Chris Selley: Central Canadians are practically goading Alberta to consider separation
Article content
Of all the problems Canada faces in 2025, the prospect of Alberta sovereigntists winning a referendum and plunging the country into constitutional hell does not appear to be one of them. A Postmedia-Leger poll released last week, found just 29 per cent of Albertans supported the province 'becoming a country independent of Canada,' which is what the straightforward referendum question recently proposed by the separatist Alberta Prosperity Project (APP) would ask. That's even fewer than the 36 per cent of Quebecers who would vote Yes in their own sovereignty referendum, according to a Leger poll released before last month's federal election.
Article content
Article content
But good grief, Central Canada could hardly be doing more to try to pump the APP's tires. Ironically, that includes some Quebec separatists.
Article content
Article content
Parti Québécois leader Paul St-Pierre Plamondon has offered support, in principle: 'I totally agree with provinces that stand up, that are loyal to their own parliament, that are capable of showing a strong hand,' he said earlier this month. This seems like the only logical strategic position for Quebec sovereigntists to take if — like the PQ, which is in pole position to win the next provincial election — they're actually planning on holding and winning a referendum and commencing divorce proceedings with Ottawa, the other provinces and First Nations.
Article content
Others in the Quebec sovereignty movement, however, haven't been able to resist broadcasting their contempt for Alberta. Legalities aside, Bloc Québécois Leader Yves-François Blanchet averred earlier this month, a proper sovereignty-seeking entity 'has to have a culture of their own.'
Article content
Article content
'I am not certain that oil and gas qualifies to define a culture,' he added disdainfully.
Article content
Article content
'In Quebec, we have a nation, a language, a culture, a distinct history,' Marie-Anne Alepin, president of the arch-nationalist Société St-Jean-Baptiste de Montréal, told The Canadian Press earlier this month. 'They want an oil-based future. We have no common goals. We're not alike.'
Article content
But in this respect, we're almost seeing a national-unity moment among Central Canadian elites — sovereigntist and federalist, Upper and Lower Canadian alike — with respect to Alberta.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
11 minutes ago
- CBC
Access to water, limited personnel: How remote northern communities struggle to fight wildfires
When the Parker Lake wildfire bore down on Fort Nelson, B.C. last year in May, firefighter Sonja Leverkus said finding water to fight the blaze became a significant challenge. "The ground was still frozen at the time," she said. "I seriously recall being on my hands and knees on the fire line, digging into the frozen dirt, still trying to make a sludge to put on some of the hot spots." It was just one example of the many challenges remote northern areas can face in fighting fires. As wildfires continue to rage in parts of Alberta, Saskatchewan and Manitoba, many of these regions are struggling with issues like access to water, dry conditions, expensive equipment and limited fire-response personnel. Drought, for example, can be a major issue in some of these areas, Leverkus said. "Places that we used to be able to dig a little hole and pull water out of to help us do mop up activities are not existent," she said. "We're really seeing a lack of water." 'On our own here' Remote communities suffer in part because when fires break out in more densely populated regions, provincial resources get reallocated to those areas, Leverkus said. "And so sometimes it does feel like... we are on our own here in the northeast." WATCH | Northern Manitoba First Nations plead for more firefighting equipment: Northern Manitoba First Nations plead for more firefighting equipment 20 hours ago Duration 2:31 First Nations in northern Manitoba want more equipment in their fight against wildfires that helped trigger a provincewide state of emergency. Pukatawagan Chief Gordie Bear said people in his community resorted to fighting the fire with hoses 'no bigger than a garden hose,' including some usually used on the community's hockey rink. Transporting firefighting equipment and resources can also pose a challenge. Moving equipment from southern B.C. to Fort Nelson can be "incredibly expensive," she said, and can take several days. One of the biggest challenges is keeping around a fire crew ready at all times. "A person has to be very creative to keep crew around to stay to be here to also help fight fire." Ken Lodge, mayor of Lac du Bonnet, Man., where wildfires recently forced around 1,000 people to evacuate, said he understands the challenges of having enough firefighters available. "We in the smaller and more remote areas don't have the revenue to staff a large, permanent — or even a small, permanent — fire department," Lodge said. "So we subsist on volunteer people." Training is "extraordinarily expensive," he said, and not everyone can do every job. And because they're volunteers, they can't always leave their paid jobs to go and fight fires, he said. "It does mean that you're very rarely going to have necessarily a full crew out fighting fires," he said. "Especially if you have a fire that's as significant as what we've had here, where it's multiple days long and there's a lot of territory that needs to be covered out here, with in some cases, limited access." WATCH | Lac du Bonnet 'shaken' by Manitoba wildfire deaths, says mayor: Lac du Bonnet 'shaken' by Manitoba wildfire deaths, says mayor 20 days ago Duration 9:14 Ken Lodge, mayor of Lac du Bonnet, Man., says those in the community who knew the two people who died in the wildfire are 'devastated,' but the town is resilient. Equipment, as well, is limited and comes with a huge cost that is borne by the municipalities, Lodge said. Still, while rural fire departments like his are relatively well trained and equipped, when it comes to wildfires, "the resources still overall aren't there to combat something of this magnitude." 