Elevance Health loses bid to challenge US Medicare star ratings
U.S. District Judge Mark Pittman in Fort Worth, Texas, sided with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services after the company sued to fight the star rating assigned to one of its contracts, arguing the agency's calculations for the ratings were flawed. Pittman said Elevance had not pointed out any major problems with the calculations and that the process is too complicated for the court to evaluate it beyond that.
Elevance, the parent of companies including Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield and Carelon, provides Medicare Advantage plans in the U.S. The plans are funded by the Medicare health insurance program for seniors and some disabled people, but administered by private insurers.
The U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, which is part of HHS, issues star ratings for the plans, from one to five stars, to help beneficiaries choose among them.
Plans with higher star ratings receive higher payments from the government if they keep costs below certain targets. Those bonus payments can be worth hundreds of millions or billions of dollars.
Elevance had said the agency's calculations for 2025 caused at least one of its contracts to just miss being rated at the next higher tier, likely costing the company at least $375 million in bonus and other payments.
A spokesperson for Elevance did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Neither did representatives for HHS.
Elevance filed its lawsuit in October, after one of its contracts received a score of 3.749565 and was assigned 3.5 stars.
The company said CMS had not followed its own regulations when it rounded down, and the contract should have been rounded up to 4 stars.
HHS countered that its scoring process was sound, arguing that if the court allowed Elevance's challenge to move forward, it would be opening the door to yearly challenges from insurers whose contracts just missed the cutoff for higher tiers.
The company was one of several health insurers to sue after CMS released the 2025 star ratings.
Last month, another Texas federal judge tossed a lawsuit brought by Humana that challenged the reduction in the health insurer's star ratings after finding that Humana had failed to exhaust all of its out-of-court options to challenge the ratings.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
19 minutes ago
- Reuters
New CEO tees up Tiger to redefine PGA Tour competition
August 20 - ATLANTA -- Brian Rolapp has a new job -- and now so does Tiger Woods. Rolapp, the PGA Tour's new CEO 18 days into his tenure, announced the formation of the Future Competition Committee on Wednesday in advance of the Tour Championship at East Lake Golf Club. Woods agreed to serve as chairman for the nine-person committee. The aim of the newly formed group, which has yet to meet, is to define a competitive model for PGA Tour events. The committee will consist of five other players -- Patrick Cantlay, Adam Scott, Camilo Villegas, Maverick McNealy and Keith Mitchell -- and three business advisors with Joe Gorder, who serves on the Tour's policy board, and John Henry and Theo Epstein, both of the Fenway Sports Group. Rolapp comes to the PGA Tour as the CEO after a career with the NFL as commissioner Jay Monahan steps aside. "We're going to focus on the evolution of our competitive model and the corresponding media products and sponsorship elements and model of the entire sport, "Rolapp said. "The goal is not incremental change. The goal is significant change." The governing principles of the player-led committee are: Parity: to strengthen a commitment to a meritocratic structure. Scarcity: to increase fan engagement by ensuring top players compete together more often. Simplicity: to better connect the regular and postseason to magnify the season-ending Tour Championship. "The strength of the PGA Tour is strong, but there's much more we need to do, much more we need to change for the benefit of fans, players and our partners," Rolapp said. "I said when I took the job that I would take it with a clean sheet of paper, and that is still true. ... I said, we're going to honor tradition, but we will not be overly bound by it. Now we're going to start turning that blank sheet of paper into action with an idea to aggressively build on the foundation that we have." PGA Tour player Harris English is one of about 20 players Rolapp has spoken with since joining the organization. English said the two spoke for about 45 minutes. "I've been out here 14 years," English said. "I've seen a lot of changes out here, and (I gave him) kind of my thoughts on what's good, what's bad, what needs to be changed." One of the key issues facing Rolapp will be the relationship between the PGA Tour and LIV Golf. The two entities continue separate paths with no prospect of a resolution anytime soon. Rolapp said he has not spoken with anyone from the Public Investment Fund, the Saudi-led group that finances LIV Golf. He was pressed about a possible resolution that would enable the world's best players to compete against each other, or at be in the same tournament fields more often. "I think I'm going to focus on what I can control," Rolapp said. "I would offer to you that the best collection of golfers in the world are on the PGA Tour. I think there's a bunch of metrics that demonstrate that, from rankings to viewership to whatever you want to pick. I'm going to lean into that and strengthen that. "I will also say that to the extent we can do anything that's going to further strengthen the PGA Tour, we'll do that, and I'm interested in exploring whatever strengthens the PGA Tour." --Chris Vivlamore, Field Level Media
Medical News Today
21 minutes ago
- Medical News Today
Revised AHA guidelines on hypertension: What's new?
