Mount Pleasant coal mine expansion halted after community legal challenge
In 2022 the Independent Planning Commission (IPC) approved MACH Energy's application to extend the life of its Mount Pleasant coal mine to 2048 and increase its output.
The Denman Aberdeen Muswellbrook Scone Healthy Environment Group (DAMSHEG) appealed the approval in the Supreme Court, arguing that the impacts of the project on the environment and climate were not properly considered by the IPC.
The NSW Court of Appeal sided with the group on Thursday morning.
DAMSHEG president Wendy Wales said it was a "landmark case".
"We're just over the moon," she said.
The group had requested a judicial review of the approval but that was denied by the Land and Environment Court.
The Court of Appeal ruling has rendered the IPC's approval invalid.
It will be subject to a review in the Land and Environment Court.
The proposed expansion would allow the company to mine an additional 247 million tonnes of coal by 2048.
In court DAMSHEG argued that the impact of scope 3 emissions — those created from the burning of exported coal — was not adequately considered.
Justice JulieWard ruled there was "nothing" in the IPC's reasoning that showed it had accepted the scope 3 emissions would contribute to global climate change.
"Thus, I consider that it has been established that the commission failed to consider a mandatory consideration in this regard," she said.
Ms Wales said she wanted the region to move away from reliance on fossil fuels.
"We would like to see that Mount Pleasant doesn't go through till 2048, doubling its rate of production," she said.
The judge ordered MACH Energy to pay the costs incurred by DAMSHEG for the appeal.
The ABC has contacted MACH Energy for comment.
The case will now proceed to the Land and Environment Court for a decision on whether the expansion approval should be reversed.
The mine employs more than 400 people in the Upper Hunter region and was previously approved to mine until the end of 2026.
Ms Wales says bringing new jobs to the Muswellbrook region needs to be the priority.
"We need to be working at how we do that and it takes all the collective brains to work towards that," she said.
"[Muswellbrook Shire] Council has been calling for much more investment in and attention to how we're going to look after the workers and the rehab of our area."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
21 minutes ago
- News.com.au
‘Dumb way' Australians measure their superannuation balances as expert shares how to hit $1 million by the time you retire
For many Australians, a million in super has been a dream scenario. But it was more than was really necessary. Most Aussies who are retired never even got close and are absolutely fine. But for you? The person who isn't going to retire for ages? It is possible. It's actually even likely, if you are young enough. About half of all people aged 30 will end up with a million in super. But which half? A million dollars in super might be pretty nice to have in the future. Because the cost of living keeps going up. If inflation is high enough, a million dollars might be enough to buy Weet-Bix and keep the lights on! In this story we're going to look at who has what, and who is likely to end up with a million dollars in super. And we are going to look at some amazing graphs. No more averages please When I talk about super, I give the full story. Not just the averages. Averages are, in this context, dumb. Because almost nobody is the average. Super is not like height, where we are all fairly similar and an average is meaningful. When it comes to super, some people are like lego people and some are bigger than giraffes. The following charts break super up by age group. They also break your age group into 20 groups, from the zeroes on the left (no super) to the superheroes on the right (loads of super), and everyone else in the middle, in chunks of 5 per cent. This is useful because it shows you not just the average for your age, but where you stand compared to your peers. You can find yourself in the following charts (there's one for men and one for women) 1. First find your age group, 2. Then find the tallest column that is less than your super balance. That's your column. 3. See where your column stands. If it is the tallest you're in the top 5 per cent, second tallest top 10 per cent, etc. If your bar is near the right side, you're near the top. If your bar is near the left, you're closer to the bottom. Each bar is 5 per cent of that age group. The height of the bar is the minimum dollar amount to be in that group. My super balance is just below the second bar for my age group. Which means I'm in the third group – the top 15 per cent for my age. Not too bad, not amazing. My holidays in retirement might be a week at the coast not a month of cruising the Mediterranean, but at least I should get some holidays! Where will I end up? So … who is likely to end up with a million in super? If we make some simplifying assumptions – say everyone puts in $9000 a year and gets 7 per cent returns, we see the following. The charts are the same as the ones above, but I've coloured red the people who are able to hit a million by age 60. For women, we see about 20 per cent of those aged 35 to 39 will hit a million by age 60. Those whose balances are over $120,000 now are on their way to seven figures. For women under 30, all of them can hit a million. If they put $9000 a year away for 30 more years and get 7 per cent returns the magic of compounding will get them over the line. The following charts are for men. More men aged 35 to 39 will hit a million in super by age 60 – about 30 per cent of them. Again, all men under 30 can hit a million in super by age 60. In reality not everyone under 30 now will get there by 60. People who have no super at age 30 are not likely to start saving $9000 a year. Putting $9000 a year away is a lot for a person making below average income in 2025, so that assumption is a bit dubious, on the other hand some of these people will still be working in 30 years and at that point $9000 a year won't be much. The above charts are best thought of as a simplified model of what's possible. Should you worry about your super? Obviously this is just a projection – a guess, estimate, forecast. If you get promoted to manager or act super frugal you can end up with more than the projection. If someone drops a steel beam on your head or your business goes broke, you end up with less. And if you fall in a fiery volcano the day before your 60th birthday it won't matter at all. Super works only if civilisation still exists at retirement. And the longer the time frame you're looking at the harder it is to predict the future. Eighteen year olds aren't thinking about retirement and honestly good on them. Go have fun. Also, every so often history dishes up a big financial event that crashes markets and destroys wealth. If that arrives in your last five years before retirement, a lot of your good work in saving hard can be undone. The assumption I've made – of 7 per cent returns steadily each year – could come to look ridiculously optimistic. For anyone about to retire and stressing about the cost of living in retirement there is comfort in the knowledge that the pension is going to be there. Politicians have raised the pension age to 67 but no further rises are planned. If you can stretch your working life and savings to age 67 then the pension ($1051 per fortnight for a single) will carry you afterwards, and you needn't worry about super at all!
