logo
Richard Satchwell trial: Gardaí ignored ‘red flags' in Tina Satchwell murder investigation

Richard Satchwell trial: Gardaí ignored ‘red flags' in Tina Satchwell murder investigation

Irish Times30-05-2025

'Red flags' emerged soon after the disappearance of
Tina Satchwell
that were 'simply ignored' by gardaí, the murder trial of her husband Richard Satchwell heard.
Concerns about the Garda investigation into Ms Satchwell's disappearance were raised in the closing stages of the murder trial of her 58-year-old
husband
.
His defence barrister, Brendan Grehan SC, said in his closing speech to the trial that the case was full of 'what ifs' and 'a lot of failures' by gardaí and it was 'simply beyond me' why gardaí were not in the Satchwell home soon after Ms Satchwell went missing in 2017.
He suspected it was also simply beyond those gardaí became involved at a later stage in the investigation, he said.
READ MORE
[
'Tina had no way of getting away from him': The full story of the Richard Satchwell murder trial
Opens in new window
]
[
'Tina was portrayed in a way that is not true to who she was': Tina Satchwell's family describe 'kind, loving and gentle soul'
Opens in new window
]
The defence lawyer's opinion appeared to be endorsed by forensic archaeologist Dr Niamh McCullagh, who was asked in 2021 – four years after Ms Satchwell's disappearance – to review the files in the case.
The review was requested by Supt Annmarie Twomey, who was not involved in the investigation until she was asked to take charge of it in August 2021.
She and Det David Kelleher, who was also assigned to the investigation in 2021, brought what Mr Grehan described as 'new energy' to it.
He said matters had progressed, 'though extremely cautiously', and said he still wondered at the reason for its 'pedestrian' pace up to October 2023 when Ms Satchwell's remains were uncovered.
Supt Twomey had said, while gardaí believed by February 2022 that Ms Satchwell was dead and had never left her home and, by August 2022, that Satchwell should be arrested, there were 56 other lines of inquiry that had to be exhausted first.
There were about 60 reported sightings of Ms Satchwell in Ireland and abroad after her disappearance, the trial heard.
Dr McCullagh told the jury of research into domestic homicides that showed they often involved a pattern – as happened in the
Satchwell
case – of a false narrative and a missing-person report.
Her own research into cases of 'concealment homicide' in Ireland found that most female victims were found within a kilometre of their home.
[
The full story of the Richard Satchwell murder trial
Opens in new window
]
Mr Grehan said such findings hardly came as news to gardaí or to many others. Gardaí 'hardly needed' to be told what happened when a wife went missing, he said, which was that a missing-person report is 'not taken at face value' and 'every police force in the world looks at the husband'.
He expected most people would hope, if they ever went missing, for a 'greater level of inquisitiveness' from gardaí.
Brendan Grehan, left, and solicitor Eddie Burke outside Central Criminal Court in Dublin. Photograph: Niall Carson/PA Wire
Mr Grehan accepted that
Satchwell
was the author of – and biggest contributor to – the delay in finding his wife's remains but said there was 'more than enough blame for that delay to go around'. That influenced the manner in which some of the investigation was dealt with, he said.
Dr McCullagh pointed to a 'red flag' at the
Satchwell home
during a search of the property by gardaí in June 2017: evidence of 'home renovations' and of a new red brick wall at the side of the stairs.
There was no invasive search of the property at that point but gardaí seized a laptop and other items.
An examination of that laptop showed another potential red flag: a YouTube video about the interaction of quicklime, which can disguise decomposition odours, with water was watched twice on March 24th, 2017.
The trial heard the laptop was examined by gardaí in 2021 but it was unclear from the evidence whether there was an earlier examination of it.
The jury did not hear a detailed explanation about why the June 2017 search of the property was not invasive.
Supt Twomey said she did not know what the focus of the investigation was at that stage. It was still a missing-person investigation. She also noted laptops and other items were seized from the
Youghal property.
After her review of the files, Dr McCullagh recommended an invasive excavation of the house, to include the use of ground radar technology and a cadaver dog.
Supt Twomey acted on that recommendation, and a specialist team, including gardaí, Dr McCullagh, a forensic anthropologist and a cadaver dog, entered the property on October 10th, 2023.
The cadaver dog showed interest in the area under the stairs. Det Brian Barry and a builder noted different concrete in the area under the stairs and poor brick work in the red brick wall alongside the stairs.
The concrete was then broken up and black plastic was observed in what turned out to be a grave site about a metre deep.
A painstaking excavation was then undertaken by hand and, on the evening of October 11th, the skeletal remains of Tina Satchwell were found.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Former TD Colm Keaveney's drug-driving case adjourned for 11th time
Former TD Colm Keaveney's drug-driving case adjourned for 11th time

