Stillborn case: SHRC recommends compensation, filling of vacancies with medical staff
'More than 4,000 rural health nurse vacancies remain unfilled in 8,488 sub-health centres in Tamil Nadu. With 50% of the posts lying vacant, the workload of the rural health nurses in service has increased drastically,' SHRC member V. Kannadasan observed in an order. The Commission recommended the State government to pay a compensation of ₹5 lakh to a pregnant woman's kin who was reportedly forced to clean up her blood before boarding an ambulance.
Even as it appreciated various programmes of the State government, the Commission observed: 'Due to the shortage of doctors and nurses in government hospitals in various districts including Villupuram, there is a delay in providing immediate treatment to patients. Activists also criticise that there is only one doctor in many primary health centers. An environment has also emerged where government doctors are psychologically affected due to low salaries and high workload.'
The Commission recommended the State government to take necessary steps to appoint more doctors, nurses and other medical staff, especially in Primary Health Centers in the village level round the clock throughout the State. It also recommended necessary steps to provide more ambulance services to give special attention to pregnant women to reach hospitals in time.
The Commission also appreciated the efforts taken by the Tamil Nadu government on its achievement projects throughout the State and recalled the introduction of various flagship schemes for maternal and child health and control of infectious diseases. It also appreciated the Chief Minister's Comprehensive Health Insurance Scheme and the Makkalai Thedi Maruthuvam scheme.
'The government of Tamil Nadu is taking various steps to reduce maternal mortality. However, the target of reducing maternal mortality can be achieved only if there are sufficient numbers of obstetricians in hospitals,' the Commission said. The restrictions in the Chief Minister's Insurance Scheme should be removed, it said. Action should be taken on complaints that some private hospitals participating in the scheme are using the entire insurance amount and charging additional fees for it, it said.
The Commission made these observations while dealing with a complaint from one K. Devamani. Her pregnant daughter K. Subulakshmi was admitted to Murugeri Primary Health Centre on April 26, 2021. While the 108 ambulance arrived to take her, auxiliary nurse midwife Prabhavathi from the PHC shouted at her and demanded that she cleaned up her blood from the bed before leaving.
The ANM did not allow it even after the ambulance staff insisted that the patient was to be shifted out at once. Due to the delay, they were not able to reach the Government Medical College Hospital at Mundiyambakkam on time and the foetus did not survive. The patient also contracted COVID-19 infection. The complainant alleged inhumane actions on the part of government employees and further sought for an investigation into the incident.
During the hearing, the Director of Public Health and Preventive Medicine submitted a detailed report. It said the ANM had to attend to two patients simultaneously, one of them injured in an accident. It was submitted that the patient's attender was not forced to clean up the blood.
Considering the oral and documentary evidence of the parties and also findings given in the enquiry report, the Commission said it was categorically established that the patient's had a stillborn due to inordinate delay in the Primary Health Centre where the patient and attender were asked to clean up the blood before boarding the ambulance.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
3 days ago
- The Hindu
All patients to register with ABHA ID, says NMC to all medical colleges and institutes
To ensure that authentic patient records are maintained by medical colleges, the National Medical Commission (NMC) has written to them directing that Ayushman Bharat Health Account (ABHA) ID should be recorded along with patient registration in the hospital. The ABHA card contains a unique 14-digit identification number called ABHA ID. The entire medical history, consultation details, and prescriptions are included in the ABHA ID. However, NMC maintained that no patient should be denied treatment without the ABHA lD. For authentic records In its letter to the dean/principals of all medical colleges and institutes under NMC, the body noted that the intent is to ensure availability of authentic records of patients and the clinical material in the associated hospital of the medical college. However, it has been noticed that this requirement is not being followed by all medical colleges and for all patients. As per the latest directive, colleges shall maintain the records of all patients. 'All in-patient records should have the entry of the unit faculty and senior residents with their name and signature authenticating that they have admitted and seen the patient. All investigative reports should be signed by a faculty in the corresponding department. Verification of the authenticity may be conducted by the NMC as part of the assessments. If at any point of time, the patient records are found to be fake; action shall be taken against the concerned faculty and the college/institute,' NMC said, adding that the move was decided in the Commission (NMC) 14th meeting held recently. All medical colleges are now required to ensure that ABHA lD be mentioned as a prerequisite for registration of patients visiting for the OPD/ IPD/ emergency services in hospitals attached to them. Additionally, all patients must have registration done with the ABHA lD in addition to the hospital's registration number, the letter noted. 'The Commission has endorsed a strong need to have authentication of patients and other clinical material in the hospital for decision on the prospects of a college (increased seats in UG or PG, new college, annual renewal of permission/recognition to admit students). The creation of ABHA lD is a very simple process and can be facilitated conveniently with the possession of Aadhaar card that has already been extended to people on a large scale,' the letters stated.
