, yet is exempt from paying VAT and often pays no corporation tax, with many online firms based offshore. It is also inescapable that gambling causes serious harm, especially in its most high-stakes forms. 'Set against a context of stark and rising levels of child poverty, it only feels fair to ask this industry to contribute a little more.' But a spokesperson for the Betting and Gaming Council said they rejected the 'economically reckless, factually misleading' proposals which they insisted 'risk driving huge numbers to the growing, unsafe, unregulated gambling black market, which doesn't protect consumers and contributes zero tax'. They added: 'Further tax rises, fresh off the back of Government reforms which cost the sector over a billion in lost revenue, would do more harm than good – for punters, jobs, growth and public finances.'
