Forum: Human mentorship and AI can make learning meaningful and personalised for children
The Chinese Development Assistance Council (CDAC) provides academic tuition for eligible low-income students of all ethnic groups under the Collaborative Tuition Programme, which is run jointly with the Eurasian Association, the Singapore Indian Development Association and Yayasan Mendaki. Since 2022, we have actively introduced educational technology into our English and mathematics tuition curriculum. These learning platforms have AI features that personalise students' learning experiences and provide instant feedback. This integration has enabled us to reach a wider cohort of students and tailor our support more effectively. Over 600 students have benefited from this approach, with positive feedback on its impact.
Also, the four self-help groups' annual Joint Learning Fiesta, launched in 2023, created further opportunities to spread the use of AI in learning to tutors.
How do our students feel about the use of AI in tuition? A recent in-house CDAC survey revealed that while students liked the immediate feedback from AI, they would still prefer their tutors' personal touch. This confirms that while AI can enhance learning, it cannot replace the encouragement and care provided by tutors.
That said, we firmly agree with the article's emphasis that emotion lies at the heart of learning. At CDAC, we place strong emphasis on nurturing relationship-based classrooms, where trust, encouragement and human understanding remain central. In line with this, we have established a Student Learning Support Team to address the holistic needs of our students, providing academic guidance alongside emotional and social support for students from more complex families.
By combining human mentorship with AI-enabled customisation, we see a promising path forward – one that balances efficiency with empathy, and innovation with inclusiveness. For CDAC, this hybrid approach is not about replacing human tutors but enhancing their effectiveness, ensuring every student can access meaningful, motivating and personalised learning support.
Pooja Trivedi
Senior Director (Education)
Chinese Development Assistance Council
More on this Topic Forum: What readers are saying
Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
AsiaOne
20 hours ago
- AsiaOne
ChatGPT, Gemini or The Wise Otter - which is the best AI tutor for Singapore students?, Digital News
SINGAPORE - Students are increasingly relying on artificial intelligence (AI) tutors for their daily work. Besides mainstream tools such as Google's Gemini and OpenAI's ChatGPT, the latest contender in this space is The Wise Otter. Created and launched in April by Singaporean developer Jotham Goh, 33, The Wise Otter incorporates grading criteria used in Singapore schools. It can tackle primary school maths, as well as secondary school and junior college maths, English, physics, chemistry and biology questions with step-by-step explanations. The Straits Times pitted the three chatbots against one another to check which AI tutor is the best for Singapore students. For ChatGPT, ST included both GPT-4o and the latest GPT-5 models in this test. GPT-5, launched on Aug 8, is said to hallucinate less and deliver more accurate answers compared with earlier editions. The chatbots were asked to solve a random sample of questions found in past-year O-level papers and school examinations, including those that involve diagrams, across four subjects: Maths, chemistry, physics and English. Maths The three bots answered correctly a probability question about a cumulative frequency diagram showing the time that adults spent on exercise in one week. The bots also provided detailed explanations for their answers. Asked to find the value of k (the minimum hours of weekly exercise for adults to stay fit), given that only 60 per cent of the adults in the diagram meet this minimum recommendation, GPT-4o and The Wise Otter failed to provide the right answer. Only Gemini provided the correct value of k, which was 3. GPT-4o and The Wise Otter wavered when told that 3 was the correct answer, quickly analysed the question again and gave 3 as their answers. To test their confidence, both bots were told again that 3 was wrong. GPT-4o was more eager to please and wavered again, stating that k's value was 2.67. When the question was fed to GPT-5, it was able to provide the correct workings, but still misread the graph and gave the answer as 3.2. Although ChatGPT and The Wise Otter struggled with understanding the graph, all three bots were able to correctly answer other text-based questions. English The three bots were prompted to write an essay plan for the following question: "'I realised that I was much stronger than I had previously thought.' Write about a time when you felt like this." All three bots were able to produce a comprehensive structure for students to follow, and suggested key points to include in each paragraph. They all prompted the writer to think of moments in life when there was a seemingly insurmountable challenge and how the writer's perspective changed after the event, as well as to use vivid language as much as possible. The Wise Otter went on to remind the writer that strength could be physical, emotional, mental or a combination of these. It also gave possible classifications of the essay as "narrative", "reflective" or "personal recount". These are three of several essay types that O-level students in local schools are taught to identify, along with the appropriate approaches for the essay types. The Wise Otter also provided advice on how to get the highest band for content, a scoring system used in GCE O levels - specifically, the essay needs to recount explicitly how the writer felt weak before, what happened to make the writer feel stronger, and how the writer realised he or she had strength all along. GCE O-level examiners typically award marks for content and language, and score the papers between bands zero and five (five for the highest marks). Chemistry A diagrammatic question on paper chromatography required the bots to identify which metals - lead, copper, iron, nickel and tin - could be found in mixture A, which contained three metals. The correct answer was lead, iron and tin, as the chromatogram of mixture A showed spots at the same heights as these metals. The bots were able to reason that matching the heights of the spots was the way to find the answer, but they were all able to correctly identify only two metals each. Gemini, GPT-4o and GPT-5 mistakenly identified copper as a metal in mixture A. The Wise Otter erroneously said that nickel was found in mixture A. Physics When given a text-based multiple choice question that tested understanding of inertia, the bots gave an accurate definition of the concept, describing it as an object's resistance to changing its state of motion. The bots explained that inertia depends only on the mass of an object, and that other factors such as speed and velocity are irrelevant. They provided the correct answer that the car had the greatest inertia as it had the greatest mass. Fed another physics question asking for the total resistance that flowed through an electrical circuit based on a diagram, the bots provided the correct answer, despite having struggled with diagrammatic maths and chemistry questions. All the bots were able to break down the calculations into two parts - first by calculating the resistance of the parallel resistors, and then by adding it to the resistance of the fixed resistor connected in series. They provided the correct formula for calculating the equivalent resistance of the parallel resistors. However, The Wise Otter's Telegram interface does not allow it to show fractions. Fractions are denoted by the symbol "/" instead. [[nid:721116]] This article was first published in The Straits Times . Permission required for reproduction.