'Thinking of ways to slow it down' Despite the resource challenges, Leverkus and other fire experts do believe there are ways to make their jobs less challenging — mitigation strategies that may help lessen the damage and destruction caused by the blazes. "I don't think that we should ever think something's going to stop a fire from impinging a community," she said. "I think that we should be thinking about ways to slow it down." WATCH | Firefighter documents battle to save Weyakwin, Sask.: Firefighter documents battle to save Weyakwin, Sask. 21 hours ago Duration 0:29 Jarret Nelson is on the front lines fighting a wildfire in Weyakwin, Sask. The community is one of many in the province that has been evacuated recently, with fires endangering property and residents and smoke filling the air. Nelson has been documenting the effort to fight the Pisew Fire with water bombers, large hoses, fire breaks and back burns. And for that, prevention is key. Cliff Buettner, former director of forestry and emergency and protective services with Prince Albert Grand Council in Saskatchewan, said it's crucial for homeowners to eliminate the potential fire fuel sources from their surroundings, or break up what's called a fire triangle — heat, air and fuel. "Get rid of the fuel around your house," he said. "Get rid of the things that can burn; move them away." Cedar trees, for example, are a particular hazard, Buettner said. "Everyone's got a nice ornamental cedar up against their house. If there's no moisture, where are the sparks going to start? In that cedar." "The wood you pile up against your house, it's called a home ignition zone around your home. Clean that up as much as you can to eliminate anything that can start on fire, anything that a spark will land on that will start it on fire." Magda Zachara, program director of FireSmart Canada, said that in the majority of cases, homes burn down from wildfires because of embers landing on their property from a fire that can be several kilometres away. "That is what causes the destruction," she said. "It's not the wall of flame. It's the embers that are transported through the air." That's why FireSmart Canada, a national program that helps make neighbourhoods in Canada more resilient against wildfires, says it's so important for people to mitigate or protect the "immediate zone" of a building or home. That's typically the 1.5 metres around the structure, as well as the structure itself. Removing combustible materials from that area increases the chances of one's home surviving by up to 90 per cent, she said. "If you're not going to focus on anything else, focus on this area and make it as non-combustible as possible. Remove anything that can easily ignite."
Calgary Herald
44 minutes ago
- Calgary Herald
'Albertans know that they have options': Alberta Tory MPs warn Carney not to ignore threat of separatism
Article content OTTAWA — With the House of Commons back in full swing, Conservative MPs from Alberta are sounding the alarm on rising separatist tensions in the province, warning Prime Minister Mark Carney to tackle the problem or reckon with a fractured country. Article content Calgary MP Shuvaloy Majumdar blasted Carney on Tuesday for leaving the first ministers' meeting in Saskatoon without giving Alberta a firm commitment on oil and gas pipelines and other energy infrastructure. Article content Article content Article content 'Yesterday, the prime minister committed to more rhetoric, more lofty words, and no actual (oil and gas) project,' said Majumdar in Tuesday's question period. Article content Article content 'Alberta's heard all this before. We don't need headlines, we need results.' Article content Majumdar told the National Post it's time for Carney to back up his words with actions, after campaigning on an implicit promise to repair the rift between Ottawa and Alberta created by his Liberal predecessor Justin Trudeau. Article content 'This is all about the pressure of resentment that has built up after (Trudeau spent) 10 years attacking the energy industry in Alberta,' said Majumdar. Article content 'The prime minister ran on addressing those issues, lifting things from the Conservative playbook… The solution here is for (him) to deliver what he's promising, lest he risk a constitutional crisis.' Article content Newly elected rural Alberta MP David Bexte said in his maiden speech last week that 'Alberta separatism is no longer a fringe idea.' Article content Article content 'I heard (separatist talk) at the doors more times than I can count, and I'll tell you plainly… Albertans know that they have options,' said Bexte. Article content 'If this House continues to insult, neglect and abuse Alberta… then the future of this country is not guaranteed.' Article content Bexte declined a request to be interviewed for this story. Article content Departing Battle River—Crowfoot MP Damien Kurek sounded the same warning in his farewell speech to Parliament, imploring all members of the House to 'fight for Canada.' Article content 'We face a national unity crisis. It is not something that can be flippantly dismissed by those in other parts of the country that would suggest that Alberta, for example, should simply pay up and shut up,' said Kurek. Article content Kurek announced shortly after April's election that he would vacate his seat to give Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre, who lost his own Ottawa-area seat, an opportunity to run in a byelection.
