Why Pakistan's middle class backs terror while poor suffer from it
Team TOI Plus
TIMESOFINDIA.COM
Updated: May 18, 2025, 18:41 IST IST
A 2012 study, which has acquired new relevance after Pahalgam and Operation Sindoor, reveals that Pakistan's urban middle class — shielded from violence and ideologically invested — sustains extremist groups
For years, the dominant explanation for terrorism in Pakistan has rested on a simple idea: that poverty breeds radicalism. It is a narrative among global policy experts that has shaped the direction of billions of dollars in international aid and development programmes.
Now, with Pahalgam and India's Operation Sindoor reigniting the debate over cross-border militancy, a 2012 Princeton-led study has acquired fresh relevance, revealing that the true drivers of extremism may lie closer to comfort than crisis.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
6 minutes ago
- Time of India
Experts Hail PM Modi's Visit as Key Step in Rebuilding India-Maldives Trust
'Stopped India-Pakistan Nuclear War': Trump's Explosive Claim, Repeats 'Five Jets Were Shot Down' US President Donald Trump has once again claimed that five fighter jets were shot down during the India-Pakistan conflict following the April 2025 Pahalgam terror attack. Trump also claimed that he personally intervened to stop a potential nuclear war between the two nations, using trade leverage. However, his comments have stirred controversy in India, especially as he did not clarify which side lost jets, nor did he provide any evidence. India had earlier confirmed that Operation Sindoor was a targeted, non-escalatory strike on terror camps in PoK. Trump's repeated claims, now adding a dramatic jet loss tally, raise questions about foreign intervention, disinformation, and global narratives. Was it an exaggeration or a classified truth?#india #pakistan #donaldtrump #opsindoor #pok #trumpclaims #operationsindoor #indiausrelations #indiapakconflict #fighterjets #nuclearwar #toi #toibharat #bharat #trending #breakingnews #indianews 16.2K views | 3 hours ago
Time of India
23 minutes ago
- Time of India
Lok Sabha LoP Rahul Gandhi takes jibe at PM Modi over US President's ceasefire claims
Congress leader and Lok Sabha Leader of Opposition (LoP) Rahul Gandhi on Wednesday hit out at Prime Minister Narendra Modi for his silence over repeated " ceasefire " claims made by US President Donald Trump . Suggesting that one can't hide from reality, he said that the entire world knows that Trump announced a "ceasefire" between India and Pakistan. Explore courses from Top Institutes in Please select course: Select a Course Category Design Thinking Degree Digital Marketing Artificial Intelligence MBA Finance CXO Others healthcare MCA Healthcare Cybersecurity Data Science Data Analytics Project Management Product Management Technology Data Science others Operations Management Public Policy Management Leadership PGDM Skills you'll gain: Duration: 25 Weeks IIM Kozhikode CERT-IIMK PCP DTIM Async India Starts on undefined Get Details "How can the Prime Minister give a statement? Kya bolenge PM, ki Trump ne karwaya hai? (What will he say? That Trump has announced it? He can't say it, but it is the truth. The entire world knows that Trump has announced a ceasefire. We can't hide from reality," Gandhi told reporters. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Join new Free to Play WWII MMO War Thunder War Thunder Play Now Undo "This is not only about a ceasefire. There are several major issues that we would like to discuss related to defence, defence manufacturing, and Operation Sindoor. The condition is not normal; the entire nation knows," he added. Intensifying his attack, Gandhi stated that the Prime Minister has not been able to provide a single response to Trump's claims about a ceasefire, which he has reiterated 25 times so far. Live Events "Those who call themselves 'deshbhakt' have run away. The Prime Minister is unable to give a single statement. Trump has claimed 25 times that he has announced a ceasefire. Who is he? This is not his work. However, the Prime Minister didn't respond once. This is reality. Can't hide from it," the Congress MP said. "They have destroyed our foreign policy. You can hardly count on your fingers the number of countries that have supported us. No one has supported us," Gandhi added. This comes after a recent statement made by Donald Trump, where he repeated his claims of "stopping the war between India and Pakistan" in the name of trade deals. "We have stopped wars between India and Pakistan. They were probably going to end up in a nuclear war. They shot down five planes in the last attack. It was back and forth, back and forth. I called them and I said no more trade if you do this. They are both powerful nuclear nations. Who knows where that would have ended up, and I stopped it," Trump said. Earlier in the day, Senior Congress leader Jairam Ramesh lambasted the Narendra Modi government over its refusal to rebut the claims made by US President Donald Trump of announcing a "ceasefire" between India and Pakistan. He said that the claims of a "ceasefire" made by Trump have reached their silver jubilee with the US president reiterating them 25 times in the last 73 days. The Congress leader attacked the centre for not providing a definite date for discussing the Pahalgam terror attack and Operation Sindoor that followed. "As the Modi government continues in its refusal to give firm dates for a debate on Pahalgam-Sindoor in Parliament and as the Modi government persists in its refusal to commit to a reply by the PM in the debate, President Trump reaches the silver jubilee, the quarter century mark on his claims. He has trumpeted 25 times in the last 73 days, but the Prime Minister of India is totally quiet - finding time only to travel abroad and to destabilise democratic institutions at home," Ramesh, General Secretary incharge of Communications in Congress, posted on X.
