Opinion - Should Congress be banned from stock trading? The devil is in the details.
Ossoff has championed this issue in one form or another since first being elected to the Senate in 2020, and its current, bipartisan permutation, the Ending Trading and Holdings In Congressional Stocks (ETHICS) Act, reflects a principle with which I and a large majority of the American electorate agree. However, as former presidential candidate Ross Perot famously opined, 'the devil is in the details.'
By any reasoned standard, government officials profiting from the regulations and laws they help enact constitutes a serious ethical issue. The magnitude of this problem was revealed starkly last September, when it was reported that former Speaker Nancy Pelosi's (D-Calif.) husband sold 2,000 shares of Visa stock for $500,000 just weeks before the Justice Department sued the company's debit card business in a lawsuit many legal experts consider unjustified. The actions by Mr. Pelosi ignited increased public concern that officials may be using their positions, and the inside information they obtain as a result, to influence the market for their own benefit.
It is not just Pelosi's husband who appears to be a beneficiary of such maneuvering. The new Unusual Whales report shows that in 2024 one member of Congress gained an eye-popping 149 percent in stock trades — more than 124 percent greater than the S&P 500's 2024 benchmark. While this report highlights the significance of this potential conflict of interest problem, an outright ban on members trading stocks is not the appropriate remedy.
In 2012, Congress passed the STOCK Act, which bars lawmakers from trading on insider information. The Pelosi scandal, however, shows why that law needs strengthening. For example, the ban must apply to representatives' immediate family members as a way to close loopholes like the one by which Pelosi's husband profited so handsomely.
An outright stock trading ban for all members paints with too broad a brush and would be grossly unfair. Contrary to popular belief, not all members of Congress are extraordinarily wealthy. Members earn $174,000 annually, with those in leadership positions receiving slightly more. That is, of course, a comfortable salary, but it does not represent 'I don't need to invest' wealth, especially considering the high cost of living in the Washington, D.C. environs.
Broadly speaking, the stock market remains one of the best tools with which all Americans can build their financial futures, and public servants should not be excluded from participating in it. That said, reform is necessary to address the unresolved conflicts of interest that come with congressional stock trading.
Instead of outright banning members' stock trading, federal lawmakers should focus on improving the enforcement of the STOCK Act by strengthening its penalties — as low as $200 for a first-term violation. Such de minimus penalties may be why Business Insider's investigation of financial disclosures found that 57 members of Congress and at least 182 top Capitol Hill staffers were late in filing their stock trades as demanded by the STOCK Act in 2020 and 2021 alone.
Increasing the STOCK Act's penalties would go a long way toward improving members' compliance and rooting out corruption and insider trading.
Federal decisionmakers' proposals and lawsuits should also be subject to greater scrutiny from key congressional committees of jurisdiction — oversight that surely would help limit, if not stop actions that are either illegal or unjustly motivated by personal or political gain.
For example, if the House Judiciary Committee, on which I served during my eight years in Congress, had held the Justice Department's feet to the fire over its seemingly baseless Visa debit card lawsuit, and demanded that it explain the reasoning behind its actions (or inactions), then the lawsuit may not have ever been filed, and the appearance or reality of Congress profiteering from such overreach would have been avoided.
Finally, incoming Attorney General Pam Bondi can (and should) establish an independent ethics panel and task it with regularly examining the financial activities of federal officials and their families.
Through stronger enforcement of existing law, Congress can better address the root of the congressional stock trading problem without unduly constraining the financial freedom of its members.
Bob Barr currently serves as president of the National Rifle Association. He represented Georgia's 7th District in the U.S. House of Representatives from 1995 to 2003. He served as the United States Attorney in Atlanta from 1986 to 1990 and in the CIA in the 1970s. He now practices law in Atlanta and serves as head of Liberty Guard.
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Insider
5 minutes ago
- Business Insider
'Big Short' investor Michael Burry reveals fresh bets on Meta, Alibaba, and UnitedHealth
Michael Burry bet big on stocks in the second quarter, swapping out bearish put options for bullish call options and adding several fresh holdings to his portfolio. The investor of "The Big Short" fame revealed in a quarterly filing on Thursday that he purchased calls on Alibaba, ASML, Estee Lauder, Lululemon, Meta, Regeneron, UnitedHealth, and VF last quarter. Burry's Scion Asset Management also built direct stakes in Bruker, Lululemon, Regeneron, UnitedHealth, and MercadoLibre, while cutting his direct wager on Estee Lauder from 200,000 shares to 150,000. The UnitedHealth wager is notable as Warren Buffett, one of Burry's key influences, also invested in the health insurer last quarter via his Berkshire Hathaway conglomerate. Call options give investors the right to buy a certain number of a company's shares at a fixed price within a set period, allowing them to lock in a purchase price that may be lower than the market price. Similarly, investors can use put options to lock in a selling price, allowing them to profit from if the stock price declines. Scion is known for making big changes to its portfolio between quarters, but this was a particularly striking overhaul. At the end of March, it owned puts on Alibaba, Baidu, Nvidia, PDD, and worth a notional $186 million, plus a roughly $13 million stake in Estee Lauder. Three months later, it held calls on nine stocks worth a notional $522 million, and a further six direct stakes valued at $56 million. It's worth underscoring that Burry may have rejigged his stock bets in recent weeks, and his disclosures may not paint a full picture of his investment strategy. Quarterly portfolio updates known as 13Fs only provide a snapshot of a firm's holdings with a six-week lag and exclude shares sold short as well as investments in private companies, foreign-listed assets, and non-stock assets such as bonds and real estate. Burry shot to fame after predicting and profiting from the collapse of the mid-2000s US housing bubble — a wager that was immortalized in "The Big Short" book and movie adaptation. He's also known for making grave predictions of market crashes and recessions, investing in GameStop before it became a meme stock, and betting against popular assets such as Tesla, Apple, Nvidia, and the entire S&P 500 index.
