Rewriting the past: Indonesia's new history books spook scholars
Scholars fear his government could use the exercise to rewrite history and cover up past abuses.
Draft volume summaries and a chapter outline seen by AFP do not include any specific section on the 1998 violence.
A summary of Suharto's rule in the volume dedicated to him only mentions how "student demonstrations... became a factor" in his resignation.
"The writing was flawed since the beginning," said Andi Achdian, historian at Jakarta's National University, who has seen the outline.
"It has a very strong tendency to whitewash history."
Suharto ruled Indonesia with an iron fist for more than three decades after grabbing power in the wake of a 1965-6 massacre.
The culture minister overseeing the government's history project, Fadli Zon, told lawmakers last week the account "does not discuss May '98... because it's small".
Neither does it promise to include most of the "gross human rights violations" acknowledged by former president Joko Widodo in 2023.
Jajat Burhanudin, a project editor, contradicted Fadli and dismissed concerns, telling AFP the new volumes would include 1998 events, with the draft outline just a "trigger for discussion".
Officials say the new historical account is needed to strengthen Indonesian identity, but warned that any omission about its darkest past will raise eyebrows over objectivity.
"What is feared is that... the cases that have been accepted by the previous government to be resolved will be ignored," said Marzuki Darusman, a former attorney general and head of a civil society coalition opposed to the volumes.
'Updated' history
While it remains unclear how the government plans to use the books, Jajat said the volumes could be used as "one of the main sources" for history books taught in schools.
Neither historian Susanto Zuhdi, who is helming the project, nor the presidential palace responded to requests for comment.
The revisionist history garnered renewed scrutiny after the culture minister questioned whether mass rape had occurred at the end of Suharto's rule.
Ethnic Chinese Indonesians bore the brunt of the bloodshed during the riots, when rape squads -- purportedly led by army thugs -- roamed Jakarta's streets.
"Was there really mass rape? There was never any proof," Fadli told local media in an interview last month.
"If there is, show it."
A 1998 fact-finding report, commissioned by Indonesia's first president after Suharto, found at least 52 reported cases of rape in the unrest.
"This project risks erasing uncomfortable truths," said Usman Hamid, executive director of Amnesty International Indonesia.
Fadli told AFP the nation-building project would go ahead despite criticism.
"The consensus (is) we continue," he said.
"This is an updated version of our history," he added, saying there would be a public debate "this month", without elaborating.
'Historical propaganda'
The project involves 113 academics including historians, but at least one of them has resigned.
Archaeologist Harry Truman Simanjuntak told AFP he quit in a dispute over language -- the term "early history" was used instead of "prehistory" for Indonesia's ancient civilisation.
Fadli told lawmakers the phrase was avoided because it was created by Indonesia's former Dutch rulers.
But Harry said it showed the political influence over the text.
"It was very obvious that editors' authority did not exist. They were under the control of the government," he said.
The furore around the project has caused some opposition lawmakers and critics to call for its suspension or cancellation.
Activist Maria Catarina Sumarsih, whose son was killed in a military crackdown after Suharto's fall, accused the writers of warping the past.
"The government is deceiving the public... especially young people," she said.
Others said documenting Indonesia's past was best left to academics.
"If the government feel this nation needs a history that could make us proud... it can't be through the government's version of historical propaganda," said Marzuki.
"It should be the result of the work of historians."
© 2025 AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
5 hours ago
- France 24
Anger in West Bank village at funeral of two young men
The village, perched atop limestone hills, is known for its colonnaded villas and manicured gardens -- and its few thousand residents who mostly come from the Palestinian diaspora in North America. Musalat, 20, was one of them. Born and raised in Florida, he ran an ice cream parlour in Tampa, arriving in the Palestinian territory just a few weeks ago with a plan to spend the summer with his mother and siblings. But on Friday, he was beaten to death by Israeli settlers in nearby Sinjil, the Palestinian health ministry said, in the latest violence to hit the village north of Ramallah. Hundreds gathered on Sunday, chanting prayers and slogans at Musalat's funeral. Inside his family's upmarket home, women wept and screamed at the sight of the young man's lifeless body. On one of the walls, the young man looked from a poster -- his beard neatly groomed and against the backdrop of the Dome of the Rock, Jerusalem's Islamic sanctuary. Two teenagers embraced as tears ran down their faces. "It's awful," one of them sobbed. In recent months, the area has witnessed frequent attacks by Israeli settlers, sometimes backed by the Israeli army, local residents say. A few days before Musalat's death, the UN said that "attacks, harassment, and intimidation by Israeli settlers against Palestinians have become a daily reality". 'Dehumanisation' Musalat's family said he was killed on farmland owned by them. Israeli settlers beat him brutally, they claimed, leaving him to die for over three hours and preventing a medical team from reaching him. The Israeli army confirmed that "violent clashes" occurred Friday "between Palestinians and Israeli civilians, along with acts of vandalism against Palestinian property" in the area, and said an investigation had been launched. The victim's father told reporters after the funeral: "We demand justice for these terrorist settlers. There's no doubt that they are terrorists. They're illegally on these lands -- they do not belong to them," said Kamil Hafez Musalat. "We demand the US government do something about it. They're always saying, you know, for justice, justice, justice. But as Palestinians, they dehumanise us," he added. Hafez Abdoul Jabar, also a dual national, said he had been waiting for help from the US Embassy for weeks. "We need protection," he told the crowd, adding that it has become nearly impossible for residents of the area to access their land without risking their lives. Jabar is also a bereaved father: his son was killed in January 2024 under unclear circumstances involving settlers and the Israeli military, his family reported. Anger In the village schoolyard, hundreds of men gathered to recite mourning prayers for Musalat and Mohammed al-Shalabi, 23, who also died on Friday after being shot during the attack and "left to bleed for hours", according to the Palestinian health ministry. "We are people trying to live in peace. We try to protect our land. We have nothing against the world or against Israelis -- we are just trying to preserve our land," said his uncle, Samer al-Shalabi, calling the attacks "barbaric and savage". "We will pursue justice as far as we can -- but what good is the law if the judge is our enemy?" Violence in the Palestinian territory has surged since the start of Israel's war against Hamas in Gaza, after the Palestinian militants' attack on October 7, 2023. At least 955 Palestinians -- both militants and civilians -- have been killed by Israeli soldiers or settlers, according to an AFP tally based on data from the Palestinian Authority. At the same time, at least 36 Israelis, including both civilians and members of security forces, have been killed in Palestinian attacks or during Israeli military operations in the West Bank, according to official Israeli data.