Time of India
3 days ago
- Time of India
30% of small scale workers diagnosed with NCDs in MTM screening drive
Trichy: More than 1,500 small-scale industry workers have been screened for health issues under the 'Makkalai Thedi Maruthuvam' (MTM) scheme, with a majority of those screened diagnosed with hypertension. The state govt extended the scheme to small-scale industry workers, since June. The workplace screening initiative follows the govt's announcement in the assembly recently that its flagship MTM scheme—which won the UN Interagency Task Force (UNIATF) Award for 2024—would be expanded to include workers in small-scale establishments, focusing on the detection of non-communicable diseases (NCDs). According to official data from the district health department, 876 establishments in Trichy district with fewer than 1,000 workers were identified for the drive by the directorate of industrial safety and health (DISH). Of these, 76 establishments have been covered so far, screening 1,672 workers. The drive aims to screen 26,760 workers across all 14 blocks in the district. In line with the MTM approach, workers are screened for NCDs such as diabetes and hypertension. Preliminary findings show that nearly 70% of those screened were normal, while the remaining 30% were diagnosed with diabetes, hypertension, or both. Specifically, 123 workers were diagnosed with hypertension, 73 with diabetes, and 20 with both. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Fully Loaded 4 BHK apts for 4.49 Cr(All Incl)* in Sec 104 ATS Triumph, Gurgaon Book Now Undo T richy has a considerable number of micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSMEs), particularly in the engineering and textile sectors. "Some workers are already aware of their condition and declare it during screening, but many are unaware and are diagnosed only after the tests," an official said. "Once diagnosed, they are referred to the nearest govt health facility in their area or block," the official added. Another official involved in the initiative said, "Workers in unorganised sectors are especially vulnerable to conditions like hypertension due to irregular work hours, job insecurity, lack of health awareness, and high levels of stress." Officials also said there are certain cases where the beneficiaries are also hesitant. "But then we convince them. All the beneficiaries are also closely monitored," the official added. Officials said the screening is conducted twice a week using existing mobile medical units, each staffed with one medical officer, a staff nurse, a health inspector, and a volunteer. There are about 390 women volunteers, who support the district health initiatives, also take part in this drive when and if needed. BOX: Workplace Screening Drive (05.06.2025 to 26.07.2025) Total Occupational Health Centres (OHCs) identified: 876 OHCs covered so far: 76 Target population for screening: 26,760 workers Workers screened so far: 1,672 Workers found normal: 1,219 Known Cases (self-declared during screening) Hypertension: 84 Diabetes: 113 Both Hypertension and Diabetes: 51 New Suspected Cases (based on screening) Hypertension: 151 Diabetes: 82 Both conditions: 26 Confirmed New Diagnoses Hypertension: 123 Diabetes: 73 Both Hypertension and Diabetes: 20
Time of India
3 days ago
- Time of India
SHRC orders 5L relief for medical negligence
Chennai: State human rights commission (SHRC) has directed state govt to pay 5lakh as relief to a woman who delivered a stillborn baby due to an alleged delay in medical attention at Murukkeri primary health centre (PHC) in Villupuram. SHRC member V Kannadasan passed the order on a complaint moved by the woman's mother, K Devamani, alleging medical negligence and inhumane treatment at the PHC, which led to the stillbirth of her daughter Subbulakshmi's baby. According to the complaint, Subbulakshmi, who was eight months pregnant, experienced heavy bleeding and was admitted to the PHC on Apr 26, 2021. She contracted COVID-19 during treatment and experienced severe physical and mental distress. You Can Also Check: Chennai AQI | Weather in Chennai | Bank Holidays in Chennai | Public Holidays in Chennai She alleged that there was a delay in transferring her to a higher medical facility as a health worker compelled the complainant to clean the blood-stained floor and bed before boarding the ambulance. Opposing the plea, the PHC's medical officer, Dr K Varadaraj, and auxiliary nurse midwife (ANM) Prabavathi denied instructing the complainant to clean the blood stains. They also denied negligence and emphasised timely medical response and referral to a higher facility. Recording the submissions, the commission found that delay in shifting the patient contributed to the death of the baby. "It was established that a worker, Muthulakshmi, was responsible for instructing the complainant to clean the delivery area, which caused the delay. The worker was later dismissed from service on Nov 6, 2022," SHRC said. The commission also noted the director of public health and preventive medicine failed to include critical documents, including statements from the victim, in the enquiry report submitted to the commission. While dismissing the complaint against the medical officer and ANM on duty for lack of direct evidence, SHRC held govt liable and ordered the relief for violation of the fundamental right to timely medical care under Article 21 of Constitution. SHRC also recommended that govt increase the number of doctors, nurses, and medical staff in PHCs, especially in rural areas, and improve ambulance services with a focus on maternal care.
