Nimisha Priya's execution: SC asks Centre to decide on granting travel permission to Yemen for negotiations
A Bench of Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta was hearing a plea filed by 'Save Nimisha Priya Action Council' seeking directions to the Union Ministry of External Affairs to use diplomatic channels to rescue the Indian national from the gallows.
Senior advocate R. Basant, representing the petitioner organisation, submitted that though Nimisha Priya's execution, scheduled on July 16, has been temporarily halted, but they would require Centre's permission to travel to Yemen to secure a pardon for the Indian citizen from the family of the victim, Talal Abdo Mahdi, who was allegedly murdered by her in 2017.
'Yemen is a country where not just anybody can go. There is a travel ban unless the government relaxes it. Let 2-3 members of the petitioner organisation and a representative of Kerala Islamic cleric be permitted to go to Yemen,' submitted Basant.
While declining to pass any judicial direction to the Centre, the Justice Nath-led Bench asked the petitioner to make a representation to the Union government seeking permission to travel to Yemen.
The senior counsel further urged the Union government to include its representative for negotiations with the victim's family by payment of blood money (diya), which is traditionally demanded in the death penalty cases under Islamic law. However, Attorney General of India R. Venkataramani, the highest law officer of the Centre, expressed an inability to make any such commitment.
'We don't want something counter-productive happening. We want this woman to come out safely," the Attorney General said.
The matter will be heard next on August 14.
Meanwhile, Abdelfattah Mehdi, brother of the deceased, has asserted that there can be no pardon for the crime, reiterating that Nimisha Priya has to be executed.
The Union Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) on Thursday said that India has been offering all possible assistance in the case and was in touch with some friendly governments to render all possible support.
"This is a very sensitive matter, and the Government of India has been offering all possible assistance in the case. We have provided legal assistance and also appointed a lawyer to assist the family. We have also arranged regular consular visits for the family, and we are in touch with both local authorities and the family members to resolve this issue," said MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal during a weekly media briefing in New Delhi.
The mother of Nimisha Priya, Prema Kumari (57), has been tirelessly campaigning to secure a waiver of the death penalty. She has also travelled to Sanaa to negotiate the payment of blood money to the victim's family. Her efforts have been supported by the Save Nimisha Priya International Action Council, a group of NRI social workers based in Yemen.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
9 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Why farmer coalition SKM opposes Centre's National Cooperation Policy 2025
The National Cooperation Policy (NCP) 2025, recently unveiled by Union Home and Cooperation Minister Amit Shah, has invited sharp criticism from farmer unions. The Samyukt Kisan Morcha (SKM), a national coalition of several farmers' organisations, has said that the policy violates the federal structure of the Constitution by attempting to centralise control over cooperative societies, a domain that constitutionally belongs to the states. Furthermore, SKM alleges that the NCP 2025 lacks any real vision to protect the rights and livelihoods of farmers, workers, and marginalised communities, and is instead a backdoor mechanism to facilitate the entry of corporations into agriculture. The farmers' coalition has called upon political parties, state governments, and the people of India to resist what it calls an 'attack on cooperative federalism.' The National Cooperation Policy 2025, introduced by Shah on July 24, aims to integrate 50 crore people into the cooperative sector and, as per the statement issued by the Cooperation Ministry, 'be a milestone in the cooperative movement of India for the next two decades from 2025-45'. Among other things, the notification gives expansive jurisdiction to the new Cooperation Ministry, from framing policy to coordinating cooperation activities across sectors and states to training personnel of cooperative departments and institutions. With a vision of 'Sahakar se Samriddhi' (Prosperity through Cooperation), the NCP 2025 is meant to promote 'cooperative-based economic development model', the notification states. There are three broad lines of criticism against the policy. Attack on federalism: Cooperative societies come under Entry 32 of the State List (List II) of the Seventh Schedule of the Indian Constitution. This gives state governments exclusive power to legislate and regulate cooperatives operating within their territory. The Supreme Court in 2021 struck down parts of the Constitution (97th Amendment) Act, 2011, which gave the Centre jurisdiction over cooperative societies operating within a state. A Bench of Justices R F Nariman, K M Joseph and B R Gavai had stated that the subject matter fell 'belongs wholly and exclusively to the State legislatures to legislate upon' and any change would require the ratification by at least one-half of the state legislatures as per Article 368(2) of the Constitution. The SKM has called this new policy the Centre's 'planned attack' on federalism since it bypasses the authority of state governments, and was introduced without their ratification. Backdoor for corporations: This centralisation of powers, the SKM says, is meant to provide corporations with a foothold into the agriculture sector in the guise of 'cooperative development'. 