logo
Homeowner's fury after 'nonsense' order to remove sunroom and chimneys

Homeowner's fury after 'nonsense' order to remove sunroom and chimneys

STV News18-07-2025
A homeowner in Glasgow has spoken of his fury about a 'nonsense' order to remove a sunroom and two wood-burning stove chimneys from his property.
Gerard Caughey has lived in the C-listed property in Seton Terrace, Dennistoun, since 1991.
His sunroom was built in 2018 as an extension to his flat on the ground floor of a two-storey terraced house. It contains a wood-burning stove, with a second installed in a workshop in the back garden. Both have flues that he has been ordered to remove.
'Should I just destroy it? …It's just going to end up in a skip somewhere' Gerard Caughey
Glasgow City Council argued that the sunroom did not 'protect the listed building's appearance' or 'complement' the area's 'period, style and character'.
Planning officers ordered its removal in November following 'various' public complaints, along with the chimneys, which they said had 'a direct impact on the amenity of the neighbouring properties' due to smoke.
'I think it's nonsense,' Mr Caughey told STV News. STV News
'Most folk I speak with in the area love the smell of the smoke, and I use it very occasionally.
'I've also had a complaint about noise when I work from my toolshed, and about a tree being up. I mean that tree has been there for 150 years.
'I've been here 35 years. When I got the flat, it was a complete shambles.'
Mr Caughey appealed to the Scottish Government to overturn the rulings, but this week they were upheld.
'…removal of the orangery… would restore the character of the listed building…' Scottish Government reporter
The reporter appointed to investigate by the Government heard that Mr Caughey's current sunroom replaced a pre-existing orangery which was in a 'dangerous condition'.
Mr Caughey's appeal argued his extension protected the listed building because of its similarity to the original structure.
Mr Caughey said that the window for planning permission was 'very small' and that the council had failed to respond to a query about retrospective planning applications.
He argued that the extension had been completed six years before the enforcement notice, that a prior notice against the flues had been dismissed, and that 'quality' Spanish hardwood shipped from abroad had been used. STV News
The council said the previous notice was not withdrawn, that the sunroom was 'incongruous' with the listed building and contributed to 'overdevelopment', and the flues were not 'a sufficient distance' from neighbouring properties, so a planning application would be refused.
The Scottish Government reporter decided that the sunroom and chimneys required planning permission and breaches had occurred.
To keep his sunroom and chimneys, Mr Caughey's only option now is to challenge the rulings at Scotland's highest court – the Court of Session. But this can only be done on a point of law.
The grounds could include a claim that the Government reporter misunderstood important evidence or didn't take it into account. STV News
The Scottish Government describe this as a 'complex legal process'.
Mr Caughey admitted it's likely his work from the past five years is going 'to end up in a skip'.
'The house is done with cast iron everywhere, proper materials from Spain,' he said, 'I think it's fabulous.
'I'd hate to take it down. It's near impossible.
'I have no idea where to start. I mean, look at it. Should I just destroy it? That's what it looks like I'm going to have to do. It's just going to end up in a skip somewhere.
'I don't know why, it's not doing anything. You can't even see the garden from out in the street.
'It's not causing anyone harm or anything. I didn't think it would be a big deal.'
The Scottish Government reporter, Simon Bonsall, refused to grant listed building consent for Mr Caughey's extension.
'While the effect of the orangery on the setting would not be harmful, I consider that the orangery through its design, location and materials would… not be in keeping with the character of the listed building,' he concluded.
'I consider that the removal of the orangery… would restore the character of the listed building to its state prior to the orangery having been built.'
Glasgow City Council has been contacted for comment.
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Fathers urged to apply for jobs at nurseries and pre-schools in Government drive
Fathers urged to apply for jobs at nurseries and pre-schools in Government drive

Rhyl Journal

time14 minutes ago

  • Rhyl Journal

Fathers urged to apply for jobs at nurseries and pre-schools in Government drive

According to the Department for Education, three workers out of every 100 in the early years sector are men. Education minister Stephen Morgan said that as part of the drive to make early years careers 'more appealing', the Government was 'reminding dads that if you've helped your own child learn and grow, you've already got the skills to make a difference to many more'. He added: 'Children thrive when they're supported by a diverse mix of role models and that starts in the early years. 'With big changes coming in September, we're backing nurseries to recruit the staff they need and encouraging more men to consider this rewarding career.' Advertisements are set to appear on social media feeds, roadside billboards and railway displays throughout the country, some featuring men looking after children while painting or at a make-believe tea party. The effort, known as 'Do Something Big', coincides with a £1,000 payment incentive for new early years staff in 38 priority regions throughout England. It is thought this could help nursery managers recruit in time for an expanded childcare offer in September, when eligible parents can receive 30 hours of funded childcare per week for children aged between nine months and two years old.