Hypertension, or high blood pressure, affects around one in every three adults is a risk factor for several health conditions, including heart attack, stroke, heart failure and kidney American Ηeart Association has recently updated its 2017 guidelines on the prevention and management of hypertension, including new research information for the 2025 advises that anyone can develop high blood pressure but that diet and lifestyle modifications can prevent or control the condition for many American Heart Association (AHA) has recently published revised its guidelines on hypertension. They state that the condition is the leading risk factor for stroke and a number of heart diseases, such as coronary artery disease, heart failure, and atrial fibrillation (AFib).The World Health Organization (WHO) states that one in three adults, or 1.3 billion people, around the world have hypertension, so preventing, detecting and treating it could prevent 76 million deaths worldwide between now and pressure is recorded as systolic, referring to the maximum pressure when the heart contracts, over diastolic — the minimum pressure just before the next contraction. Ideally, it should be 120/80 millimeters of mercury (mmHg) or full guidelines, published in the journal Hypertension, aim to help medical practitioners detect and treat hypertension, but also contain valuable advice to help people control and manage their own blood pressure. Cheng-Han Chen, MD, board certified interventional cardiologist and medical director of the Structural Heart Program at MemorialCare Saddleback Medical Center in Laguna Hills, CA, who was not involved in developing the guidelines, told Medical News Today that:'The new blood pressure guidelines have several changes that emphasize earlier assessment and intervention of elevated blood pressure. In particular, it affirms the importance of lifestyle changes to help control blood pressure, such as with limiting sodium and alcohol intake, eating a heart healthy diet, maintaining physical activity, and managing weight and stress. This is a welcome message that will hopefully help us manage hypertension before it contributes to more serious cardiovascular disease.''Adults should have blood pressure measured at least once a year'To update their guidelines, the AHA carried out a comprehensive review of clinical studies, reviews and other evidence about hypertension published since February describe the guidelines as a 'living, working document updating current knowledge in the field of high blood pressure aimed at all practicing primary care and specialty clinicians who manage patients with hypertension.'Daniel W. Jones, MD, FAHA, volunteer chair of the guideline writing committee and a past-president of the AHA (2007-2008), dean and professor emeritus of the University of Mississippi School of Medicine in Jackson, MS, and a member of the writing committee for the 2017 high blood pressure guideline, told MNT that:'All adults should have their blood pressure measured at least once a year, more often for patients with any level of high blood pressure. Patients with high blood pressure who have a reading above 180/120 mmHg should seek advice from their clinician, urgently if there are symptoms of chest pain, shortness of breath, paralysis or speech difficulty.'New AHA hypertension guidelines: 5 key pointsAs part of the update, the AHA has also published a summary for patients of the top 10 things that people should know about high blood highlighted the key updates for 2025, which include:the goal of achieving a systolic blood pressure of 130 mmHg or below, and ideally of 120 mmHg, for adults with high blood pressuremore clear and robust evidence that intensive lowering of blood pressure reduces the risk of cognitive decline and dementia'in adults with an average blood pressure of 130/80 mm Hg [or more], and at lower 10-year cardiovascular disease risk defined by the PREVENT risk calculator of <7.5%, initiation of medication therapy to lower blood pressure in addition to lifestyle modification are recommended if average blood pressure remains 130/80 mmHg [or more] after an initial 3- to 6-month trial of lifestyle modification only'recommendations of 'moving toward an ideal limit of 1500 mg/day [milligrams per day]' for sodium consumptionthe advice to stop consuming, 'or at least to reduce alcohol intake to [less than] 1 drink/day for women and [less than] 2 drinks/day for men to prevent or treat elevated blood pressure and hypertension.'To this he added that 'patients with high blood pressure who have a reading above 180/120 mmHg should seek advice from their clinician, urgently if there are symptoms of chest pain, shortness of breath, paralysis or speech difficulty,' Jones to keep your blood pressure at a healthy levelThe AHA advises that anyone can develop high blood pressure, so it is important to have it checked regularly. It also states that although lifestyle and dietary changes can be effective in reducing blood pressure, many people will also need medications to get their blood pressure down to healthy levels.'These new guidelines will hopefully encourage clinicians to further recommend lifestyle changes to patients with elevated blood pressure. They also promote the use of a specific risk calculator to help us determine which patients may benefit most from medical therapy for hypertension,' Chen told MNT.'Some lifestyle recommendations for people trying to reduce blood pressure on their own include eating a heart healthy diet low in sodium, avoiding/eliminating alcohol intake, maintaining a healthy weight, getting regular physical activity, and managing their stress levels,' he guidelines also emphasize that losing at least 5% of your body weight if you have overweight or obesity can help lower or prevent hypertension, and advise that people can learn more about how to improve their heart and brain health from Life's Essential 8, which is also published by the AHA.'Nearly one of every two adults in the U.S. has high blood pressure, and it is the [number] one modifiable risk factor for [cardiovascular disease]. Every person has the opportunity to change the course of their future, their health — annual screening, prevention and early treatment for high blood pressure are the keys to a longer, healthier life.'– Daniel W. Jones, MD, FAHA
Reuters
22 minutes ago
- Reuters
Solar may account for half of new US electricity added this year, EIA says
NEW YORK, Aug 20 (Reuters) - Developers are on track to add 33 gigawatts of solar power in the U.S. this year, accounting for about half of the total new electricity generating capacity planned for the country in 2025, the Energy Information Administration said on Wednesday. If the plans are realized, large-scale solar power additions in the U.S. would reach a record high, said the EIA, which based its analysis on a survey of developers. New battery storage, which stores electricity from solar farms and other energy sources, may also hit a yearly record in 2025. Wind and natural gas power plants accounted for the rest of the capacity additions, the EIA said. Solar energy does not produce global warming emissions. That makes it central to plans by U.S. states to decarbonize, while also meeting record-high electricity demand brought on by Big Tech and other expanding industries. Many of the federal government financial incentives that propelled the development of solar power over the last several years, however, will disappear under the administration of President Donald Trump, adding uncertainty to future development of the technology. Texas, which last year surpassed California as the state with the most large-scale solar capacity, accounted for more than a quarter of the solar power developed so far in 2025. For the rest of the year, the Lone Star State plans for another 9.7 gigawatts of new solar capacity, or nearly half of all of U.S. solar planned for development over the time period. Texas' sunny weather, availability of large amounts of land and quickly-increasing power demand have drawn solar energy development.