News.com.au
21 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Save $284 on this Dyson Airwrap Multi-styler and Dryer
The winter mid-year slump is well and truly here, and if you're feeling a little restless stuck indoors, you're not alone. But if you can't quite afford a Europe getaway with the rest of your Instagram feed, a little self-care goes a long way. And right now, the crazy good Dyson Airwrap multi-styler and dryer is a huge $284 off, down to just $565. What makes this deal even better? The brand new Dyson Airwrap Co-anda 2x is about to launch on July 30 for a whopping $999. While it comes with a few upgraded features, you're essentially saving nearly 50 per cent with this version. The best-selling device dries, curls, shapes, smooths and hides flyaways all with no heat damage. Featuring six different attachments for every style and hair type, it seriously is the hair tool to end all hair tools. checkout editor, Hannah Paine, previously tested the Airwrap and said it's a 'great investment' and '100 per cent worth it'. 'Plus, just the mere fact that the Airwrap can replace a blow dryer, straightening iron and curling tongs makes it worth purchasing, especially if you're someone who styles their hair frequently,' she said. Others also agree. The device has over 41,000 five-star reviews on the Dyson website plus thousands of social videos and posts. 'It was also really simple to use and I picked up the techniques needed for each attachment quite quickly thanks to video tutorials. It's easily the best, most versatile hair tool! Don't know what I'd do without it,' wrote one very impressed customer. Another wrote, 'Brought my Airwrap two weeks ago. Been looking at it for years trying to justify the cost then thought I'd just buy it. Wish I'd done it sooner, easy to use, great attachments, dries my hair so well & smooth. Definitely worth the cost.' So if you've been thinking about it, follow this reviewer's advice and buy now. Sign up to our weekly shopping newsletter to get all the best deals, shopping tips and guides delivered straight to your inbox.
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
‘Gone from shelves': Popular chip discontinued at Coles, Woolies
A popular Aussie snack has been discontinued 'due to insufficient levels of consumer demand' – leaving fans of the potato chip devastated. Tyrrells was created in England back in 2002, before it began importing the famous chips to Australia 12 years later. Shortly after landing a deal to be sold exclusively at Coles, the UK-based company acquired Yarra Valley Snack Foods, creating the company's first manufacturing facility outside the Herefordshire farm on which it was founded. It spent $6 million importing fryers and spinners to the Victoria-based factory in order to recreate the English 'crisps' using locally farmed potatoes, and even secured a government grant to help expand the Tyrrells operation. But fast-forward 10 years, and Snackbrands Australia – the new name for the umbrella company that manufactures Tyrrells along with a string of other popular chips – has confirmed it will no longer make Tyrrells chips for Australia. 'We always aim to bring delicious snacks to our consumers in line with their needs, however we sadly had to retire the Tyrrells brand from market due to insufficient levels of consumer demand,' a spokesperson told 'We realise that there will always be true lovers of the brand out there, however we need to balance the requirements of our consumers as well as our retail partners when making these tough decisions.' It is understood the factory will continue to produce Tyrrells for its Asia-Pacific markets. Those who had already noticed the cult-chip was missing from Coles and Woolies shelves have shared their disappointment at the brutal axing, describing it as 'really sad news'. 'Gone from their shelves without warning or even clearance tags. Didn't even get a chance to stock up,' ranted one disappointed Aussie on Reddit. 'These were f**king good, made in Australia with Aussie potatoes, and at $3.80 for 165g. Price does what it says, without stupid price hikes and fake offers,' raged another. 'This is really sad news, Tyrells are definitely one of my favourites, especially the cheddar and chive flavour,' shared someone else. Meanwhile one added the news was 'really disappointing', describing Tyrrells as 'the best chips on the shelves'. 'These are the king of chips and I am heartbroken,' mused one more. Snackbrands Australia said Tyrrells fans could find 'great alternatives' in its range, suggesting its Kettle and Natural Chip Company brands. 'For anyone still keen to get their hands on Tyrrells, they will continue to be sold for the foreseeable future in certain Harris Farm outlets,' the spokesperson added. Coles and Woolworths both confirmed to the brand was no longer on sale in its stores.