Fathers urged to apply for jobs at nurseries and pre-schools in Government drive
Fathers urged to apply for jobs at nurseries and pre-schools in Government drive

Western Telegraph

time26 minutes ago

  • Western Telegraph

Fathers urged to apply for jobs at nurseries and pre-schools in Government drive

According to the Department for Education, three workers out of every 100 in the early years sector are men. Education minister Stephen Morgan said that as part of the drive to make early years careers 'more appealing', the Government was 'reminding dads that if you've helped your own child learn and grow, you've already got the skills to make a difference to many more'. With big changes coming in September, we're backing nurseries to recruit the staff they need and encouraging more men to consider this rewarding career Education minister Stephen Morgan He added: 'Children thrive when they're supported by a diverse mix of role models and that starts in the early years. 'With big changes coming in September, we're backing nurseries to recruit the staff they need and encouraging more men to consider this rewarding career.' Advertisements are set to appear on social media feeds, roadside billboards and railway displays throughout the country, some featuring men looking after children while painting or at a make-believe tea party. The effort, known as 'Do Something Big', coincides with a £1,000 payment incentive for new early years staff in 38 priority regions throughout England. It is thought this could help nursery managers recruit in time for an expanded childcare offer in September, when eligible parents can receive 30 hours of funded childcare per week for children aged between nine months and two years old.

Boeing 787 Dreamliner narrowly avoided crash after engine failure
Boeing 787 Dreamliner narrowly avoided crash after engine failure

Metro

time7 hours ago

  • Metro

Boeing 787 Dreamliner narrowly avoided crash after engine failure

A Boeing 787 Dreamliner crash nearly crashed just moments after taking off because of an engine failure. The United Airlines plane took off from Washington Dulles Airport bound for Munich on Friday but was forced to turn around just minutes into the flight. A 'Mayday' was declared by the crew at around 5,000 feet after a malfunction was reported in the aircraft's left engine. The crew on the plane were directed by air traffic control to a holding pattern northwest of Washington so that they could dump fuel. They asked the pilots: 'How long do you expect to hold, fuel, or just get set up there?' The pilot responded: 'We'll have to climb six [thousand feet] and adjust fuel.' The Dreamliner remained at around 6,000 feet for several minutes while it dumped the fuel. The pilot told air traffic control: 'We're dumping fuel at six thousand. We'll let you know when complete.' Luckily, the crew managed to land the plane safely back at Dulles Airport, and no injuries were reported, and all passengers disembarked safely. Because of engine failure, the plane had to be towed off the runway by the ground crew. Flight data shows that the aircraft's left engine failed while it was climbing after it departed. The aircraft is still grounded at the airport while engineers inspect the engine and the damage. Aviation authorities, including the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), are expected to investigate the incident. A United Airlines spokesperson told Metro: 'United flight 108 to Munich returned to Washington Dulles shortly after takeoff to address a mechanical issue. 'The plane landed safely, and all passengers deplaned normally at the gate. 'The flight was subsequently cancelled and we arranged alternate travel arrangements to take customers to their destination as soon as possible.' Boeing has been approached for comment. The safety model of the Boeing 787 Dreamliner is currently under scrutiny because of the Air India crash last month. That incident involved both engines failing shortly after take-off from Ahmedabad airport. More Trending The tragic crash killed more than 260 people and the circumstances around it are still under investigation. Other problems with Boeing 787s have been reported this year, including an Ethiopian Airlines Boeing 787 en route from Addis Ababa to Mumbai. It experienced a mid-air depressurisation event, prompting an emergency descent. Oxygen masks were deployed, and seven passengers needed medical attention when they landed in Mumbai. Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: Wizz Air launches 5 new Spanish routes from the UK – but not everyone is happy MORE: One of the world's highest volcanos erupts after 8.8-magnitude quake MORE: New York City skyscraper shooting victims identified: Everything we know

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store