Straits Times
a day ago
- Straits Times
Former data analyst creates AI tutor that assesses students based on Singapore schools' criteria
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Mr Jotham Goh quit his data analyst job in 2024 to tinker with AI and, in April, launched an AI tutor to help students. SINGAPORE – Growing up, Mr Jotham Goh had always dreamt of having an on-demand artificial intelligence (AI) tutor so he would have more time to rest after school. 'I had three to four tuition classes weekly after school. I dreaded them as I still had to go even if I was tired,' said Mr Goh. When the 33-year-old quit his data analyst job in 2024 to tinker with AI, his natural inclination was to revisit his childhood ideas. In April, he launched The Wise Otter – an AI tutor to help primary, secondary and junior college students with mathematics, English, chemistry, physics and biology. The tool comes amid increasing use of AI in the education sector. It competes with mainstream tools such as OpenAI's ChatGPT (of which an update was rolled out on Aug 8), Google's Gemini and Anthropic's Claude. Mr Goh, who graduated with a finance degree from the Singapore Management University in 2016, said: ' The Wise Otter is more tailored to the needs of Singapore students. The Wise Otter is trained on hundreds of pages of past-year examination papers, assessment books and model answers from local teachers. 'For a subject like English, I codified the syllabus and the grading criteria used in the local school system, which is why the bot is more tailored to the needs of Singapore students. The bot is able to spot mistakes made by students like how a teacher would, such as when they don't follow a certain structure.' Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Profile of Kpod user has shifted from hardcore drug users to young people: Experts Singapore 4 men arrested after police search operation in forested area near Rail Corridor World Thousands protest in Tel Aviv against Israeli govt move to expand Gaza war Opinion Recognising our imperfections is part of what makes Singapore whole Opinion I used to be impatient. Then I became a granddad Business The risks of using 'decoupling' to own two properties Asia Manila struggles to keep a lasting hawker culture, casts eyes on how Asian nations lifted street food The bot is accessible via messaging platform Telegram. Students can either type out their questions or upload a photo of their homework. The bot is equipped to break down complex maths problems and solve them, unpack English comprehension passages and explain science theories and concepts. Mr Goh's Telegram bot answers up to eight AI queries daily. A weekly fee starting from $4.20 for 1,000 queries per month will kick in after that. The Wise Otter's website allows JC students to brush up on their knowledge on current affairs and essay-writing techniques for General Paper. Students get five AI requests for free daily, or they can pay a monthly fee starting from $16 for 1,000 requests . After the bot was created and launched in April, he promoted it on online forum Reddit, which has a subgroup frequented by Singaporean students seeking advice on examinations. Since then, The Wise Otter has garnered around 600 weekly active users – most of whom ask maths questions, he said, declining to reveal how many of them are paying ones. Mr Goh admitted that about 10 per cen t of the answers provided by The Wise Otter are wrong, and the bot still needs tweaking. In its current form, he added, The Wise Otter does not replace human tutors, who will still be needed for identifying and addressing recurring weaknesses in each student's workings and understanding of a topic. Students can use The Wise Otter bot to brush up on their skills in several subjects, such as practising conversational skills for an oral examination. PHOTO: SCREENSHOT FROM THE WISE OTTER Kaitlyn Ang, 16 , has been using the bot almost daily for three months to revise English and mathematics to prepare for her O-level examinations as a private candidate. She cannot afford a human tutor, but finds the bot to be as good as one. She practises English oral topics with the bot, which guides her on what needs elaboration. She said she also gained a better understanding of trigonometry, which she had struggled to grasp in the past. 'It can provide helpful exam tips, explanations for questions I struggle with, and give feedback,' she said. She acknowledged that the bot is not perfect, but said that the answers are better aligned with what her school teachers taught than answers from ChatGPT and Claude. The use of AI in education dominated headlines in recent months due to its potential for academic dishonesty. To promote responsible academic use of the chatbot, OpenAI on July 30 rolled out a Study Mode for ChatGPT that uses a Socratic tutoring style to respond to students' questions. The style emphasises guided discovery through questioning rather than giving direct answers. Study Mode, which can be turned on or off, will eventually provide direct solutions if asked repeatedly for the answers. Study Mode's approach is aligned with The Wise Otter's. For instance, The Wise Otter does not generate