Maharashtra orders probe into NGO over report highlighting poor state of Mumbai's public toilets
In its report, Praja Foundation had said that there is only one public toilet seat for every 752 men and 1,820 women residents of Mumbai. This is much below the guidelines under the Swachh Bharat Mission, which recommends that there should be at least one public toilet seat for every 100 to 400 men and 100 to 200 women.
Based on data received through Right to Information applications, the non-profit also highlighted that there is only one community toilet seat for every 86 men and 81 women.
A community toilet is a shared facility meant for a defined group of residents or an entire settlement.
The Swachh Bharat Mission norms prescribe one toilet for 35 men and 25 women, respectively.
On Monday, Shiv Sena MLA Prakash Surve, Bharatiya Janata Party's Raj Todsam and Nationalist Congress Party (Sharadchandra Pawar) leader Rohit Pawar raised questions in the Maharashtra Assembly based on the Praja Foundation's report.
In response, Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde said that Mumbai has one toilet seat for every 46 men and 38 women.
Milind Mhaske, the chief executive officer of Praja Foundation, told Scroll on Tuesday that the organisation was yet to receive a formal request or communication from the government regarding the data mentioned during the Assembly session.
'Praja remains committed to collaborate with the government to improve quality of life across our cities,' added Mhaske.
Samant had claimed on Monday that the Praja Foundation's report was 'not accurate'.
'This NGO has brought out a report on availability of toilets in Mumbai,' the minister was quoted as saying by The Indian Express. 'The data given in the report is not accurate. In such cases, it leads to the defamation of the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
MP Shrikant Shinde refutes Sanjay Raut's ambulance scam allegations
Kolhapur: MP Shrikant Shinde on Saturday reacted to allegations made by Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut , that a significant ambulance purchase contract had been awarded to his close associate's firm, by insisting that accusers should provide evidence. "Who is Sanjay Raut? I don't know any Sanjay Raut. I am not obliged to respond Sanjay Raut's allegations. If someone is accusing someone, it should be done with evidence," Shinde said during a day-long visit to Kolhapur. On Friday, Sanjay Raut had said, "State govt floated a tender for the purchase of ambulances. Its contract was awarded to a company belonging to a close associate of deputy chief minister Eknath Shinde's son, Shrikant Shinde. The contract for the purchase of ambulances worth Rs 800 crore was awarded to Sumit Facilities Limited. Its actual cost was Rs 100 crore, but the contract amount was inflated to Rs 800 crore." Shrikant Shinde, during his Kolhapur visit, inaugurated a health camp at the Services Hospital at Kasba Bawda. He interacted with patients and senior citizens who had come for health checks. Free spectacles and hearing aids were distributed. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like After Losing Weight Kevin James Looks Like A Model 33 Bridges Undo Meanwhile, speaking about the upcoming local body elections, Shinde said, "All three Mahayuti parties will contest together. Mahayuti will also succeed in the local body elections in the same way that it achieved success in the assembly elections." Later, Shinde inaugurated the Shiv Sena Sampark Karyalay located at Khanvilkar petrol pump. He also addressed office-bearers and party workers. "Deputy CM Eknath Shinde is taking welfare decisions after considering every section of society. In the same way, we want to resolve the problems of the people of Kolhapur. Municipal elections are coming soon. We have to hoist the flag of Shiv Sena-Mahayuti in these elections, and everyone should start preparing. " Shinde also visited the revered Mahalaxmi temple and Kailasgadchi Swari temple. Former Shiv Sena (UBT) district president Vinayak Salokhe rejoined Shiv Sena at this time. MP Shrikant Shinde was accompanied by guardian minister Prakash Abitkar, state planning commission head MLA Rajesh Kshirsagar, MP Dhairyasheel Mane, MLA Chandradeep Narke, MLA Rajendra Patil Yadravkar, MLA Ashok Mane, former MP Sanjay Mandlik, and other office bearers.