France 24
15 hours ago
- France 24
Trump reflects on assassination attempt one year later
02:03 13/07/2025 Mexico eyes uncertainty as US announces 30 percent tariffs Americas 13/07/2025 Trump announces 30 percent tariffs on EU, Mexico imports Americas 12/07/2025 Haiti gang violence claims 5,000 lives in less than a year, UN report shows Americas 12/07/2025 US State Department lays off more than 1,300 employees Americas 11/07/2025 US Secretary of State Marco Rubio spoke to Chinese FM at Asia summit Asia / Pacific 11/07/2025 US Secretary of State Marco Rubio speaks at ASEAN summit in Malaysia Asia / Pacific 11/07/2025 Marco Rubio met with Russian & Chinese counterparts during ASEAN summit Asia / Pacific 11/07/2025 Texas officials are trying to figure out who's really missing from the floods Americas 11/07/2025 'Brazil is ours!': Protests in Sao Paulo after Trump threatens 50% levy Americas
France 24
a day ago
- France 24
Rewriting the past: Indonesia's new history books spook scholars
The 10-volume account was ordered by the administration of President Prabowo Subianto, an ex-general accused of abducting activists in the unrest that preceded dictator Suharto's fall, claims he denies. Scholars fear his government could use the exercise to rewrite history and cover up past abuses. Draft volume summaries and a chapter outline seen by AFP do not include any specific section on the 1998 violence. A summary of Suharto's rule in the volume dedicated to him only mentions how "student demonstrations... became a factor" in his resignation. "The writing was flawed since the beginning," said Andi Achdian, historian at Jakarta's National University, who has seen the outline. "It has a very strong tendency to whitewash history." Suharto ruled Indonesia with an iron fist for more than three decades after grabbing power in the wake of a 1965-6 massacre. The culture minister overseeing the government's history project, Fadli Zon, told lawmakers last week the account "does not discuss May '98... because it's small". Neither does it promise to include most of the "gross human rights violations" acknowledged by former president Joko Widodo in 2023. Jajat Burhanudin, a project editor, contradicted Fadli and dismissed concerns, telling AFP the new volumes would include 1998 events, with the draft outline just a "trigger for discussion". Officials say the new historical account is needed to strengthen Indonesian identity, but warned that any omission about its darkest past will raise eyebrows over objectivity. "What is feared is that... the cases that have been accepted by the previous government to be resolved will be ignored," said Marzuki Darusman, a former attorney general and head of a civil society coalition opposed to the volumes. 'Updated' history While it remains unclear how the government plans to use the books, Jajat said the volumes could be used as "one of the main sources" for history books taught in schools. Neither historian Susanto Zuhdi, who is helming the project, nor the presidential palace responded to requests for comment. The revisionist history garnered renewed scrutiny after the culture minister questioned whether mass rape had occurred at the end of Suharto's rule. Ethnic Chinese Indonesians bore the brunt of the bloodshed during the riots, when rape squads -- purportedly led by army thugs -- roamed Jakarta's streets. "Was there really mass rape? There was never any proof," Fadli told local media in an interview last month. "If there is, show it." A 1998 fact-finding report, commissioned by Indonesia's first president after Suharto, found at least 52 reported cases of rape in the unrest. "This project risks erasing uncomfortable truths," said Usman Hamid, executive director of Amnesty International Indonesia. Fadli told AFP the nation-building project would go ahead despite criticism. "The consensus (is) we continue," he said. "This is an updated version of our history," he added, saying there would be a public debate "this month", without elaborating. 'Historical propaganda' The project involves 113 academics including historians, but at least one of them has resigned. Archaeologist Harry Truman Simanjuntak told AFP he quit in a dispute over language -- the term "early history" was used instead of "prehistory" for Indonesia's ancient civilisation. Fadli told lawmakers the phrase was avoided because it was created by Indonesia's former Dutch rulers. But Harry said it showed the political influence over the text. "It was very obvious that editors' authority did not exist. They were under the control of the government," he said. The furore around the project has caused some opposition lawmakers and critics to call for its suspension or cancellation. Activist Maria Catarina Sumarsih, whose son was killed in a military crackdown after Suharto's fall, accused the writers of warping the past. "The government is deceiving the public... especially young people," she said. Others said documenting Indonesia's past was best left to academics. "If the government feel this nation needs a history that could make us proud... it can't be through the government's version of historical propaganda," said Marzuki. "It should be the result of the work of historians." © 2025 AFP