'SKM warns that the policy aims to integrate farmers into corporate-dominated systems through cooperative societies and Farmer Producer Organisations (FPOs), thereby allowing agribusinesses to dictate prices and markets,' said Jagmohan Singh, general secretary of Bharti Kisan union (BKU) Dakaunda. 'This corporate takeover will lead to widespread exploitation of farmers, workers, and all those engaged in agriculture, services, trade, and manufacturing,' he added. While the text of the policy itself does not mention corporations, it delineates several functional avenues — such as entry into emerging sectors, cooperative-led export platforms, and digital ecosystems — that are typically dominated by corporate entities. This, critics say, will open the door for indirect corporate involvement through service provision, platform partnerships, infrastructure development, and technology integration. Not doing enough for the marginalised: According to the SKM, the NCP 2025 lacks any concrete perspective to protect the rights of farmers and workers, particularly regarding livelihood issues, Minimum Support Price (MSP), minimum wage, and fair surplus distribution from cooperatives. The policy has no roadmap for modernising agriculture, establishing agro-based industries, or building cooperative marketing networks. It also ignores the need for producer and consumer cooperatives, collective farming, and the use of science and technology to enhance productivity and reduce costs. While the policy makes tall claims about helping tribals, Dalits, and women, it offers no concrete measures for their empowerment or welfare, SKM said. SKM urges the Union Government to empower state governments, respect Cooperative Federalism, and allocate 50% of Centre's resources to support modernisation of cooperatives at the state level. Corporate entry into agriculture and agro-industries should be strictly regulated to ensure MSP for farmers and minimum wages for workers. To resist NCP 2025, the SKM is mobilising farmers and workers across India. Having already called for a nationwide protest on August 13, 2025, under the banner 'Corporations Quit India', SKM has now appealed to all political parties and state governments to join the protest to oppose the policy. The August 13 agitation also aims to press for long-standing demands such as guaranteed MSP based on the Swaminathan Commission's recommendations, loan waivers, a halt to privatisation and forced land acquisitions, opposition to WTO provisions, and resistance to the India-US trade deal.
New Indian Express
11 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
‘May sell oil to India some day': Amid tariff rift, Trump says US to develop Pakistan's oil reserves
Just hours after hitting India with steep tariffs, US President Donald Trump revealed a new trade agreement with Pakistan focused on developing the country's oil reserves. In a pointed remark, he suggested Islamabad might sell oil to New Delhi "some day." In a post on Truth Social, Trump stated that the US and Pakistan were currently in the process of selecting an oil company for the partnership. "We have just concluded a Deal with the Country of Pakistan, whereby Pakistan and the United States will work together on developing their massive Oil Reserves. We are in the process of choosing the Oil Company that will lead this Partnership. Who knows, maybe they'll be selling Oil to India some day!" Trump wrote. The US President's post came hours after he announced a 25% on India and an additional penalty for India's purchases of Russian energy and military equipment. Trump's surprise announcement came a day after Indian officials said that a US trade team would visit from August 25 to negotiate a trade deal. The announcement is being seen as a pressure tactic to get New Delhi to agree to demands made by the US, which has, in recent days, got favourable trade deals with major partners like Japan, the UK and the European Union. Commenting on the development, New Delhi said it is studying the implications of these tariffs and is still hopeful of concluding a fair, balanced and mutually beneficial trade agreement. "India and the US have been engaged in negotiations on concluding a fair, balanced and mutually beneficial bilateral trade agreement over the last few months. We remain committed to that objective," it said. Meanwhile, Trump, in a Truth Social post, further stated that he had conversations on trade deals with leaders of many countries, noting "all of whom want to make the United States extremely happy." "We are very busy in the White House today working on Trade Deals. I have spoken to the Leaders of many countries, all of whom want to make the United States 'extremely happy.' I will be meeting with the South Korean Trade Delegation this afternoon. South Korea is right now at a 25% Tariff, but they have an offer to buy down those Tariffs. I will be interested in hearing what that offer is," the post read. He also noted that many countries are currently making offers to the US for "Tariff reduction." "Likewise, other Countries are making offers for a Tariff reduction. All of this will help reduce our Trade Deficit in a very major way. A full report will be released at the appropriate time. Thank you for your attention to this matter. MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN!" it further read.