full General Paper essays for students. Instead, the bot provides feedback on how to improve written essays in ways that are similar to how human teachers work. An example of how The Wise Otter gives feedback to improve a student's General Paper essay. PHOTO: SCREENSHOT FROM THE WISE OTTER Mr Goh said : 'For example, if you write an introduction and request a review, the AI will be able to give advice such as how to make a lengthy hook more concise. Students can learn straightaway with timely feedback, instead of waiting a whole week for the teacher to mark an essay.' He has been able to make a small profit so far due to low business costs, but said it is not yet enough to cover his daily living expenses. He does not see himself returning to a corporate job in the near term and is committed to improving The Wise Otter, noting that he has enough savings to last him for the next five to 10 years. 'Even if this fails, I would have the AI skills that will probably be useful in the future.'
Straits Times
a day ago
- Straits Times
Man United splashing cash on new strikers adds pressure on Ruben Amorim to deliver
MANCHESTER, England - After their worst season in 51 years last term, the only way is up for Manchester United. Complete with a new £200 million (S$350 million) strike force, coach Ruben Amorim has the backing of fans to bring about lasting change. Now he must deliver. From the start, Amorim has always said, given the choice, he would not have taken on the monumental task of awakening English football's most successful club from its slumber when he did, mid-season. The Portuguese coach insisted he was given a 'now or never' ultimatum before succeeding Erik ten Hag in November 2024, taking an underperforming side to plentiful lows – worst finish, most defeats, fewest points and fewest goals in their Premier League history. Amorim asked supporters to judge him after he had a full pre-season to instil his ideas properly. Three new forwards gives him greater tools to succeed. Such spending comes as a surprise. New co-owner Jim Ratcliffe insisted only in March that the club were so low on cash when his company Ineos bought a minority stake in late 2023 they faced going 'bust by Christmas'. RB Leipzig striker Benjamin Sesko has been confirmed as a United player this weekend and could be flanked for next week's season opener against Arsenal by exciting forwards Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo, who both have something United attackers of late have lacked – Premier League goalscoring pedigree. As United slumped to an unfathomable 15th last term, the concession of 54 goals was their joint-third worst defensive record in Premier League history. It was their inability to score that proved more damaging, however. They mustered a record-low 44 league strikes, five fewer than in any Premier League season. 'The hardest part of last season was to go to the games and know that we are not going to be competitive,' Amorim told reporters on the club's pre-season tour of the United States. 'Nowadays I'm better, I'm more excited. I also think I learned a lot. We will be a better team. Not just because I truly believe that we can be better, but I truly believe that I will be better at managing this season. 'Now we are in a better place, but we are just beginning. We have to perform. And I really like the pressure. If I have the feeling that before the game we are going to be competitive, we'll be OK. I just don't want to return to that feeling that we are thinking it's not a 50-50 game.' Pull still there Supporters have been buoyed that new signings have not been put off by the fact United will not be competing in any European competition this season for the first time in 11 years. Mbeumo and Sesko especially had plenty of other clubs reportedly interested in them, but the pull of United, despite being without a league title since 2013, remains. 'From the start, I wanted to join this massive club,' Mbeumo said after signing. 'Now I'm here, I'm just really happy. For me, it's the biggest club in the world. The fans are crazy, the stadium is amazing. Every player wants to play here.' More new signings are needed across the team for any major improvement this season, however. Skipper Bruno Fernandes labelled the last US tour performance in a 2-2 draw with Everton as 'lazy' and called on the club to make more additions before the transfer window shuts at the end of the month. Manager Ruben Amorim asked United supporters to judge him after he had a full pre-season to instil his ideas properly. PHOTO: REUTERS Otherwise, their trip across the Atlantic was unanimously positive. With a starting line-up retaining nine of the team that performed so poorly in their Europa League final loss to Tottenham Hotspur, United looked energised and, at times, entertaining in a 4-1 win over Bournemouth, while also beating West Ham to finish unbeaten in their three-match series. Amorim faces some daunting early fixtures, with Arsenal, Manchester City and Chelsea in their opening five games. Nonetheless, he needs to harness some rare positivity gleaned from scoring some goals over pre-season to at least start setting United back on the right path. REUTERS