Time of India
4 hours ago
- Time of India
Yuva Sena alleges 695 institutes got illegal fee hike nod; FRA says everything as per rules
Pune: Representatives of Yuva Sena, the Shiv Sena's youth wing, recently submitted a complaint letter to Maharashtra Fee Regulatory Authority (FRA) on Friday, accusing it of illegally approving fee hikes for 695 unaided professional institutions in the state. According to the letter, the fee hikes were approved after the legally mandated date of Oct 31, in violation of Maharashtra Unaided Private Professional Educational Institutions (Regulation of Admission and Fees) Act, 2015, resulting in financial exploitation of students. Kalpesh Yadav, the president of Yuva Sena, demanded that all fee hike approvals granted after the official deadlines be immediately withdrawn. He also requested FRA to instruct institutions to charge fees based on previous academic year's approved structure. "The rules state that if FRA's decision is not acceptable to a college, it should file a re-application within 15 days, and FRA is expected to arrive at a decision before March 31. But this time, FRA extended the dates to apply for fee hikes multiple times after Oct 31, and the latest order asks colleges to apply before August 15 for any fee-related approval. It is like they are encouraging colleges to apply, which is illegal, and we will move court if they don't reverse the decisions taken on applications after Oct 31," said Kalpesh Yadav, joint secretary, Yuva Sena. You Can Also Check: Pune AQI | Weather in Pune | Bank Holidays in Pune | Public Holidays in Pune However, Arjun Chikhale, member secretary, FRA, said that there is a provision in law to give extensions to colleges to apply. "There is nothing illegal in the process of giving extensions, and FRA has the right to give extensions. We tried to explain all this to the complainant also. FRA has not done anything illegal."
The Print
4 hours ago
- The Print
Maharashtra's cattle trade comes to near standstill as traders allege ‘free rein' to gau rakshaks
But it has been getting worse with each passing year, especially during Bakra-Eid, they say. Shaikh comes from the Qureshi community. An estimated 2 lakh members of the community, who are part of the cattle trade in Maharashtra, have been on a strike since the start of July to protest harassment by cow vigilantes. The harassment, which can easily spiral into physical assault, has become a part and parcel of their profession over the past decade, since the passage of Maharashtra Animal Preservation (Amendment) Act, 2015. Mumbai: Hamid Shaikh is a licensed cattle trader and was on his way to sell a buffalo and three bulls. It would fetch him Rs 1.5 lakh, he hoped. But the 55-year-old returned home with bruises all over his body, no livestock and no money. 'Cow vigilantes stopped our truck and said we were taking these animals for slaughter which was not the case,' Shaikh told ThePrint about the incident from about three weeks ago. For instance, in Hamid Shaikh's case, he said he 'bought them (livestock) from Pachod (near Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar) market a few days ago and was taking them to Ch. Sambhajinagar (Aurangabad) market for selling them'. 'I have all proper documentation for animals. Despite that, they took away my animals. They slapped me twice. I told them to not hit me since I had a bypass (surgery), but they still hit me. I was scared,' he added. Imran Babu Qureshi, national vice-president of All India Jamaitul Qureshi, told ThePrint that members of the community decided to go on strike 'because there is no response' from either the state government or police. 'There is an increase in incidents of cow vigilantes hitting our drivers, traders. That is the reason we have called this bandh.' In March 2015, the BJP-Shiv Sena government led by Devendra Fadnavis banned sale, possession and consumption of beef by amending the Maharashtra Animal Preservation Act, 1976, which allowed slaughter of old bulls and bullocks with permission from civic authorities. The amendment brought about a complete ban on slaughter of cows and their progeny, bulls and bullocks. It allowed slaughter of buffaloes subject to certain conditions. On 15 July this year, the All India Jamiatul Quresh (AIJQ), a union of cattle traders, met Maharashtra Minister of State (MoS) for Home Yogesh Kadam as well as Director-General of Police (DGP) Rashmi Shukla with a letter, seeking protection from gau rakshaks. They sent another letter on 24 July, demanding the police issue directions/orders as assured to them to make sure cattle traders are not harassed by cow vigilantes. 'We would also like to state that due to pressure of such unauthorized persons/vigilantes, the concerned police officers in various villages, tehsils and districts in the state are pressured to proceed to seize such transport vehicles and animals which otherwise are permitted to be transported. This creates further harassment and troubles on the transporter and the trader,' the Maharashtra AIJQ president wrote in this letter. Members of the Qureshi community are now planning to meet again next week to decide on a plan of action. When contacted, Yogesh Kadam confirmed to ThePrint that he met AIJQ representatives and told ThePrint that there are always two sides to a story. The minister said he had already assured action against those harassing cattle traders. 