NDTV
24 minutes ago
- NDTV
Farmers Protest To Justice Varma Case, When J Dhankhar Crossed 'Lakshman Rekha'
New Delhi: Jagdeep Dhankhar resigned as Vice President Monday and brought the curtain down on a three-year term filled with controversies, and moments when he crossed the ' laxman rekha ', that mythical red line. It was an unexpected resignation, one triggered by a government irritated with the Rajya Sabha Chairperson's decision to accept an opposition-backed motion - when an identical motion, championed by the ruling BJP, had been presented in the Lok Sabha - to impeach Justice Yashwant Varma. The fact Mr Dhankhar, who has had several run-ins with the opposition, both as the Veep and, earlier, as the Governor of Bengal, accepted the motion (he must have known about the Lok Sabha notice) was surprising. The fact he did so without informing the BJP has been seen as puzzling. Either way, the result, after whispered talks between high-ranking members of the government, was a brief 'I resign' letter, shared first on X at 9.25 pm, to President Droupadi Murmu. Government sources told NDTV there were multiple instances of Mr Dhankhar crossing the red line. Jagdeep Dhankhar And Raghav Chadha In December 2023 the Rajya Sabha Privileges Committee found the Aam Aadmi Party's Raghav Chadha - suspended from August 11 for not following House rules - guilty of presenting misleading facts to the media. However, his suspension was ended by Mr Dhankhar, which irked the government. The motion said Mr Chadha's 114-day suspension was considered 'sufficient punishment' but, before it was passed, Mr Dhankhar told the House the committee found the AAP leader guilty on both counts. The complaint against Mr Chadha - that he had proposed a Select Committee to consider the contentious Delhi services bill and named four MPs, without consent - had been sent by Mr Dhankhar. ... And Raghav Chadha, Again Sources also referred NDTV to the issue invovling Mr Chadha's allotted bungalow, in central Delhi, as a parliamentarian. The AAP leader was given a bungalow a level above his status as a first-time MP. But when the allottment was cancelled, Mr Chadha refused to vacate and moved the courts, securing a stay from the Delhi High Court. Earlier a trial court had ordered the AAP leader to leave the bungalow. By appealing the trial court order - which said he did not have an absolute right to continue living in the bungalow - the Rajya Sabha Secretariat had been stopped from evicting the AAP leader. The matter is still being heard by the court. ... And The Opposition During his time as the Veep Mr Dhankhar frequently clashed with the opposition; he was accused of being partisan towards the ruling BJP by denying them a chance to speak in Parliament. In fact, those accusations prompted last year's no-confidence bid. Since then, sources said the government has been concerned about a shift in his functioning, one that now allows opposition leaders a greater voice. NDTV was referred to Congress boss Mallikarjun Kharge being allowed to attack the BJP over Operation Sindoor on Monday. The attack itself would have been dismissed, but Mr Dhankhar allowing it to continue, despite the government having expressed willingness for a formal debate, was not appreciated, sources said. Sources also said the government was displeased with Mr Dhankhar saying he would take up the issue with the leaders of various parties, including the BJP. That prompted BJP boss JP Nadda to formally contradict the Vice President, not a good fit for the government. ... And Farmers Sources also said Mr Dhankhar taking on the government over farmers' protests for a minimum support price - which has rumbled on since August 2020 - was not well received. In December Mr Dhankhar, speaking at a public event, posed searching questions of Agriculture Minister Shivraj Chouhan. "I request you to please tell me, what was promised to the farmer? Why was the promise not fulfilled? There was a movement last year... there is a movement this year too. The wheel of time is turning..." Mr Dhankhar, who comes from a farming background, also prodded the government on direct cash subsidy for fertilisers and wanted inflation be considered for financial assistance, like it is for MPs. ... And The Supreme Court Earlier this month Mr Dhankhar hit out at the judiciary over the Justice Yashwant Varma row. He called for a criminal investigation to be launched into the recovery of the cash, and, at his Shakespearean best, warned the judiciary to "beware the Ides of March"
