Safety warning issued over Red Sea dive boat trips
Britons are being warned "to book through reputable vendors only" when planning trips on Egyptian liveaboard dive boats in the Red Sea, due to safety concerns. Sixteen incidents involving liveaboard vessels operating in the area have occurred in the last five years, UK investigators said, with a number resulting in deaths.A Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) report published on Thursday found boats were "poorly constructed" and essential lifesaving equipment was "defective, out-of-date for service and, in some cases, missing".It comes after a BBC investigation heard accusations of safety failings on the Sea Story, an Egyptian dive boat that sank in the Red Sea last November.
Up to 11 people died or are still missing, including two Britons, Jenny Cawson and Tarig Sinada from Devon.At the time, Egyptian authorities attributed the disaster to a huge wave of up to 4m (13ft). However, survivors and family members have since raised concerns over alleged safety failings on board.These claims have been supported by a leading oceanographer, who told the BBC weather data from the time suggests a wave could not have been responsible, and that a combination of crew error and failings in the boat were the likely cause.One survivor said there had been a lack of functioning emergency equipment, making evacuation difficult when the vessel started taking on water.Witnesses also claimed that the Sea Story boat had undergone structural modifications that may have compromised its seaworthiness.Egyptian authorities launched an investigation into the disaster but the findings are yet to be publicly released. The BBC previously contacted the company that ran the boat trip for comment but received no response.As well as the Sea Story incident, the MAIB report also referenced the dive boat Carlton Queen, which capsized and foundered in April 2023 with 33 people on board - all were rescued but many were injured, including UK nationals.The report also looked at a fire on the dive boat Hurricane in June 2023. Three British passengers died in the incident.Chief Inspector of Marine Accidents, Andrew Moll, said the MAIB was aware of 16 incidents in the area in the last five years and it was "deeply regrettable that a number of these accidents have resulted in the loss of life". That number included three liveaboard dive boats lost in the last 20 months that resulted in numerous deaths, including some UK nationals, investigators added.Mr Moll said: "While MAIB does not have the jurisdiction to investigate accidents involving non-UK flagged vessels operating within the territorial waters of another coastal state, we have made the appropriate authorities aware of our national interest and offered every assistance with any safety investigation they conduct."It is important to remember that such vessels are unlikely to be built, maintained, equipped, and operated to the standard of similar vessels in the UK and we urge the exercise of extreme caution when choosing a boat."Other safety issues identified by the MAIB included emergency escape routes being unmarked, via lockable doors and with no emergency lighting.Investigators also found that safety briefings to passengers "were of a poor standard or not conducted at all and crews appeared poorly trained and were unfamiliar with their vessels".As part of safety recommendations, the MAIB told potential passengers to ensure they request a thorough safety briefing from the crew when arriving on liveaboard vessels, before departure.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Edinburgh Live
4 hours ago
- Edinburgh Live
Antiques Roadshow guest gushes 'I can't believe that' as value of inherited item unveiled
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info A guest on Antiques Roadshow was utterly astounded by the hefty valuation given to his Rolex watch by expert Richard Price. During a rerun of the much-loved BBC show, which aired on Sunday 8th June, Brodie Castle served as the backdrop for a host of valuable discoveries. The episode showcased a man who presented Richard with a 1960s Rolex GMT-Master that once belonged to his uncle. Richard, examining the timepiece closely, told the owner: "All Rolex collectors refer to these things by their reference number," and "You know as well as I do because it says so on the dial that it's a GMT-Master." The owner shared that he had held onto the watch for about 32 years after inheriting it from his uncle, reports the Express. (Image: BBC) He guessed that the watch might have been a present to his uncle in the 1960s, leading Richard to investigate its provenance further. Richard clarified: "It's the reference 1675, which is the classic GMT-Master when you said 60s, I think we could fairly safely say 1960 to 1961, so that all fits in." Upon closer examination, Richard was delighted to discover the watch was unmodified, pointing out that many watches are often altered during servicing, which can disappoint collectors. He detailed: "They would've changed the bezel and they would've changed the dial with an upgrade," and then remarked: "You would've had it back thinking, 'Oh, it looks like new'. Collectors hate that, it's absolutely original, spot-on." The expert was then left a tad disappointed after inspecting the watch further, noting that it sported a jubilee bracelet rather than the original oyster type. He informed the downcast owner: "It's a Rolex product of course, but it says 'Made in the USA'. So perhaps he specified that he did not want the oyster bracelet, he wanted a jubilee bracelet and they put this one on for him. "Which sort of detracts from it a little bit, probably detracts from it by a couple of thousand pounds." (Image: BBC) The guest's spirits dipped further when Richard valued the watch at what would have been £300 to £350 in the early 60s. Reacting to the valuation, the guest said ruefully: "Wish he bought more." However, Richard had some uplifting news, announcing that the Rolex is likely worth £12,000 to £15,000. The guest was left utterly gobsmacked as applause erupted around him. Visibly moved, he uttered: "I can't believe that, can't believe that." Antiques Roadshow is streaming now on BBC iPlayer.