Vancouver Sun
2 hours ago
- Vancouver Sun
What we know about the wildfires burning in Canada and sending smoke to the U.S. and U.K.
High winds coupled with a warm, dry spring are fuelling a wave of forest fires across western Canada and parts of Ontario. More than 200 fires were reported across the country as of Tuesday morning, half of which are labelled out of control. Wildfires have already burned close to 2.2 million hectares this year, equivalent to the size of about 4 million football fields. At about seven times its ten-year average, the burn area is unusually large for this time of year. Communities in Alberta, Saskatchewan and Manitoba are shrouded in smoke and air quality alerts have been issued across the provinces and bordering U.S. states. Start your day with a roundup of B.C.-focused news and opinion. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sunrise will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. With summer still weeks away, this year's fire season is running far ahead of schedule. Here's what you should know. The worst blazes have occurred in the prairie provinces and has led Saskatchewan and Manitoba to declare province-wide emergencies in late May. Saskatchewan The Shoe fire in Saskatchewan's Narrow Hills Provincial Park has scorched 408,000 hectares as of Monday, roughly 18 times the size of the city of Saskatoon, and is threatening 11 communities. To the north, a 83,000 hectare fire in La Ronge, Sask, forced several neighbouring communities to evacuate. On Monday , the fire had crossed into the town's airport. The evacuation also included 45 acute and long-term care patients from the care homes and a health centre in La Rouge, the Saskatchewan Health Authority said. In total, more than 8,000 people, or about 30 communities, have been ordered to evacuate so far. There are 18 fires across the province, around half of which are uncontained. It's already shaping up to be the worst wildfire season Saskatchewan has seen in recent memory. Manitoba In Manitoba, more than 17,000 residents, including 5,000 people from Flin Flon, a mining city located near the Saskatchewan border, were forced to evacuate from their homes. The smoke has been too thick for water bombers to reach, leaving firefighters struggling to contain the blazes. Multiple fires beset the First Nations communities of Pimicikamak Cree Nation and Pukatawagan, prompting the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs to make an urgent plea for emergency response on May 30. The fires made the roads inaccessible stranding close to 4,000 members from both communities. Military planes carried out the evacuations save for a handful of holdouts who have so far refused to leave. Many of the evacuees have been allowed to carry only one bag with them and are told it might be weeks before they have a chance to return. The province has 25 fires, 10 of which are out of control. With accommodations in cities and First Nations communities becoming scarce, evacuees have had to be flown outside the province. Hundreds of Pimicikamak Cree Nation residents have been taken to Niagara Falls, Ont., where hotel rooms are becoming difficult to wrangle. Many of the evacuees have been allowed to carry only one bag with them and have been told it might be weeks before they have a chance to return. In mid-May, two people were reported dead in Lac du Bonnet, Man., a little over an hour's drive from Winnipeg, where evacuation orders were in place. Alberta Cooler weather mild showers kept fires from escalating overnight in Alberta, but the rest of the week is expected to bring warmer weather. More than 4,500 people have been ordered to leave their homes, including the town of Swan Hills, located northwest of Edmonton. The fires have claimed more than 500,000 hectares, primarily in the province's northwest. Of the 53 active wildfires in Alberta, 24 are out of control and six are being held, meaning the fire is expected to be contained under given conditions. The province has had 505 wildfires this season. The province's oil sands sector has also been affected, shutting down about seven per cent of Canada's oil production, or about 350,000 barrels a day, according to Bloomberg. British Columbia Nearly all of the wildfires are concentrated in the province's Northeast corner. A third evacuation order has been issued in Prince George as winds in excess off 50 kilometres per hour this week are expected to fan the flames toward the Alberta border. Much of the land is severely drought-stricken, according to Agriculture Canada. This week, a major clean up response took place after a fire near Summit Lake cut off 160 km of the Alaska highway close to Fort Nelson, B.C. The major arterial roadway, which connects Alaska to the Yukon, was shut down for much of Tuesday. It reopened to a single lane that evening, according