Why Pakistan's middle class backs terror while poor suffer from it
Team TOI Plus
TIMESOFINDIA.COM
Updated: May 18, 2025, 18:41 IST IST
A 2012 study, which has acquired new relevance after Pahalgam and Operation Sindoor, reveals that Pakistan's urban middle class — shielded from violence and ideologically invested — sustains extremist groups
For years, the dominant explanation for terrorism in Pakistan has rested on a simple idea: that poverty breeds radicalism. It is a narrative among global policy experts that has shaped the direction of billions of dollars in international aid and development programmes.
Now, with Pahalgam and India's Operation Sindoor reigniting the debate over cross-border militancy, a 2012 Princeton-led study has acquired fresh relevance, revealing that the true drivers of extremism may lie closer to comfort than crisis.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hans India
a minute ago
- Hans India
Delhi court reserves verdict on issuing notice to Robert Vadra in land deal case
New Delhi: A Delhi court on Thursday reserved its decision on issuing a notice to businessman Robert Vadra, son-in-law of former Congress President Sonia Gandhi, in connection with a money laundering case linked to a land deal in Haryana's Shikohpur. The Rouse Avenue Court will likely pronounce its verdict on July 31 regarding the issuance of a notice to Vadra, the husband of Congress MP Priyanka Gandhi Vadra. The Enforcement Directorate (ED) had filed a prosecution complaint under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), claiming that Vadra's Skylight Hospitality 'fraudulently' purchased 3.53 acres of land situated in the village of Shikohpur in Haryana's Gurugram district through 'false declaration'. During the hearing, advocate Zoheb Hossain, appearing for the ED, stated that the sale deed falsely declared a payment of Rs 7.5 crore, whereas in reality, no such payment was made. This amount was paid at a later stage to evade stamp duty, a fact that has been confirmed by key witnesses, added Hossain. Further, the federal anti-money laundering agency claimed that Vadra, 'through his personal influence', obtained a commercial license on the land purchased. As per the ED, the land was later sold to DLF at a higher price, and this aspect of the case is still under investigation. In April this year, Vadra was questioned in multiple rounds by the ED, during which his statement was also recorded. The land purchase deal in question was executed in February 2008 when Congress was at the helm in Haryana, and Bhupinder Singh Hooda was the Chief Minister. The mutation process, which usually takes months, was done the next day. Months later, Vadra received a permit to develop a housing society on the land, and the value of the plot increased. He sold it to DLF in June at Rs 58 crore. Suspecting the proceeds to be part of a money laundering scheme, the ED has been probing the trail behind the windfall gains. In October 2012, IAS officer Ashok Khemka (now retired), who was then posted as the Director General of Land Consolidation and Land Records-cum-Inspector-General of Registration of Haryana, cancelled the land purchase deal, citing procedural irregularities. Later in 2013, an in-house government panel gave a clean chit to both Vadra as well as DLF. When the BJP-led government came to power, an FIR was registered by the Haryana Police against former Chief Minister Hooda, Vadra, and others.
The Hindu
a minute ago
- The Hindu
Operation Sindoor fallout: Chinese-made surveillance gear banned, aerial monitoring boosted for Independence Day
In the wake of Operation Sindoor, this year's Independence Day celebrations will feature enhanced aerial monitoring and a complete ban on the usage of 'Made In China' surveillance equipment in and around the Red Fort in the national capital. With Prime Minister Nadrendra Modi set to make his Independence Day address from the ramparts of Red Fort on August 15, the venue was taken over by the Ministry of Defence from July 15. This year, more guests are being invited to attended the Independence Day celebrations in comparison to previous years, sources said. Security agencies, intelligence agencies, and Defence Ministry officials who attended a recent high-level meeting regarding security at Red Fort held a detailed discussion on possible security breaches through unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) and unmanned aircraft systems (UAS). Anti-drone systems 'Installation of anti-drone devices and radar systems near the Red Fort and possible threats were discussed in detail with defence forces. Ministry of Defence will be deploying anti-drone systems to stop any aerial breach and the Indian Air Force will be on high alert. Drones are among the key security concerns. We have also given clear instructions to the vendors installing CCTVs in and around the venue to not install any 'Made in China' equipment for surveillance purposes,' said an official. The Indian government has banned Chinese surveillance equipment, including CCTV cameras, citing potential data leakage risks. Another official said that aerial security is a major concern this Independence Day. Teams of experts have visited the Red Fort and surrounding areas to assess the minute details of all possible security threats. Another high-level meeting has been called on Friday to discuss the preparations for the event in detail, including the security aspect. Operation Sindoor was a drone-centric war, with Pakistan using loitering munitions and swarm drones. These attempts, however, were effectively neutralised by India's comprehensive and multilayered air defence architecture. Smart video surveillance Security agencies said that they will be installing intelligent video surveillance systems, including features such as a vehicle number plate recognition system, face detection, people movement counting, tripwires, audio detection, defocus, and spotting intrusions and abandoned or missing objects. The advanced facial recognition system facility on live cameras as well as on recorded videos will help to detect any matches with faces on the government's watch list database and provide alerts to the control room.
The Hindu
a minute ago
- The Hindu
We will never demand for coalition government in Tamil Nadu: CPI(M) P. Shanmugam
'We will not demand for ministerial postings or coalition government from our alliance partners until we form a government on our own,' said Communist Party of India (Marxist) State secretary P. Shanmugam. Addressing press during a party event in Ramanathapuram on Thursday, he added that AIADMK general secretary Edappadi K. Palaniswamy, in frustration that no one was accepting his invitation for alliance, seemed to be contradicting his own statements. 'The BJP which is one of the parties in alliance with AIADMK has set a precedent in other States that it will not simply let off their partners. AIADMK, despite knowing that there is danger to their existence, continues to be with them,' he stated. Condemning Prime Minister Narendra Modi's visit to United Kingdom on the days of Parliament's monsoon session, he said that Mr. Modi knowing that key issues like Pahalgam terror, operation Sindoor, among others were to be discussed, has deliberately avoided attending the sessions. 'By dodging the questions from the opposition, he tries to avoid being held accountable for his actions,' he noted. Further, he said that BJP and its affiliates should stop communalizing the police interrogation of Madurai Adheenam. 'As he made a communal remark regarding an accident, a case was booked against him. The investigation is only regarding that. Giving it a religious colour is condemnable,' he added. Also, he insisted the State government to expedite implementing the Cauvery-Vaigai-Gundar project. By implementing the project, the water needs of areas like Ramanathapuram and Pudukkottai could be fulfilled, he added.