BBC News
16 hours ago
- BBC News
Fire breaks out at fish and chips shop in Brown Edge
Fire crews have been battling a blaze at a fish and chip shop. Flames broke out at Sandy Lane Fish and Chips in Brown Edge, Staffordshire, on Sunday a post on X shortly after 15:30 BST, Staffordshire Fire and Rescue Service said four crews were sent to the scene on Sandy Lane, and urged people to avoid the area.A fire service spokesperson told the BBC nobody was hurt and it was believed the blaze started accidentally, although a cause had not been identified. Firefighters had since left the scene, the spokesperson added. Follow BBC Stoke & Staffordshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
The National
a day ago
- The National
Scottish grandmother volunteers to help displaced Gazans
'You can't justify that – a three-year-old child is a three-year-old child,' said Smith, from Berwickshire. 'It does not matter where on the planet they are from, they do not deserve to be targeted, maimed and murdered.' Equally harrowing was hearing about a young mum who lost her baby and one arm when an Israeli explosive hit as she was breastfeeding. It's only now, a month since Smith returned to Scotland from Cairo in Egypt, that she is able to talk about her experience because the trauma she witnessed was so overwhelming. READ MORE: Freedom Flotilla urges UK Government to 'protect' ship from Israel as it nears Gaza However, she is determined other Scots should hear about the thousands of Palestinians who have escaped the bombardment of Gaza but whose current living hell has been largely overlooked. Most were allowed to cross the border into Egypt because they needed urgent medical treatment for injuries cause by Israeli explosives but are now trying to survive in some of the worst slum areas of Cairo without status, jobs or welfare. 'What I saw and heard in Cairo was catastrophic – not just the aftermath of war but the bureaucracy of abandonment, the quiet violence of being rendered invisible,' Smith (below) told the Sunday National. There are more than 100,000 Gazans now living in Cairo with no legal status. 'They are not refugees. They are not asylum seekers. Nor do they want to be. They want to go home. In the meantime, they are people with no rights, no support and no safety net — invisible in a sprawling, chaotic city of over 10 million. Their kids can't go to Egyptian schools and none of them are allowed to work. It's the most impossible situation for them as if they haven't been through enough,' she said. Smith spent a month volunteering mostly with Network for Palestine, a charity set up by Palestinians to help the evacuees. Her trip was entirely self-funded as she felt she could no longer see the carnage on the TV news without trying to help. A long-time supporter of Medical Aid for Palestine, she had previously worked with Palestinians in the West Bank under the auspices of the British Council in 2010. 'Of all the countries in the world, Palestine is the most like Scotland,' said Smith, right. 'They have some of the best of us – gallows humour, hospitality, national and civic pride, warmth and openness, innovation, resourcefulness and they love a hoolie.' One of the hardest aspects of her visit was seeing the effects of war on the children. Before the current Israeli onslaught and even under occupation, the children were bright and full of energy. The Gazan children in Cairo, by contrast, had completely shut down. READ MORE: 'Joy, celebration and warmth' of Palestinian art to be showcased at Edinburgh Fringe On her first day Smith met a three-year-old who had not spoken for months. A day or two later, she was invited to an Eid party at a hospital in a slum area known as Garbage City. There are more than 150 Gazans living in the grounds of the hospital, mostly injured children. 'The party was organised and paid for by a couple of ordinary young lads from North London and there were bouncy castles and music,' Smith said. During the event, a minibus drew up full of injured kids recently arrived from Gaza. As the children got off the bus, Smith saw they were missing limbs and had other life-changing, visible injuries. They were thin, grey, silent and just stood on the sidelines watching. When Smith met parents, she was struck by how they immediately wanted to show her pictures of their former homes, family, friends, parties they had held for their children and barbecues in their Gazan gardens. At first she found it strange but then she realised they wanted her to know that their current circumstances did not define them. 'It was to say 'I had a life there, I worked as a computer technician, my husband was a paralegal, we had this car, my kids went to this school',' explained Smith. 'Although they have lived under military occupation in a huge compound, they have obviously striven to be educated, happy, free spirited, creative and resourceful. 'Even in their temporary homes in Cairo, even in pain and limbo, they show strangers photos of their lives before to say – this is who I really am. They are not their current situation.' On her trip to Cairo, Smith took £5000 she had raised plus four reconditioned laptops and an iPad. 'I wish I had been able to take much more as many of the children are trying to keep up their education but can't go to school so are trying their best on their mums' phones,' she said. 'Palestinians have one of the highest literacy rates in the world at 99.25%. That's higher than the European average, much higher than the US and even higher than Israel. Education is not just a value – it's a form of resistance.' A ray of light is two Montessori schools that have been set up for the children, while Network for Palestine is working hard to cater for all the families' other needs. 'Network for Palestine in Cairo are absolute heroes and have helped more than 25,000 women, children and families,' said Smith. 'On the days I spent at their HQ, the phones never stopped, the human traffic over the door was relentless and the staff and volunteers were clearly pressed at every turn.' Operating in not much more than a single room only one year ago, the network's HQ has grown so much it is now like Glasgow's Refuweegee charity 'on steroids', according to Smith. 'It is an absolutely huge donation centre with clothes for women, children and men, food, furniture, offices and meeting rooms for all the social work as well as counselling rooms where children, young people and their families get expert support from clinical psychologists trained to support the kind of trauma they have and continue to live with,' she said. However, even those delivering help, who are mostly volunteers, are buckling under the pressure. One said: 'It's emotionally, psychologically and physically exhausting just to keep going, especially when you haven't processed your own trauma and you're faced with the trauma of others that seems never-ending. You are desperate for every piece of news from Gaza, but you're also scared to know what's happening.' Now back in Berwickshire, Smith is doing all she can to raise awareness. Smith said: 'One thing people said to me time and time again is that they just want to be seen. They want it acknowledged that they deserve to live and deserve to be.'