Scroll.in
11 minutes ago
- Scroll.in
Pune: FIR against 7 for harassing Kargil veteran's family over citizenship
The Pune Police on Wednesday filed a case against seven persons for unlawful assembly after a Hindutva group allegedly barged into a house belonging to the family of a Kargil War veteran and accused them of being undocumented migrants from Bangladesh, the Hindustan Times reported. The family claimed that a mob of about 80 persons allegedly affiliated to a Hindutva group forcibly entered their home on Saturday night and accused them of being 'illegal' migrants. Irshad Shaikh, whose elder brother Hakimuddin Shaikh served in the Indian Army during the 1999 Kargil War and currently lives in Uttar Pradesh, said that his family had been living in Pune for more than six decades, the newspaper reported. 'We tried to explain that our family has deep roots here, and several of us have served in the armed forces, but they continued hurling accusations,' the Hindustan Times quoted Irshad Shaikh as saying. The mob abused the family and demanded to see Aadhaar and other identity documents to prove their Indian citizenship, the family claimed, adding that some of them alleged that their papers were fake. Women and children were also allegedly forced to produce documents. Irshad Shaikh also claimed that two men in plainclothes had identified themselves as police officers but did not intervene when the mob allegedly harassed the family. The family said that they were taken to the Chandannagar Police Station and made to wait for hours. Eventually, they were told to return the next day or risk being declared as 'Bangladeshi nationals'. After seeking support from social activists and lawyers, the family met Pune Police Commissioner Amitesh Kumar on Wednesday and demanded action against the mob, the Hindustan Times reported. 'He [Kumar] assured us that stringent action is being taken against anti-social elements,' the newspaper quoted Irshad Shaikh as saying. Kumar told the Hindustan Times that a first information report had been filed for unlawful assembly. 'On receiving a call about suspected Bangladeshi nationals, police found people raising slogans outside the house,' he said. 'The mob's actions are under scrutiny, and based on fresh statements, more sections may be added or a separate FIR may be filed.' Deputy Commissioner of Police Somay Munde also told The Indian Express that information had been received on Saturday about 'suspected illegal Bangladeshi nationals' in the area. 'So we went to the spot [on Saturday],' Munde said. 'Some of their documents were checked and some were brought to the police station. They were released as it was getting late and were called back the next morning.' The officer claimed that the action was taken at night 'as sometimes in these combing operations suspects flee'. Kumar also claimed that most police personnel were in uniform when the incident took place but did not rule out the possibility that some were in plainclothes. The family's documents were verified and found to be in order, he added. Irshad Shaikh said that his family had valid documents to prove their citizenship, adding: 'If necessary, we can trace our citizenship back 400 years.' He also told The Indian Express that his family had a 130-year history of serving in the Army. 'My own brother Hakimuddin joined the Bombay Sappers in 1982 in Pune and was posted across India after his training,' the newspaper quoted Irshad Shaikh as saying. 'He fought in the Kargil War and retired in 2000. He resides in Pratapgarh in Uttar Pradesh.' Meanwhile, Hakimuddin Shaikh told the Hindustan Times that it was 'disheartening' that a family with a history of military service had to face such humiliation. 'If required, I'll personally speak to the authorities to seek accountability,' he added. Since the April 22 Pahalgam terror attack, Bengali-speaking migrant workers have been rounded up by the police in several states ruled by the Bharatiya Janata Party and asked to prove that they are Indian citizens. In some cases, individuals who were mistakenly sent to Bangladesh returned to the country after state authorities in India proved that they were Indians. In May, the Union home ministry directed the states and Union Territories to verify the credentials of persons suspected to be undocumented migrants from Bangladesh and Myanmar.