Fox News
5 minutes ago
- Fox News
Mike Castle, Delaware's last Republican governor and congressman, dead at 86
Former Delaware Gov. Mike Castle, a Republican moderate who championed creating the popular 50 State Quarters Program of commemorative coins while he served in Congress, has died. He was 86. The Delaware Republican Party announced that Castle died Thursday in Greenville but shared no other details. Castle was among Delaware's most successful politicians, never losing a race until his stunning upset in a 2010 primary for the U.S. Senate seat that Democrat Joe Biden held before becoming vice president. During his 18 years in Congress, Castle became a leader of centrist Republicans, earning a reputation as a fiscal conservative and social moderate not afraid to challenge the party line on issues ranging from government spending to environmental protection and abortion. As Delaware's lone representative in the U.S. House from 1993 to 2011, he supported a pay-as-you-go policy for both spending and tax cuts. Castle played roles in improving child nutrition programs and establishing the No Child Left Behind education reform program. His signature issue in Congress was the commemorative quarters program that featured coins honoring each state, starting with Delaware. He was dubbed by the coin grading service Numismatic Guaranty Company as "The Coinage Congressman." The quarters boosted federal revenues as they were taken out of circulation. He also helped establish a similar program honoring U.S. presidents with dollar coins, beginning in 2007, and an "America the Beautiful" quarter program honoring national parks, monuments and nature areas starting in 2010. "The Honorable Michael Castle embodied the best of public service — moderation, integrity, and a steadfast commitment to all Delawareans," Delaware GOP Chairman Gene Truono said in a statement Thursday. Castle had been a state lawmaker and lieutenant governor before becoming governor in 1985. Delaware Gov. Matt Meyer ordered flags flown at half-staff for the next week in Castle's honor. "During his time as governor, Mike Castle visited every single school in our state, including mine, where he spoke to my high school class with the same warmth, humility, and commitment to public service that defined his career," said Meyer, a Democrat.
Business Upturn
24 minutes ago
- Business Upturn
Mission 10K Aims to Deliver 10,000 Units at Startup Speed to Fight America's Housing Meltdown
FREMONT, Calif., Aug. 14, 2025 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) — The U.S. is in the midst of the worst housing affordability crisis in modern history—and it's getting worse, fast. Since 2020, American salaries have grown by 25%. But average mortgage payments? They've surged by an eye-watering 112%. That delta has frozen millions out of the dream of homeownership. Meanwhile, rents continue to rise, new supply remains anemic, and federal and state solutions are paralyzed by red tape and political gridlock. Into this widening gap steps Mission 10K, a startup with a radical goal: build 10,000 high-quality rental townhomes at startup speed. Powered by a 40-person globally distributed team, Mission 10K is applying Silicon Valley-style velocity to real estate—centralizing design, entitlements, capital, construction, and leasing under one tightly controlled platform. 'We can't wait for public policy to solve this crisis. It's private innovation or nothing,' said CEO Neal Bawa. 'Our model uses speed as a weapon. Every day we save is a day a family moves into an affordable, dignified rental townhome.' The company's approach flips the traditional development model on its head. Instead of reinventing the wheel for each site, Mission 10K deploys what it calls a Community Creation Engine—a standardized, AI-enhanced playbook that rapidly identifies suburban parcels near job corridors, accelerates entitlements, and rapid-builds townhome-style rentals optimized for modern renters. By stacking functions that are normally siloed across dozens of vendors, the team removes friction at every stage. Their in-house teams collaborate across time zones and software stacks to compress timelines and lower cost per unit—without sacrificing quality. With over 3,000 townhomes in the pipeline and 19 land sites already secured—many at deep off-market discounts—Mission 10K is scaling aggressively across many high-growth metros. Investors are paying attention, drawn by the rare fusion of real asset security and startup-style scale economics. In an era of mounting despair and disappearing affordability, Mission 10K is building what others say can't be built: fast, smart, and at scale. About Mission 10K Mission 10K is a full-stack real estate development startup on a mission to deliver 10,000 high-quality townhomes at startup speed. The company leverages a proprietary Community Creation Engine that integrates AI-driven site selection, vertically stacked operations, and standardized design to rapidly scale housing across the U.S. With over 3,000 units in the pipeline and 19 sites secured, Mission 10K is proving that housing can be fast, affordable, and dignified—without waiting on broken systems or red tape. Learn more at . Contact Information Mission 10KJen DeVore, Director of Marketing(904) 382-7255 [email protected]