Irish Times

timean hour ago

  • Irish Times

Former TD Colm Keaveney's drug-driving case adjourned for 11th time

The case against former Galway East TD Colm Keaveney who has been accused of drug driving and having no insurance has been adjourned for the 11th time. His defence solicitor informed the court there were medical issues that needed to be addressed. Mr Keaveney, a former Labour and Fianna Fáil TD, was present in Tuam Court on Tuesday when his solicitor Gearóid Geraghty informed Judge James Faughnan there would now be a plea to all matters. Mr Keaveney (54), of the Milltown Road, Tuam, Co Galway faces a charge of driving while under the influence of cocaine, as well as a no insurance charge, after he was stopped and arrested in Tuam on June 12th, 2023. The defendant has also been charged with driving without insurance on July 25th, 2023 at Vicar Street, Tuam when stopped by a garda. READ MORE Three days later he was again detected by the same garda for allegedly driving without insurance at the N17 Plaza in Tuam. Initially, the court was told the defendant would be contesting the drug-driving charge on the grounds there was an inordinate delay of three months between the Medical Bureau of Road Safety testing his blood sample for alcohol, and the test for drugs and that the sample remained unsealed in the meantime. However, Mr Geraghty told Tuam Court a plea would be entered to all offences as he sought a final adjournment in the matter. He said 'something has arisen that I want to deal with' as he applied for the adjournment. 'There will be a plea and it won't trouble the court. There are a number of medical issues that need to be addressed,' he said. Judge Faughnan said there would be no further dates available to the defendant and agreed that the matter will be put back to the September 9th sitting of the court for finalisation.

Highest number of abuse allegations in 16 years received by Catholic Church's safeguarding body
Highest number of abuse allegations in 16 years received by Catholic Church's safeguarding body

Irish Times

timean hour ago

  • Irish Times

Highest number of abuse allegations in 16 years received by Catholic Church's safeguarding body

The Catholic Church 's safeguarding board received the highest number of abuse allegations in a single year since it began publishing annual reports 16 years ago. There was a 50 per cent increase in the number of new clerical abuse allegations received by the National Board for Safeguarding Children in the year to March 31st, according to its latest annual report which has just been published. The board received 385 clerical child abuse allegations in the year compared with 252 in the previous year. The vast majority of the new allegations relate to five decades – 1950s-1990s – with 332 or 86 per cent of the new 385 allegations reported in the year covering those 50 years. READ MORE Just three of the new abuse allegations reported related to the past 25 years, though 47 of the new allegations, or 12 per cent, did not have any definite time frame attributed to them. By contrast, in the report for the previous year to the end of March 2024, the number of clerical child sex abuse allegations increased by just one on the previous year, to 252, compared with 251 in the year to March 2023. The board chief executive Aidan Gordon said the large increase in new allegations related to the scoping inquiry report on abuse at schools that was published last September. He said the increase in allegations received by the board occurred 'predominantly' from September 2024 and 'coincided with the release of the Report of the Scoping Inquiry into Historical Sexual Abuse in Day and Boarding Schools run by religious (members of religious orders) and the subsequent media coverage'. 'These events in September 2024 appear to have given individuals renewed strength to tell of their experiences,' he wrote. [ 'Shocking, shocking:' Justice Sean Ryan on the abuses of children uncovered in his report Opens in new window ] 'While this is undoubtedly an extremely difficult undertaking for those who have suffered any type of abuse as a child, it is good to be able to begin to address that trauma and we are grateful for the production of such a comprehensive and far-reaching report by Mary O'Toole SC,' he said, referring to the lawyer who carried out the scoping inquiry. Her report found that almost 2,400 allegations of historical sexual abuse were recorded by 308 schools run by religious orders across Ireland with allegations made against 884 accused. Some 182 survivors spoke to the inquiry about what happened to them over the decades from the early 1960s to the early 1990s. Of the total 385 abuse allegations received by the board up to March 31st last, 338 were made against members of the clergy, with 44 made against diocesan priests. Of the total allegations received, 291 concerned sexual abuse, with 55 relating to physical abuse, while other allegations concerned boundary violations where someone's personal space was invaded, emotional abuse and neglect. The worst decade for newly reported abuse allegations was the 1970s, from which 111 allegations were made. This was followed by the 1980s, which gave rise to 92 allegations, followed by the 1960s with 81 allegations and the 1950s with 34. Fourteen allegations related to incidents from the 1990s, while there were no allegations for the period covering the 2000s. There was just one relating to the 2010s and two in the 2020s to date. The accused clergy in these latest figures number 376, of whom 241 are dead. There were 34 in prison, while 52 had been laicised or were out of ministry. [ Commission on abuse in schools must examine how seminary training formed perpetrators Opens in new window ] Meanwhile, in the wake of the scoping inquiry report last September, a high-level Inter-Departmental Group (IDG) was appointed by the then minister for education Norma Foley to examine its recommendations and to draft terms of reference for a commission of investigation into schools. It is understood the group has reported to the Minister for Education Helen McEntee and she is in consultation with the Attorney General before bringing recommendations to Government on what should happen next.