'During our meeting, I told them to follow all the rules required to conduct their business as many times the transporters do not have requisite documents. At the same time, I have assured action against those who were harassing them and also asked to share their details. I have not received any information from them yet,' Kadam told ThePrint. On 14 July, MoS Home (Rural) Prakash Bhoyar told the Legislative Council that the state government was thinking of bringing in a new law against beef smuggling and also planning to withdraw cases against gau rakshaks by way of a new law to protect cow progeny. Also Read: Fodder for thought: Modi govt's cow welfare agency has been headless for 4 yrs, Rs 500 cr lying idle 'Will die of hunger' In Maharashtra, the slaughter of bovine is prohibited, and a certificate from a veterinary is required to slaughter buffaloes. This certificate needs to specifically mention that the buffalo is 'unfit' for milking and is not pregnant. Most of the 292 livestock markets in Maharashtra are now closed, barring some in Pune and Mumbai. These attract those who want to sell or buy animals for slaughter, and also farmers and traders who want to buy or sell animals either for farming or dairy businesses. The state government last year gave 'Rajyamata' status to cows and also approved the animal husbandry department's proposal to provide Rs 50 daily subsidy per animal to cow shelter operators. Members of the Qureshi community ThePrint spoke to say approximately 300-500 animals are traded at every market, each costing anywhere between Rs 10,000 to over a lakh, depending on the size, age and the fitness of the animal. They add that harassment of cattle traders at the hands of cow vigilantes has been steadily rising since the passage of the 2015 legislation. 'There is a lot of hooliganism in the name of gau raksha in the state. The police are not cooperating with us. We are all very scared. Markets used to be full of animals but everything is closed now. We are suffering huge economic losses as well,' said Aziz Qureshi, Nanded district coordinator, AIJQ. 'About 50,000 people from our community are in this trade in the entire district. They are saying we will die of hunger but think twice before going back into the trade,' he added. Community members said the bandh started about a month ago with the Nagpur market and slowly spread across the state. They also alleged that while police do not register their complaints, FIRs are filed against members of the Qureshi community instead. Asked to comment on these allegations, minister Kadam said, 'I told them to tell me which particular area they are facing issues with. Won't be happening all over Maharashtra. So they need to give me a particular area or organisation troubling them. I will make sure that I tell the police to act accordingly. But except for the letter, I haven't received any official complaint. If need be, we will talk to them again.' The Qureshi community is demanding strict action against vigilantes/extortionists and proper implementation of the provisions of sections 6 and 8 of the Maharashtra Animal Preservation Act, 1976, and the Transport of Animal Rules, 1978. Another allegation is that the animals gau rakshaks confiscate are taken to 'gaushalas' (cow shelters) operated by the government. Cattle trader Moinuddin Qureshi alleged his truck containing seven buffaloes was taken away by gau rakshaks on 6 June and an FIR was registered against him and the truck driver. ThePrint has seen a copy of the FIR. The animals were later sent to a gaushala while the police investigated the matter and found nothing suspicious, he said. According to Moinuddin, the police then wrote to the gaushala saying that 'during the investigation, we found that Qureshi has all the documentation including fitness certificate for the buffaloes' and that the complaint was made out of a 'misunderstanding'. ThePrint has seen a copy of the letter. However, Moinuddin is yet to get his livestock back. 'In fact, now the gaushala has gone to local court against us and refusing to give us our animals … Everything is legal, we have the documents but only because of our religion, we are being harassed.' Other cattle traders too said once the animals are sent to the local gaushala, it is very difficult to recover them. 'Behind every animal, the government gives a certain amount for nourishment of these animals at the gaushalas. But when our farmers and traders are trying to get back the animals from gaushalas, they are not there. So where did our animals go? Where are they taking them?' asked AIJQ acting president Javed Qureshi. Shaikh agreed. He was told his animals were taken to Badnapur gaushala. 'But even two days back when I went there, I did not see my animals there. Don't know where they are. I might never get them back now.' (Edited by Ajeet Tiwari) Also Read: BJP's 'cow protection brigade' gets official stamp in new animal husbandry ministry