to the Drive B.C. website. Ontario Several high-risk fires are burning in northern Ontario. Several First Nations communities have been evacuated since May and two have declared states of emergencies. Wabaseemoong Independent Nations, located west of Kenora, were placed under evacuation orders in mid-May. Fires started near the Manitoba border and have since scorched more than 36,000 hectares. Evacuations for Webequie First Nation, in Nipigon, where the fires have blackened 8,000 hectares, were carried out last week, and more than 400 members relocated. Deer Lake First Nation was also being evacuated this week, with 1,300 members needing relocation. A majority of the fires have been man-made, as is typical for this time of year. Of the 111 total wildfires in Manitoba this season, 100 are believed to be human-caused while six are under investigation and another five are believed natural. Over the weekend, Saskatchewan premier Scott Moe estimated that people were to blame for 90 per cent of fires in the province. Man made fires entail anything from burns that spread out of control, campfires that were left unattended, discarded cigarettes or, as in some cases, an act of malice. Lightning becomes the primary driver starting in June, and these fires are usually the most devastating. During 2023's record-breaking fire season, lightning accounted for 93 per cent of the area burned. Alberta, Saskatchewan, Ontario and Manitoba are seeing larger fires at this point in the year than their five-year average. In Central Canada, a combination of weather conditions — including warm temperatures, drought and lack of humidity — made fires more prone to spread. Manitoba exceeded average temperatures by double digits in the spring. Parts of Saskatchewan where fires are active were also several degrees warmer than average. Alberta also experienced a warm spring and is braced for heatwaves leading into summer. Current models forecast Central Canada will remain dry and hot throughout the summer. Fires have also been whipped up by strong winds and a lack of meaningful rains, conditions which are set to persist in much of the fire-stricken until later this week. Hundreds of communities are under Environment Canada's air quality warnings. The severity of smoke in any particular area can depend on factors such as wind direction, speed and fire proximity, according to the agency. A large part of southern and central Manitoba has been blanketed with hazardous levels of smoke. Advisories have also been issued for communities in northern Alberta, northern Saskatchewan and north western Ontario. Smoke caused by the wildfires has extended from the Midwest states into the plains and even as far southeast as Georgia. Minnesota, in particular, was placed under a statewide advisory, while multiple bordering states have advised their people to reduce exposure by staying inside as much as possible and keeping doors and windows shut. Health authorities are recommending the use of air filters at home or for going to locations with filtered air, such as libraries or malls. U.K. skies were also covered in a dull haze this week as smoke apparently carried across the Atlantic. Fumes also blew over into the Northern Europe, the Mediterranean and Greece a little over two weeks ago, with more expected in the coming weeks, according to the climate monitoring service Copernicus. The haze is hovering at high altitudes and poses no health risks, experts say, but has obscured the sun in an orangish haze. Wildfires release small particles in the air that are more harmful than regular air pollution. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency map shows moderate to severe concentrations of particles known as PM2.5 and ozone levels, in Minnesota, Wisconsin and Iowa. These particles are used as a measure of air quality, with moderate levels affecting sensitive groups and more severe levels causing severe discomfort and even death. Young people, the elderly and those with heart and lung conditions are particularly at risk. At unhealthy levels, studies show an increase in stroke, heart attack and lung cancer among those who inhale wildfire smoke. 'Ground-level ozone and PM2.5 cause respiratory and cardiovascular problems and lead to tens of thousands of premature deaths, with costs of more than $100 billion, each year,' guidelines from the NOAA states. Wildfire smoke contributes to nearly 18,000 deaths a year, according to the Lung Health Foundation. It recommends keeping an emergency kit, filtering indoor air and checking carbon monoxide monitors to stay protected. At severe levels, the use of an air conditioner is not recommended. Instead, it is advised to check local governments for nearby cooling locations. Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark and sign up for our daily newsletter, Posted, here .