Former death row inmate ‘Sunny' Jacobs never let tragedies define her, funeral hears
Former death row inmate ‘Sunny' Jacobs never let tragedies define her, funeral hears

Irish Times

timean hour ago

  • Irish Times

Former death row inmate ‘Sunny' Jacobs never let tragedies define her, funeral hears

Sonia 'Sunny' Jacobs, a former death row inmate who was later released, always believed 'freedom is a gift you give yourself', her daughter has told her funeral. Ms Jacobs (77) died last week in a house fire along with her carer, Kevin Kelly (31), at her isolated cottage in Glenicmurrin in Connemara, Co Galway. New York-born Ms Jacobs became a world-famous advocate against the death penalty following her release from a Florida prison in 1992. She had been sentenced to death, later commuted to 40 years in jail, for the murder of two prison officers shot in February 1976. Her then-partner Jesse Tafero was executed after being convicted of murder. In 1998 she met Peter Pringle, who had been wrongly sentenced to death for the murder of two gardaí in Ballaghaderreen, Co Roscommon in 1980. His death sentence was commuted and he was released from prison in 1995 having served 16 years for murders he did not commit. READ MORE The couple were married in 2011, and he died in 2023. Former death row prisoners Sonia 'Sunny' Jacobs and Peter Pringle. File photograph: Dara Mac Dónaill/ The Irish Times Their daughter Christina told her funeral service by video link on Monday that her mother believed everybody had the freedom to free themselves from their past and their present circumstances. 'You can change them by changing how you behave within those circumstances,' she said. 'The main thing is that no one can take away the freedom to love another. She truly lived by that. Through every trial and triumph she chose love.' She said her mother 'chose to keep her heart open' and 'let the light shine out'. She described her mother as 'our teacher, our protector and our friend', who demonstrated to others how to live with compassion and courage. [ The life and tragic death of Sunny Jacobs: how a US death row survivor ended up in Connemara Opens in new window ] She was a 'radiant soul' to everyone who knew her and she cared deeply about her family, animals and those who were wrongly incarcerated. 'Her love was boundless and without conditions. She gave of herself freely, quietly and with so much strength,' said Christina. The funeral service was held at Shannon Crematorium in Co Clare. In a written statement read out to the congregation, Christina and her brother Eric said their mother was 'our rock, our constant guide in our lives'. Ms Jacobs never needed to raise her voice to make her point known. She faced her share of challenges in life, but she never let the tragedies in her life define her. 'She lived with purpose, grace and determination, which inspired everybody around her,' they added. 'She once said that everybody gets challenged in life. You can spend your life looking backwards or make the decision to keep going. 'That's the choice I made.' 'She was a woman who chose to keep going, who chose love and she gave that love freely to her family, her friends and to anyone who needed a bit of light in their lives.' Ms Jacobs spent five years in solitary confinement on death row. Her death sentence was commuted to life in prison in 1981. Two years later, she won her appeal against her sentence and was released from prison after 16 years and 233 days. Florida state prosecutors were entitled to seek a retrial, but they instead entered into a special plea bargain for which Ms Jacobs did not admit guilt but admitted the prosecutors had incriminating evidence against her. She later claimed she agreed to this plea under duress.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store